`data.json`

734 lines
[
{
"file": "2026-08-31-TK10978-pr-momentum-567-add-yard-pilot.md",
"ticket": "TK-10978",
"title": "PR/Momentum 567-product add-yard recovery \u2014 20-product live pilot",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 86,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "20 products (pilot); 567 cohort",
"panel_rationale": [
"Per-product live guards + prestate + rollback-all.mjs make each add reversible via DELETE undo",
"20-product pilot with hold-again before the 547 remainder is correct bounded staging",
"Pricing $48.58-$71.60/yd is real money \u2014 pin hw_price vs retail_price before scaling"
],
"dissent": "'Sold Per Yard' uses inventory_policy=continue with no verified inventory \u2014 mispriced/oversellable variant is real exposure at 567 scale",
"next_action": "Run the 20-product pilot --limit=20 --live, verify all 20, HOLD before the remaining 547"
},
{
"file": "TK-11018-carnegie-metafield-backfill.md",
"ticket": "TK-11018",
"title": "Carnegie metafield + MFR backfill (3 real fields + 34 Arctic mfr)",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 88,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "~5,907 products / ~13,280 metafields",
"panel_rationale": [
"Snapshot-first + metafieldsSet replay / metafieldDelete undo is fully reversible; join key verified 99.1%",
"Fills only 3 genuinely-real fields + 34 Arctic mfr; correctly BLOCKS color/durability fabrication",
"Writes dwc.* leaving legacy global.* \u2014 two live schema gens, acceptable churn-avoidance"
],
"dissent": "dw_sku metafield is 0/5,962 today \u2014 stamping DWAG- onto 5,907 is a large net-new field; a stale join stamps a wrong dw_sku",
"next_action": "Snapshot-first in <=500 batches (>=90s gap), verify batch 1 joins, then proceed"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-31-TK-10519-tiktok-golive-steve-portal.md",
"ticket": "TK-10519",
"title": "TikTok DW Marketing \u2014 one portal session to go live",
"gate_class": "identity",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 90,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1 TikTok channel (DW Marketing app)",
"panel_rationale": [
"All local prep done + verified \u2014 nothing left an agent CAN do",
"Every remaining step is a TikTok portal write + DW OAuth authorize = identity/external, Steve-only",
"SELF_ONLY sandbox posts are private + portal-undoable, so risk is low"
],
"dissent": "The demo-video chicken/egg could stall Steve mid-session; Part D review is days-to-weeks",
"next_action": "Do Part A (attach icon + Save) then Part B (add DW as Sandbox Target User + Authorize) on developers.tiktok.com"
},
{
"file": "TK-00058-muralsource-canary-launchd-install-2026-08-31.md",
"ticket": "TK-00058",
"title": "Install Muralsource off-Shopify guard (launchd)",
"gate_class": "scheduled-job",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 94,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1 launchd job (2 fires/day, read-only)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Canary already built + ran clean; emits correct fleet-health vocabulary; only automates a read-only check",
"Read-only Shopify GET twice daily, zero writes; closes Cody's real hardening gap",
"Scheduled-job install is hard-gated but blast radius is minimal; bootout+rm reverses it"
],
"dissent": "Read-only canary with trivial undo \u2014 arguably friction-level gating, but scheduled-job install is an explicit hard-gate class",
"next_action": "launchctl bootstrap the com.steve.muralsource-offshopify-canary.plist, kickstart to verify one run"
},
{
"file": "TK-11029-maya-rep-width-request.md",
"ticket": "TK-11029",
"title": "Maya Romanoff rep \u2014 width request for 2 discontinued SKUs",
"gate_class": "email",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 82,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1 email, 2 SKUs",
"panel_rationale": [
"Draft is clean; the 2 SKUs are correctly web-unrecoverable (collection 404s)",
"Send-to-list/outward = hard-gated AND under the standing 'do not send emails' rule \u2014 cannot auto-run",
"Recipient address is a blank placeholder \u2014 cannot send as-is; needs the rep email first"
],
"dissent": "BLOCK is defensible \u2014 TK stays open on just 2 harmless width-less rows; may not be worth sending",
"next_action": "Supply the current Maya rep email, then say 'send it' to route via steve-office George"
},
{
"file": "TK-11036-usre-prod-redeploy-023.md",
"ticket": "TK-11036",
"title": "usre prod \u2014 apply migrations 020-023 to live box",
"gate_class": "prod-db",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 80,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "prod DB (usrealestate, 382k brokers) \u2014 4 additive migrations",
"panel_rationale": [
"Path A applies 4 idempotent ledger-tracked migrations; 020-022 additive, only 023 behavior-relevant (DELETE-survival FK)",
"Prod is healthy, not urgent \u2014 Path A gets 023 with no code overwrite, far safer than v0.18->v0.22 Path B",
"Live-serving DB, but additive columns + endpoint 200-verify + column-drop rollback keep it bounded"
],
"dissent": "Path B full redeploy is a manual rsync overwrite of a live instance w/ no .deploy.conf \u2014 higher-risk trap; DEFER also valid",
"next_action": "Choose Path A: scp 02{0,1,2,3}_*.sql then ssh 'npm run migrate' via ! ; confirm endpoints stay 200"
},
{
"file": "cron-fire-canary-gated-dead-2026-08-31.md",
"ticket": "cron-fire-canary",
"title": "3 gated launchd jobs not firing \u2014 kickstart approval",
"gate_class": "scheduled-job",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 76,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "3 launchd jobs (one = sample-followup-SEND email)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Canary correctly refused to auto-kickstart; kickstart is reversible (bootout to stop)",
"Must split not blanket-approve \u2014 sample-followup-SEND hits the 'do not send emails' rule, must NOT kickstart",
"daily-overnight-skus + firm-phone-enrich lower-risk but confirm each safe first"
],
"dissent": "firm-phone-enrich/daily-overnight-skus may be silently broken (flat runs counter = crash) \u2014 check err.log, kickstart won't fix that",
"next_action": "Kickstart ONLY firm-phone-enrich + daily-overnight-skus (check err.logs); HOLD sample-followup-send"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-31-TK-10279-govarbitrage-app-review-rejection.md",
"ticket": "TK-10279",
"title": "GovArbitrage App Store review rejection \u2014 surface rejection text",
"gate_class": "identity",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 92,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1 iOS app v1.0 in Resolution Center",
"panel_rationale": [
"Mechanical prereqs pass; only the Apple-side rejection reason is unknown \u2014 no code fix knowable yet",
"Pure Steve console action (paste rejection text); no agent-fireable step",
"Correctly does NOT resubmit blind \u2014 invites a second bounce"
],
"dissent": "App may be waiting-on-Apple not us \u2014 confirm state isn't already re-review before Steve invests time",
"next_action": "Steve pastes full Resolution Center rejection text (guideline #) into TK-10279 before any resubmit"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-31-TK-10635-CONTAMINATED-DS-do-not-relink.md",
"ticket": "TK-10635",
"title": "Contaminated $4.25 price-override DS \u2014 do NOT re-link (variant-blind join)",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "BLOCK",
"confidence": 98,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "GMC primary feed / 38+ sample offers mispriced up to $1,312",
"panel_rationale": [
"Root cause proven \u2014 join by pid (variant-blind) stamps roll price onto shared-pid sample offers; $4.25 swatch -> $1,312 live",
"Link fired then correctly rolled back pre-reprocess; both ledgered, feed restored \u2014 guardrail memo, honor it",
"Re-linking as-built = customer-charge error + Merchant-Center suspension"
],
"dissent": "Verify the corrected variant-aware rebuild's genuine-roll-leak scope ('few dozen') before any relink \u2014 don't trust the estimate",
"next_action": "Do NOT relink; rebuild payload variant-aware (exclude Sample:/-sample), re-canary 0 sample offers touched, then gate relink"
},
{
"file": "GMC-remediation-trackA-trackB-runbook.md",
"ticket": "TK-10406/10993/10751",
"title": "GMC remediation Track A (kill auto-crawl offers) + Track B (drop-UK, add-CAD)",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 85,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "~17,252 CA/GB disapprovals + ~26.7k phantom offers",
"panel_rationale": [
"Each of A1/B1/B2 is console-only, reversible; order A-then-B stops regrowth first",
"B1 CAD shipping rate needs a real number; B2 reverses TK-10406's enable-UK on a 9/9 DTD verdict \u2014 needs explicit confirm",
"Track A must verify offer count drops by ~26.7k phantom, not the real catalog"
],
"dissent": "Confirm the DROP-UK verdict is still current business intent (vs enabling GBP) before B2 \u2014 the one business-owned fork",
"next_action": "Steve confirms CAD rate + DROP-UK intent, then fires A1->B1->B2 from consoles; re-run GMC canary"
},
{
"file": "TK-00058-fentucci-needs-width-clear-2026-08-31.md",
"ticket": "TK-00058",
"title": "Fentucci clear stale custom.needs_width flag (504 active)",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 90,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "504 live Fentucci metafield writes",
"panel_rationale": [
"Audit proves flag stale \u2014 all 504 carry a real uniform 36in width; script snapshot-first + idempotent + guarded",
"Reversible via snapshot re-set, $0 Admin API; only gate trigger is >500 cap + live-store touch",
"504 barely exceeds the 500 cap, uniform + internally-verifiable \u2014 low real risk"
],
"dissent": "Value is a display metafield not price/status \u2014 arguably below hard-gate threshold, but 504>500 + live-store rule holds it",
"next_action": "Fire dry-run -> --apply --limit=1 canary -> --apply all 504"
},
{
"file": "TK-00058-sanderson-publish-506-READY-2026-08-31.md",
"ticket": "TK-00058",
"title": "Sanderson publish 506 CLEAR products (UK duty repriced)",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 88,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "504 net-new creates + 2 upserts, 506 activations",
"panel_rationale": [
"Reprice done in staging (1.10 duty, snapshot+ledger); publishable-only payload (exactly 506) blocks the 81 settlement items",
"Reversible (created products archivable via created.jsonl; price restorable); Google channel excluded to dodge $4.25 mismatch",
"Settlement + 5-field + image gating enforced at activate"
],
"dissent": "Shared ~1k/day Shopify cap makes this multi-run/resumable \u2014 confirm dedup of the 2 existing Dalmatians drafts holds across resumes",
"next_action": "Fire canary create+golive --limit=1, eyeball live PDP, then full create --apply then golive --apply"
},
{
"file": "TK-10881-TOKEN-ROUTING-RUNBOOK.md",
"ticket": "TK-10979",
"title": "Route full-access Shopify token into scope-blocked write_inventory pipelines",
"gate_class": "identity",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 86,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "2 one-line script edits (var name flip)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Option A is surgical \u2014 flips SHOPIFY_ADMIN_TOKEN->SHOPIFY_FULL_ACCESS_TOKEN in 2 git-tracked files; edit fires nothing",
"git-revertible per file; Option B (global secrets swap) correctly rejected for fleet-wide blast",
"Broadens the live pipeline credential (identity-class) but the routing edit is inert; writes stay separately gated"
],
"dissent": "A scoped-broader default token is a standing footgun for future readers \u2014 add a comment noting why full-access is used",
"next_action": "Say 'route it' -> apply Option A 2-line edits; the write_inventory --apply runs stay separately gated"
},
{
"file": "TK-10286-wear-sales-live-golive.md",
"ticket": "TK-10286",
"title": "/wear apparel \u2014 flip real Stripe+Printful sales LIVE",
"gate_class": "spend",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 90,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "Live e-commerce: real card charges + POD fulfillment",
"panel_rationale": [
"Hard blocker is PRINTFUL_API_KEY \u2014 flipping WEAR_SALES_LIVE=1 without POD charges cards with no fulfillment",
"spend + customer-facing + deploy = always hard-gated; nothing fires until Steve does \u00a73",
"Polo margin thin @27% ship-absorbed; pricing decisions are business-owned + unresolved"
],
"dissent": "Printful costs are ESTIMATES until the key lands \u2014 real base cost could push polo margin negative",
"next_action": "Route PRINTFUL_API_KEY -> fetch exact costs -> decide shipping/polo pricing -> set 3 env flags + deploy + smoke one order"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-31-GMC-DEGRADED-CONSOLIDATED-durable-fix.md",
"ticket": "TK-10993",
"title": "GMC DEGRADED consolidated durable fix (Tracks A-E)",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 86,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "~26.7k orphan deletes; CA/GB shipping; ~6.5k publish",
"panel_rationale": [
"Diagnosis fresh, read-only, codex-confirmed; C+D already fired, so only A (crawl-off + bounded delete) and B (CAD/GBP) remain",
"A bundles a durable MC toggle with a large delete \u2014 enumerate to an exact deduped list before firing; don't approve as one blob",
"Track E blanket 12,422 publish is correctly self-BLOCKed (5,921 Carnegie at-cost must not go live)"
],
"dissent": "Crawl-off vs CAD/GBP near-equal leverage; B is the safer independent single-action win, land it first",
"next_action": "Approve B (Steve console); for A require enumerated deduped orphan list before delete; keep E blocked"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-31-TK10978-unbuyable-recovery-remaining-gated-menu.md",
"ticket": "TK-10978",
"title": "Unbuyable-recovery closed + remaining-work decision menu",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 90,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "Menu only; next = Rebel Walls 494 variant add",
"panel_rationale": [
"Decision menu not an auto-fire; ticket already CLOSED, 368 recovered w/ per-product DELETE undo",
"Reframe is sound: 23,269 of 24,844 unbuyable are correctly quote-only by design",
"Rebel Walls (494, per-m2 price staged, no spend/login) is the correct cheapest-first greenlight"
],
"dissent": "Rebel Walls per-m2 unit overlaps TK-10029 relabel judgment (280 roll/bolt) \u2014 confirm unit before the variant add",
"next_action": "Greenlight Rebel Walls 494 as scoped reversible win; Track B awaits Steve cost list"
},
{
"file": "TK-10999-stroheim-settlement-gate-BLOCKED-gemini-credits.md",
"ticket": "TK-10999",
"title": "Stroheim settlement-gate blocked on depleted Gemini credits",
"gate_class": "spend",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 95,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "471 imgs ~$0.52 Gemini; verdicts idempotent",
"panel_rationale": [
"Genuinely blocked externality: prepay $0, all 429 RESOURCE_EXHAUSTED, $0 billed, nothing published",
"Ran gate directly not resume.sh, so no customer-facing draft write fired",
"Re-run is idempotent + cheap; blocker is purely Steve billing top-up"
],
"dissent": "None material \u2014 wait-on-Steve billing action, not a technical decision",
"next_action": "Top up Gemini prepay credits, then re-run settlement-gate.mjs --apply"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-31-TK-11026-firecities-agentabrams-alias.md",
"ticket": "TK-11026",
"title": "firecities.agentabrams.com short-alias (DNS + vhost)",
"gate_class": "dns",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 88,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1 CF A-record + server_name + nginx reload",
"panel_rationale": [
"Cosmetic shorter-share alias to an already-live hub; paste-ready + rollback-documented",
"Safe default (keep Basic-Auth gated, matching firecities.crcp) is the conservative choice",
"DNS + nginx reload hard-gated by rule but low-risk + independently reversible"
],
"dissent": "Low value (skippable per memo itself) \u2014 could be deferred behind higher-ROI items",
"next_action": "Run the 4 paste steps (CF A-record, HUB_PAGES, server_name, nginx reload) keeping auth gated"
},
{
"file": "dedup-DRYRUN-20260831.md",
"ticket": "\u2014",
"title": "Catalog dedup dry-run (0 clean pairs, 1265 held)",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 92,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "0 archives this run; live path gated behind LIVE-dedup touch",
"panel_rationale": [
"Dry-run is read-only + self-restraining: 0 clean pairs, 1265 ambiguous HELD, nothing auto-archived",
"Restore-map written before any archive + ACTIVE->ARCHIVED only = fully reversible",
"Going live is a separate manual gate (touch LIVE-dedup) \u2014 no fire requested"
],
"dissent": "With 0 clean pairs the report is a no-op; verify the descriptive-keeper heuristic before any future live run",
"next_action": "No action \u2014 informational; do not touch LIVE-dedup until worklist CSV is reviewed"
},
{
"file": "local-model-upgrade-2026-08-31.md",
"ticket": "\u2014",
"title": "Local model upgrade -> official Qwen3.8-27B-8bit",
"gate_class": "other",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 80,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "~27GB one-time HF download; no default swap until A/B",
"panel_rationale": [
"Official mlx-community 8-bit, verified HTTP 200, fits 96GB M3 Ultra, avoids abliterated fork",
"No spend (bandwidth/disk); default stays Qwen3.6-35B until A/B proves the swap",
"Download command correctly Steve-gated, not auto-run"
],
"dissent": "Pure disk/bandwidth $0 API arguably clears the reversibility tier \u2014 but leaving the swap gated is right",
"next_action": "Run the huggingface-cli pull, then A/B vs Qwen3.6-35B before making it the standing default"
},
{
"file": "TK-11002-COMMERCE-MORNING-DECISIONS.md",
"ticket": "TK-11002",
"title": "Commerce morning decision queue (overnight)",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 84,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "TK-10029 relabel 1467; TK-10209 GMC publish 132",
"panel_rationale": [
"Clean overnight run: 0 emails/$0/0 writes, each item verified read-only",
"TK-10029 Swipe B (apply 1187 unambiguous first, confirm the 280 roll/bolt unit before those) is the conservative path \u2014 don't blanket-apply 1467",
"Correctly declined to self-escalate to full-access token for theme/content scopes"
],
"dissent": "TK-10209 GMC publish of 132 O&L is external-publish and should sequence AFTER the GMC disapproval floor (TK-10993 A/B) lands",
"next_action": "Approve TK-10029 Swipe B; hold TK-10209 until GMC Tracks A/B land; leave token routing to Steve"
},
{
"file": "070926-gmc-orphan-reconcile-2026-08-31.md",
"ticket": "gmc-orphan-reconcile",
"title": "GMC orphan reconcile \u2014 80 new orphans, 10 auto-deleted",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 78,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "<=80 GMC offers (10 auto-fired, 70 gated)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Reversible \u2014 archived offer re-adds via the normal feed; deletes hit dead/archived landings only",
"Option 1 (10 account-health, $4.25-on-dead-landing) is the real suspension risk and clears cleanly",
"Memo already auto-fired 10 Content-API deletes under a prior standing approval \u2014 verify those 10 were account-health class"
],
"dissent": "Some 'approved'+$4.25 rows self-expire in 30 days; deleting an approved offer is a small opportunity cost",
"next_action": "Approve option 1 (account-health list) only; hold option 2 pending a per-vendor spot-check of the Maharam 35"
},
{
"file": "TK-10981-job1-innovations-mfrsku-backfill.md",
"ticket": "TK-10981",
"title": "Innovations mfr_sku backfill (13 archived rows)",
"gate_class": "dw_unified-write",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 88,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "13 rows, all ARCHIVED",
"panel_rationale": [
"The 13 codes share provenance with the KNOWN-corrupted scrape \u2014 shape-plausible is not proof; fabrication risk",
"All 13 ARCHIVED = zero customer-facing urgency, no cost to waiting for an authoritative re-scrape",
"Codex second-opinion + the memo author itself recommend HOLD"
],
"dissent": "Write IS reversible (old value recorded), so fire-then-revert-if-wrong is technically low-risk",
"next_action": "Hold; fold the 13 into a future authoritative Innovations re-scrape that corroborates each code"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-30-TK-10981-junk-mfr-sku-repair.md",
"ticket": "TK-10981",
"title": "Canonical mfr_sku cleanup \u2014 13 recover, 4,009 to NULL",
"gate_class": "dw_unified-write",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 72,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "4,022 shopify_products rows (391 ACTIVE)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Transactional design is sound (immutable restore-map, locked ID set, count asserts, auto-rollback)",
"The 13-row recovery conflicts with the sibling JOB1 HOLD \u2014 same suspected-corrupt codes, should NOT write them",
"391 ACTIVE rows go junk-token -> NULL \u2014 confirm GMC feed + go-live gate treat NULL no worse than 'TRUE'"
],
"dissent": "Nulling the 4,009 could be split out + auto-run as reversible cleanup, deferring only the 13 contested recoveries",
"next_action": "Revise: drop the 13 recoveries (per JOB1 HOLD), execute only the 4,009->NULL transaction with restore-map"
},
{
"file": "TK-10832-pj-mailer-presend-runbook.md",
"ticket": "TK-10832",
"title": "PJ Fall 2026 mailer pre-send runbook",
"gate_class": "email",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 90,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "CC trade-list send + DNS DKIM write",
"panel_rationale": [
"Runbook is a $0 checklist, nothing executed; the DKIM gap is correctly the blocking step-1",
"send-to-list + DNS write both hard-gated; must not go until DKIM aligns or Gmail munges the From (17529.5)",
"List-Unsubscribe one-click + suppression scrub unverified \u2014 bulk send without them risks compliance"
],
"dissent": "DMARC p=none already adequate for CC; the only true blocker is the CC Self-Auth DKIM CNAMEs \u2014 short path to sendable",
"next_action": "Hold send; run CC Self-Authentication -> add the 2 ctctN CNAMEs via the DNS agent, then test-send"
},
{
"file": "dw-doubleroll-lengthless-273-regression.md",
"ticket": "dw-doubleroll-canary",
"title": "273 new roll SKUs shipped without S/R+D/R lengths",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 80,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "413 length-less roll products + importer fix",
"panel_rationale": [
"Root-cause-first is correct \u2014 identify the vendor/importer (likely outside current VMAP tooling) before any backfill",
"The read-only dig needs no gate; only the metafield backfill is the gated customer-facing write",
"Evidence is a cached 13:26 canary verdict \u2014 re-verify with the token for the exact SKU/vendor list first"
],
"dissent": "Backfilling lengths without fixing the importer just re-accrues the backlog \u2014 the code fix must land first or in tandem",
"next_action": "Approve the read-only root-cause dig; return vendor mix + SKU list before authorizing the gated backfill"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-27-TK-10449-norma-ig-roster-past-35-DRAFT.md",
"ticket": "TK-10449",
"title": "Grow Norma IG roster past 35 (relinks + new accounts)",
"gate_class": "identity",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 83,
"reversible": false,
"blast_radius": "Meta fleet + never-expiring token (bulk-signup ban vector)",
"panel_rationale": [
"The drift finding (roster silently 35->34, @grasscloth unlinked) is real; its registry-regen auto-fix is reversible/ledgered",
"Phase 0/0b zero-signup relinks are low-risk, need only Steve's one Meta login; bulk new-account creation is the ban vector",
"New IG signups are irreversible identity actions under one Business Manager/IP \u2014 #1 trigger for Meta nuking the fleet"
],
"dissent": "Even Phase 0 relinks require the account-holder Connect, so nothing here is agent-executable regardless",
"next_action": "Approve only Phase 0 relinks (@grasscloth, @hospitalityfabrics); Steve does the Meta login; hold all new-account creation",
"escalated": {
"verdict": "A",
"vote": "6/6 unanimous",
"confidence": "high",
"note": "External 5-LLM panel CONFIRMS: Phase-0 relinks only, never batch new signups."
}
},
{
"file": "TK-10484-jeffrey-stevens-reonboard-RECONCILED.md",
"ticket": "TK-10484",
"title": "Jeffrey Stevens peel-and-stick re-onboard (reconciled)",
"gate_class": "spend",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 81,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "portal scrape (uncertain spend) + 74-SKU pricing",
"panel_rationale": [
"Critical path is a yorkwall/NuWallpaper trade-portal scrape \u2014 metered, uncertain spend that can exceed the $5 auto-cap",
"Reconcile corrected two stale claims; Item C archive is reversible/snapshot-backed and can go once cost is sourced",
"51 mfr codes + cost are locally unrecoverable \u2014 no fabrication (keep-old-never-mint); downstream blocks on the scrape"
],
"dissent": "Item C (archive 34 junk slug rows) is fully reversible + snapshot-backed and could be approved independently now",
"next_action": "Hold; run the gated /brewster yorkwall scrape to source cost + 51 codes, then price/activate"
},
{
"file": "TK-10096-dwyg-vahallan-filemaker-add.md",
"ticket": "TK-10096",
"title": "Add DWYG (Vahallan) line to FileMaker WALLPAPER master",
"gate_class": "other",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 83,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "394 FM WALLPAPER records in 303,886-row live master",
"panel_rationale": [
"Reconcile verified live; per-record before/after snapshots + combo-sku uniqueness make creates idempotent + repairs revertible",
"Quote-only mapping matches live storefront; contamination diagnosis (foreign FDG/F-codes) well-evidenced",
"No delete verb in MCP forces neutralize-via-update (option b) \u2014 accept for audit trail"
],
"dissent": "394-record bulk write to canonical FM master with no delete primitive; want a 5-SKU pilot create+verify first",
"next_action": "Approve Steps 1-2 via MCP + execute Step 3 as option (b) neutralize-update; pilot 5 creates first"
},
{
"file": "TK-10066-reid-witlin-onboarding-reconcile.md",
"ticket": "TK-10066",
"title": "Reid Witlin private-label onboarding reconcile + registry fix",
"gate_class": "prod-db",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 80,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1-row vendor_registry write now; ~922+34 Shopify onboarding deferred",
"panel_rationale": [
"Registry fix DWRK-->DWKR- is a bounded reversible 1-row write with recorded rollback \u2014 approvable in isolation",
"Vendor shrank 1071->149 \u2014 blind bulk onboarding would publish hundreds of discontinued SKUs; correct to hold",
"Shared DWKR- prefix with dormant Edelman needs the allow-map decision resolved same-time, else prefix canary fires"
],
"dissent": "The registry write could ship now on its own; bundling it behind the re-scrape over-gates a clean reversible fix",
"next_action": "Approve the 1-row registry SQL + Edelman allow-map option (a); run $0 rwltd re-scrape before any Shopify onboarding"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-27-TK10875-130-variant-datarepair.md",
"ticket": "TK-10875",
"title": "130 irregular unbuyable products \u2014 variant data-repair",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 78,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "130 live products (123 Ronald Redding + 5 Thibaut + 2 Cole & Son)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Three defect classes precisely characterized; restructure of live variants riskier than add but reversible",
"Revenue-recoverable mislabeled-sellable products \u2014 real upside; RR sample-priced-at-retail is a clear defect",
"Memo lacks explicit per-class rollback map + no pilot named \u2014 restructure touches live variants"
],
"dissent": "No stated rollback manifest or pilot; approve the PASS but require per-product before-state + pilot each class",
"next_action": "Route to vp-dw-commerce as gated batch; require per-product before-snapshot + one-SKU pilot per defect class"
},
{
"file": "carnegie-link-2075-2026-08-26.md",
"ticket": "TK-10901",
"title": "Carnegie mfr_sku/dw_sku recovery LINK from staging",
"gate_class": "prod-db",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 85,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "2,000 DUAL rows in Kamatera shopify_products (mfr_sku only)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Dual-key cross-validation 2000 agree / 0 disagree is strong; backup table + PRE/POST guards + one-line undo",
"APPROVE-MFR-ONLY recovers only the unambiguous real mfr code \u2014 pure keep-old-number recovery, no minting",
"DWAG- staging dw_sku resembles reverted mints \u2014 safe default leaves dw_sku blank pending Steve's ruling"
],
"dissent": "Kamatera-canonical shopify_products write = hard-gated per split-brain doctrine; 2,000 rows > caution even if reversible",
"next_action": "Approve APPROVE-MFR-ONLY (2,000 DUAL, mfr_sku only); hold dw_sku + the 395 SINGLE + 3,526 ambiguous"
},
{
"file": "sku-integrity-rescrape-scope-2026-08-26.md",
"ticket": "TK-10896",
"title": "Scope: recover canonical dw_sku for 15,577 blank rows, no minting",
"gate_class": "other",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 88,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "Scope/plan doc only \u2014 0 writes",
"panel_rationale": [
"Read-only scope classification A-E is sound and honors keep-old-never-mint; no execution requested",
"Identifies JOB 1 (~2.7k recoverable-now via self-copy/LINK) as the cheap clear win, defers the 11.3k re-scrape",
"Approving the SEQUENCING \u2014 each downstream write stays independently gated"
],
"dissent": "Per-vendor staging-LINK coverage is unmeasured (Romo probe empty) \u2014 JOB 1 sizing is optimistic until measured",
"next_action": "Approve the scope/sequencing; require per-vendor LINK-coverage measurement before each JOB 1 batch"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-26-MaharamSOURCE-price-load-plan.md",
"ticket": "MaharamSOURCE",
"title": "Load Maharam per-yard prices to Shopify + re-publish 1,429",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 72,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1,429 live DWAX- products: add variant + reprice + re-publish to Google",
"panel_rationale": [
"Staging + rollback manifest exist; each step reversible (variant delete, price revert, unpublish)",
"Assumed sell-at-list proceeds without the Maharam trade discount \u2014 margin unknown, could sell near cost",
"Re-publish to Google channel is external-publish (GMC) \u2014 hard-gated regardless of reversibility; $/yd unit unconfirmed"
],
"dissent": "Sell-at-list default risks thin/negative margin; a 1,429-product GMC re-publish on an unverified unit risks disapproval recurrence",
"next_action": "Confirm sell-at-list vs cost-markup + min-order increment, dry-run a handful, then gate GMC re-publish separately"
},
{
"file": "sku-integrity-phase2-phase4-2026-08-26.md",
"ticket": "TK-10896",
"title": "SKU backlog Phase 2 disposition + Phase 4 prefix decision aid",
"gate_class": "other",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 82,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "Decision-aid only \u2014 0 writes; Phase 4 = 12,590 rows pending rulings",
"panel_rationale": [
"Read-only analysis; Phase 2 correctly refuses to blind-fix collisions (would cement wrong identity)",
"Bucket B/C allocate INTO prefixes \u2014 sequential MINTING, collides with keep-old-never-mint",
"Phase 4's premise is the exact allocation Steve reverted 12,216 of; needs explicit prefix rulings"
],
"dissent": "Bucket A auto-adopt is trivially safe and could split off \u2014 but B/C minting means HOLD not APPROVE overall",
"next_action": "Hold for Steve's per-bucket prefix rulings (esp. Carnegie DWAG- 5,921, PR, Hollywood); do not allocate until ruled"
},
{
"file": "koroseal-quote-only-loadplan.md",
"ticket": "KoroSealSOURCE",
"title": "Koroseal quote-only load plan (no price/publish)",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 88,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "~2,448 active Koroseal; ~212 $4.25-leak fix",
"panel_rationale": [
"No cost column anywhere, cost/0.65/0.85 uncomputable; auto-pricing would fabricate a price",
"Option A (quote-only + fix $4.25 leak) is right; the leak is an active GMC-disapproval risk worth clearing",
"display_prices flip is a global-default column read by unknown storefronts \u2014 verify no regress before flipping"
],
"dissent": "2,448>500 means even the reversible metafield/leak fix should stage (25->verify->rest), not one bulk run",
"next_action": "Approve Option A; execute $4.25-leak fix + quote-flow wiring staged, hold pricing until dealer list ingested"
},
{
"file": "TK-10881-sdg-cadence-arm.md",
"ticket": "TK-10881",
"title": "Arm SDG daily-publish cadence launchd job (~5,800 products)",
"gate_class": "scheduled-job",
"verdict": "HOLD",
"confidence": 82,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "~4,620 live products over ~23 days, unattended",
"panel_rationale": [
"Gates well-built (settlement + 6-field + 0.85 auto-halt + rollback), but this is a perpetual unattended external-publish job",
"Hard-blocked on the sibling write_inventory scope anyway \u2014 arming now is premature",
"A self-perpetuating job publishing 200/day live has no human eyes per-batch; the auto-halt is self-graded"
],
"dissent": "Once scope lands + batch-1 proves clean, the auto-halt+ledger+rollback may justify arming \u2014 but not before",
"next_action": "Hold cadence until write_inventory granted and batch-1 ships clean; then re-review arming"
},
{
"file": "TK-10881-shopify-write-inventory-scope.md",
"ticket": "TK-10881",
"title": "Grant write_inventory scope to DW Shopify admin app",
"gate_class": "identity",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 90,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "one credential scope on live store admin app",
"panel_rationale": [
"Clean root-cause \u2014 403 write_inventory missing, scope lapsed since the 7/26 import; agent cannot self-grant",
"Low-risk additive scope, removable later, fully reversible; only Steve can do it in Shopify admin",
"Granting also silently re-enables the cadence + Hollywood job to write inventory \u2014 confirm those consumers intended"
],
"dissent": "Approving the scope implicitly greenlights every inventory-writing job on the token \u2014 decouple approval from arming the cadence",
"next_action": "Approve scope grant; if token rotates route new token via secrets skill and finish batch-1 only"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-26-TK-10878-phase1-add-disk.md",
"ticket": "TK-10878",
"title": "Grow Kamatera Postgres volume >=100GB before pg_partman",
"gate_class": "spend",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 85,
"reversible": false,
"blast_radius": "one Kamatera prod volume resize; recurring monthly spend",
"panel_rationale": [
"Box ~90% full, partman rewrite needs ~table-sized scratch, must grow before converting or it stalls prod",
"Recurring monthly cost + can't-easily-shrink resize make this a genuine spend decision for Steve",
"No data risk, but confirm the resize targets the correct PG mount (not just /)"
],
"dissent": "Adding disk treats the symptom; verify the 16GB/wk growth is truly unprunable before perpetual storage spend",
"next_action": "Approve >=100GB grow; verify df on the PG mount shows >=75GB free, then draft Phase 2",
"escalated": {
"verdict": "C",
"vote": "4C / 2A",
"confidence": "med-high",
"note": "External panel REFINES approve->C: grow >=100GB now AND add a retention/prune policy after."
}
},
{
"file": "2026-08-26-philromano-samples-and-price.md",
"ticket": "TK-10872",
"title": "Phillipe Romano/MDC: add Sample variants + make $0 non-orderable",
"gate_class": "shopify-write",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 84,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "1,280 live PR/MDC products (lamp excluded)",
"panel_rationale": [
"restore-original.json before each PUT + additive contact-for-price tag = fully reversible; lamp anomaly excluded via price==0 filter",
"Closing a live $0-orderable hole across 1,280 SKUs is real value + a GMC risk; DTD 8/8 for Option A",
"1,280>500 must stage (25->verify PDP live->rest); display_variant tag preservation re-checked on the pilot"
],
"dissent": "Sample-price $4.25 vs task-text $0.25 is an unresolved fork \u2014 proceed on $4.25 default but flag reversible if wrong",
"next_action": "Approve staged 25-item pilot w/ price/prefix guard + display_variant preservation; verify live, then remainder"
},
{
"file": "2026-08-26-chargeandexplore-4.3-spam-resubmit.md",
"ticket": "chargeandexplore-release",
"title": "Charge & Explore 4.3-spam rejection resubmit strategy",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "REVISE",
"confidence": 72,
"reversible": false,
"blast_radius": "App Store account (9 apps) suspension risk; EAS spend; app deletion",
"panel_rationale": [
"P0 account-hygiene insight correct \u2014 resubmitting under a live duplicate-calculator pattern risks 4.3(a) escalation",
"P0 app deletion is destructive+irreversible, P1 is metered EAS spend, Submit is an Apple-account write \u2014 3 distinct gates bundled",
"A UX rebuild may still not overturn a saturated-category 4.3"
],
"dissent": "Don't delete the calculator app \u2014 de-emphasize/differentiate or withdraw C&E instead; deletion is the least-reversible lever",
"next_action": "Split into 3 separate gated approvals; get Steve's explicit call on the app-deletion lever before any resubmit",
"escalated": {
"verdict": "A",
"vote": "4A / 2B (split)",
"confidence": "medium",
"note": "External panel FLIPS to A (delete duplicate, then resubmit) vs the Claude-panel B. Human-gated: confirm the calc app has no independent value before the irreversible delete."
}
},
{
"file": "2026-08-25-dw-reels-ig-accounts-wireup.md",
"ticket": "dw-marketing-reels",
"title": "DW Reels IG accounts wireup \u2014 deploy + 5 missing IG accounts",
"gate_class": "publish",
"verdict": "APPROVE",
"confidence": 86,
"reversible": true,
"blast_radius": "one prod deploy to marketing.dw; 5 IG-account creations (Steve-only)",
"panel_rationale": [
"Root-cause correct \u2014 one shared page token authorizes all 35; the '(needs creds)' label was a union artifact; fix committed + DRY-verified",
"Deploy is git-revertable, no data/spend/DNS; posting stays gated behind SOCIAL_LIVE_ARMED",
"Confirm the deploy doesn't flip SOCIAL_LIVE_ARMED + the 5 pending brands genuinely have no IG account"
],
"dissent": "The @philipperomano vs @philliperomanodesigns duplicate needs a keep/drop decision before creating a placeholder identity",
"next_action": "Approve the /deploy (posting stays gated); hold the 5 IG-account creations, resolve the PR handle duplicate first"
}
]