`5x/REPORT.md`

30 lines
# 5x Report — Carnegie product 7923134693427

## Verdict

**FIX FIRST** — the Carnegie SKU itself is complete and its shopper-visible controls work, but the optional cross-domain enrichment endpoint is returning HTTP 503, preventing a clean `/5x` result.

| Sweep | Six-way state | Caught | Fixed | Commit |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
| 1 | 5/7 | 3 | 2 harness root causes | shared ignored skill file; no project commit |
| 2 | 6/7 | 1 | 0 (production-gated) | report commit |

## Final state

- PASS: HTTP, headless render, Chrome, Safari, Firefox, full visible-control click-through.
- PASS: five gallery images and all five thumbnail interactions.
- PASS: title, Carnegie brand, DW SKU, variants, and persisted specification content.
- OPEN: `grassclothwallpaper.com/dw-api/enrich` returns 503.

## Contrarian gate

- Engineer: FIX FIRST — a production dependency is red even though fallback content works.
- Designer: SHIP IT — the product presentation and five-image gallery are intact.
- User: SHIP IT — title, SKU, specifications, variants, and images are usable.
- Skeptic: FIX FIRST — calling a dead endpoint on every product view is unresolved operational debt.
- Strategist: FIX FIRST — restore or remove the dependency before claiming the storefront is clean.

Vote: 3× FIX FIRST, 2× SHIP IT. Strongest dissent: the visible product journey is already complete; however `/5x` explicitly requires zero defects, so the committed verdict is **FIX FIRST**.

Highest-leverage next action: approve restoration of the production enrichment service (or removal of the obsolete theme call), then rerun until two consecutive clean sweeps.