`data/codex-yoloforever/cycle-20260908T1534Z.q8Ieot/dtd-final.md`

24 lines
# DTD Verdict — persist monitoring and return

## DECISION: SHIP
Confidence: medium · Vote: 2/2 valid · Panel availability: 2/6. Scope: truthful monitoring record and normal return to existing runner. Both source outcomes remain UNRESOLVED.

## Model references
| Reference | Runtime | Actual model/reference | Vote | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | Disabled in zero-cost mode | sonnet reference | abstain | No invocation |
| Codex | Codex CLI | gpt-6-astra | SHIP | Persist failure and gates explicitly; do not certify pending work |
| Qwen | Local Ollama | qwen3:14b | SHIP | Bounded monitoring, no new source action |
| Grok | Disabled provider path | grok-4.5 reference | abstain | Paid endpoint forbidden |
| Kimi | Disabled provider path | kimi-k2.5 reference | abstain | Paid endpoint forbidden |
| Muse | Local Ollama unavailable | muse-spark-1.2 | abstain | No valid vote |

## Dissent
None among valid voters. Cody Strategist initially objected to repeated ceremony; final five-lens vote accepted accurate current monitoring. Repeated observations are not implementation.

## Post-decision Codex debate
KEEP. Prosecutor objected that failure, critical skips and unfinished persistence block completion. Defender restricted SHIP to recording those limitations and returning. Judge upheld that distinction while rejecting Qwen unsupported consensus and only-viable-option claims. Future completion claims require actual persistence/commit proof; worker exit remains observable only after return.

## Why this verdict
The current source fails at3074MB; real wholesale/vendor-SKU inputs and exact write approvals remain absent. This decision authorizes no business mutation, source closure, approval inference or schedule change. Closing empirical checks and locked ledger readback are still required.