Document DTD split vote and completed closing conditions

149eea98065a1d1c7c83dc696ed55ceb15eec6ed · 2026-09-10 20:33:00 -0700 · Steve Abrams

Files touched

A data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260911T0302Z.1CLFdX/DTD-VERDICTS.md

Diff

commit 149eea98065a1d1c7c83dc696ed55ceb15eec6ed
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date:   Thu Sep 10 20:33:00 2026 -0700

    Document DTD split vote and completed closing conditions
---
 .../cycle-20260911T0302Z.1CLFdX/DTD-VERDICTS.md    | 28 ++++++++++++++++++++++
 1 file changed, 28 insertions(+)

diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260911T0302Z.1CLFdX/DTD-VERDICTS.md b/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260911T0302Z.1CLFdX/DTD-VERDICTS.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..13c25ceb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260911T0302Z.1CLFdX/DTD-VERDICTS.md
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
+# DTD verdicts — bounded cycle0302
+
+## Increment decision: A — isolated WebKit causal reproduction
+
+Confidence: medium. Vote:2/2 valid families; availability2/6. Mandatory post-decision Codex debate: KEEP. Prosecutor warned that passing revised timing alone does not establish causality. Defender required the same app, state and request policy with original failures retained. Judge accepted the bounded investigation subject to those controls.
+
+## Final decision: FIX-THEN-SHIP — closing conditions now satisfied
+
+Confidence: medium for isolated acceptance. Initial vote:1 SHIP,1 HOLD; availability2/6. Preliminary tie resolved to SHIP because acceptance explicitly excluded public adoption. Mandatory post-decision Codex debate: OVERTURN, replacement FIX-THEN-SHIP. Judge agreed the helper could be accepted separately from public readiness, but required the unfinished closing checks and ledger first. Parent then completed the realHTTP stuck/released-request checks in both engines, health200/auth401, canonical order, guard/source/memo preservation, and exact-one ledger append/readback.
+
+| Model reference | Runtime actually used | Model | Increment vote | Final vote |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| Claude | Disabled; not invoked | None | Abstain | Abstain |
+| Codex | Codex CLI, existing plan | Runtime model not independently attested | A | SHIP |
+| Qwen | Local Ollama, Mac1 | qwen3:14b | A | HOLD-FOR-STEVE |
+| Grok | Unavailable; no provider call | None | Abstain | Abstain |
+| Kimi | Unavailable; no provider call | None | Abstain | Abstain |
+| Muse | Local endpoint unavailable | muse-spark-1.2 requested | Abstain | Abstain |
+
+## Dissent
+
+Increment: none among valid votes. Final: Qwen emphasized unfinished wider readiness and the outstanding closing work. Its deployment concern does not expand the expressly isolated acceptance scope, and its ownership-defect claim was already corrected. The post-decision prosecutor correctly identified the remaining mandatory closing obligations; those were completed rather than waived.
+
+## Why this verdict
+
+Independent original/candidate app checks, realHTTP negative checks, and12 recorded Browse actions support the precise recorder correction. The full recorded journey still has one Licensing Preview readiness timeout; three narrower replays do not disprove it. FullCTA and source public readiness remain FAIL/PARTIAL. No adoption, deployment, attestation, send, external write or source closure is authorized.
+
+Raw voters and debates are retained in `dtd-increment/` and `dtd-final/`. Closing evidence is in `verification/e2e-proof.json` and `ledger-append-proof.json`.

← 8ec9c971 Record ordered cycle and verified Browse recorder correction · back to Ticket System · Record bounded cycle ledger and exact ordered dispositions bd72990d →