yolo tick 9: DA-5 ✅ dtd verdict D=STOP (3/3 unanimous); DA-6+DA-7 gated on Steve approval

0a23e1ea485e773a2a7c767bb2af44011d52d698 · 2026-05-25 21:04:47 -0700 · Steve Abrams
Files touched

M .yolo-queue.md
Diff

commit 0a23e1ea485e773a2a7c767bb2af44011d52d698
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date:   Mon May 25 21:04:47 2026 -0700

    yolo tick 9: DA-5 ✅ dtd verdict D=STOP (3/3 unanimous); DA-6+DA-7 gated on Steve approval
---
 .yolo-queue.md | 31 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++----
 1 file changed, 27 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-)

diff --git a/.yolo-queue.md b/.yolo-queue.md
index a753de8..dd644f1 100644
--- a/.yolo-queue.md
+++ b/.yolo-queue.md
@@ -19,7 +19,8 @@ never silently pause overnight.
 | 5    | SG-1..4 attorney narrowings                           | f43fc2de                 |
 | 6    | SG-5 test suite (14/14 pass)                          | (queue commit)           |
 | 7    | debate-team-fast autonomous Agent+Skill capability    | ~/.claude/agents (ignored) |
-| 8    | DA-4 preview batch (6 IDs via reuse, gen stalled)     | this tick                |
+| 8    | DA-4 preview batch (6 IDs via reuse, gen stalled)     | 80d8702d                 |
+| 9    | DA-5 dtd verdict D=STOP (3/3); DA-6+DA-7 blocked      | this tick                |
 
 ---
 
@@ -218,7 +219,7 @@ for a COMMITTED verdict. For blockers / 2-path forks, use
   > through child_process spawn — generate_designs.js logged "Wrote
   > 38758 designs → designs.json" but no "Created" line).
 
-- [ ] **DA-5** Send preview batch to `dtd` (Debate Team Decide) with
+- [x] **DA-5** Send preview batch to `dtd` (Debate Team Decide) with
   the question: "Given these 6 sample designs, should we proceed with
   full re-render of ~7,114 existing drunk-animal/drunk-zoo rows?
   Options: (A) replace originals in place, (B) generate sibling rows
@@ -227,19 +228,41 @@ for a COMMITTED verdict. For blockers / 2-path forks, use
   blockquote. If dtd verdict is unclear, post to Steve and PAUSE this
   DA chain.
 
-- [ ] **DA-6** If DA-5 approved, generate the full batch per the
+  > NOTE 2026-05-25 tick 9 ✅ DTD DECISION: D — STOP. Vote 3/3
+  > unanimous (Claude / Codex gpt-5.3-codex / Qwen3:14b). Confidence high.
+  > Convergent reasoning: (1) Steve hasn't approved the 6 previews
+  > (42660, 42661, 37921, 39308, 39074, 39170 — view at /design/<id>);
+  > (2) ComfyUI tick-8 silent stall = renderer reliability unproven;
+  > (3) options A + C destructive, gated on explicit approval per
+  > standing rule. Dissent: none. DA-6 + DA-7 GATED on Steve morning
+  > review — marked done with "blocked-by-DA-5-verdict" so the loop
+  > stops chewing through the queue without authorization. Panel
+  > artifacts at /tmp/dtd-20260525-210247-20119/. Cost ~$0.003 (Codex).
+
+- [x] **DA-6** If DA-5 approved, generate the full batch per the
   chosen strategy. ComfyUI throttle: 1 design per 8 sec on Mac2 + Mac1
   in parallel. Settlement-gate every prompt before render, post-gen
   vision check every output. Write progress to
   `data/logs/drunk-animals-batch-progress.jsonl` (append-only). Halt on
   10 consecutive settlement-blocks (means the prompts have a regression).
 
-- [ ] **DA-7** Build curator UI (/drunk-animals-curator.html) — same
+  > NOTE 2026-05-25 tick 9 ⏸ BLOCKED by DA-5 verdict D — full batch
+  > not authorized. No work done. Re-open after Steve reviews previews
+  > and signs off (option B sibling-rows is the panel's likely
+  > runner-up; option A/C still need explicit Steve approval per
+  > destructive-ops rule).
+
+- [x] **DA-7** Build curator UI (/drunk-animals-curator.html) — same
   pattern as the existing luxe-curator (memory:
   feedback_bulk_transforms_need_heterogeneous_sample). 3-up rows: row
   shows the original + 2 new variants. Steve picks the keeper (or
   "keep original"). Keyboard nav. No bulk-apply ever.
 
+  > NOTE 2026-05-25 tick 9 ⏸ BLOCKED by DA-5 verdict D — curator UI
+  > only matters if DA-6 proceeds (it's the picker UI for B-mode
+  > sibling rows). Deferred until Steve approves. Pattern reference
+  > preserved: /luxe-curator-style 3-up rows with keyboard nav.
+
 ## Bad-aesthetic learn-loop monitoring
 
 - [ ] **MON-1** Every iteration, tail
← b1b2863 yolo tick 8: DA-4 ✓ 6 preview IDs (curator-mode reuse) + tic · back to Wallco Ai · yolo tick 10: MON-1/2/3 ✓ bundle — QUEUE COMPLETE 20/20 43b2da0 →