← back to Ticket System
Persist cycle ledger and record host environment context
ca66a4da5afd444af1daaa7c32c47abf1687fd63 · 2026-09-16 15:36:51 -0700 · Steve Abrams
Files touched
M data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonlM verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.mdM verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json
Diff
commit ca66a4da5afd444af1daaa7c32c47abf1687fd63
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date: Wed Sep 16 15:36:51 2026 -0700
Persist cycle ledger and record host environment context
---
data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl | 1 +
verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md | 2 ++
verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json | 6 +++++-
3 files changed, 8 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)
diff --git a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
index eeba2954..062c0532 100644
--- a/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
+++ b/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl
@@ -534,3 +534,4 @@
{"timestamp":"2026-09-16T20:24:57.776934+00:00","cycle_id":"yf2015.Qw7Kd2","source_tickets":["TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat","TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da"],"ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"id":"TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat","disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Further cleanup requires exact Steve approval and fresh target-use/owner verification; no missing safe local preparation reproduced. Existing historical cleanup recommendations not safety-certified by this assessment.","evidence":"parent-memo-check.json; empirical-final.json; ops.json"},{"position":2,"id":"TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da","disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Explicit sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 requirement remains; later canonical consolidator supersession and literal 50x25 instruction need owner reconciliation/handoff. No fresh handoff. Ticket-named worker matches absent; no active-owner or abandonment claim. No router claim/edit/re-enable.","evidence":"router-refresh.json; owner-processes.json"}],"implementation_progress":0,"local_preparation":0,"execution_slots_used":0,"execution_cap":6,"monitoring":{"canary":"WARN8percent78GiB","negative":"UNKNOWN","unauth_api":401,"owner_change":false,"status_change":false},"action":"Record unchanged ordered monitoring; preserve existing gates","dtd_verdict":"No initial increment; unchanged blockers not re-debated","cody_verdict":"SHIP IT5/5 monitoring-only","cody_top_fix":"Keep zero progress explicit; require sole-writer handoff/reconciliation before router edits","final_dtd_verdict":"SHIP5/5 monitoring receipt only","tests_evidence":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2015.Qw7Kd2","next_seed":"Fresh queue; router sole-owner reconciliation or changed disk band/explicit approval","gated_memos":["/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md","/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11821-mac2-disk-reclaim-2026-09-16.md","/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11837-color-columns-python-api-pivot.md"],"new_gated_memos":0,"cost":{"provider_usd":0,"paid_http_calls":0,"codex_tokens":"not metered here"},"scheduler":"Existing600sec launchd retained; noSTOPPED","source_outcomes":"UNVERIFIED","terminal_status":"Headless refusal; no force paint","durable_manifest_files":38}
{"timestamp":"2026-09-16T20:45:09.338537+00:00","cycle_id":"yf2036.a3WVke","source_tickets":["TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat","TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da"],"ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"id":"TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat","disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Further cleanup requires exact Steve approval and fresh target-use/owner verification; no missing safe local preparation reproduced. Existing historical cleanup recommendations not safety-certified by this assessment.","evidence":"parent-memo-check.json; empirical-final.json; TK-11784.json"},{"position":2,"id":"TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da","disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Explicit sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 requirement remains; later canonical consolidator supersession and literal 50x25 instruction need owner reconciliation/handoff. No fresh handoff. Ticket-named worker matches absent; no active-owner or abandonment claim. No router claim/edit/re-enable.","evidence":"router-refresh.json"}],"implementation_progress":0,"local_preparation":0,"execution_slots_used":0,"execution_cap":6,"monitoring":{"ordered_entries_assessed":2,"disk":{"unit":"Mac2","reachable":true,"free_pct":8,"free_gb":77,"size_gb":887,"verdict":"WARN"},"note":"Fresh final floor77GiB vs earlier78; same8percentWARN band, no exact1GiB loss inference"},"action":"Read-only assessment; preserve existing gates/owners; retain monitoring receipt","dtd_verdict":"NOT RUN: no new exact implementation increment; unchanged blockers not re-debated","cody":{"verdict":"SHIP IT","tally":"5/5","scope":"receipt only","top_fix":"No reproduced defect; finalize empirical and persistence evidence"},"final_dtd_verdict":{"timestamp":"2026-09-16T20:44:22.745463+00:00","decision":"SHIP","scope":"Monitoring receipt only, conditional on final empirical/persistence checks","confidence":"high for narrow receipt only","tally":"5/5 valid","votes":{"root_codex":"SHIP","codex_cli":"SHIP","qwen":"SHIP","ops":"SHIP","risk":"SHIP"},"non_votes":{"grok":"cost-disabled","kimi":"cost-disabled","muse":"retired","heretic":"error","exo":"no loaded eligible model"},"dissent":"No opposing votes. Strongest objection: repeated monitoring is not implementation progress; outstanding empirical/persistence checks must actually pass.","rejected_claims":["Qwen durable preservation confirmed was premature","Qwen no blockers and absence of dissent do not apply to operational outcomes or stated reviewer objections"],"source_closure":false,"operational_authorization":false,"cost_usd":0},"tests_evidence":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2036.a3WVke","e2e":"PASS monitoring assertions; operational source outcomes UNVERIFIED","next_seed":"Fresh queue; router sole-owner reconciliation or changed disk band/explicit approval","gated_memos":["/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md","/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11821-mac2-disk-reclaim-2026-09-16.md","/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11837-color-columns-python-api-pivot.md"],"new_gated_memos":0,"cost":{"provider_usd":0,"mode":"ZERO_COST_REQUIRED","runtime":"Codex and local model endpoints only","token_count":"not metered here"},"scheduler":"Existing launchd600seconds/noSTOPPED unchanged; cycle exits for next runner invocation","source_status_changes":0,"closures":0}
{"cycle_id": "yf-cycle.xt2EFt", "source_tickets": ["TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat", "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da"], "ordered_dispositions": [{"position": 1, "ticket": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat", "disposition": "no-safe-increment", "reason": "Existing concrete disk memos unchanged; no new safe preparation defect. Further cleanup requires exact approval and fresh target-use proof."}, {"position": 2, "ticket": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da", "disposition": "external-blocked", "reason": "Sole-owner handoff/reconciliation with consolidator supersession absent; related TK11831 worker active."}], "implementation_progress": 0, "local_preparation": 0, "execution_iterations": 0, "max_execution_iterations": 6, "source_closures": 0, "new_gated_memos": [], "monitoring": ["canonical ownership reread", "three memo hashes and link", "pure disk probe and negative case", "API timeout then401", "zero-cost installed preflight", "scheduler600/noSTOPPED"], "initial_dtd": "Not run: no implementation increment selected; unchanged known blockers not re-debated", "next_seed": "Fresh supplied queue; changes to approval/owner handoff; repeat API availability probe before labeling initial timeout persistent.", "timestamp": "2026-09-16T21:14:55.710813+00:00", "action": "Completed ordered read-only monitoring; retain existing gates and owners", "dtd_verdict": "No implementation increment; unchanged blockers not re-debated", "cody": {"verdict": "SHIP IT", "tally": "5/5", "top_fix": "Retain initial API timeout/recovered401 and missing-env dynamic SKIP; no new defect"}, "final_dtd_verdict": {"verdict": "SHIP", "scope": "Monitoring receipt only; source operational outcomes unverified", "tally": "5/5 valid votes", "confidence": "high for receipt only", "dissent": "No opposing vote; Cody limitations retained. Qwen explicit vote but truncated paragraph; no additional claims inferred.", "votes": {"codex.txt": "VERDICT: SHIP\n\nAccept this monitoring-only receipt conditional on completing the final empirical rerun, durable evidence, locked ledger append with readback, and local evidence commit. Those actions remain pending; this verdict establishes neither operational completion nor authorization for source work, cleanup, ownership changes, or closure. The dynamic missing-env test remains SKIP and uncertified; the timeout followed by 401 does not prove a persistent outage. All existing gates, source owners, open statuses, and the USD0 constraint remain intact.", "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n", "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n", "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n", "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n", "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n", "qwen.txt": "VERDICT: SHIP \nThe monitoring-only cycle receipt is accepted as described, with no new defects introduced and all\n", "root-vote.txt": "VERDICT: SHIP\nMonitoring receipt only, conditional on empirical and persistence completion. Source gates and unverified outcomes remain; retain timeout and dynamic-test SKIP.\n", "final-ops.txt": "VERDICT: SHIP\n\nAccept this monitoring-only receipt conditional on the planned final empirical checks, durable evidence retention, locked ledger append with readback, and local evidence commit completing successfully. Ordered assessment identified no new safe preparation or reproduced defect; preserving the disk cleanup gate and sole-owner handoff boundary is operationally correct, while zero implementation and unverified source outcomes are explicitly recorded. The transient API timeout with subsequent401 does not establish an outage, and the skipped dynamic missing-environment test remains an explicit limit rather than a success claim. This vote grants no source execution, closure, runtime mutation, or expanded approval; exit cleanly after persistence and let the existing scheduler supply the next fresh queue. Direct guard/env verified; providerUSD0.\n", "final-risk.txt": "VERDICT: SHIP\nThe monitoring receipt accurately distinguishes observed evidence, skipped certification, unresolved ownership and cleanup gates, and zero executed work. Acceptance is limited to that receipt and remains conditional on the stated empirical rerun and durable persistence with readback; those pending steps must not be presented as already completed. The transient timeout followed by 401 does not establish an outage, and neither ticket closure nor source work is authorized. The explicit missing-env SKIP and retained gates preserve the evidence boundary. USD0 guard was directly verified as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED with DTD_ZERO_COST=1; other technical claims are assessed solely as supplied in final-question.txt.\n"}, "cost_usd": 0}, "tests_evidence": {"final_empirical": "WARN8percent78GiB; negativeUNKNOWN; HTTP401; source state/hash readback PASS", "api_initial": "exit28/10s then401", "zero_cost": "pinned preflightPASS; dynamic missing-envSKIP", "terminal": "headless/refused; noforce", "scheduler": "600sec active; noSTOPPED"}, "cost": {"provider_usd": 0, "paid_endpoints": false, "controls_unchanged": true}, "evidence": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf-cycle.xt2EFt"}
+{"timestamp":"2026-09-16T22:35:40.961841+00:00","cycle_id":"yf2139.YF57g8","coordinator_ticket":"TK-11287-drive-open-tickets-in-board-order-using","source_tickets":["TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor","TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has","TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat","TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2","TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active","TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26","TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude","TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god","TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro","TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a","TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos","TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da","TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit","TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar","TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40"],"ordered_dispositions":[{"position":1,"id":"TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor","disposition":"execute-local","reason":"Implemented offline18-row audit;3/4371cross-name candidate identities UNPROVEN,15/1872unverified; source cost repair remains blocked on identity/priced join evidence and gated adoption.","evidence":["join-parent-proof.json","join-audit/verification/e2e-proof.json"]},{"position":2,"id":"TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has","disposition":"prepared-gated","reason":"Narrow handler-only removal patch verified; preserve7 local photos; exact active application and target activation await Steve.","evidence":["prestige-parent-proof.json","prestige/review.dtOpeo/handoff.json"]},{"position":3,"id":"TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat","disposition":"no-safe-increment","reason":"Existing corrected disk/reclaim memos unchanged; fresh pure canary WARN8percent78GiB, negative UNKNOWN; no missing safe prep reproduced. Cleanup remains gated.","evidence":["existing-memos.json","disk-probe.log.txt","reread-11784.json"]},{"position":4,"id":"TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2","disposition":"prepared-gated","reason":"Concrete roster/capacity memo verified; missing Gemma, WARN8percent78GiB; intended contender and scoped download approval required.","evidence":["model-parent-proof.json","model-prep/handoff.json"]},{"position":5,"id":"TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active","disposition":"prepared-gated","reason":"Verified prefix/source manifest corrects59.50 to sellingprice only; actual acquisitioncost/currentcohortcounts NOT_MEASURED, external vendorproof needed before any gated costmap adoption.","evidence":["pr-parent-proof.json","pr-anchors/source-anchors.json"]},{"position":6,"id":"TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26","disposition":"prepared-gated","reason":"Actual26-row evidence-request manifest verified;10704keymatches and populatedcolumncounts kept separate. Vendor-external costbasis/units/currency/date/discount/identity proof needed before gatedadoption.","evidence":["column-parent-proof.json","column-manifest/manifest.json"]},{"position":7,"id":"TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude","disposition":"owner-active","reason":"Related masterdot worker TK11841 PID94755 and terminal ownerTK11831 PID42322 active; identity diagnosis overlaps their surface; no dispatcher edits/repaint.","evidence":["owner-refresh.json","TK-11851.json"]},{"position":8,"id":"TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god","disposition":"execute-local","reason":"Completed isolated committed one-line detector candidate;9parent-replayed checks PASS, installedsource unchanged. Operational activation and real2daemon proof remain gated/SKIP; sourceblocked, no closure.","evidence":["watch-parent-proof.json","watchtower/review.uegK64/handoff.json"]},{"position":9,"id":"TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro","disposition":"deferred-execution-cap","reason":"Safe offline authority-conflict fixtures identified by DW owner; not executed after6slots. Monetary precedence and canonical price writes remain unapproved.","evidence":["TK-11858.json","queue-final-reread.json"]},{"position":10,"id":"TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a","disposition":"deferred-execution-cap","reason":"Missing concrete credential restriction/quota/budget plan deferred after6slots. Both-host egress and measured cap prerequisite; identity/project changes remain gated.","evidence":["TK-11853.json","queue-final-reread.json"]},{"position":11,"id":"TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos","disposition":"deferred-execution-cap","reason":"Missing concrete29-offer appeal triage/parity packet deferred after6slots. Console appeals and outwardpolicy submissions gated; no blanket appeal authorization.","evidence":["TK-11847.json","queue-final-reread.json"]},{"position":12,"id":"TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da","disposition":"external-blocked","reason":"Explicit sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 and conflicting consolidator supersession require reconciliation/handoff; related terminal worker remains present. No router write/re-enable.","evidence":["TK-11838.json","existing-memos.json","parent-owner-state.json"]},{"position":13,"id":"TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit","disposition":"deferred-execution-cap","reason":"Shared gate/negative-price/productType and nested-repo residual fixes need isolated owner-aware work; deferred after6slots. No existing dirty/source edits taken.","evidence":["TK-11857.json","queue-final-reread.json"]},{"position":14,"id":"TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar","disposition":"deferred-execution-cap","reason":"57-job artifact classification needs per-job post-side-effect proof; deferred after6slots. Live creatorprocess alone not used as activeownership evidence.","evidence":["TK-11856.json","queue-final-reread.json"]},{"position":15,"id":"TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40","disposition":"deferred-execution-cap","reason":"Shared Merchant read-name repair can be isolated and boundarytested; deferred after6slots. No Merchant Center write authorized.","evidence":["TK-11846.json","queue-final-reread.json"]}],"execution_slots_used":6,"execution_cap":6,"actual_implementation_progress":{"local_code_candidates":3,"evidence_manifests":2,"capacity_approval_packet":1,"description":"Offline join audit; Prestige handler patch; isolated Watchtower parser commit; PR source manifest; actual26-vendor cost evidence requests; Gemma roster/capacity memo. These six increments resolve zero operational outcomes for this cycle.","operational_writes":0,"tickets_closed_by_cycle":0},"monitoring":{"assessed_entries":15,"gates_collisions_reads_count_as_implementation":false,"empirical":{"timestamp":"2026-09-16T22:32:05.121635+00:00","scope":"cycle empirical observations and unchanged boundaries, not operational source completion","checks":[{"check":"cost_controls","verdict":"PASS","guard":"ZERO_COST_REQUIRED","environment":"1","dynamic_missing_environment":"SKIP; control deliberately not unset"},{"check":"prestige_existing_API_photo","verdict":"PASS","status":200,"photos":7,"image_status":200,"source_unchanged":true,"candidate_runtime":"SKIP gated"},{"check":"ollama_tags","verdict":"PASS","models":["qwen2.5vl:7b","hermes3:8b","qwen3:14b"],"gemma_missing":true,"interpretation":"Observation only; no restore claim"},{"check":"arena_unauth_API","verdict":"PASS","http_status":401,"authenticated_availability":"NOT_MEASURED"},{"check":"real_disk_probe_and_negative","verdict":"PASS","observations":[{"unit":"Mac2","reachable":true,"free_pct":8,"free_gb":79,"size_gb":887,"verdict":"WARN"},{"unit":"Negative","reachable":false,"verdict":"UNKNOWN"}]},{"check":"cost_snapshot_unchanged","verdict":"PASS","sha256":"fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a"},{"check":"installed_watchtower_unchanged","verdict":"FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT","baseline_head":"5659b951a5da820786da84bfd2079187e5f899a8","observed_head":"a7e005c255e46255f9eb9b633af9502d03a66657","external_owner_evidence":"external-owner-drift.json","full_watch_run":"SKIP forbidden escalation path"},{"check":"existing_scheduler","verdict":"PASS","interval":600,"stopped":false,"launchctl_registered":true},{"check":"modified_UI_CTA_screenrecord","verdict":"SKIP","reason":"No activated or runnable modified web/UI surface; R0 patch only; existing local API/media exercised. Source operational outcomes remain unverified."}],"verdict":"PARTIAL: external-owner installed Watchtower drift; other scoped empirical checks recorded; operational critical paths SKIP and source tickets unresolved"},"peer_watchtower_status":"done","peer_watchtower_owner":"night-TK-11848","peer_claims_independently_certified":false},"action":"Retain reviewed local artifacts, record blockers, preserve peer ownership, exit bounded cycle","dtd_verdicts":{"increment1":{"verdict":"A","valid_tally":"5/5","dissent":"none; limitations and gates retained","votes":{"exo.txt":"[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n","kimi.txt":"[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","heretic.txt":"[ERR heretic]\n","grok.txt":"[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","qwen.txt":"VERDICT: A \nPreparation is required to ensure compliance with hard gates and ZERO_COST constraints. A LOCAL patch artifact must isolate removal of the unused /api/places/photo/:i route while preserving local photo rendering logic and /api/places mapping, as confirmed by server.js analysis. An approval memo is necessary to document assumptions (e.g., no active dependencies on the removed route, local photo plumbing integrity) and flag any proposal changes. Source/data assumptions must be explicitly reproduced to avoid unintended deletions, and the absence of an existing ticket-specific approval memo necessitates this step. No credential/production changes are permitted, aligning with DTD_ZERO_COST=1 and local-only execution requirements.\n","codex.txt":"VERDICT: A\n\nCanonical reread confirms TK-11850 remains open and assigned to claude-run-11615; the checkout is clean at `59d77fc`. All seven photo entries resolve to existing local files, with zero Google references. Prepare removal only of the proxy handler and its accompanying comment, preserving `/api/places`, `photo_urls`, and `/media` rendering. This explicitly corrects the ticket\u2019s broader \u201cdelete photos plumbing\u201d proposal; future Google references would still map to the removed endpoint and require separate review. Artifact persistence is blocked by this session\u2019s read-only filesystem, so no patch or approval memo was saved, no ownership claimed, and no closure or execution performed.","muse.txt":"[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n","root":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare exact patch with local image boundary preserved; execution remains gated.\n","ops":"VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the bounded local patch artifact and approval memo because canonical TK-11850 describes dormant cleanup with no current customer degradation, so creating a key adds credential scope and operational obligations without an established need. The ticket recommendation to delete photos plumbing is broader than the supplied source finding that /api/places maps local images; preserve that mapping and local rendering, and explicitly record the narrower proposal as a correction requiring review. Before proposing route removal, reproduce the local-versus-Google-reference mapping and data assumptions so latent proxy dependencies are surfaced rather than silently severed. Keep the active checkout, service, credentials, and data unchanged, attach evidence and a reversible patch for Steve to review, and retain the source ticket until any approved execution is separately verified.\n\nGuard evidence: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1. Read complete a2a-contract and dtd skills and canonical TK-11850 with tk show. Codex voter only; no Claude runtime, external model APIs, or provider spend. Correlation: yf2139-i1-ops.\n","risk":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare the local patch and approval memo because this permits review without introducing credential exposure, spending authority, or a customer-facing change. The canonical TK-11850 record confirms a dormant key-dependent route and manual scripts, but its earlier suggestion to delete photos plumbing is broader than the present bounded increment: preserve local-photo rendering and /api/places mapping, verify current source/data and references, and explicitly report any Google-reference mapping left pointing at the proposed removed route. The patch must remain an artifact, with no active checkout edits, credential creation, deployment, ticket closure, or assertion that customer behavior is unchanged without evidence. B crosses the credential gate unnecessarily; C leaves authorized low-risk preparation undone.\n\nGuard evidence: independently read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read complete a2a-contract/SKILL.md and dtd/SKILL.md and reread canonical ticket with tk show TK-11850. No other voter outputs read. Provider spend: $0; no Claude runtime or paid APIs.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i1-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Remaining gate: Steve approval for any active/customer-facing/credential execution. Safest next action: parent independently review artifact and prepare the bounded proposal.\n"},"cost_usd":0},"increment2":{"verdict":"A","valid_tally":"5/5","dissent":"none; limitations and gates retained","votes":{"exo.txt":"[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n","kimi.txt":"[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","heretic.txt":"[ERR heretic]\n","grok.txt":"[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","qwen.txt":"VERDICT: A \nPreparation only: A local approval memo is required to restore gemma3:12b, contingent on Steve confirming its intended use and approving the ~8GB download against a fresh disk preflight. The memo must document source roster/tag evidence (e.g., server.js inclusion of gemma3:12b, /api/tags listing qwen2.5vl:7b, hermes3:8b, qwen3:14b) and downstream partial-rating risks (e.g., Mac2 canary WARN8percent78GiB, missing-input UNKNOWN returns). No pull/roster changes or battle actions are permitted without explicit Steve-gated authorization. Existing ticket-specific memo absence is noted, and runtime output files remain isolated but dirty. Model production restart/roster mutation remains under Steve\u2019s control. Codex CLI/local endpoints enforce ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 guardrails. No closure actions are taken.\n","codex.txt":"VERDICT: A\n\nTK-11852 \u00b7 cycle yf2139.YF57g8 \u2014 Approval memo draft: Restore `gemma3:12b` only after Steve confirms it remains intended and approves the ~8GB download against a fresh Mac2 disk preflight. [Source roster](/Users/macstudio3/Projects/model-arena/server.js:78) includes it; supplied `/api/tags` observations list only `qwen2.5vl:7b`, `hermes3:8b`, and `qwen3:14b`. Disk helper reported `WARN8percent78GiB`; missing-input test returned `UNKNOWN`. Arena `/api/models` returned unauthenticated 401, so availability remains unverified. Missing contenders risk incomplete battle coverage and partial ratings. Creator11723 was absent from the supplied exact owner scan; canonical source remains open. Preserve `ZERO_COST_REQUIRED=1`; no pull, restart, roster change, battle, or closure. Runtime outputs remain untouched. Local memo persistence is blocked by this session\u2019s read-only filesystem; this draft was not saved.","muse.txt":"[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n","root":"VERDICT: A\nEvidence-based gated restoration proposal preserves roster intent and disk safety.\n","ops":"VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the local approval memo because the current source roster and reported live tags show a configuration-versus-capacity discrepancy, but neither proves whether gemma3:12b was deliberately retired. A blind roughly 8GB pull would consume scarce disk on a host with a disk-critical history, while deleting the contender would change the meaning of future ratings without a confirmed product decision. The memo should present the roster/tag evidence, distinguish the historical ticket claim about /api/models from the present unauthenticated 401, explain the risk of apparently complete ratings from a reduced field, and ask Steve to confirm roster intent before any restoration. If restoration is approved, require a fresh disk preflight with capacity headroom for download and extraction; neither this memo nor the existing WARN reading authorizes a pull, battle, restart, live roster edit, or ticket closure.\n\nGuard evidence: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1 again for this increment; canonical TK-11852 read using tk show. Codex only, no external provider calls, spend $0. Correlation: yf2139-i2-ops.\n","risk":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare the approval memo because the missing intended contender can bias subsequent ratings, but neither a model download nor a live roster removal is authorized. Preserve the distinction between directly observed Ollama tags and source roster evidence, historical ticket observations, and the presently unverified authenticated API availability field. The reported 78 GiB free does not nullify the 8-percent disk warning or prove that an approximately 8 GB download plus transient storage is safe under concurrent workloads; require a fresh capacity check and Steve confirmation that gemma3:12b remains intended before any pull. Record the partial-rating risk and require post-approval verification of model availability and participant completeness before claiming recovery. B spends storage and changes runtime state without approval; C changes contest semantics without confirming retirement intent.\n\nGuard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment2-question.txt and reread canonical TK-11852 with tk show. Required a2a-contract and dtd skills were read in full earlier in this same delegated session. No other voter outputs read. Provider spend $0; no paid API or Claude runtime.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i2-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Remaining gates: confirmation of intended contender and approval for download or live roster mutation. Safest next action: parent independently inspect this vote and prepare a factual local approval memo, without closing the source ticket.\n"},"cost_usd":0},"increment3":{"verdict":"A","valid_votes_seen":5,"votes":{"exo.txt":"[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n","kimi.txt":"[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","heretic.txt":"[ERR heretic]\n","grok.txt":"[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","qwen.txt":"VERDICT: A \nThe correct action is to prepare the isolated detector fix as specified, replacing `argv grep` with `ps -axo command=` to ensure accurate detection of the PM2 daemon process (`^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon`). This avoids invoking `watch.sh` (which risks unauthorized Claude interactions or state alterations) and adheres to the prohibition against modifying scheduled scripts or starting/stoping PM2. Testing with decoy text and command fixtures at the parser-to-alert threshold ensures robustness without compromising the $0 guard/env or source integrity. The proposed fix from vp-operations aligns with the ticket\u2019s requirement to avoid real second-daemon operational proof pending approval, while maintaining HEAD5659b95\u2019s clean state and avoiding scheduled writer collisions.\n","codex.txt":"VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare an isolated, committed one-line detector fix from clean HEAD `5659b95` for TK-11848, cycle `yf2139.YF57g8`, using `ps -axo command=` and anchored `^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon`. Independently verify live single-daemon detection, decoy rejection, and zero/one/two-daemon fixtures through the parser-to-alert threshold; include replay/negative tests and an activation memo. Preserve the $0 guard/env. Do not invoke `watch.sh`, Claude, paid endpoints, daemon lifecycle operations, sends, or installed-script changes. Explicitly **SKIP real second-daemon operational proof pending approval**; keep the source ticket open and live scheduled activation gated.","muse.txt":"[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n","root":"VERDICT: A\nIsolate and prove parser boundary now; operational activation and real second-daemon proof stay gated.\n","ops":"VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare and commit the isolated detector fix because process-command anchoring directly addresses the documented false alarm while leaving the active scheduled watcher untouched. Read the original script to preserve its actual shell/error semantics, and make the zero-daemon fixture verify both the resulting count and whether grep -c returning status 1 can prematurely terminate the caller; one/two-daemon fixtures must drive the real parser-to-alert threshold rather than a separately invented interpretation. Use read-only live process output to confirm the current genuine daemon spelling and prove decoy command arguments do not count. Keep activation and a real second-daemon lifecycle test explicitly unperformed and gated: fixture success validates the bounded patch, not the complete operational repair, so the source ticket remains open until authorized real-path proof is accepted.\n\nDirect guard evidence: /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1. Canonical TK-11848 reread; installed watch.sh not invoked, no daemon/source action or delegation. Provider spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i3-ops.\n","risk":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare the isolated committed detector fix and activation memo because the canonical evidence identifies an argv-text false positive and the anchored command-column match directly addresses it without executing the installed watcher. The replay must exercise the actual parser-to-alert threshold with zero, one, and two daemon fixtures plus embedded decoy text, and verify the zero-match exit behavior: grep -cE prints 0 but returns status 1, which can abort scripts under errexit instead of producing the intended alert. Inspect the actual shell options and threshold logic, report any necessary deviation from the proposed one-line scope, and validate the local live single-daemon measurement independently. Fixture success cannot establish the real second-daemon operational path; label that critical check skipped and retain the source ticket open pending authorized lifecycle testing and scheduled activation. B risks Claude execution, sends, and runtime mutation; C leaves a concrete, authorized correction unprepared.\n\nGuard evidence: freshly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment3-question.txt and canonical TK-11848 with tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills were read earlier in the same delegated session. No other votes read; no watch.sh execution. Provider spend $0, no Claude runtime or paid API.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i3-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Gates retained: installed script activation, daemon lifecycle, sends, and actual second-daemon proof. Safest next action: parent independently review the vote and prepare the isolated patch and bounded evidence, with source completion explicitly withheld.\n"},"cost_usd":0,"dissent":"none among received votes","rejected_details":[]},"increment4":{"verdict":"A","valid_votes_seen":5,"votes":{"exo.txt":"[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n","kimi.txt":"[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","heretic.txt":"[ERR heretic]\n","grok.txt":"[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","qwen.txt":"VERDICT: A \n**Option A: Create a reusable OFFLINE audit script and retain JSON/Markdown artifacts** \n\nThe task requires generating a **reusable OFFLINE audit script** from the existing `cost-source-triage.json` artifact, preserving metadata (`source_hash`, `generated_at`, and original totals: 18/6243/0). The script must: \n1. **Enumerate 18 COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN rows**\u2014columns with no valid join relationships, which may indicate data integrity gaps or orphaned entries. These rows are preserved without modification. \n2. **Mark three cross-name table candidates** as `UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY` (e.g., `Phillip Jeffries->phillipe_romano_catalog3392`, `Designer Wallcoverings->designers_guild_catalog978`, `Studio Ditte->studio_printworks_catalog1`), explicitly noting their impact on 4371 products. These are flagged due to **heuristic mismatches** (e.g., name variations, catalog ID discrepancies) but not inferred as proven. \n3. **Document six key attempts** to resolve these mismatches (e.g., fuzzy matching, catalog ID alignment, metadata cross-referencing) and **silent SQL errors** (e.g., uncaught join failures, missing constraints). \n4. **Avoid priced-row filtering** to ensure no assumptions about reachability or cost coverage are made. \n\nThe script must **test real artifacts** (e.g., valid `cost-source-triage.json`) and **malformed/mismatched inputs** (e.g., invalid catalog IDs, missing hashes) to validate robustness. No DB/API queries, cost-map edits, or canonical/customer mutations are permitted. \n\n**Key Heuristics**: \n- **Cross-name candidates** are flagged due to name variations (e.g., \"Phillip Jeffries\" vs. \"phillipe_romano_catalog3392\") or catalog ID mismatches, suggesting potential ownership gaps. \n- **Zero reachability** is not proven absent explicit cost or join validation, aligning with the \"no priced-row filtering\" constraint. \n- **Arithmetic verification** (18/6243 + 4371) ensures consistency with prior generator output (parent TK11427). \n\nThis approach adheres to the requirement for **independent root verification** and avoids ownership claims beyond the audit scope. The script is isolated, artifact-based, and compliant with $0 guard/env constraints.\n","codex.txt":"VERDICT: A\n\nCreate the isolated offline audit, preserving source hash, generated_at, all 18 rows and original 18/6243/0 totals. Mark the three cross-name candidates UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY (4,371 products); the other 15 remain unproven. Heuristic table selection, six attempted keys, swallowed SQL errors and no priced-row filtering cannot establish absent cost or broken joins. Require real-input validation and malformed/mismatched-input rejection. Creator process activity does not prove child ownership. This is preparation only, with no coverage lift or source closure.\n\nExecution is blocked by this session\u2019s read-only filesystem: no script or retained artifacts were created, and no tests were run.","muse.txt":"[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n","root":"VERDICT: A\nCorrect the evidence classification without inventing cost facts or touching pricing.\n","ops":"VERDICT: A\n\nCreate the isolated offline audit because retaining the original report and separating heuristic evidence from proven table identity is the most useful bounded correction before any live cost-authority work. Preserve the input hash, generated_at, all 18 rows, and original 18/6243/0 totals; mark the three named cross-table candidates UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY with their combined 4371-product impact without implying the other 15 identities are verified. The output must explain that six attempted join keys, swallowed SQL errors, and missing priced-row filtering cannot establish either absent cost or a broken authoritative join; do not silently reclassify historical zero reachability as a trustworthy measurement. Fail explicitly on malformed or structurally mismatched input and retain real-artifact evidence, while keeping source ownership unchanged and all DB, API, cost-map, pricing, and customer changes outside scope. The live creator process does not prove current ownership of this child task, but the independent offline output also avoids competing with that process.\n\nGuard evidence: independently read config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and environment DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11859 reread. This artifact and its ticket log are the only writes; no other ballots, source edits, APIs, database calls, or paid providers. Cost $0. Correlation yf2139-i4-ops.\n","risk":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare the offline audit and retained artifacts because the source classification overstates what heuristic table selection and six attempted keys can establish. Preserve 18 vendors, 6243 active products, and 0 reported reachable as original report values with source hash and generated_at, not fresh canonical findings. Mark the three named cross-name associations UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY affecting 4371 products; name differences alone establish neither a valid association nor a definitive mismatch, and the other 15 associations remain unverified. Record that silently caught SQL errors, limited key attempts, and absent priced-row filtering prevent the reported zero from proving absent costs or a broken join. Validate expected schema, class count, numeric totals, and malformed/mismatched rejection before emitting conclusions; avoid any implicit cost-coverage lift or repair authorization. B would change live cost authority on insufficient evidence; C leaves a misleading repair premise uncorrected.\n\nGuard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment4-question.txt and canonical TK-11859 via tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills were read earlier in this delegated session. No other ballots read. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API query, or source mutation.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i4-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edits or commit. Residual uncertainty: all 18 candidate table identities and live cost reachability require separate verification; the saved report cannot establish present canonical state. Remaining gates: any cost-map, price-source, canonical, or customer mutation. Safest next action: parent independently inspect this vote and prepare the offline evidence correction, keeping TK-11859 open.\n"},"cost_usd":0,"dissent":"none among received votes","rejected_details":["Qwen invented fuzzy matching/key examples and table suffix numbers in increment4; use literal generator KEYS and tables only"]},"increment5":{"decision":"A","tally":"5/5valid","dissent":"none","votes":{"exo.txt":"[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n","kimi.txt":"[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","heretic.txt":"[ERR heretic]\n","grok.txt":"[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","qwen.txt":"**VERDICT: A** \n\n**Paragraph:** \nOption A is the correct choice because it aligns with the canonical definitions and audit requirements. The ticket claim incorrectly treats Greenland59.50 as a cost, but the canonical skill explicitly identifies it as a **Yard variant/Retail Price**, not a cost. This necessitates marking **SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE** and rejecting the use of Greenland59.50 as a cost (invalidating Option B). Older quote-only notes are explicitly superseded, ensuring no outdated data influences current wholesale absence claims. By preparing an **offline source-anchor manifest** with exact bounded increments, canonical terms (e.g., Cork-legacy DWGL-, DWWL-=RIGO, DWPP-=MDC), and source file hashes, the integrity of Phillipe Romano\u2019s cost sourcing is preserved. Acquisition cost and cohort counts are correctly marked **NOT_MEASURED**, avoiding invented decomposition prefixes (e.g., \"invented232prefix\"). Retaining **PR13066** as active and isolating key-matched rows from catalog rows ensures compliance with cardinality proof requirements. No edits to DB/API/customer/price-map systems are permitted, and the parent\u2019s independent verification of scraper-manager skills confirms the isolated additive evidence. Option C (no correction) would perpetuate the erroneous ticket claim, while Option B conflates retail price with cost. Thus, **A** is the only valid path to rectify the claim and uphold data accuracy.\n","codex.txt":"**VERDICT: A.** Prepare only an isolated, additive offline source-anchor manifest with file hashes and exact cited lines: canonical `Cork-` (legacy `DWGL-`), `DWWL-` = RIGO, and `DWPP-` = MDC. The complete Greenland skill explicitly labels $59.50 as Yard variant/Retail Price: **SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE**; superseded quote-only notes cannot establish current wholesale absence. Acquisition cost and cohort counts remain **NOT_MEASURED**, with no invented 232-prefix decomposition. Preserve reported 13,066 active and 1,082 key-matched separately from 474 populated catalog rows; infer no count bound without cardinality proof. Keep execution Codex/local-only, $0, with environment guards and no DB/API/customer/source/price-map edits. Creator-parent completion establishes no active child claim; this evidence increment does not complete cost sourcing.","muse.txt":"[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n","root":"VERDICT: A\nSource-anchor correction prevents sell-price-to-cost confusion without creating cost authority.\n","ops":"VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the offline source-anchor manifest because correcting a sell-price-versus-acquisition-cost assumption is necessary before the proposed cost model can be reviewed responsibly. Preserve canonical prefix provenance, exact cited source lines and file hashes, explicitly classify 59.50 as SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE, and leave acquisition cost and unsampled cohort counts NOT_MEASURED; superseded quote-only language supplies historical context but cannot prove current wholesale absence. Keep 13,066 active products, 1,082 key matches, and 474 populated candidate catalog rows as separately labeled report measurements, since join fan-out, uniqueness, row predicates and distinct-product cardinality have not been proved, and do not invent a decomposition for the claimed 232 prefixes. This additive manifest advances a concrete correction without competing with creator work or changing canonical cost authority; subsequent sourcing, live reads, pricing changes and source-ticket closure remain outside this decision.\n\nGuard evidence: directly reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11861 reread. No DB/API/source edits, claims, other ballots, terminal painting, Claude runtime or delegation. Provider spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i5-ops.\n","risk":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare the offline source-anchor manifest because the ticket risks turning a documented retail selling price into acquisition cost across a private-label umbrella. Cite and hash the canonical sources for Cork- (legacy DWGL-), DWWL-, and DWPP- without claiming those anchors exhaust or size the reported 232 prefixes. Label 59.50 SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE, acquisition cost and current cohort counts NOT_MEASURED, and superseded quote-only notes historical rather than proof of present wholesale absence. Retain the reported 13066 active products, 1082 key matches, and 474 populated catalog rows as distinct measurements: without uniqueness, fan-out, priced-row, and key-domain proof, their relationship establishes neither priced yield nor a product-count bound. The artifact corrects evidence interpretation only; any acquisition-cost authority or source closure requires separate verification. B risks propagating an unsupported cost; C preserves a material misconception.\n\nGuard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment5-question.txt and canonical TK-11861 via tk show; no other ballots. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills previously read in this delegated session. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API queries, or source edits.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i5-risk\nStatus: complete (independent decision vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Residual risk: current acquisition costs, cohort distribution, join cardinality, and priced coverage remain unmeasured. Remaining gates: any source/price-map/canonical/customer mutation. Safest next action: parent independently verify source anchors and construct the isolated additive manifest when the preceding increment permits; do not claim a coverage lift or close TK-11861.\n"},"cost_usd":0,"operational_authority":false},"increment6":{"decision":"A","tally":"5/5valid","dissent":"none","votes":{"exo.txt":"[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n","kimi.txt":"[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","heretic.txt":"[ERR heretic]\n","grok.txt":"[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n","qwen.txt":"**VERDICT: A** \n\n**Paragraph:** \nOption **A** is the only viable path to ensure compliance with the declared-sourcing requirements while preserving data integrity and avoiding unproven assumptions. Preparing an **offline evidence-request manifest** for the **ACTUAL26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows** explicitly enforces the need for **SKU-matched vendor-external quotes/invoices**, **unit/currency/date alignment**, and **evidence-backed discounts**\u2014all critical to validate cost mappings without relying on unverified metadata (e.g., `price_source/price_effective_date` or `Newmor live_price`). By **preserving candidate table/key/populated-column counts and key-match counts separately**, the process avoids conflating data completeness with cost reachability, which is explicitly disallowed. \n\nStructural/total validation of the **real artifact** and **malformed data** ensures no DB/API/source/cost-map edits are made, preserving the original state of the **cost-source-triage.json** and **historical totals26/12852/10704**. This aligns with the requirement to **block external cost evidence** until verified, preventing premature financial measurement/coverage lifts. While **B** (turning 10704 keymatched into verifiedcost) and **C** (leaving correction undone) may appear expedient, they risk unproven cost assertions or data stagnation. **A** ensures the **ticket remains blocked** until external evidence is formally submitted, maintaining governance and preventing gated adoption without rigorous validation. The **$0guard/env/Codexlocal** context further reinforces the need for artifact-only processing, avoiding any environmental dependencies. Thus, **A** is the only choice that satisfies all constraints: **no edits, no unproven metadata, and strict evidence requirements**.\n","codex.txt":"**VERDICT: A.** Independently read the generator and actual 26 rows; historical totals reconcile to **26 / 12,852 / 10,704**, generated `2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z`. Prepare only the offline manifest, retaining source SHA-256 and every candidate table, key, populated-column count, and key-match count separately. The generator matches keys without requiring populated prices and swallows query errors; names and discount stamps prove neither priced-row reachability nor net cost. Flag `price_source`/`price_effective_date` as metadata-shaped and Newmor `live_price` as unproven. Require declared vendor/table provenance, SKU-matched vendor-external quote/invoice, unit, currency, effective date, and evidence-backed discount before mapping. Include structural/total validation and malformed-input rejection. No sends, DB/API/source/cost-map edits, fresh financial measurement, or coverage lift; preserve $0/env/Codex-local constraints. TK-11860 stays blocked pending external evidence and later gated adoption.","muse.txt":"[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n","root":"VERDICT: A\nActual26-row evidence manifest is concrete safe prep; no cost assertion from shape or join.\n","ops":"VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the offline evidence-request manifest from the report's literal 26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows rather than the ticket's mixed illustrative vendor list, preserving source hash, timestamp and historical 26/12852/10704 totals. Keep populated-column counts and key-match counts separate: the generator's unrestricted key matching and swallowed query errors do not prove populated priced-row reachability, verified net acquisition cost, or a trustworthy coverage lift. Explicitly flag metadata-shaped price_source and price_effective_date columns and unproven derived live_price evidence; for every candidate require a SKU-matched vendor-external quote, invoice or authoritative price basis, dated unit/currency terms, and documented discount provenance where applicable. Structural and total-validation failures must stop generation rather than silently drop rows, while the resulting manifest prepares a precise sourcing request without querying live systems, sending messages, adopting prices, or closing the source ticket.\n\nGuard evidence: directly reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11860 read. Own this vote file and required source log only. No other ballots, source edits or claims, DB/API calls, external messages, paid endpoints or Claude runtime. Spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i6-ops.\n","risk":"VERDICT: A\nPrepare the offline evidence-request manifest from the actual 26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows because the ticket currently conflates matched keys, populated columns, and verified acquisition costs, and its example vendor list diverges from that artifact. Preserve source hash/generated_at and historical 26/12852/10704 totals, with candidate identity, key-match counts, and each populated-column count kept separate. Neither 10704 key matches nor column population proves their intersection, priced reachability, join uniqueness, or net-cost semantics; swallowed query errors further limit the report. Mark price_source and price_effective_date metadata-shaped rather than confirmed price values, leave Newmor live_price unproven, and require SKU-matched vendor-external evidence with unit, currency, effective date, price basis, and any evidence-backed discount before adoption. One example SKU can support an evidence request but cannot automatically validate every row or vendor-wide discount. B converts unverified matches into financial authority; C preserves a misleading readiness claim.\n\nGuard evidence: freshly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment6-question.txt and canonical TK-11860 with tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills previously read in the same delegated session. No other ballots read. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API query, or external message.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i6-risk\nStatus: complete (independent decision vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit, claim, or commit. Residual risk: all financial semantics, current measurements, priced-row reachability, and vendor-wide applicability remain unverified. Remaining gates: external messaging and later cost-map/canonical/customer adoption. Safest next action: parent independently inspect vote and prepare structurally validated source-faithful requests; do not claim cost coverage or source completion, and retain the external-evidence dependency.\n"},"cost_usd":0,"operational_authority":false}},"cody":{"verdict":"SHIP IT isolated preparation artifacts; operational PARTIAL / UNVERIFIED","top_fix":"Reproduced stale position8 report corrected; final external-owner drift retained as FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT","evidence":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-addendum.json"},"final_dtd_verdict":"HOLD-FOR-STEVE","final_dtd_tally":"5/5 valid","tests_evidence":{"report":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md","join_tests":6,"watchtower_checks":9,"other_evidence":["prestige-parent-proof.json","model-parent-proof.json","pr-parent-proof.json","column-parent-proof.json","empirical-final.json"],"source_critical_paths":"SKIP or unresolved; no source completion claim"},"next_seed":"Fresh canonical queue and ownership check. Reconcile peer Watchtower closure evidence; cost-authority conflict TK11858 only if not owned by another active worker. No new implementation after six slots.","gated_memos":[{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md","sha256":"c2b345515c007293bf407e108134426a34748afe69b77af394e8c24a961625c1","state":"pending_approval","copy":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md"},{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md","sha256":"34c462e4a20182ed14d2ac5b62058d6e6d6af919128ebfbcc05cb74e4381a2bf","state":"pending_approval","copy":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md"},{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/_done/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md","sha256":"907658b8314ef432fa21105dee5db70c9c21577bd5924df24c4eb498418adfb6","state":"moved_done_by_other_worker_claims_unverified","copy":"/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md"}],"existing_memos":[{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md","exists":true,"sha256":"b0ccba428030d8b4760a319c3e80023e9677d6453d4f23b2b3e129ed8bdae7b3"},{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11821-mac2-disk-reclaim-2026-09-16.md","exists":true,"sha256":"7bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1"},{"path":"/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11837-color-columns-python-api-pivot.md","exists":true,"sha256":"a7d7cfeb5983a93df549491497a97de9dff9816d033d16b006979f3add25ca9f"}],"cost":{"provider_api_usd":0,"codex_cli_usage":"not independently metered","guard":"ZERO_COST_REQUIRED","DTD_ZERO_COST":"1","controls_changed":false},"deviations":{"execution_order":{"execution_cap":6,"execution_order":[{"slot":1,"position":2,"ticket":"TK-11850","decision":1},{"slot":2,"position":4,"ticket":"TK-11852","decision":2},{"slot":3,"position":1,"ticket":"TK-11859","decision":4},{"slot":4,"position":5,"ticket":"TK-11861","decision":5},{"slot":5,"position":6,"ticket":"TK-11860","decision":6},{"slot":6,"position":8,"ticket":"TK-11848","decision":3}],"order_deviation":"Initial cost-owner-active classification relied on live creator process. Subsequent canonical parent status showed DONE; process alone did not prove child ownership. Positions2and4 preparation occurred before correcting position1; later execution held until positions1,5,6 were assessed and prepared. This ordering deviation is recorded, not described as strict execution order.","prevent_recurrence":"Check canonical parent/source ownership and recent ticket activity before treating process liveness as a collision. Isolated local prep can remain safe."},"fixture_retention":"Initial join test harness cleanup violated retention; corrected to retained fresh dirs and independently retested; no source/prod deletion","evidence_collector":"Duplicate argument corrected; rerun exposed real external source drift, not hidden"},"scheduler":{"existing_interval_seconds":600,"changed":false,"STOPPED":false},"correlation_id":"yf2139-final"}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md
index 1a76cb30..023b7d8b 100644
--- a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md
@@ -50,3 +50,5 @@ Three concrete memos were created; two remain pending and the Watchtower memo wa
The existing scheduler remains registered at600seconds; this cycle did not change it. Next seed is a fresh queue and owner-aware reconciliation, including cost-authority conflict TK-11858 if it is still safely available; several deferred items were claimed by other workers during finalization. No new coordination ticket was created. Terminal-status verification was refused by the headless ownership guard; no parent pane was force-painted.
Final peer update: TK-11848 is now **done** under **night-TK-11848** per 2026-09-16T22:34:26.172Z. This is the other worker's closure; this cycle neither closed it nor independently certified its operational proof. See watch-peer-final.json and cody/final-addendum.json.
+
+Final environment observation: a host command explicitly scoped to the ticket-system working directory lacked DTD_ZERO_COST, while home-context calls still inherited1 and the filesystem guard remained ZERO_COST_REQUIRED. No DTD or provider call ran in that context. Root did not unset or rewrite either control; installed entry-point guard enforcement was already verified.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json
index 3e61f41e..d89e69ca 100644
--- a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json
@@ -6,5 +6,9 @@
"entry_sha256": "7eaac7617e1895247614a136b1d45ae6b7a6b144366d672e5bcad742c97665ca",
"ordered_queue_equality": "PASS15",
"all_disposition_evidence_present": true,
- "source_correlation": "yf2139-final"
+ "source_correlation": "yf2139-final",
+ "canonical_coordinator_readback": "PASS yf2139-final",
+ "guard_final": "PASS unchanged",
+ "environment_observation": "Home-context calls inherit DTD_ZERO_COST=1. Host exec call explicitly scoped to ticket-system workdir returned None; root did not unset or change controls. No DTD/paid/runtime action ran in that missing-env context; guard remains ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and installed guard-forcing preflight passed.",
+ "ledger_first_attempt": "Aborted before append due heterogeneous DTD key names; normalized then single append/readback succeeded"
}
\ No newline at end of file
← 0882c516 Record bounded cycle evidence and preserve concurrent Watcht
·
back to Ticket System
·
Record ordered monitoring cycle with peer ownership changes e53b3918 →