`data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260908T1508Z.kSOq7u/dtd-final.md`

24 lines
# DTD Verdict — persist bounded monitoring and return

## DECISION: SHIP
Scope: monitoring evidence and normal return to the existing runner only. Both source outcomes UNRESOLVED; 0/6 implementation increments.
Confidence: medium · vote 2/2 valid · panel availability 2/6.

| Reference | Runtime | Actual/configured model | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | Disabled by zero-cost guard | sonnet reference | Abstain | Invocation prohibited |
| Codex | Codex CLI | gpt-6-astra | SHIP | Preserve accurate unresolved monitoring and gates |
| Qwen | Local Ollama | qwen3:14b | SHIP | Persist record and retain schedule |
| Grok | Disabled paid runtime | grok-4.5 reference | Abstain | Paid endpoint prohibited |
| Kimi | Disabled paid runtime | kimi-k2.5 reference | Abstain | Paid endpoint prohibited |
| Muse | Local Ollama unavailable | muse-spark-1.2 configured | Abstain | No valid verdict |

## Dissent
None among valid votes. Cody Strategist objects to repetitive monitoring; cadence changes remain outside this cycle. Qwen's broad claim that no actionable defects exist is not evidence; no new reproduced actionable source defect is established by this scoped review.

## Post-decision Codex debate
KEEP. Prosecutor objects that source remediation and final persistence remain unproven and panel availability is only two families. Defender and Judge hold that recording unresolved failures is valid without certifying either remediation or unperformed persistence. Final empirical and append/readback evidence remain mandatory; future worker exit belongs to launchd.

## Why this verdict
The two supplied entries remain blocked by existing approval/input dependencies. Repeated historical preparation is unnecessary, and neither the vote nor the monitoring checks widen authority. Retain exact unresolved outcomes and finish only the bounded record.