← back to Ticket System
Record TK-11197 evidence-only hold cycle
430e75050bf76b7e7a76d2ea7693a1dc1403ee50 · 2026-09-03 13:01:16 -0700 · Steve Abrams
Files touched
A data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11197-20260903T1959Z/e2e-proof.jsonM data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
Diff
commit 430e75050bf76b7e7a76d2ea7693a1dc1403ee50
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date: Thu Sep 3 13:01:16 2026 -0700
Record TK-11197 evidence-only hold cycle
---
.../TK-11197-20260903T1959Z/e2e-proof.json | 53 ++++++++++++++++++++++
data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl | 1 +
2 files changed, 54 insertions(+)
diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11197-20260903T1959Z/e2e-proof.json b/data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11197-20260903T1959Z/e2e-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b7eac0cd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11197-20260903T1959Z/e2e-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
+{
+ "intent": "Prove one bounded zero-cost yoloforever cycle that found no safe reversible ungated non-colliding pickup and therefore retained a timestamped HOLD without touching underlying work.",
+ "risk_tier": "R0",
+ "environment": "Mac2 local ticket system; canonical event ledger and ticketmaster selector",
+ "ticket": "TK-11197-codex-yoloforever-bounded-monitoring-cyc",
+ "timestamp": "2026-09-03T19:59:31Z",
+ "build_identity": "ticket-system HEAD bbec66f770897b096bdc014354508b13b0512454",
+ "baseline": {
+ "snapshot_at": "2026-09-03T19:50:11.437Z",
+ "snapshot_sha256": "60f33715fd34e2c7291f22f309193bff87a8ee44ab61a4e0cc0787c2c701b8f7",
+ "open_or_active": 61,
+ "materialized_top_rows": 25,
+ "actionable_pickups": 0,
+ "executable_rows": 0
+ },
+ "journey": {
+ "entry": "Fresh inbox was consumed and ticketmaster regenerated its canonical snapshot.",
+ "action": "DTD selected a read-only owner audit; vp-cncp audited eligibility and ownership; parent independently reproduced the handoff; Cody reviewed the actual HOLD; final DTD selected SHIP for the scoped record only.",
+ "observable_outcome": "No underlying ticket, project, process, service, external, production, catalog, Merchant Center, Shopify, or dw_unified action was executed.",
+ "cleanup": "No temporary DTD directory was deleted; OS-managed unique temporary directories remain for reclamation as required. Evidence and ticket events are intentionally retained."
+ },
+ "checks": [
+ {"name": "ticketmaster urgency policy", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "18 assertions passed"},
+ {"name": "ticket-system native suite", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "7 tests passed"},
+ {"name": "yoloforever zero-cost DTD enforcement", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "Both installed DTD entry-point families forced zero-cost from the canonical guard"},
+ {"name": "yoloforever preflight launch boundary", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "Launch boundary canary passed"},
+ {"name": "canonical event JSON", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "All event records parsed as JSON objects during the final check"},
+ {"name": "initial DTD bundle", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "/var/folders/rq/j8g1f7nn6jv6_lr1cfmqym6w0000gn/T/tmp.KUhEnUcV3Z; Codex=A, Qwen=A, mandatory judge FINAL KEEP"},
+ {"name": "final DTD bundle", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "/var/folders/rq/j8g1f7nn6jv6_lr1cfmqym6w0000gn/T/tmp.wu13Fr7kPL; Codex=SHIP, Qwen=SHIP, mandatory judge FINAL KEEP"},
+ {"name": "selector boundary", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "Hashed JSON explicitly stores actionable_pickups=0 and materializes zero execute/fast-local rows among 25 ranked rows"},
+ {"name": "A2A boundary", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "Correlation CYF-20260903-1250-TK11197-OWNER-AUDIT-01; producer claim and structured handoff logged; parent independently reproduced snapshot counts, hash, guard, and TK-11198 ownership"},
+ {"name": "zero-cost guard", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "Exact ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; SHA-256 8cae41cd92c49ab229b26a9061bea48712416efcc6534496a94d69a67f5aa7ed"},
+ {"name": "UI/browser proof", "result": "SKIP", "reason": "No web or UI surface changed; the required domain-appropriate non-UI canary/test flow was executed instead."}
+ ],
+ "negative_checks": [
+ {"claim": "The top-25 selector independently proves all 61 open/active ticket dispositions", "result": "REJECTED", "evidence": "Only 25 ranked rows are materialized; the verdict is explicitly point-in-time and bounded."},
+ {"claim": "actionable_pickups=0 is not retained in the hashed snapshot", "result": "DISPROVED", "evidence": "jq -e '.orchestration_reasons.actionable_pickups == 0' returned true."},
+ {"claim": "TK-11198 is a new unowned pickup", "result": "DISPROVED", "evidence": "Canonical ticket fold shows assignee showroom-line-steward and overlapping showroom scope."}
+ ],
+ "residual_risks": [
+ "The selector is point-in-time and only materializes the top 25 rows.",
+ "Panel availability was 2/6, sufficient under DTD rules but low confidence for broad claims.",
+ "The next cycle must repoll and must not reuse this eligibility conclusion."
+ ],
+ "gates": {
+ "tk_10993_track_c": "HOLD; never link or relink without a newly rebuilt immutable identity-bearing 400/400 baseline.",
+ "tk_10993_track_d": "Re-enumerate and dedupe immediately before any separately approved execution.",
+ "tk_10993_track_e": "Only revised scoped form after A/B, a fresh preflight, and exact approval."
+ },
+ "side_effects": "Only canonical ticket events, this evidence file, and the required cycle ledger entry are retained. No external message, provider API, paid endpoint, spend, deploy, publish, production write, or underlying task mutation occurred.",
+ "verdict": "PASS_FOR_SCOPED_EVIDENCE_ONLY_HOLD",
+ "cost_usd": 0
+}
diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
index 23bfa173..869e9700 100644
--- a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
@@ -65,3 +65,4 @@
{"timestamp":"2026-09-03T18:50:00Z","ticket":"TK-11189-codex-yoloforever-bounded-monitoring-cyc","action":"Fresh snapshot and canonical-owner audit found no safe reversible ungated non-colliding unowned pickup. Preserved all TK-10993 Track C/D/E rails. Cody's reproduced evidence-provenance defect was corrected with a durable frozen event log, snapshot, fold reconciliation, and E2E proof; no underlying project, service, external, production, or catalog mutation.","dtd_verdict":"A=read-only full-board eligibility/ownership/collision/gate audit, 2/2 valid local voters (Codex+Qwen), mandatory Codex debate FINAL KEEP","cody_verdict":"FIX FIRST 4/5; top fix=correct false 64/65 chronology and persist exact fold inputs/output. Reproduced and fixed: snapshot 61 + post-snapshot TK-11189 = 62 task records; +2 excluded scheduled_job = owner 64; later TK-11190 = current 65.","final_dtd_verdict":"FIX-THEN-SHIP after 1-1 split with SHIP; conservative tie resolution because a reproduced evidence fix was required; mandatory Codex debate FINAL KEEP; fix applied and passed.","tests_evidence":["data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11189-20260903T1848Z/e2e-proof.json","frozen events SHA256 e9a89c6f8f1226054f5609b914b42b85171e86c37bc95eacd0e622ffbfbe4f45","snapshot SHA256 45cce4be67cf61c1eec652532011aaeed4dce450d7794152dbc6ef4934f82665","canonical fold replay PASS","61/64/65 record-level reconciliation PASS","ticketmaster urgency 18/18 PASS","wrong-hash rejection PASS","JSON parse PASS","zero-cost guard exact PASS"],"next_seed":"Fresh inbox and full-board ticketmaster snapshot next launchd cycle; if still no eligible pickup, perform read-only TK-10928 scheduler correlation at its recheck. Do not reuse this point-in-time eligibility conclusion.","gated_memos":[],"cost":"$0"}
{"timestamp":"2026-09-03T19:20:23Z","ticket":"TK-11196-codex-yoloforever-bounded-monitoring-cyc","action":"Fresh ticketmaster selector reported zero actionable pickups and materialized zero execute/fast-local rows. Initial DTD committed a bounded no-op; no canonical owner execution was authorized. Cody independently shipped the scoped HOLD/no-op. No underlying ticket, project, process, service, external, production, catalog, or gated state changed.","dtd_verdict":"C=no further audit/record gated-only after 1-1 valid-voter split (Codex A, Qwen C) and mandatory Codex FINAL OVERTURN; 2/6 availability","cody_verdict":"SHIP IT 4/5 for bounded no-op/HOLD only; top fix=state exact point-in-time selector scope (67 reported total, 25 materialized, zero executable rows), never claim exhaustive all-67 audit","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP 2/2 valid local voters; mandatory Codex debate FINAL KEEP; monitoring record only","tests_evidence":["data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11196-20260903T1919Z/e2e-proof.json","snapshot sha256 aee6d9ad6579f425d95ed3c60b2caca5132fa09f7a3db1d9047297dfc42bdd9e","canonical locked ticket fold PASS","selector boundary and negative executable-row assertion PASS","ticketmaster urgency 18/18 PASS","initial/final DTD artifact parse PASS","zero-cost guard exact PASS","live JSONL direct-parse concurrency failure captured and replaced by locked canonical fold"],"next_seed":"Fresh inbox and ticketmaster snapshot next launchd cycle; do not reuse this timestamped selector conclusion. If no pickup appears, continue read-only backlog monitoring without touching live-owned, dirty, or gated work.","gated_memos":[],"cost":"$0"}
{"timestamp":"2026-09-03T19:34:15Z","ticket":"TK-10993-gmc-degraded-remediation-durable-feed-co","action":"Fresh ticketmaster snapshot found zero actionable pickups. Canonical owner and parent independently reproduced a strict read-only HOLD: gmc-titlefix dirty collision, Track C baseline absent/not ready/DO NOT RELINK, no Track D JIT enumeration, and no revised Track E preflight. No project or external mutation.","dtd_verdict":"A=read-only owner readiness audit then HOLD; Codex+Qwen 2/2 valid, 2/6 available; mandatory Codex judge KEEP","cody_verdict":"SHIP IT 3/5 for evidence-only HOLD only; top fix=label 5/5 tests guard-logic-only and preserve C/D/E rails","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP the evidence-only HOLD record only; Codex+Qwen 2/2 valid, 2/6 available; mandatory Codex judge KEEP; zero execution authority","tests_evidence":["data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-1234/e2e-proof.json","ticketmaster urgency 18/18 PASS","Track C guard-logic 5/5 PASS","baseline absence and 400/385/3/12 null-identity assertions PASS","reconciliation exact/immutable/ready=false PASS","snapshot SHA256 cae5c13a7fa22e305700388508dcd6334981c6db6273688fa20cdb0c487f5f3a"],"next_seed":"Fresh board re-evaluation; preserve DO NOT RELINK C; require immediate D re-enumeration/dedupe and revised E fresh preflight plus exact approval before any execution","gated_memos":[],"cost":"$0"}
+{"timestamp":"2026-09-03T19:59:31Z","ticket":"TK-11197-codex-yoloforever-bounded-monitoring-cyc","action":"Fresh ticketmaster selector and canonical-owner audit found no safe reversible ungated non-colliding pickup. A post-snapshot candidate was already assigned and overlapping. No underlying ticket, project, process, service, external, production, catalog, Merchant Center, Shopify, or dw_unified action occurred.","dtd_verdict":"A=one read-only canonical owner/backlog audit then HOLD; Codex+Qwen 2/2 valid, 2/6 available; mandatory Codex judge KEEP","cody_verdict":"SHIP IT 3/5 for evidence-only HOLD; top fix=narrow proof boundary to 25 ranked rows plus audited deltas. Reproduced top-25 limitation; disproved claim that actionable_pickups=0 was absent from hashed JSON.","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP the timestamped evidence-only HOLD record; Codex+Qwen 2/2 valid, 2/6 available; mandatory Codex judge KEEP; zero execution authority","tests_evidence":["data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/TK-11197-20260903T1959Z/e2e-proof.json","e2e-proof SHA256 573ca52a9001990920bfe40bf3279b4d9202bcff7cc2ca97025c24477d9ba67b","ticketmaster urgency 18/18 PASS","ticket-system native suite 7/7 PASS","zero-cost DTD enforcement PASS","preflight launch boundary PASS","canonical event JSON PASS","initial/final DTD bundle parse PASS","snapshot SHA256 60f33715fd34e2c7291f22f309193bff87a8ee44ab61a4e0cc0787c2c701b8f7"],"next_seed":"Fresh inbox and ticketmaster snapshot next launchd cycle; do not reuse this point-in-time conclusion. Continue read-only monitoring if the selector again has no eligible pickup.","gated_memos":[],"cost":"$0"}
← bbec66f7 Record TK-10993 evidence-only hold cycle
·
back to Ticket System
·
record TK-11199 monitoring cycle evidence 638de497 →