Persist bounded cycle disposition ledger

e95a67fbc0920e2f2f84eb5b1c07695870b3220f · 2026-09-07 15:07:27 -0700 · Steve Abrams
Files touched

M data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
Diff

commit e95a67fbc0920e2f2f84eb5b1c07695870b3220f
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date:   Mon Sep 7 15:07:27 2026 -0700

    Persist bounded cycle disposition ledger
---
 data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl | 1 +
 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+)

diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
index 7ef7d4f3..00a36635 100644
--- a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
@@ -214,3 +214,4 @@
 {"schema_version":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:02:03.040832+00:00","cycle_id":"cycle-20260907T2051Z.TqDVfB","source_tickets":["TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol"],"standing_ticket":"TK-11287-drive-open-tickets-in-board-order-using","queue_captured_at":"2026-09-07T20:51:36.560Z","ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"ticket":"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","rank":42,"disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Explicit MONITOR mandate; loaded and historical300 creation canary passes. Current live publication/backlog unresolved; no changed inputs or missing local preparation demonstrated. Manual publication/schedule mutations gated.","assignee":"vp-dw-commerce","source_updated_at":"2026-09-07T20:08:43.084Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-07T15:00:11.754Z","claim":false},{"position":2,"ticket":"TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol","rank":56,"disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Authoritative wholesale pricing and vendor mapping missing in known inputs; local read-only mirror contains zero positive costs/prices; concrete memo already exists. Exact catalog/variant/tag write approval also required.","assignee":"claude-missing-desc","source_updated_at":"2026-09-05T11:05:55.689Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-04T17:57:40.266Z","claim":false}],"execution_iterations":0,"execution_limit":6,"implementation_progress":{"count":0,"changes":[]},"monitoring_progress":{"ordered_queue_entries_reviewed":2,"in_flight_entries_reviewed":20,"new_monitoring_increment":0,"refreshed_checks":["SDG loaded state and historical300 creation canary","READ ONLY pricing SQL with ROLLBACK","29known input metadata and scoped filenames","canonical owner/activity and supplied in-flight records","ticket API health200/auth401 and native authenticated reads"]},"action":"Completed ordered monitoring; no new safe increment or missing preparation found; retained existing gated memo. Sources remain unresolved.","dtd_verdict":{"verdict":"not-applicable","reason":"No new execution increment selected. The unchanged blockers were not re-debated.","execution_iterations":0},"cody_verdict":{"verdict":"SHIP IT","tally":{"SHIP IT":5},"top_fix":"Accept the monitoring checkpoint with both source outcomes unresolved; wait for changed authoritative inputs before selecting execution.","dissent":"Strategist: unchanged monitoring is no implementation progress; retain execution 0/6 and implementation 0 in final result. Conceded as report blocker because that limitation is already explicit.","reproduced_report_defects":[]},"final_dtd_verdict":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:01:02.780805+00:00","preliminary":"SHIP","final":"SHIP","scope":"Accept monitoring record only; final proof,append/readback,local commit required before cycle completion; both source outcomes unresolved","availability":"2/6","tally":"2/2 SHIP","confidence":"medium","votes":{"Claude":"abstain","Codex":"SHIP","Qwen":"SHIP","Grok":"abstain","Kimi":"abstain","Muse":"abstain"},"references":[{"reference":"Claude","runtime":"disabled by zero-cost guard","model":"sonnet","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Codex","runtime":"Codex CLI","model":"gpt-6-astra","vote":"SHIP"},{"reference":"Qwen","runtime":"Ollama http://127.0.0.1:11434","model":"qwen3:14b","vote":"SHIP"},{"reference":"Grok","runtime":"disabled by zero-cost guard","model":"grok-4.5","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Kimi","runtime":"disabled by zero-cost guard","model":"kimi-k2.5","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Muse","runtime":"local model unavailable","model":"muse-spark-1.2","vote":"abstain"}],"post_decision":"KEEP","dissent":"No minority among valid model voters. Prosecutor challenged premature completion while closing work remains; Judge retained SHIP solely for monitoring evidence with all closing requirements intact.","rejected_inferences":["Qwen wording that implementation progress is unresolved is imprecise: this cycle has exactly zero implementation. Source outcomes are unresolved."],"directory":"/private/tmp/dtd-final-cycle2051.6w90Bq","panel_exit_code":0,"post_exit_code":0},"tests_evidence":{"directory":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2051Z.TqDVfB","e2e_counts":{"PASS":18,"FAIL":0,"SKIP":3},"e2e_proof":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2051Z.TqDVfB/e2e-proof.json","critical_source_skips":["Full live SDG publication/canonical backlog/checkout","Authoritative wholesale/vendor mapping/live sellability"],"runner_exit":"Future observation by runner after this turn returns; not yet observed","ui":"No runnable UI produced; canary, READ ONLY SQL and API positive/negative paths used per yoloforever"},"a2a":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T20:58:22.713529+00:00","accepted":true,"scope":"Monitoring facts and reported source limitations only; source outcomes unresolved; final proof and ledger pending","correlations":{"packet":"dm-mtrpxrup-93028-77ta1t","receipt":"action-mtrpz3px-17434-nj17ja","handoff":"action-mtrq23r5-17434-qyl209","parent_acceptance":"action-mtrq3qa4-93028-sigmym"},"artifact_sha256":{"cody-review.json":"9509395101f688007bb884dda1b338ce971292c6e27424987e82f757924ee0a1","cody-review.md":"43a148dcc0f50883cdb27bda17d02769150f4c1b0bcb225de259172c63fac643"},"reproduced_report_defects":[]},"next_seed":{"instruction":"Use next fresh supplied board order. Reassess changed authoritative SDG publication/backlog evidence or priced vendor rows/mapping; no reproduced new defect.","source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"}},"gated_memos":{"retained":[{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-04-TK-10066-architectural-fabrics-1005-active-no-price.md","sha256":"e342c17c6431f9957ee6f7d53484d7122ae400290d9092e3e483a3f80042b717"}],"new":[],"approval":false},"clarify":{"questions":[],"reason":"No new decision-changing ambiguity found; existing specific dependencies and memo retained."},"cost":{"paid_api_spend_usd":0,"paid_api_calls":0,"provider_keys_accessed":false,"claude_invocations":0,"codex_cli_reported_tokens":{"codex.cli.log":38714,"codex-debate.cli.log":6134},"codex_cli_total_reported_tokens":44848,"root_and_review_tokens":"not aggregated; do not infer zero token use","local_endpoints_only":true},"hard_gates":{"source_owner_or_status_changes":0,"source_code_or_runtime_changes":0,"external_writes":0,"tk10993":"Exact carried ABCDE only; C HOLD absent immutable400/400 rebuilt baseline; E only afterA/B+fresh preflight; D re-enumerate/dedupe before execution. Zero actions this cycle."},"continuation":{"schedule_seconds":600,"scheduler":"existing launchd com.steve.codex-yoloforever","stopped_sentinel":"absent; unchanged","action":"return normally; no pause/stop/install"},"source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"}}
 {"schema_version":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:24:19.202797+00:00","cycle_id":"cycle-20260907T2114Z.eNuGuI","source_tickets":["TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol"],"standing_ticket":"TK-11287-drive-open-tickets-in-board-order-using","queue_captured_at":"2026-09-07T21:14:11.616Z","ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"ticket":"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","rank":42,"disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Explicit MONITOR mandate; loaded and historical300 creation canary passes. Current live publication/backlog unresolved; no changed inputs or missing local preparation demonstrated. Manual publication/schedule mutations gated.","assignee":"vp-dw-commerce","source_updated_at":"2026-09-07T20:08:43.084Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-07T15:00:11.754Z","claim":false},{"position":2,"ticket":"TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol","rank":57,"disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Authoritative wholesale pricing and vendor mapping missing in known inputs; local read-only mirror contains zero positive costs/prices; concrete memo already exists. Exact catalog/variant/tag write approval also required.","assignee":"claude-missing-desc","source_updated_at":"2026-09-05T11:05:55.689Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-04T17:57:40.266Z","claim":false}],"execution_iterations":0,"execution_limit":6,"implementation_progress":{"count":0,"changes":[]},"monitoring_progress":{"ordered_queue_entries_reviewed":2,"in_flight_entries_reviewed":20,"new_monitoring_increment":0,"refreshed_checks":["Loaded SDG job and historical300 canary","READ ONLY local pricing transaction with ROLLBACK","29known metadata/scoped filename checks and5SDG hashes","Fresh pure Ticketmaster owner/activity without side effects","Real ticket API health200/auth401 plus native authenticated canonical reads"]},"action":"Ordered monitoring complete; no new safe increment or missing concrete preparation found. Existing memo retained; sources unresolved.","dtd_verdict":{"verdict":"not-applicable","reason":"No execution increment selected; user explicitly prohibits repeated debate of unchanged known blockers","execution_iterations":0},"cody_verdict":{"verdict":"SHIP IT","tally":{"SHIP IT":5},"top_fix":"Finalize only the bounded monitoring record with both source outcomes explicitly UNRESOLVED; preserve execution 0/6 and implementation 0.","dissent":"Skeptic's metadata fingerprint concern is real in principle but no preserved-mtime content change is demonstrated; the narrow explicit limitation defeats a FIX FIRST vote.","reproduced_report_defects":[]},"final_dtd_verdict":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:23:36.778091+00:00","preliminary":"SHIP","final":"SHIP","scope":"Accept monitoring record only; sources unresolved,closing duties remain required","availability":"2/6","tally":"2/2 SHIP","confidence":"medium","references":[{"reference":"Claude","runtime":"disabled by guard","model":"sonnet","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Codex","runtime":"Codex CLI","model":"gpt-6-astra","vote":"SHIP"},{"reference":"Qwen","runtime":"Ollama127.0.0.1:11434","model":"qwen3:14b","vote":"SHIP"},{"reference":"Grok","runtime":"disabled by guard","model":"grok-4.5","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Kimi","runtime":"disabled by guard","model":"kimi-k2.5","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Muse","runtime":"local model unavailable","model":"muse-spark-1.2","vote":"abstain"}],"post_decision":"KEEP","dissent":"No minority among valid model voters. Prosecutor challenged Qwen closure language and incomplete technical certification; Judge restricts verdict to monitoring acceptance. Cody metadata coverage concern retained as limitation.","rejected_inferences":["Qwen finalize closure wording does not authorize source closure or presume final proof/ledger/commit already complete.","DTD review is not independent technical verification; root real checks provide that evidence for monitoring only."],"directory":"/private/tmp/dtd-final-cycle2114.ntqXzL","panel_exit_code":0,"post_exit_code":0},"tests_evidence":{"directory":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2114Z.eNuGuI","e2e_counts":{"PASS":18,"FAIL":0,"SKIP":3},"e2e_proof":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2114Z.eNuGuI/e2e-proof.json","critical_source_skips":["Full live SDG publication/canonical staging backlog/checkout","Authoritative wholesale mapping/live sellability"],"runner_exit":"Observed only after worker returns; future","ui":"No runnable UI produced: actual canary, READ ONLY SQL/ROLLBACK and API positive/negative flows substitute for CTA and screenrecord"},"a2a":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:20:43.388489+00:00","accepted":true,"scope":"Monitoring facts and source limitations only; sources UNRESOLVED. Parent inspected actual review and earlier independent canary/SQL/native readback; final rechecks follow.","correlations":{"packet":"dm-mtrqr3h5-86511-7hychr","receipt":"action-mtrqs2yb-24072-0af5gc","handoff":"action-mtrqv1v9-24072-1vq0lh","parent_acceptance":"action-mtrqvy5d-86511-vn8utr"},"artifact_sha256":{"cody-review.json":"e74364e87356c69a4b6e893d662798d8f38041add80b7187190a256511f8d6e2","cody-review.md":"ec5452edbb05ee8eeb2728b5be2df74574faf852481318dafdfd4fe2e6aefd90"},"reproduced_report_defects":[],"reproduced_limitations":["Historical canary reads last300 audit events only","READ ONLY pricing/schema query is local mirror only","29file size/mtime scan is scoped,5hashes prove only local continuity"]},"next_seed":{"instruction":"Next fresh supplied queue in board order. Act when authoritative pricing/vendor mapping or SDG operational evidence changes; no new reproduced defect.","source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"}},"gated_memos":{"retained":[{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-04-TK-10066-architectural-fabrics-1005-active-no-price.md","sha256":"e342c17c6431f9957ee6f7d53484d7122ae400290d9092e3e483a3f80042b717"}],"new":[],"approval":false},"clarify":{"questions":[],"reason":"Existing specific dependencies and memo retained; no new decision-changing ambiguity currently found"},"cost":{"paid_api_spend_usd":0,"paid_api_calls":0,"provider_keys_accessed":false,"claude_invocations":0,"local_endpoints_only":true,"codex_cli_reported_tokens":{"codex.cli.log":6457,"codex-debate.cli.log":7825},"root_and_review_tokens":"not aggregated; do not infer zero token use","codex_cli_total_reported_tokens":14282},"hard_gates":{"source_status_or_owner_changes":0,"source_code_or_runtime_changes":0,"external_writes":0,"tk10993":"Exact carried ABCDE constraints only; C HOLD pending rebuilt immutable400/400 identity baseline; E revised scope only afterA/B+fresh preflight; D re-enumerate/dedupe immediately before approved execution. No actions this cycle."},"continuation":{"schedule_seconds":600,"scheduler":"Existing launchd com.steve.codex-yoloforever","stopped_sentinel":"Absent and unchanged","action":"Return normally; no pause/stop/install"},"source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"}}
 {"schema_version":1,"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:45:48.553846+00:00","cycle_id":"cycle-20260907T2135Z.WnpzK5","source_tickets":["TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol"],"standing_ticket":"TK-11287-drive-open-tickets-in-board-order-using","queue_captured_at":"2026-09-07T21:35:36.344Z","ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"ticket":"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","rank":42,"disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Explicit MONITOR mandate; loaded and historical300 creation canary passes. Current live publication/backlog unresolved; no changed inputs or missing local preparation demonstrated. Manual publication/schedule mutations gated.","assignee":"vp-dw-commerce","source_updated_at":"2026-09-07T20:08:43.084Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-07T15:00:11.754Z","claim":false},{"position":2,"ticket":"TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol","rank":57,"disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Authoritative wholesale pricing and vendor mapping missing in known inputs; local read-only mirror contains zero positive costs/prices; concrete memo already exists. Exact catalog/variant/tag write approval also required.","assignee":"claude-missing-desc","source_updated_at":"2026-09-05T11:05:55.689Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-04T17:57:40.266Z","claim":false}],"execution_iterations":0,"execution_limit":6,"implementation_progress":{"count":0,"changes":[]},"monitoring_progress":{"ordered_queue_entries_reviewed":2,"in_flight_entries_reviewed":20,"new_monitoring_increment":0,"refreshed_checks":["Loaded SDG and historical300 canary","READ ONLY local pricing query with ROLLBACK","29known local metadata/scoped filename scan and5SDG hashes","Pure current Ticketmaster owner/activity; supplied order unchanged","Real API health200/auth401 plus native authenticated canonical readback"]},"action":"Completed ordered monitoring and closing empirical proof; no safe new increment or missing concrete prep found. Persist this record with append/readback and local commit; source outcomes remain unresolved.","dtd_verdict":{"verdict":"not-applicable","reason":"No new execution increment selected; user requires not repeatedly debating unchanged known blockers","execution_iterations":0},"cody_verdict":{"verdict":"SHIP IT","tally":{"SHIP IT":5},"top_fix":"Keep both source outcomes explicitly UNRESOLVED until current SDG publication/backlog evidence or authoritative wholesale/vendor input arrives.","dissent":"Strategist: repeated unchanged monitoring is not delivery; zero implementation remains explicit.","reproduced_report_defects":[]},"final_dtd_verdict":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:45:01.490818+00:00","preliminary":"SHIP","final":"FIX-THEN-SHIP","scope":"Accept monitoring record after completing prescribed closing empirical proof,ledger append/readback and local commit. Both sources remain UNRESOLVED.","availability":"2/6","preliminary_tally":"2/2 SHIP","confidence":"medium","references":[{"reference":"Claude","runtime":"disabled by zero-cost guard","model":"sonnet","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Codex","runtime":"Codex CLI","model":"gpt-6-astra","vote":"SHIP"},{"reference":"Qwen","runtime":"Ollama http://127.0.0.1:11434","model":"qwen3:14b","vote":"SHIP"},{"reference":"Grok","runtime":"disabled by zero-cost guard","model":"grok-4.5","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Kimi","runtime":"disabled by zero-cost guard","model":"kimi-k2.5","vote":"abstain"},{"reference":"Muse","runtime":"local model unavailable","model":"muse-glimmer:30b-mlx","vote":"abstain"}],"post_decision":"OVERTURN","controlling_argument":"Judge rejected completed acceptance while closing empirical rerun,ledger append/readback and local commit were pending. Root maps overturn to FIX-THEN-SHIP for those safe closing requirements; no source completion or external approval.","dissent":"No minority in valid initial votes. Mandatory Codex adversarial Judge overturned conditional SHIP because acceptance evidence remained pending.","rejected_inferences":["Qwen live publication intact is unsupported; full current external publication remains unverified. Its no actionable defects refers only to safe monitoring scope, not resolution of missing source prices."],"directory":"/private/tmp/dtd-final-cycle2135.JhQkvG","panel_exit_code":0,"post_exit_code":0,"reproduced_issue":"At time of verdict no ledger cycle record/local commit existed; proof predates final DTD. Finalization itself is prescribed in user step6/7, not a new implementation defect.","required_fixes":["Run closing empirical verifier after DTD","Append and read back exactly one cycle record","Commit verified local evidence and verify committed blobs"]},"tests_evidence":{"directory":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2135Z.WnpzK5","e2e_counts":{"PASS":18,"FAIL":0,"SKIP":3},"e2e_proof":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2135Z.WnpzK5/e2e-proof.json","critical_source_skips":["Full current SDG publication/canonical backlog/checkout","Authoritative wholesale/vendor mapping and live sellability"],"runner_exit":"Future observation by runner after worker returns; not yet observed","ui":"No runnable UI produced: actual canary, READ ONLY SQL/ROLLBACK and API positive/negative flows substitute for CTA and screenrecord"},"a2a":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T21:42:26.897056+00:00","accepted":true,"scope":"Monitoring facts and stated limitations only. Root inspected actual review artifacts and independently ran canary,READ ONLY SQL,API and canonical reads; both source outcomes unresolved. Final DTD/proof/ledger remain required.","correlations":{"packet":"dm-mtrriabr-78223-qmktlu","receipt":"action-mtrrj913-7878-wjq6qz","handoff":"action-mtrrlt73-7878-bb5gip","parent_acceptance":"action-mtrrnx8x-78223-3cv7qp"},"artifact_sha256":{"cody-review.json":"677030f7a177d54c38561af6b17d6642213ec1ea30b10a0a58b7f11adc533036","cody-review.md":"7a64c6456ae426faa49f878d1ddf1f207de7bbe14dc255cd2621ac7d0148d27a"},"reproduced_report_defects":[],"reproduced_limitations":["Historical300 canary is not current publication or full backlog","Local mirror and 29-file scoped scan do not establish universal pricing absence"]},"next_seed":{"instruction":"Use next fresh supplied queue in board order. Reassess changed authoritative pricing/vendor mapping or SDG operational evidence; no new reproduced source defect.","source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"}},"gated_memos":{"retained":[{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-04-TK-10066-architectural-fabrics-1005-active-no-price.md","sha256":"e342c17c6431f9957ee6f7d53484d7122ae400290d9092e3e483a3f80042b717"}],"new":[],"approval":false},"clarify":{"questions":[],"reason":"No new decision-changing ambiguity; existing specific dependencies/memo retained with conservative unchanged default"},"cost":{"paid_api_spend_usd":0,"paid_api_calls":0,"provider_keys_accessed":false,"claude_invocations":0,"local_endpoints_only":true,"codex_cli_reported_tokens":{"codex.cli.log":32336,"codex-debate.cli.log":7915},"root_and_review_tokens":"Not aggregated; do not infer zero token use","codex_cli_total_reported_tokens":40251},"hard_gates":{"source_status_or_owner_changes":0,"source_code_or_runtime_changes":0,"external_writes":0,"tk10993":"Exact carried ABCDE only. C HOLD absent rebuilt immutable400/400 identity baseline; E revised scope only afterA/B+fresh preflight; D re-enumerate/dedupe immediately before approved execution. Zero actions this cycle."},"continuation":{"schedule_seconds":600,"scheduler":"Existing launchd com.steve.codex-yoloforever","stopped_sentinel":"Absent and unchanged","action":"Return normally; no pause/stop/install"},"source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"}}
+{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T22:06:41.757758+00:00","cycle_id":"cycle-20260907T2157Z.U3TJbt","source_tickets":["TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol"],"ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"ticket":"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd","rank":42,"disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Explicit MONITOR mandate; loaded and historical300 creation canary passes. Current live publication/backlog unresolved; no changed inputs or missing local preparation demonstrated. Manual publication/schedule mutations gated.","assignee":"vp-dw-commerce","source_updated_at":"2026-09-07T20:08:43.084Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-07T15:00:11.754Z","claim":false},{"position":2,"ticket":"TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol","rank":57,"disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Authoritative wholesale pricing and vendor mapping missing in known inputs; local read-only mirror contains zero positive costs/prices; concrete memo already exists. Exact catalog/variant/tag write approval also required.","assignee":"claude-missing-desc","source_updated_at":"2026-09-05T11:05:55.689Z","owner_last_activity":"2026-09-04T17:57:40.266Z","claim":false}],"execution_iterations":0,"execution_limit":6,"implementation_progress":0,"monitoring":{"refreshed":true,"new_verified_increment":0,"canary":"historical300 CREATED/0 HELD/0 ERR","local_pricing":"1470rows;positive costs0/prices0;Vahallan pricing columns0","known_input_files":29,"changed_inputs":0,"input_scan_scope":"29 known file size/mtime records and scoped filenames only; not exhaustive or byte identity","inflight_checked":20},"action":"Retain unresolved source outcomes; record bounded read-only monitoring and return normally","dtd_increment":{"verdict":"not-run","reason":"No exact execution increment; unchanged known blockers not re-debated"},"cody":{"timestamp":"2026-09-07T22:03:37.561003+00:00","accepted":true,"scope":"Monitoring accuracy only; both source outcomes UNRESOLVED; parent independently reproduced real canary,READ ONLY SQL,API positive/negative,source states and protected hashes in e2e-proof.json","verdict":"SHIP IT","tally":{"SHIP IT":4,"FIX FIRST":1},"top_fix":"Lead parent handoff with both source tickets UNRESOLVED and 0/6 execution.","reproduced_report_defects":[],"reproduced_limits":["Live publication and current backlog remain unproved; the last 300 CREATED audit events cannot establish either.","Zero positive prices in the local mirror and zero price/cost columns in vahallan_catalog do not prove no authoritative vendor pricing exists elsewhere.","The changed-input check compares metadata for known files and pricing-related filenames in four directories; content changes preserving metadata or differently named new documents can escape it."],"correlations":{"packet":"dm-mtrs9oft-78474-dw9tlc","receipt":"action-mtrsawes-96025-i1qwos","handoff":"action-mtrsdcpp-96025-cl6tk3","parent_acceptance":"action-mtrsf33h-78474-tteb6h"},"artifacts":[{"path":"cody-review.json","sha256":"89a39025d4a1a115508fa1bc4c18491f123d046b2a13cda45a1c9ebad0b155f1"},{"path":"cody-review.md","sha256":"0e0ff3b661f1b38151986f724908bca9679cbdd594224875176a4fea10fba3f0"}]},"final_dtd":{"verdict":"FIX-THEN-SHIP","preliminary":"SHIP","tally":{"SHIP":1,"KILL":1},"valid_voters":2,"roster":6,"confidence":"low","votes":{"Codex":"SHIP","Qwen":"KILL","Claude":"abstain","Grok":"abstain","Kimi":"abstain","Muse":"abstain"},"post_decision":"OVERTURN","controlling_reason":"Judge rejects acceptance before mandatory closing replay,exactly-once append/readback,evidence commit and worker return. Does not require resolving source tickets. Safe closing steps applied; actual worker exit remains runner observation.","dissent":"Qwen rejects record because source outcomes and implementation remain unresolved/zero; retain criticism about zero progress, reject its implication that monitoring cannot be accepted.","scope":"Monitoring record only; both source outcomes UNRESOLVED; no live action authorization","required_closing":["final empirical replay","safe exactly-once append/readback","local evidence commit","normal return for runner to observe"],"evidence_directory":"/private/tmp/dtd-cycle2157-final.0ei6GI"},"tests":{"counts":{"PASS":18,"FAIL":0,"SKIP":3},"evidence":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260907T2157Z.U3TJbt/e2e-proof.json","ui":"No runnable UI produced; real canary,READ ONLY SQL,API positive/auth-negative substitute for CTA and screenrecord","limits":[{"name":"full current SDG publication/canonical backlog/checkout","verdict":"SKIP","detail":"Monitoring mandate; source operational outcome unresolved"},{"name":"authoritative wholesale mapping and live sellability","verdict":"SKIP","detail":"Missing authoritative input and exact external write approval"},{"name":"worker process exit","verdict":"SKIP","detail":"Runner observes only after this worker returns"}]},"next_seed":"Reassess next fresh supplied queue in board order; act on changed authoritative pricing/vendor mapping or new SDG operational evidence","gated_memos":{"retained":[{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-04-TK-10066-architectural-fabrics-1005-active-no-price.md","sha256":"e342c17c6431f9957ee6f7d53484d7122ae400290d9092e3e483a3f80042b717"}],"new":[],"approval":false},"clarify":{"questions":[],"reason":"No new decision-changing ambiguity; conservative unchanged default; existing memo retained"},"cost":{"paid_api_spend_usd":0,"paid_api_calls":0,"provider_keys_accessed":false,"claude_invocations":0,"dtd_runtimes":"Codex CLI and local model endpoints only","codex_cli_reported_tokens":{"codex.cli.log":32274,"codex-debate.cli.log":6165},"codex_cli_actual_models":{"codex.cli.log":"gpt-6-astra","codex-debate.cli.log":"gpt-6-astra"},"codex_cli_total_reported_tokens":38439,"root_and_child_tokens":"Not aggregated; zero provider spend does not mean zero token use"},"source_outcomes":{"TK-11201-sdg-publish-cadence-launchd-com-steve-sd":"UNRESOLVED","TK-11250-load-vahallan-architectural-fabrics-whol":"UNRESOLVED"},"hard_gates":{"source_claims":0,"source_status_owner_changes":0,"source_code_runtime_changes":0,"external_writes":0,"tk10993":"Zero actions; only carried exact A/B/C/D/E scope. C HOLD until rebuilt immutable400/400identity baseline; E revised scope afterA/B and fresh preflight; D re-enumerate/dedupe immediately before approved execution"},"continuation":{"schedule_seconds":600,"action":"Return normally to existing launchd runner; no stop/pause/install","worker_exit":"future runner observation"}}
← 2d3d2ae1 Record ordered ticket monitoring and preserve unresolved sou · back to Ticket System · Record ordered monitoring cycle with unresolved source outco 4f76f88b →