`data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260908T1221Z.HzXvuQ/dtd-vienna/qwen.txt`

3 lines
VERDICT: A  
Option A enforces a fail-closed, immutable manifest consumer with rigorous validation (SHA256, identity checks, age/scope) before any credential or network usage, ensuring safety and consistency. It mandates nonmutating plans, durable journals, and replay/rollback of only successful records, aligning with the ticket's emphasis on hermetic proof and no live operations. By separating manifest generation from live approval (TK11299) and avoiding bypassing manifests, it avoids unproven risks while enabling calibrated offline testing for edge cases (injection, drift, retries). This contrasts with B's unsafe CLI writer and C's forbidden live writes, making A the only choice that fully satisfies the ticket's constraints on local code, immutability, and zero-cost unattended safety.