log TK-10993 safe hold cycle

ca91ad6d208d2ec81d8be3d0fb101d43ab093e2e · 2026-09-02 20:44:58 -0700 · Steve Abrams
Files touched

A data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0343/e2e-proof.json
M data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
Diff

commit ca91ad6d208d2ec81d8be3d0fb101d43ab093e2e
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date:   Wed Sep 2 20:44:58 2026 -0700

    log TK-10993 safe hold cycle
---
 .../evidence/20260903-0343/e2e-proof.json          | 31 ++++++++++++++++++++++
 data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl                |  1 +
 2 files changed, 32 insertions(+)

diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0343/e2e-proof.json b/data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0343/e2e-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a4ba072b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0343/e2e-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+{
+  "intent": "Prove the bounded TK-10993 read-only readiness audit without widening external authority",
+  "risk_tier": "R3 read-only external identity check; no write path",
+  "environment": "Mac2 local plus Google Content API GET-only sample",
+  "build_identity": {
+    "gmc_titlefix_head": "4cadd625c52d5bc07d0fed96590fe45b55e26cac",
+    "ticketmaster_snapshot_sha256": "85b7a3fb713968fb3951c878b04c65b2d9b8bfc17739e33c7dcfc5a59b51b91e"
+  },
+  "timestamp": "2026-09-03T03:43:00Z",
+  "correlation_id": "CYF-20260902-2038-TK10993",
+  "baseline": {
+    "worktree": "dirty only with pre-existing untracked enumerate-genuine-rollleaks.mjs",
+    "track_c_baseline": "missing",
+    "track_c_reconciliation": {"immutable_baseline_captured": false, "ready_to_link": false},
+    "retained_attempt": {"total": 400, "approved": 385, "disapproved": 3, "readErrors": 12, "identity_fields_present": false},
+    "track_d_fresh_jit_enumeration": false,
+    "track_e_fresh_revised_preflight": false
+  },
+  "checks": [
+    {"boundary": "Track C local safety", "command": "node --test test/track-c-safety.test.mjs", "assertion": "immutable snapshot, rollback identity, and fail-closed verifier behavior", "verdict": "PASS", "evidence": "5/5 tests passed"},
+    {"boundary": "Merchant read identity", "command": "GET one canary product and productstatus", "assertion": "merchant 146735262 and selected offer resolve on both read endpoints", "verdict": "PASS", "evidence": "HTTP 200/200; identity_match=true"},
+    {"boundary": "400/400 prerequisite", "assertion": "single sample must not be promoted to immutable full baseline", "verdict": "FAIL", "evidence": "baseline file missing; retained attempt has 12 read errors"},
+    {"boundary": "ticketmaster selection", "command": "node test/urgency.test.js", "assertion": "policy, collision, and ranking behavior", "verdict": "PASS", "evidence": "14/14 assertions passed; fresh snapshot has zero actionable pickups"},
+    {"boundary": "worktree preservation", "command": "git status --short", "assertion": "no cycle-created project changes", "verdict": "PASS", "evidence": "only pre-existing ?? enumerate-genuine-rollleaks.mjs remains"},
+    {"boundary": "web UI", "assertion": "CTA and screenrecord", "verdict": "SKIP", "reason": "No web/UI surface changed; domain-appropriate API/test canary substituted per yoloforever"}
+  ],
+  "cleanup": "No test state created; GET-only API sample; no project mutation",
+  "verdict": "PARTIAL_SAFE_HOLD",
+  "critical_path_skip": false,
+  "remaining_gate": "Track C must remain HOLD and must not be linked/relinked until a newly rebuilt canary has immutable identity-bearing 400/400 proof. Track D requires immediate re-enumeration/dedupe before any separately approved execution. Track E requires A/B plus a fresh revised-scope preflight and exact approval."
+}
diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
index b25360a7..bbdb36ee 100644
--- a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
@@ -28,3 +28,4 @@
 {"timestamp":"2026-09-03T02:39:07Z","ticket":"TK-11148","correlation_id":"CYF-20260903T0235-GATEDONLY","action":"Fresh ticketmaster snapshot, collision/worktree audit, and bounded read-only ticket-system canary; zero eligible execute or fast-track-local pickups and no external/product/process mutation.","dtd_verdict":"A read-only ticket-system integrity canary; Codex 1/6 availability, formally inconclusive under Codex-only/$0 constraint; inline Codex adversarial judge KEEP.","cody_verdict":"FIX FIRST 5/5; top fix claimed shell-robust status plus ledger repair.","cody_top_fix":"Dropped after reproduction: forced Bash is unsupported and documented direct/zsh status passes; all nonblank canonical events parse, while destructive canonical-ledger rewriting remains gated.","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP this bounded evidence-only cycle; Codex 1/6 availability, formally inconclusive; inline prosecutor argued HOLD for Cody defects, defender showed both were phantoms/non-actionable, judge FINAL KEEP. No authority widened.","tests_evidence":["ticketmaster urgency 14/14 PASS","ticket-system 29/29 PASS","direct runner status rc=0 loaded=yes running=lock-held stopped=no last_exit=0","109545 nonblank canonical events parsed with zero invalid nonblank records","data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0239/e2e-proof.json","CTA/screenrecord N/A: no web/UI mutation; R0 non-UI canary substituted"],"next_seed":"Fresh snapshot and full-canonical diff next cycle; take only newly eligible execute/fast-track-local work. Preserve TK-10993 constraints: C HOLD absent rebuilt immutable 400/400 identity baseline; D re-enumerate/dedupe immediately before any separately approved execution; E revised scope only after A/B and fresh preflight.","gated_memos":[],"cost_usd":0}
 {"timestamp":"2026-09-03T02:57:44Z","ticket":"TK-11149","correlation_id":"CYF-20260902T1951-11149","action":"Fresh ticketmaster snapshot plus full canonical ownership fold routed through vp-cncp found zero safe reversible non-colliding pickups; no project, process, status, product, or external mutation.","dtd_verdict":"B read-only monitoring and NO SAFE ITEM; Qwen 1/6 valid, formally inconclusive under Codex-only/$0 constraints; mandatory nested Codex debate unavailable, so conservative safe default applied.","cody_verdict":"SHIP IT 5/5.","cody_top_fix":"Anchor the final record to the full canonical zero-open/all-doing-owned fold; treat ranked latest.top dispositions as corroboration only. Applied in retained evidence.","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP this bounded evidence-only cycle; Qwen 1/6 valid, formally inconclusive; nested Codex debate unavailable. SHIP grants no gated authority.","tests_evidence":["full canonical fold PASS: open=0, doing=20, doing_unassigned=0","immutable ranked snapshot PASS: open_or_active=73 and execute/fast-track-local absent","ticket-system npm test 29/29 PASS","launchd running runs=373 pid=56584 last_exit=0","data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0258/e2e-proof.json","CTA/screenrecord N/A: no web/UI mutation; R0 non-UI canonical fold and native canary substituted"],"next_seed":"Fresh snapshot and full-canonical delta next cycle; select only a newly eligible execute/fast-track-local item. Preserve TK-10993: Track C HOLD absent rebuilt immutable 400/400 identity baseline; Track D re-enumerate/dedupe immediately before any separately approved execution; Track E revised scope only after A/B plus fresh preflight.","gated_memos":[],"cost_usd":0}
 {"timestamp":"2026-09-03T03:31:00Z","ticket":"TK-10933","correlation_id":"codex-yoloforever-20260902T2010","action":"Implemented and locally shipped a durable hybrid Gemini HTTP-429 breaker for the Stroheim settlement gate across commits 795876a, bff26d1, and fd91592; hard quota persists across restart, soft exhaustion trips after four terminal items, corrupt state remains durably fail-closed, concurrent runs are excluded, and stale-lock refusals are durably redacted.","dtd_verdict":"A implement/test the local hybrid breaker; Codex 1/6 valid under explicit Codex-only/$0 constraint, formally below two-family quorum; mandatory Codex adversarial judge FINAL KEEP.","cody_verdict":"Final SHIP IT 5/5 after two reproduced FIX FIRST rounds.","cody_top_fix":"Persist invalid-state refusal across restarts and record lock refusals without auto-removing ambiguous stale locks; reproduced independently and fixed in fd91592.","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP local commit fd91592 only; Codex 1/6 valid/formally inconclusive, mandatory adversarial judge FINAL KEEP. Paid/provider/production scope remains HOLD-FOR-STEVE.","tests_evidence":["verification/TK-10933-e2e-proof.json PASS","breaker suite PASS: hard 42/42 one attempt; soft 43/24 attempts; corrupt 44/44 zero work; concurrent [0,45]; stale lock [45,45] with redacted evidence","diagnostics 4/4 PASS","watchdog PASS 307ms/6 events","node syntax, evidence JSON, git show --check PASS","canonical payload/verdict hashes unchanged","CTA/screenrecord N/A: no web/UI surface; real deterministic settlement canary/API-style flow substituted"],"next_seed":"Fresh ticketmaster snapshot and full canonical delta next cycle; select only newly safe non-colliding work. TK-10933 real provider/spend/launchd/Shopify canary remains gated. Preserve TK-10993 Track C HOLD absent rebuilt immutable 400/400 identity proof; re-enumerate/dedupe Track D immediately before any separately approved execution; Track E revised scope only after A/B plus fresh preflight.","gated_memos":[],"cost_usd":0}
+{"timestamp":"2026-09-03T03:43:00Z","ticket":"TK-10993","correlation_id":"CYF-20260902-2038-TK10993","action":"Fresh ticketmaster snapshot and canonical-owner read-only readiness audit found zero actionable pickups; independently confirmed the gmc-titlefix collision and that Tracks C/D/E are not execution-ready. No project, product, process, or external mutation.","dtd_verdict":"A read-only owner audit then HOLD; Codex 1/6 valid, formally inconclusive under explicit Codex-only and USD 0 constraints; inline mandatory Codex adversarial judge FINAL KEEP.","cody_verdict":"SHIP IT 5/5 for the evidence-only no-mutation HOLD; no execution authority.","cody_top_fix":"Final DTD must record HOLD-FOR-STEVE, never link/relink C without rebuilt immutable identity-bearing 400/400 proof, and preserve D just-in-time enumeration plus E fresh revised preflight.","final_dtd_verdict":"HOLD-FOR-STEVE; Codex 1/6 valid/formally inconclusive, inline mandatory Codex adversarial judge FINAL KEEP. No safe reversible fix applied because the relevant worktree is dirty and live prerequisites are absent.","tests_evidence":["Track C safety 5/5 PASS","ticketmaster urgency 14/14 PASS","Google Content API GET-only sample product/status HTTP 200/200 with merchant/offer identity match","Track C baseline missing; retained attempt 400/385/3/12; reconciliation false/false","data/codex-yoloforever/evidence/20260903-0343/e2e-proof.json","CTA/screenrecord N/A: no web/UI mutation; real API/test canary substituted"],"next_seed":"Fresh ticketmaster snapshot and full canonical delta. Resolve ownership of gmc-titlefix/enumerate-genuine-rollleaks.mjs before any local rebuild. Track C remains HOLD and must not be relinked; Track D requires immediate re-enumerate/dedupe before separately approved execution; Track E requires A/B and fresh revised-scope preflight plus exact approval.","gated_memos":[],"cost_usd":0}
← 5b09f51c record TK-10933 breaker cycle · back to Ticket System · log gated-only monitoring cycle 4f85d7b4 →