`verification/TK-11350/dtd-verdict.md`

27 lines
# DTD Verdict — remediation priority

## Decision: A — prioritize demonstrated technical, content-delivery, and monitoring defects before content expansion

Confidence: medium. Vote: **2/2 valid voters**. Panel availability: **2/6**. Run directory: `/tmp/TK-11350-dtd`; `DTD_ZERO_COST=1`. This is a prioritization recommendation, not authorization to deploy or change account settings.

| Reference | Provider/runtime | Actual model | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | Anthropic CLI | sonnet configured, not run | abstain | Disabled by zero-cost mode |
| Codex | OpenAI Codex CLI fallback | gpt-6-astra | A | Unreliable monitoring and implementation defects undermine readiness verification |
| Qwen | Ollama, Mac1 | qwen3:14b | A | Correct demonstrable technical and monitoring defects before expansion |
| Grok | xAI | grok-4.5 configured, unavailable | abstain | No paid request in zero-cost mode |
| Kimi | Moonshot | kimi-k2.5 configured, unavailable | abstain | No paid request in zero-cost mode |
| Muse | Ollama | muse-spark-1.2 configured, unavailable | abstain | Runtime unavailable |

The panel script advertised the default Codex API model, but the actual CLI logs identify **gpt-6-astra**. No vote is attributed to an uncalled model.

## Dissent

None among the two valid voters. Four references abstained; this is not six-model consensus.

## Post-decision Codex debate

**Result: KEEP**, using gpt-6-astra through the CLI fallback. The prosecutor argued that a 401 may be intentional and technical cleanup should not indefinitely block substantive content work. The defender emphasized that broken monitoring prevents knowing whether improvements work. The judge retained A with the constraint to correct demonstrated defects, preserve legitimate authentication, and avoid an indefinite content freeze.

The subsequently confirmed article rendering defect is part of repairing content delivery: existing material is not reaching readers. It strengthens the case for correcting the existing build and reviewing its prose before generating more articles.