`5x/REPORT.md`

56 lines
# /5x REPORT — https://govarbitrage.agentabrams.com (live, 2026-07-13 ~09:30 PT)

Target: all public surfaces, live through cloudflared tunnel → pm2 govarbitrage :3737.
Stop condition reached: TWO consecutive clean sweeps (sweeps 1 & 2, 0 defects each).

## Sweep 1 — six-way + all-path + console
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| 3x runner on /newsletter (M1 HTTP, M2 headless render, M3 Playwright E2E, B4 Chrome, B5 Safari, B6 Firefox, clickthrough) | 7/7 PASS, 0 JS errors, subscribe button exercised |
| /newsletter /deals /deals/2026-07-13 /pricing /sitemap.xml /robots.txt — HTTP + content | all 200 + expected content |
| /login | 200; client-rendered — headless confirmed 1 password + 1 email input (curl-grep false alarm, harness limitation not a defect) |
| Console errors (5 pages, headless networkidle) | 0 on all |
| /pricing tier prices | $12 + $29 render |
| sitemap.xml \<loc\> base | public origin, no localhost leak |
| Rate-limit IP source | reads x-forwarded-for (cloudflared supplies real client IP) — no shared-bucket trap |

Defects caught: 0. Fixes: none needed.

## Sweep 2 — API behavior + six-way on /deals
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| POST subscribe bad email | 400 |
| POST subscribe honeypot filled | fake-OK 200, NO outbox entry (no send) |
| GET confirm bogus/missing token | 404 / 400 |
| GET unsubscribe bogus token | 404 |
| /listings (auth-walled page) publicly | 307 → login |
| /api/listings publicly | 401 |
| 3x runner on /deals | 7/7 PASS, 0 JS errors |

Defects caught: 0. Fixes: none needed.

## Final state
All six verification layers green on both entry pages; API validation, token handling,
honeypot, rate-limit plumbing, auth wall, sitemap, robots all correct on the LIVE origin.
Site stayed live the whole time (no restarts needed — no fixes required).

Open items (not defects): 0 CONFIRMED subscribers until Steve clicks his confirm link;
0 deals currently clear the hot-deal gate (empty-state renders honestly).

## Contrarian gate → FIX FIRST → fixed (sweeps 3-4)
Contrarian caught 3 gaps the clean sweeps missed:
1. /newsletter had ZERO OG/social tags (acquisition page unfurled blank) → openGraph +
   twitter metadata added; 5 og: tags verified live.
2. "Launching soon" copy became a lie once the digest went live → present-tense honest
   copy on page + confirm email; stale copy verified gone.
3. localhost fallback in sendDigestToSubscribers could put localhost unsubscribe links in
   a real email → live mode now throws unless NEWSLETTER_BASE_URL is https; verified.
Resilience chain verified (not a code fix): tunnel plist KeepAlive+RunAtLoad,
com.steve.pm2-resurrect, govarbitrage in pm2 dump. Shared-tunnel SPOF documented as
accepted infra (dedicated tunnel = future option).

## Sweeps 3-4 (post-fix)
Sweep 3: fixes verified live (OG ×5, honest copy, guard passes with https base) — clean.
Sweep 4: 3x runner /newsletter 7/7, console clean on 4 pages — clean.
STOP: two consecutive clean sweeps AFTER fixes. Final verdict: stable.