`5x/REPORT.md`

45 lines
# /5x REPORT — Fleet Tickets board (http://127.0.0.1:9794/)

**Target:** the adjustable-columns ticket-board table · basic auth admin:•••
**Outcome:** ✅ CLEAN — 2 consecutive sweeps, zero real defects. Stopped at 2 (clean-twice), not 5.

## Sweep ledger
| Sweep | M1 HTTP | M2 render | M3 E2E | B4 Chrome | B5 Safari | B6 Firefox | Clickthrough | Real defects | Commit |
|-------|:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:|:--:|--------|
| 1 | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ (579 rows, 0 JS err) | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 6/6 buttons ✅ | **0** (1 false-positive) | — none needed |
| 2 | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ (579 rows, 0 JS err) | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | 6/6 buttons ✅ | **0** (same false-positive) | — none needed |

## The one recurring FAIL — a harness false-positive, NOT a board defect
`[FAIL] density slider — locator.fill: Malformed value`

- **Root cause:** the shared 3x clickthrough drives every input with Playwright `locator.fill()`. `fill()` does not work on `<input type=range>` — Playwright rejects it with "Malformed value" because a range slider is set by value+`input` event, not by typing text. This is a limitation of the generic harness against range inputs, present for ANY app with a slider.
- **Independent proof the slider works** (own Playwright test, not the harness): setting `#dens` value=12 + dispatching `input` → CSS var `--rowpad` changes **7px → 12px**, persists to `localStorage.tkDens=12`, **0 console errors**. CTA earlier independently confirmed the same (td padding 7px→14px).
- **Why no code fix:** the fix would be to swap the density slider for a non-range control purely to satisfy a broken test — that degrades the UX and violates /5x's "never weaken to make a sweep pass." The control is correct and works; the harness is what can't fill it.

## Final six-way state
- Request (M1): HTTP 200 text/html ✅
- Render (M2): 456KB screenshot, table populates ✅
- Interaction (M3): 579 rows matched, **0 JS errors** ✅
- Cross-browser: Chrome (automated) + Safari + Firefox all render ✅
- Every header control (▦ Columns · ◍ Pills · ⤢ Detail · ✉ DMs · ↺ Reset) responds ✅
- Prior CTA run: 14/14 components PASS in Chrome + Safari, 0 console errors.

## Contrarian gate — caught what the button-only sweeps structurally could not
Handing REPORT to /contrarian was the right call. It confirmed the slider diagnosis but flagged three things the six-way suite never exercised (mouse-drag paths + full-thread search):

- **REAL BUG — search (FIXED, commit c6d04bc):** `match()` searched only `lastText(t)` (the single most-recent comment/action). Text living in an older comment, or in a note/win/challenge/cody entry, returned zero results. Fixed to search the FULL thread (all comments of every kind + all actions). Verified: `TK-10000` has "Koroseal" only in a note — now searchable (was not before).
- **Untested → now VERIFIED (resize persistence):** real mouse-drag on `.rsz` → title 420px→520px → `tkWid` saved → **survives reload at 520px**. Works.
- **Untested → now VERIFIED (drag-reorder persistence):** native HTML5 DnD reorder → `tkOrder` saved → **column order survives reload**. Works.
- Pill ✕ / Reset path: contrarian read it as correct; holds. Cell XSS: all cells use `esc()`; covered.

## Final tally (3 sweeps + contrarian gate + confirming sweep)
| Phase | Result |
|-------|--------|
| Sweeps 1–2 (six-way) | M1–M3 ✅ · B4–B6 ✅ · 6/6 buttons ✅ · only recurring FAIL = harness range-input false-positive |
| Contrarian gate | caught 1 real bug (search) + 2 untested persistence paths |
| Sweep 3 fix + verify | search FIXED + resize/reorder persistence PROVEN via real drag test; 0 console errors |
| Confirming sweep | clean, no regression (only the known harness false-positive) |

## Open items
None. The lone recurring FAIL (`density slider — locator.fill: Malformed value`) is a property of the 3x runner's generic `.fill()` against `<input type=range>`, not this build (slider independently proven: --rowpad 7px→12px, persists, 0 errors). Every real interaction — toggles, sort, resize+persist, reorder+persist, full-thread search, inline pill ✕ — is verified working.