`data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260908T1426Z.m5TdEy/dtd-final.md`

24 lines
# DTD Verdict — bounded cycle monitoring

## DECISION: SHIP
Confidence: medium · Vote: 2/2 valid voters · Panel availability: 2/6
Scope: accept this monitoring record and exit normally; both operational source outcomes remain UNRESOLVED.

| Reference | Runtime/model | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | Disabled by filesystem zero-cost guard | Abstain | No invocation |
| Codex | Codex CLI, actual gpt-6-astra | SHIP | Truthful monitoring, existing gates preserved |
| Qwen | Local Ollama qwen3:14b | SHIP | Normal bounded cycle completion |
| Grok | xAI disabled | Abstain | Paid endpoints forbidden |
| Kimi | Moonshot disabled | Abstain | Paid endpoints forbidden |
| Muse | Local Ollama muse-spark-1.2 | Abstain | Model unavailable |

## Dissent
None among valid voters. Cody's Strategist objects that repeated monitoring consumes attention without operational progress. The current user explicitly requires continued monitoring on the existing schedule; this does not authorize source actions.

## Post-decision Codex debate
Result: KEEP. Prosecutor challenged sparse evidence and Qwen's unsupported approval statement. Defender limited acceptance to the monitoring record. Judge gave Qwen's approval assertion no weight and preserved SHIP only for normal cycle completion, with reduced confidence.

## Controlling evidence
Parent independently retained25PASS0FAIL3SKIP and verified Cody20PASS0FAIL, hashes, receipt and canonical handoff. Root remains3049MBFAIL; pricing inputs remain missing. No implementation or operational closure. Existing approval memos are requirements for future action, not approval. No repeated historical rehearsal or new approval draft.