← back to Commercialrealestate
5x: final REPORT — clean twice (sweeps 4-5) with strengthened gate after contrarian caught 3 real defects in sweep 3
2f5592ef58ff21be00daacf0a7c3c60f6c99adc6 · 2026-06-28 22:12:59 -0700 · Steve
Files touched
M 5x/REPORT.mdA 5x/sweep-4.rawA 5x/sweep-5.raw
Diff
commit 2f5592ef58ff21be00daacf0a7c3c60f6c99adc6
Author: Steve <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date: Sun Jun 28 22:12:59 2026 -0700
5x: final REPORT — clean twice (sweeps 4-5) with strengthened gate after contrarian caught 3 real defects in sweep 3
---
5x/REPORT.md | 56 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-----------------------
5x/sweep-4.raw | 15 +++++++++++++++
5x/sweep-5.raw | 15 +++++++++++++++
3 files changed, 63 insertions(+), 23 deletions(-)
diff --git a/5x/REPORT.md b/5x/REPORT.md
index 003db4e..d766951 100644
--- a/5x/REPORT.md
+++ b/5x/REPORT.md
@@ -1,31 +1,41 @@
# /5x REPORT — http://127.0.0.1:9911/deals.html (Deal Intelligence dashboard)
## Sweep-by-sweep ledger
-| Sweep | Six-way core | Real defects caught | Fixed | Commit |
-|---|---|---|---|---|
-| 1 | 6/6 PASS (0 JS errors) | 0 real (gap: no interactive controls) | Added live Refresh + pipeline metric toggle (Deals⇄Median $); refactored to pull()/draw() with chart-destroy guards | `7a4f457` |
-| 2 | 6/6 PASS (0 JS errors) | 0 real | — (sweep-1 fix held + verified) | — |
+| Sweep | Six-way core | Strong gate (deals-assert) | Real defects caught | Fix | Commit |
+|---|---|---|---|---|---|
+| 1 | 6/6 · 0 JS err | — | dashboard was static (no controls) | live Refresh + Deals⇄Median$ toggle; pull()/draw() + chart-destroy guards | `7a4f457` |
+| 2 | 6/6 · 0 JS err | — | (premature "clean twice") | — | — |
+| **contrarian gate** | — | — | **3 real, verifier-invisible**: (a) `medAll` ÷0 → "$NaN" tile; (b) `grad()` undefined-color crash SWALLOWED by pull().catch on empty data → 5 charts silently un-rendered; (c) sweeps only asserted `.glass.tile` exists, never that charts drew data | — | — |
+| 3 | — | built + PASS | fixed (a)+(b)+(c) | NaN guards (medAll/F.money/F.num/countUp); harden `grad()`; controls made verifier-discoverable; **new `deals-assert.js`** = charts-drew-data + empty-data + no-NaN gate | `292b7fb` |
+| 4 | 6/6 · 0 JS err | PASS | 0 | — | — |
+| 5 | 6/6 · 0 JS err | PASS | 0 | — | — |
-**Result: clean twice → DONE.** Halted at sweep 2 (stop condition met; not the 5-cap).
+**Result: clean twice (sweeps 4 & 5) with the STRENGTHENED gate → DONE.** Stop condition met, not the 5-cap.
-## Final six-way state
-- M1 HTTP 200 · M2 render (not blank) · M3 E2E 0 JS errors · B4/B5/B6 Chrome+Safari+Firefox parity. **6/6.**
-- Sweep-1 controls independently verified: count⇄median toggle re-sorts + relabels; Refresh re-pulls live data
- and re-draws all 6 charts with no Chart.js "canvas already in use" leak; 0 JS errors throughout.
+## What the contrarian gate changed (the real value of this /5x run)
+The first "clean twice" (sweeps 1–2) was clean against a WEAK assertion (`.glass.tile` present = 4 divs exist).
+/contrarian proved that bar was the floor, not the bar: it would pass on an empty page rendering "$NaN".
+Three real defects were hiding under it:
+1. **`medAll` divide-by-zero** — with no priced segment, the "Median deal size" tile rendered `$NaN`. Fixed:
+ filter to `med>0` and guard the denominator; `F.money`/`F.num`/`countUp` now reject non-finite → "—"/0.
+2. **Swallowed `grad()` crash** — on empty/edge data `grad()` did `undefined+'33'`, threw inside Chart.js,
+ and `pull().catch` ate it silently, leaving only 1 of 6 charts drawn. Fixed: `grad()` falls back to `#888888`
+ for a non-string color. Empty-data now renders all 6 charts (empty) with 0 errors, tile reads `$0` not `$NaN`.
+3. **Verification too weak** — added `5x/deals-assert.js`: asserts all 6 `Chart.getChart()` instances exist
+ with `data.length>0` (NORMAL), AND that the mocked all-endpoints-empty path shows no NaN tile and throws
+ no JS error. This is the gate `--selector` could never be.
-## What sweep 1 actually improved
-The dashboard was static (render-once). It now has two real, useful controls — a live **Refresh** (re-pull +
-redraw) and a **Deals ⇄ Median $** pipeline toggle — making "dynamic charts" genuinely dynamic.
+## Final state (verified)
+- Six-way: M1 200 · M2 render · M3 0 JS err · B4/B5/B6 Chrome+Safari+Firefox. 6/6, twice.
+- Strong gate: NORMAL → 6/6 charts with data (8/4/6/8/10/8 pts), tiles real, 0 NaN, 0 err. EMPTY → 6/6 charts
+ created empty, tiles `$0`, 0 NaN, 0 err, asof "0 properties · updated just now".
+- Controls independently verified: count⇄median re-sorts+relabels; Refresh re-pulls + redraws all 6 (no
+ Chart.js double-init); 0 JS errors.
## Open / escalated (NOT deals.html defects)
-1. **clickthrough.js is hardcoded to the curator apps.** It probes only `#fSearch` and `.vbtn.{dw,wpb,both,skip}`
- (clickthrough.js:91-97) and does not auto-discover generic controls, so its Phase-C reports 6 FAILs on ANY
- app lacking those exact selectors — including this one. These are false-negatives, not build defects.
- - *Recommendation (not done — shared skill, affects all /3x+/5x users):* make clickthrough.js auto-discover
- `button, [role=button], select, input` generically and assert 0 new JS errors per click, instead of
- hardwiring curator selectors. Would let Phase C exercise deals.html's real Refresh/toggle controls.
-2. Did NOT modify the shared skill unprompted (gate: shared tooling other sessions rely on). Flagged for Steve.
-
-## Honest stop statement
-No real defect remains open on deals.html. The only FAILs are a verifier limitation in clickthrough.js, proven
-by source inspection — not a fault in the page. Chasing them would be gaming, which /5x forbids.
+- **clickthrough.js hardcoded probes** (`#fSearch`, `.vbtn.{dw,wpb,both,skip}`, lines 91-97) FAIL on any
+ non-curator app — unavoidable false-negatives. CORRECTION to sweep-1/2 notes: the agent DOES auto-discover
+ some controls (`.seg button`, `header .btn`, `select`), so I added `seg`/`btn` classes to make Refresh+toggle
+ reachable — but the 6 hardcoded probes still fail by construction. Not chased (gaming forbidden).
+ *Recommendation (shared skill, not edited unprompted):* replace the hardcoded curator selectors with generic
+ `button,[role=button],select` discovery + per-click 0-new-error assertion.
diff --git a/5x/sweep-4.raw b/5x/sweep-4.raw
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..5125948
--- /dev/null
+++ b/5x/sweep-4.raw
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
+
+/3x — verifying http://127.0.0.1:9911/deals.html
+
+Phase A — 3 unique methods:
+ [PASS] M1 HTTP contract request layer — HTTP 200 text/html
+ [PASS] M2 headless render render layer — screenshot 298KB → /var/folders/2n/jmw9_4v56_x4m3539tr4v0lr0000gn/T/3x-NhDD3c/render.png
+ [PASS] M3 automation E2E interaction layer — 4×".glass.tile", 0 JS errors
+
+Phase B — 3 browsers (cross-browser):
+ [PASS] B4 Google Chrome cross-browser — automated render OK
+ [PASS] B5 Safari cross-browser — automated render OK
+ [PASS] B6 Firefox cross-browser — automated render OK
+
+ RESULT → 6/6 passed
+ artifacts: /var/folders/2n/jmw9_4v56_x4m3539tr4v0lr0000gn/T/3x-NhDD3c
diff --git a/5x/sweep-5.raw b/5x/sweep-5.raw
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..d2a36ab
--- /dev/null
+++ b/5x/sweep-5.raw
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
+
+/3x — verifying http://127.0.0.1:9911/deals.html
+
+Phase A — 3 unique methods:
+ [PASS] M1 HTTP contract request layer — HTTP 200 text/html
+ [PASS] M2 headless render render layer — screenshot 302KB → /var/folders/2n/jmw9_4v56_x4m3539tr4v0lr0000gn/T/3x-jetiEn/render.png
+ [PASS] M3 automation E2E interaction layer — 4×".glass.tile", 0 JS errors
+
+Phase B — 3 browsers (cross-browser):
+ [PASS] B4 Google Chrome cross-browser — automated render OK
+ [PASS] B5 Safari cross-browser — automated render OK
+ [PASS] B6 Firefox cross-browser — automated render OK
+
+ RESULT → 6/6 passed
+ artifacts: /var/folders/2n/jmw9_4v56_x4m3539tr4v0lr0000gn/T/3x-jetiEn
← 292b7fb 5x sweep 3 (contrarian-gated): fix medAll ÷0 → $NaN tile; gu
·
back to Commercialrealestate
·
5x: overnight refinement night-log + queue 14b36ac →