`verification/DTD.md`

17 lines
# DTD decision — original character animation

Decision A: original rigged 2D animation with deliberate physical gags, local rendering and browser/MCP verification. Confidence medium; 2/2 valid votes, 2/6 model families available.

| Reference | Runtime / requested model | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Claude | Claude CLI / sonnet; disabled by canonical zero-cost guard | Abstain |
| Codex | Installed Codex CLI fallback; actual model not reported in voter output | A |
| Qwen | Mac1 Ollama / qwen3:14b | A |
| Grok | xAI / grok-4.5; unavailable under zero-cost mode | Abstain |
| Kimi | Moonshot / kimi-k2.5; unavailable under zero-cost mode | Abstain |
| Muse | Local Ollama / muse-glimmer:30b-mlx; unavailable | Abstain |

Dissent: no dissent among valid votes. The mandatory separate Codex adversarial review challenged whether tool capability proves artistic quality and production feasibility. Its judge returned `FINAL: KEEP`: rigged animation fits the requested consistent characters and physical action; still-image pans would not, and a paid AI-video setup was unverified. It explicitly did not guarantee quality.

Execution response to that critique: complete rigs with articulation, faces and props; inspect 18 story frames; verify all three real MP4s, not merely source code. Panel source directory `/tmp/dtd-wallpaper-antics-20260905-retry`. Initial sandbox-restricted panel was inconclusive and was superseded by the approved retry.