`runs/20260503-235131/animals-iter4-final.md`

76 lines
# Claude-Codex 8-way debate run: yolo-animals-iter4-20260503-235131

- Started: 2026-05-04T13:29:53Z
- Ended:   2026-05-04T14:04:46Z
- Rounds:  2 of 2
- Mode:    report-only
- Workdir: /Users/stevestudio2/Projects/animals

## Last round status
- Codex:        ERROR/RATELIMIT — first 2 lines: OpenAI Codex v0.128.0 (research preview) -------- 
- Claude:       ok (      46 lines)
- Qwen3:14b:    ok (       1 lines)
- Kimi K2.5:    ok (       1 lines)
- DeepSeek-R1:  ok (7 lines)
- GPT-OSS:      ok (1 lines)
- Phi-4:        ok (27 lines)
- Mistral:      ok (17 lines)

## Last round findings

### Codex
```

```

### Claude
```
## CRITICAL
**public/mockups/biz-13663-a.html:4** (and 4061 other mockups + 1232 site pages) — Google Fonts URL is double-encoded: `%26family%3D` collapses both font requests into a single `family=` query value, so the second font (e.g. IBM Plex Sans, Inter) silently fails to load and falls back to system fonts.
**public/sites/doggy-daycare-delight-crystal-lake-il-5641/services.html:45** (pattern across all `services.html`/`team.html`/`contact.html`) — page is the full `index.html` (hero + service grid + footer) with the page-specific section appended *after* `</footer>`, even after the implicit body close, producing duplicated H1s and content out of `<body>`.
**public/sites/doggy-daycare-delight-crystal-lake-il-5641/index.html:35-43** — boarding/daycare business is rendered with vet-clinic copy ("Veterinary care… vaccinations… surgical suite… in-home euthanasia"); same template-mismatch in `biz-13663-*` (Humane Society / shelter labelled but selling "Concierge medicine, Direct cell-phone access to your DVM").
**public/mockups/biz-13663-a.html:1, all files** — no `<html lang>`, no `<title>`, no `<meta name=viewport>`, no `<meta name=description>` anywhere — mobile renders desktop-zoomed-out, screen readers can't announce language, every browser tab reads "untitled", every share/SEO surface is broken.
## HIGH
**public/sites/march-animal-hospital-il-il-5722/index.html:49** — footer reads `1000 East Central Road, IL, 60005 · …` (city missing; slug `…-il-il-5722` reveals a `{city}` template var resolved to the state); 60005 is Arlington Heights.
**public/sites/march-animal-hospital-il-il-5722/index.html:37,41** — eyebrow says "established · 1989" while the body claims "For thirty years…" — 2026−1989 = 37, baked-in date drift.
**public/sites/.../index.html:38, biz-*-a.html:42, biz-*-b.html:34** — every CTA points to `href=#book` / `#about` but no element with those ids exists on any page; "Book online" / "Become a client" / "Meet the team →" are dead clicks.
**public/sites/doggy-daycare-delight-crystal-lake-il-5641/services.html:42** — `Surgery & Dental` has unescaped `&` (HTML5-tolerated but breaks any downstream XML/RSS/AMP pipeline and trips strict validators).
```

### Qwen3:14b
```

```

### Kimi K2.5
```

```

### DeepSeek-R1:14b (Mac1)
```

```

### GPT-OSS:20b (Mac1)
```

```

### Phi-4:14b (Mac1)
```
**CRITICAL**
**HIGH**
**MEDIUM**
**NO FINDINGS**
```

### Mistral:7b (Mac1)
```

```

## All round logs
- /Users/stevestudio2/.claude/skills/claude-codex/runs/yolo-animals-iter4-20260503-235131/round_1/
- /Users/stevestudio2/.claude/skills/claude-codex/runs/yolo-animals-iter4-20260503-235131/round_2/