[object Object]

← back to Ticket System

Record bounded cycle evidence and preserve concurrent Watchtower drift

0882c516fc1dd60c0ab7c95765b4a734f40341a0 · 2026-09-16 15:35:58 -0700 · Steve Abrams

Files touched

Diff

commit 0882c516fc1dd60c0ab7c95765b4a734f40341a0
Author: Steve Abrams <steve@designerwallcoverings.com>
Date:   Wed Sep 16 15:35:58 2026 -0700

    Record bounded cycle evidence and preserve concurrent Watchtower drift
---
 verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md   |   52 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11784.json        |  157 +++
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11838.json        |   27 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11846.json        |   26 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11847.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11848.json        |   33 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11850.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11851.json        |   40 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11852.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11853.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11856.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11857.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11858.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11859.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11860.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11861.json        |   19 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/arena-models.json    |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/canonical-final.json |  158 +++
 .../cody/column-join-mismatch.json                 |    1 +
 .../cody/column-malformed.json                     |    1 +
 .../cody/column-replay.json                        | 1464 ++++++++++++++++++++
 .../cody/column-summary.json                       |    1 +
 .../cody/final-addendum.json                       |   52 +
 .../cody/final-proof.json                          |   57 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-review.md |   31 +
 .../cody/initial-proof.json                        |   14 +
 .../cody/initial-review.md                         |   37 +
 .../cody/join-test-1/input.json                    |    1 +
 .../cody/join-test-2/input.json                    |    1 +
 .../cody/join-test-3/input.json                    |    1 +
 .../cody/join-test-4/review.json                   |  743 ++++++++++
 .../cody/join-test-4/review.md                     |   41 +
 .../cody/join-test-5/input.json                    |    1 +
 .../cody/join-test-6/input.json                    |    1 +
 .../cody/prestige-rollback/server.js               |  910 ++++++++++++
 .../cody/second-proof.json                         |   14 +
 .../cody/second-review.md                          |   23 +
 .../cody/watch-proof.json                          |   25 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/decoy_only.fixture.txt       |    1 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/live-process-summary.json    |    8 +
 .../watch-replay/non_numeric_version.fixture.txt   |    1 +
 .../old_decoy_false_positive.fixture.txt           |    2 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/one.fixture.txt              |    1 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/one_plus_decoy.fixture.txt   |    2 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/results.json                 |   83 ++
 .../cody/watch-replay/two.fixture.txt              |    2 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/two_plus_decoy.fixture.txt   |    3 +
 .../cody/watch-replay/zero.fixture.txt             |    1 +
 .../cost-assessment/assessment.json                |   83 ++
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cycle-record.json    |  512 +++++++
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.log.txt   |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.sh        |   26 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/dispositions.json    |  107 +-
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.json |   84 ++
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.py   |   36 +
 .../empirical-harness-correction.json              |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/execution-order.json |   43 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/existing-memos.json  |   17 +
 .../external-owner-drift.json                      |   24 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-dtd.json       |   31 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-ops-vote.txt   |    5 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-question.txt   |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-risk-vote.txt  |    4 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-root-vote.txt  |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/finalize-evidence.py |   67 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-ops.txt   |    5 +
 .../increment1-panel.log.txt                       |    9 +
 .../increment1-question.txt                        |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-risk.txt  |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-root.txt  |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-ops.txt   |    5 +
 .../increment2-panel.log.txt                       |    9 +
 .../increment2-question.txt                        |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-risk.txt  |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-root.txt  |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-ops.txt   |    5 +
 .../increment3-panel.log.txt                       |    9 +
 .../increment3-question.txt                        |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-risk.txt  |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-root.txt  |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-ops.txt   |    5 +
 .../increment4-panel.log.txt                       |    9 +
 .../increment4-question.txt                        |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-risk.txt  |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-root.txt  |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-ops.txt   |    5 +
 .../increment5-panel.log.txt                       |    9 +
 .../increment5-question.txt                        |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-risk.txt  |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-root.txt  |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-ops.txt   |    5 +
 .../increment6-panel.log.txt                       |    9 +
 .../increment6-question.txt                        |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-risk.txt  |    6 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-root.txt  |    2 +
 .../join-parent-tests.log.txt                      |   17 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memo-retention.json  |   20 +
 .../memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md |   52 +
 .../TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md    |   41 +
 .../TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md       |   26 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/models-tags.json     |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/owner-refresh.json   |   45 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/claude.txt               |    2 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/codex.txt                |    3 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/exo.txt                  |    1 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/grok.txt                 |    1 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/heretic.txt              |    1 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/kimi.txt                 |    1 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/muse.txt                 |    1 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/question.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/final-dtd-path/qwen.txt                 |    2 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/codex.txt           |    3 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/exo.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/grok.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/heretic.txt         |    1 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/kimi.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/muse.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/question.txt        |    1 +
 .../panels/increment1-dtd-path/qwen.txt            |    2 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/codex.txt           |    3 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/exo.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/grok.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/heretic.txt         |    1 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/kimi.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/muse.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/question.txt        |    1 +
 .../panels/increment2-dtd-path/qwen.txt            |    2 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/codex.txt           |    3 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/exo.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/grok.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/heretic.txt         |    1 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/kimi.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/muse.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/question.txt        |    1 +
 .../panels/increment3-dtd-path/qwen.txt            |    2 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/codex.txt           |    5 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/exo.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/grok.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/heretic.txt         |    1 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/kimi.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/muse.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/question.txt        |    1 +
 .../panels/increment4-dtd-path/qwen.txt            |   17 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/codex.txt           |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/exo.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/grok.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/heretic.txt         |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/kimi.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/muse.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/question.txt        |    1 +
 .../panels/increment5-dtd-path/qwen.txt            |    4 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/codex.txt           |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/exo.txt             |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/grok.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/heretic.txt         |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/kimi.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/muse.txt            |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/question.txt        |    1 +
 .../panels/increment6-dtd-path/qwen.txt            |    6 +
 .../parent-owner-state.json                        |  202 +++
 .../persistence-proof.json                         |   10 +
 .../queue-final-reread.json                        |  239 ++++
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-numbers.json   |    1 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11784.json    |  142 ++
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11848.json    |   37 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11852.json    |   24 +
 .../reread-11859-claim.json                        |   44 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/scheduler.json       |    1 +
 .../terminal-owner-final.txt                       |    2 +
 .../yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-durable.json   |    6 +
 .../watch-peer-final.json                          |   33 +
 .../watchtower-baseline.json                       |    8 +
 .../zero-cost-preflight.log.txt                    |   12 +
 173 files changed, 6443 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-)

diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..1a76cb30
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+# Bounded cycle yf2139.YF57g8
+
+Final DTD: **HOLD-FOR-STEVE**, 5/5 valid votes. Cody: **SHIP IT for preparation artifacts only**, five inline lenses from one independent reviewer. Six execution slots used; all 15 supplied entries assessed. No operational source outcome completed or ticket closed by this cycle. Provider API spend $0; Codex usage was not independently metered.
+
+## Actual implementation and evidence
+
+- TK-11859: built retained offline audit of all 18 join candidates. Six boundary tests passed. Three candidate table identities remain unproven (4,371 historical active products); all candidates still need actual cost/join proof.
+- TK-11850: staged a narrow photo-route removal patch preserving the seven local photos. Parent syntax, exact patch, unchanged source and existing API/media checks passed. Modified application runtime, CTA and screenrecord SKIP; activation is gated.
+- TK-11852: prepared roster/capacity decision memo. Real tags show Gemma missing; authenticated arena availability NOT_MEASURED (unauthenticated request401). Disk probe WARN8%, final79GiB; negative probe UNKNOWN. No download or roster change.
+- TK-11861: verified ten exact source quotations across three source hashes. Greenland59.50 is selling-price evidence, not acquisition cost. Current cost/cohort measurements remain NOT_MEASURED.
+- TK-11860: generated the actual26-vendor evidence-request manifest, preserving key matches separately from populated columns; structural totals and malformed-input rejection passed. No external requests sent or costs adopted.
+- TK-11848: committed isolated detector candidate dfa2963a10f92bd675c40d39ef5071898ece883e. Parent and Cody independently replayed nine parser/threshold checks; real second-daemon and whole-watcher proof not performed by this cycle.
+
+## Final operational boundary: PARTIAL
+
+Final empirical verification caught **FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT**: installed Watchtower changed from5659b95 to a7e005c after another worker claimed TK-11848. That worker moved the memo to `_done` and appended claims of activation and real-second-daemon testing. These are third-party claims, not this cycle's independently verified operational proof. This cycle did not install, revert, activate, rerun the full watcher, or recertify that change. The isolated candidate remains retained. Reconcile current ownership and evidence before further action. See [drift](external-owner-drift.json), [empirical checks](empirical-final.json), and [current source states](canonical-final.json).
+
+Other final checks passed: existing Prestige API+media, actual Ollama tags, arena unauth401, disk positive/negative probes, unchanged cost-input hash, cost controls, existing600-second launchd registration and absent STOPPED sentinel. Critical operational paths remain SKIP; this is not an E2E completion claim for source outcomes. Read-only assessments and gates count as zero implementation.
+
+## Ordered dispositions
+
+| Position | Source | Disposition | Evidence-backed reason |
+|---|---|---|---|
+| 1 | TK-11859 | execute-local | Implemented offline18-row audit;3/4371cross-name candidate identities UNPROVEN,15/1872unverified; source cost repair remains blocked on identity/priced join evidence and gated adoption. |
+| 2 | TK-11850 | prepared-gated | Narrow handler-only removal patch verified; preserve7 local photos; exact active application and target activation await Steve. |
+| 3 | TK-11784 | no-safe-increment | Existing corrected disk/reclaim memos unchanged; fresh pure canary WARN8percent78GiB, negative UNKNOWN; no missing safe prep reproduced. Cleanup remains gated. |
+| 4 | TK-11852 | prepared-gated | Concrete roster/capacity memo verified; missing Gemma, WARN8percent78GiB; intended contender and scoped download approval required. |
+| 5 | TK-11861 | prepared-gated | Verified prefix/source manifest corrects59.50 to sellingprice only; actual acquisitioncost/currentcohortcounts NOT_MEASURED, external vendorproof needed before any gated costmap adoption. |
+| 6 | TK-11860 | prepared-gated | Actual26-row evidence-request manifest verified;10704keymatches and populatedcolumncounts kept separate. Vendor-external costbasis/units/currency/date/discount/identity proof needed before gatedadoption. |
+| 7 | TK-11851 | owner-active | Related masterdot worker TK11841 PID94755 and terminal ownerTK11831 PID42322 active; identity diagnosis overlaps their surface; no dispatcher edits/repaint. |
+| 8 | TK-11848 | execute-local | Completed isolated committed one-line detector candidate;9parent-replayed checks PASS, installedsource unchanged. Operational activation and real2daemon proof remain gated/SKIP; sourceblocked, no closure. |
+| 9 | TK-11858 | deferred-execution-cap | Safe offline authority-conflict fixtures identified by DW owner; not executed after6slots. Monetary precedence and canonical price writes remain unapproved. |
+| 10 | TK-11853 | deferred-execution-cap | Missing concrete credential restriction/quota/budget plan deferred after6slots. Both-host egress and measured cap prerequisite; identity/project changes remain gated. |
+| 11 | TK-11847 | deferred-execution-cap | Missing concrete29-offer appeal triage/parity packet deferred after6slots. Console appeals and outwardpolicy submissions gated; no blanket appeal authorization. |
+| 12 | TK-11838 | external-blocked | Explicit sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 and conflicting consolidator supersession require reconciliation/handoff; related terminal worker remains present. No router write/re-enable. |
+| 13 | TK-11857 | deferred-execution-cap | Shared gate/negative-price/productType and nested-repo residual fixes need isolated owner-aware work; deferred after6slots. No existing dirty/source edits taken. |
+| 14 | TK-11856 | deferred-execution-cap | 57-job artifact classification needs per-job post-side-effect proof; deferred after6slots. Live creatorprocess alone not used as activeownership evidence. |
+| 15 | TK-11846 | deferred-execution-cap | Shared Merchant read-name repair can be isolated and boundarytested; deferred after6slots. No Merchant Center write authorized. |
+
+## Deviations and reproduced corrections
+
+Actual execution order was positions **2,4,1,5,6,8**, not strict queue order. A live creator process was initially mistaken for active ownership; canonical parent status later showed DONE. Earlier cost preparation was then resumed before later execution. Future collision checks must include current source/parent ownership and activity, not process liveness alone. See execution-order.json.
+
+The first join-test harness deleted its own temporary fixtures; this violated the requested retention rule. It was corrected to fresh retained directories and tests were independently rerun. No source/production deletion occurred. Cody reproduced stale position8 reporting; root corrected it and Cody verified the correction. The final empirical collector had a duplicate-argument TypeError; its local parameter was corrected, then rerun caught the genuine external drift and retained that failure.
+
+## Retention and next cycle
+
+Three concrete memos were created; two remain pending and the Watchtower memo was moved to `_done` by another worker. [Memo paths/hashes](memo-retention.json). No authority is inferred from that move. Five cost/photo/model source tickets remain blocked; Watchtower was blocked by this cycle and subsequently claimed by a peer. Source statuses are point-in-time snapshots, not an ownership lock.
+
+The existing scheduler remains registered at600seconds; this cycle did not change it. Next seed is a fresh queue and owner-aware reconciliation, including cost-authority conflict TK-11858 if it is still safely available; several deferred items were claimed by other workers during finalization. No new coordination ticket was created. Terminal-status verification was refused by the headless ownership guard; no parent pane was force-painted.
+
+Final peer update: TK-11848 is now **done** under **night-TK-11848** per 2026-09-16T22:34:26.172Z. This is the other worker's closure; this cycle neither closed it nor independently certified its operational proof. See watch-peer-final.json and cody/final-addendum.json.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11784.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11784.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..54a7eaa6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11784.json
@@ -0,0 +1,157 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-15T20:56:55.270Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "title": "yoloforever autonomous loop \u2014 DTD+Cody gated, reversible-only, draft gated",
+    "project": "ops",
+    "agent": "yoloforever-loop",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-15T20:58:57.513Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "yoloforever-loop",
+    "text": "Cycle1 seed=Mac2 disk CRITICAL (3%/28GB). Routed read-only diag to vp-operations. Parallel prep: dead-plist cluster verified = gated installs not kickstarts (approval-invisibility/eas-asc-gap missing/DRAFT plist; dw-mdc-margin DRAFT by-design=drop)."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T00:33:49.814Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "yf0024-ops COMPLETE bounded READ-ONLY reassessment only, source outcome UNVERIFIED. Canonical open/assignee yoloforever-loop re-read before work; PID11381 absent, no exact-ticket process observed, no ownership transfer inferred. Fresh local Data volume df remains98% capacity/about24GiB available. Existing Sep12 TK11542 Steve-only disk-clear bundle and two Henry offload scripts retained/read/hashed; reclaim yield stale and scripts not run or safety-certified. No duplicate memo needed. Exact blocker: current owner handoff/specific cleanup authorization and current target reclaim evidence absent. Safest next: with owner/parent agreement refresh existing proposal for one exact reclaim target plus active-use evidence, then Steve approval before cleanup. Evidence /private/tmp/yf0024.GCwa1x/ops-assessment.json and .md; JSON/exact readback PASS, source recovery SKIP. Guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED verified; paidprovider$0,0execution slots,0implementation,0newmemos; no external calls,recursive scans,Claude,runtime/status/owner changes. No commit; parent acceptance pending. correlation=yf0024-ops"
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T09:39:07.488Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "kind": "note",
+    "agent": "dot-supervisor",
+    "text": "[dot-supervisor/lightblue] Mac2 Data volume verified 98% used / 20GB free at 2%, trending down (28GB\u219224GB\u219223GB\u219220GB since 2026-09-15 20:58); reclaim memo 2026-09-15-mac2-disk-CRITICAL-reclaim.md + _BATCH-DISK-SAFE-RECLAIM.sh sit unapproved in pending-approval, and the session carries no ticket id (label says TK REQUIRED) though TK-11784 already owns this seed \u2014 blocked on Steve's disk-delete gate, not on agent work. \u2014 suggest: Steve runs the safe Tier-1 reclaim now (npm/uv/pi"
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T11:00:58.763Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1049-ops-correction COMPLETE local informational preparation only after finalDTD6/6 FIX-THEN-SHIP/KEEP. Reverified ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 and canonical open owner yoloforever-loop/activity09:39:07.488Z; ownership/status retained. New standalone correction /Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md sha256 bf9d732faa8a6e6e9033ea523d6054af764318533a9643a58ba6071802338ee0. R0 proof /private/tmp/yf1049.MPMeY4/ops-correction.json: exclusive-create/fsync/readback/arithmetic/original-hash unchanged PASS.54/926=5.8315%,7% requires64.82GiB under stated assumptions; no fresh measurement. Original linked/preserved; non-executable informational APPROVE/REVISE/BLOCK cannot approve operations; no duplicate cleanup ask.1local prep,0operational implementation,source outcomesUNVERIFIED. No actual reclaim/freshcanary/restore-safety certification; all cleanup/DB/model/offload/destructive gates HELD. No new ticket/Claude/paid endpoints/terminal paint. providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance,durable retention and commit pending; safest next independently verify correction and retain with parent monitoring receipt."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T11:09:49.125Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "kind": "note",
+    "agent": "night-TK-11819",
+    "text": "READ-ONLY corroboration (night-TK-11819, 4AM loop 2026-09-16T11:07, NOT taking ownership \u2014 this is a live loop): confirming your disk seed independently. /System/Volumes/Data = 926Gi, 868Gi used, 19Gi avail, 98% capacity (matches dot-supervisor's 20GB->trending-down reading). Reclaim stays Steve-gated (disk deletes) \u2014 memo + _BATCH-DISK-SAFE-RECLAIM.sh already drafted in pending-approval. No agent action from me; standing down on this ticket."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T15:51:15.048Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "masterdot-lightblue",
+    "text": "masterdot-lightblue re-verify: the Mac2-disk-CRITICAL seed this ticket was tracking (yoloforever cycle1, 2026-09-15 20:58) is RESOLVED -- Steve fired dropdb stayclaim + ollama rm heretic at 15:41:19Z (logged under TK-11791), disk moved 18Gi/2%(CRITICAL)->66Gi/7.13%(WARN). Re-verified live via df just now, matches. Flagging here since this ticket's cycle-log still shows the CRITICAL framing as of the 11:09Z note."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T15:51:45.446Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1548-ops NEW SOURCE FACTS read-only: current Mac2 Data df used=861887316KiB avail=69109700KiB capacity=93%; exact canary floor(avail*100/(used+avail))=7, verdict=WARN. Disk CRITICAL clearance proven at sample; WARN remains. Existing owner memo sha256=09827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b now reports Steve executed stayclaim deletion and Heretic removal at15:40Z; executed-reversible ledger lines83464-83465 corroborate. These are owner/Steve actions, not this loop implementation or further cleanup approval. Canary latest still15:21:28Z FAIL/2%/18GiB predates reclaim. Local Ollama /api/tags lacks qwen3.8-27b-heretic:latest; panel retains reference and ERR fallback, no pull/inference. Restore integrity, service and autonomous-loop recovery NOT certified. Canonical re-read immediately before append: open owner yoloforever-loop, prior activity11:09:49.125Z retained. Disposition no-safe-increment for this loop; further cleanup external-gated, runtime UNKNOWN.0implementation/0execution slots/providerUSD0. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1548.L231qV/ops.json and ops.md; parent acceptance pending."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T15:53:51.534Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1548-ops CORRECTION to15:51:45 source action: earlier read of disk canary latest showed15:21:28Z FAIL/Mac2 2%/18GiB; while this read-only assessment ran, scheduled canary updated latest at15:51:29Z to top-level WARN, Mac2 WARN7%/65GiB and other3 units OK. Re-read confirms15:51:29Z snapshot. Prior action incorrectly carried earlier stale wording across this concurrent update; temporal race now corrected in ops.json/ops.md. Point-in-time disk CRITICAL clearance remains proven and stored canary independently corroborates it; no canary run initiated by this child. Restore was not tested and is not required for disk-threshold claim. Canonical re-read: open owner yoloforever-loop unchanged; no status/owner change.0implementation/slots/providerUSD0, guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 reverified."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T16:30:13.163Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1625-ops MONITORING ONLY: fresh Data df 853572312KiB used/77424704KiB available (73.838GiB), canary floor 8% WARN; scheduled 2026-09-16T09:21:30-07:00 independently Mac2 WARN8%/74GiB, other3 OK. Critical clearance persists; WARN remains; runtime/restore not certified. Guard exactly ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env DTD_ZERO_COST1. Source open owner yoloforever-loop retained. Existing cleanup gates and TK11821 unpushed-commit caution retained, no-safe-increment.0implementation/slots/providerUSD0, no operations/canary run/cleanup/terminal changes. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1625.p5jHYW/ops.json and ops.md; child receipt complete, parent independent acceptance pending. Safest next existing scheduled monitoring, exact approval before any additional cleanup."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T16:54:28.593Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1649-ops MATERIAL FACT monitoring: fresh Data volume 84.206GiB/9% WARN; stored canary 2026-09-16T09:51:31-07:00 corroborates WARN9%, previously8%. TK11821 proposal hash changed with reconciliation/backup claim plus retained bottom caution; no independent target/restore certification or additional cleanup permission. Source owner/status retained. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1649.VDC2S9/ops.json; zero operational implementation.",
+    "correlation_id": "yf1649-ops-source"
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T17:39:21.601Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1734-ops COMPLETE bounded read-only monitoring. Data df 82.177GiB/9% WARN; stored10:21:35-07:00 Mac2 WARN9%, othersOK. MATERIAL evidence-location change: original critical reclaim memo absent at pending root, exists pending-approval/_done/2026-09-15-mac2-disk-CRITICAL-reclaim.md with identical SHA25609827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b; two other memo hashes unchanged. Filing is not approval or proof of cleanup. Source open/yoloforever-loop preserved; no-safe-increment,0implementation,USD0. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1734.Jd4Mjc/ops.json and ops.md; runtime/restore checks SKIP outside monitoring; parent acceptance pending. Next independent path/hash verification and existing scheduled monitoring; exact cleanup scope still gated."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T18:50:23.778Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1840-disk MATERIAL monitoring change: actual installed disk canary probe now WARN8percent79GiB (earlier cycle sample WARN9percent79GiB); negative unreachable UNKNOWN, API401, three existing memo hashes unchanged. Source remains open/yoloforever-loop. No cleanup/operations/closure; current source outcomes UNVERIFIED. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1840.CgXUrC/empirical-final.json. Guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1;0implementation/0slots/USD0. Preserve exact cleanup approval gate."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:11:34.629Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1902-linkfix RESUME scoped local preparation after DTD5/5 A: repair only informational correction Source href by adding _done/, preserve all gate text and original memo. Canonical source open/yoloforever-loop re-read; owner/status retained. Before SHA256bf9d732faa8a6e6e9033ea523d6054af764318533a9643a58ba6071802338ee0; target hash verified. No cleanup or operational approval; guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1, providerUSD0."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:11:44.904Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1902-linkfix COMPLETE local documentation preparation only: changed ONE Source href in existing yf1049 correction to _done/2026-09-15-mac2-disk-CRITICAL-reclaim.md. E2E parsed Markdown destination exists/hash09827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b; exact one-link diff and all other bytes/original unchanged PASS. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1902.dMfJps/linkfix.json with before.md/after.md; ops.json/ops.md reconcile execute-local,1localprep,1of6slots,0operationalimplementation. Source stays open/yoloforever-loop; cleanup/DB/model/offload/destructive gates unchanged. GuardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1, providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance and retained-evidence commit pending; runtime/restore SKIP outside scope."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:14:15.163Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1902-parent-accept Parent independently verified scoped local preparation: existing correction Source href now resolves _done original SHA25609827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b; exact one-href diff, all remaining correction bytes and gates preserved. Live correction SHA256b0ccba428030d8b4760a319c3e80023e9677d6453d4f23b2b3e129ed8bdae7b3. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1902.dMfJps/parent-link-proof.json and linkfix.json.1local-prep/1of6 slots,0operational implementation. Source open/yoloforever-loop retained; cleanup/runtime/restore outcomes UNVERIFIED and exact approval gates unchanged. Cody final5/5 SHIP IT for local repair; final DTD and cycle persistence pending. ProviderUSD0."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:33:28.416Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1928-ops MATERIAL documentation defect: existing TK-11821 reclaim memo still attributes historical recovery to on-its-own/APFS churn, while canonical source15:51:15Z records Steve dropdb stayclaim + ollama rm heretic15:41:19Z. Propose exact historical-attribution correction to existing memo only, pending root DTD; zero implementation/newmemos/slots. Fresh df WARN8percent 79.319GiB; prior repaired Source link resolves and original hash unchanged. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/ops.json and ops.md. Source owner/status retained; cleanup/restore/target safety gates HELD, runtime checks SKIP. GuardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent acceptance pending."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:36:05.723Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1928-increment-resume RESUME source for bounded local memo preparation. Canonical re-read open/yoloforever-loop, latest action our ops proposal; TK11821 is done and no ticket-named active process found, memo unchanged hashadd08e9a. Parent reproduced unsupported APFS attribution versus15:51:15.048Z canonical report. DTD majority A (panel Codex+Qwen and root+Ops; risk ballot pending). Execution waits final ballot; exact one-paragraph correction only with reported attribution, all remaining bytes/gates retained. No operational writes/closure. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN.",
+    "correlation_id": "action-mu4i3zze-73052-3pckew"
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:37:19.010Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1928-ops-repair COMPLETE local preparation only after root DTD A5/5 and resume. Replaced EXACTLY ONE State bullet in existing TK11821 memo: historical recovery now explicitly reported by canonical TK11784 event15:51:15.048Z, Steve cleanup15:41:19Z,66GiB/7.13%WARN; independent causality not established. Exact single replacement/all other bytes+gates/live backup equality PASS. Before SHA256add08e9a8cc39423a60a7027c5f6100f52cb2d27c603beb4072d2c2119679940 after SHA2567bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/repair.json before.md after.md ops.json ops.md.1localprep/1slot/0operationalimplementation/0closures; source open/yoloforever-loop retained. Runtime/restore/cleanup safety SKIP outside scope; no embedded command executed. GuardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent acceptance/retention pending."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:38:08.991Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1928-parent-accept Parent independently accepted repair: direct before/after splitlines shows exactly State line9 changed; all other bytes identical, live equals after SHA2567bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1; reported attribution and causal limitation explicit.1localprep/1of6 slots/0operational implementation. Source outcome UNVERIFIED/open, gates unchanged. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/parent-repair-proof.json. Proceeding queue position2 assessment, Cody/finalDTD and retention pending.",
+    "correlation_id": "action-mu4i6n94-73052-v34bio"
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:57:49.691Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1954-ops COMPLETE bounded read-only assessment: no-safe-increment. Canonical source open/yoloforever-loop; three existing memo hashes unchanged from accepted repairs, Source resolves, historical attribution/causal limitation retained. Fresh df WARN 8% 78.848GiB; scheduled12:51:41PDT WARN8percent78GiB. No further local defect reproduced; operational/restore/target safety UNVERIFIED. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1954.Dkx8oQ/ops.json and ops.md.0implementation/0slots/0newmemos/0closures; gates HELD, guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance pending."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11838.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11838.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9ef1ea47
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11838.json
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T18:45:55.731Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+    "title": "dot-screen-router durable anti-thrash: data-drive layout.json + ENFORCED flock + git-track + fan-out discipline (DTD verdict C)",
+    "project": "infra",
+    "agent": "night-TK-11831",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T18:46:40.985Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "night-TK-11831",
+    "text": "DTD verdict (human /dtd, night-TK-11831, 2026-09-16): C=BOTH, hardened by Cody. 4/5 C (Claude+Arch+Ops+Codex), 1 B (pragmatist); qwen abstain, grok/kimi cost-disabled. DO: 1) move layout params shape/column/overlap/tile OUT of router.sh INTO layout.json [B]; 2) replace the ADVISORY DM-hold with a REAL flock/pidfile mutex the launchd loop refuses to write/reload through [A enforced, not advisory \u2014 advisory failed 5x today]; 3) git-track router.sh + layout.json [fixes the standing gitify-rule violation]; 4) fan-out discipline: route ALL layout edits through ONE owner screen1-columns-coord/TK-11837, stop parallel sessions on this serial file."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T19:39:15.334Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+    "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "text": "correlation=yf1928-router-monitor READ-ONLY ordered queue position2: canonical still open/night-TK11831 at18:46:40.985Z. Ticket worker PIDs66785/TK11838 and58420/TK11831 observed earlier this cycle, absent on19:38:37Z direct ps recheck; no productivity or abandonment inferred. Existing sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 instruction preserved; TK11837 later carries conflicting auto-fit versus superseded-by-consolidator reports. Disposition external-blocked pending sole-owner reconciliation/handoff; no claim, router edit/re-enable, or closure. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/ownership.json and router-owner-events.json. Prior liveness assertion failed and was replaced with fresh explicit evidence;0implementation for this entry.",
+    "correlation_id": "action-mu4i8105-73052-ryzibh"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11846.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11846.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..cc69c05a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11846.json
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:28.737Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+    "title": "gmc-titlefix _mc-read-v1.js getProduct() 400s on legacy bare-variant-id offers \u2014 a NOT_MEASURED that reads like 'no data'",
+    "project": "gmc-titlefix",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11307",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:40.425Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11307",
+    "text": "Found while verifying TK-11307's MDC Google sample titles. _mc-read-v1.js toV1Name() unconditionally prepends 'online~', producing accounts/<mid>/products/online~en~US~<offerId>. MDC's 945 offers are on the LEGACY bare-variant-id feed and are named en~US~<offerId> (no 'online~'), so getProduct() returns HTTP 400 '[name] Invalid' for every one \u2014 12/12 in my first sample. Hitting the stored gmcName directly returned all 945 fine. RISK: a caller that treats a throw/400 as 'no override present' gets a clean-looking FALSE NEGATIVE on a compliance check. Fix shape: accept a full gmcName, or only prepend 'online~' when the id is not already a '<lang>~<country>~<id>' triple, and make a 400 loudly NOT_MEASURED rather than an absence. Read-only finding; nothing changed."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:43.250Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11307",
+    "text": "Low urgency but real: the shim is shared, and its own header says the field-mapping risk is meant to live in ONE audited place \u2014 this is that place, so the fix belongs here rather than in each caller. Repro: node -e with getProduct('44594816778291') vs a direct GET on accounts/146735262/products/en~US~44594816778291."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11847.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11847.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a3bd66df
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11847.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:04.463Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+    "title": "GMC alcohol/legal_restrictions false positives: 29 offers disapproved because 'Champagne' is a COLORWAY name \u2014 same classifier bug as TK-11449's Hemp/tobacco, appeal-clearable",
+    "project": "dw-commerce",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11449",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:45.082Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11449",
+    "text": "FILED BY claude-run-11449, found while closing TK-11449. Nobody was looking for this \u2014 it surfaced from an account-wide policy-family walk I ran only to prove TK-11449's tobacco count was complete.\n\nMEASURED 2026-09-16, READ-ONLY, $0: complete products.list walk, 61,992 live GMC offers, walk_complete=true. 29 offers carry DISAPPROVED|legal_restrictions_policy_violation (all 29 also carry NOT_IMPACTED|alcohol_policy_violation, which names the classifier doing it). Evidence: gmc-titlefix/data/tk11449-policy-locate.json.\n\nIT IS THE SAME BUG TK-11449 JUST SPENT DAYS ON, WEARING A DIFFERENT WORD. TK-11449's six were DISAPPROVED for tobacco_policy_violation because 'Hemp' is in the product name of a grasscloth wallcovering. These are DISAPPROVED because a COLORWAY is named after a drink: 22 of the 29 titles contain 'Champagne' \u2014 Fasano Champagne, Caorle Champagne, Polignano Champagne, Portovenere Champagne, Termoli Champagne, Follonica Champagne, Fasano Champagne III. 21 of 29 are Fentucci Naturals, the SAME vendor. Nobody is selling champagne; 'Champagne' is a beige.\n\nTHE FOOTPRINT IS WIDER THAN THE OBVIOUS WORD, AND THAT MATTERS FOR WHOEVER SCOPES THE FIX \u2014 a grep for 'champagne' would miss a quarter of them. The 7 non-Champagne titles:\n  44724797538355  2appr/4disa  Apollo Chardonnay\n  44724798193715  2appr/4disa  Infinity White Zinfandel\n  44736900464691  0appr/6disa  Vista Wine | Maharam\n  40977437818931  2appr/4disa  McKinley Park Type 2 | Phillipe Romano\n  44508742418483  2appr/4disa  Colonne Une V\u00e9ritable Affinit\u00e9 | Elitis\n  44508735209523  2appr/4disa  Volutes Le Go\u00fbt De L'\u00e9trange | Elitis\n  39561548791859  2appr/4disa  Minakari Geo Rosewood | Designers Guild\nChardonnay and Zinfandel are the same colorway-named-after-a-drink shape. 'Vista Wine' is likelier a TRUE positive and should be triaged separately, not appealed reflexively. The last four carry no alcohol word I can see at all \u2014 so either the classifier is reading the IMAGE or a non-title attribute, or there is a second cause. NOT-MEASURED: I did not determine which, and I am not guessing.\n\nSEVERITY \u2014 THESE ARE LIVE, UNLIKE TK-11449's SIX. 28 of 29 read 2 approved / 4 disapproved contexts, i.e. still SERVING in some surfaces while disapproved in others. TK-11449's tobacco six were 0appr/6disa \u2014 fully inert. So this cohort is losing real reach on 4 of 6 surfaces RIGHT NOW, and it is a bigger cohort (29 vs 6).\n\nTHE REMEDY IS PROVEN AND CHEAP, WHICH IS THE WHOLE REASON THIS IS WORTH A TICKET. TK-11449 established, end to end, that these classifier false-positives ARE appeal-clearable on merchant 146735262: 6 of 6 Hemp/tobacco appeals were submitted (1 on 09-13, 5 by Steve on 09-14) and ALL 6 now read 6/6 approved with zero item-level issues. Same account, same vendor, same false-positive mechanism.\n\nTWO TRAPS TK-11449 PAID FOR \u2014 INHERIT THEM, DO NOT RE-LEARN THEM:\n1. THERE IS NO API FOR APPEALS. Merchant Center console only. Automation via openclaw was tried hard and the MC item-detail SPA would not hydrate the appeal control. Expect a human-clicked pass, and budget for 29 of them or find a bulk path (a bulk-appeal landmine was flagged on TK-11449 \u2014 do not bulk-appeal blind).\n2. lastUpdateDate IS NOT THE TEST, n=2. An approved appeal does NOT bump it, and console-approval lags item-status in both directions (TK-11449's appeal 1 read APPROVED in console while its item still measured DISAPPROVED the same day). Test ONLY via destinationStatuses/itemLevelIssues, and re-read after a lag \u2014 a single post-submit DISAPPROVED read means 'too early', not 'failed'.\n3. PRE-CLEAR PRICE PARITY BEFORE APPEALING ANYTHING. TK-11449's hardest lesson: clearing a disapproval on an offer whose advertised price is wrong converts it from inert into a live WRONG ad (the Batik/Glambeads case). Check advertised == landing per offer first; note 22 of these are mid-price grasscloth, not $4.25 samples.\n\nNOTHING FIRED, NOTHING GATED DRAFTED. Appeals are outward-facing policy submissions on a fraud-sensitive account and stay Steve's. This ticket is the measurement + the route. @google-merchant-agent @vp-dw-commerce"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11848.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11848.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ec42d90b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11848.json
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:08.427Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "title": "yoloforever-watchtower watch.sh: pm2 God count greps ps argv text (PM2.*God) \u2192 false pm2-god:2 from peer tk-log text; anchor to '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon' on ps -axo command=",
+    "project": "yoloforever",
+    "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:09.307Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+    "text": "Evidence 2026-09-16 21:07:47Z false pm2-god:2: live ps = 1 God (pid 3334); pm2-fracture-canary 21:05Z god_count=1; watch.sh L27 'ps aux | grep -E PM2.*God' matched peer claude-run-11715's tk-log argv text (TK-11715 events 21:07:31-33Z contain PM2+God). Fix is a one-liner: GOD=$(ps -axo command= | grep -cE '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon'). Also consider reading pm2-fracture-canary/data/latest.json god_count instead of re-measuring. TK-11431 class: measuring the wrong thing (argv text) and calling it a daemon count."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:10.898Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+    "text": "@vp-operations owner: reversible one-line skill-script fix, no launchd plist change needed. Watchtower left watch.sh untouched (READ-ONLY loop); needs a negative test proving it still goes red on a real 2nd God (spawn one under a scratch PM2_HOME) and stays green on a decoy argv."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:55.101Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+    "text": "Second-model check: codex 429 (project spend cap, TK-11571 class still open) \u2192 grok-4.5 fallback AGREES benign FP. Grok's caveat (a ^ anchor fails on 'ps aux' because the line starts with USER) is already covered: the proposed fix uses 'ps -axo command=' (COMMAND field only). Watchtower triage closed; no live action taken."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11850.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11850.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..d205cd8b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11850.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:55.508Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has",
+    "title": "prestige-car-wash: Places photo route has no key since TK-11615 rotation \u2014 mint restricted key or delete the dead route",
+    "project": "prestige-car-wash",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11615",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:12:20.567Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11615",
+    "text": "Spun out of TK-11615 (leaked-Places-key rotation) so that security ticket can close. NOT A BREAKAGE \u2014 this is dormant-feature cleanup, and the credential-desk note that spawned it ('prestige .env GOOGLE_PLACES empty after rotation') overstates it. Measured today: server.js has exactly ONE key-dependent route, /api/places/photo/:i, whose guard is 'if (!key || !name) return res.status(404).end()' \u2014 with the key line stripped it short-circuits to 404, it does not error. grep -rno over public/ finds ONE api/places reference in the entire frontend (index.html:177, fetch('/api/places')) \u2014 that is the LOCAL data/places.json route and needs no key \u2014 and ZERO references to places/photo anywhere. The two scripts that read the key (scripts/places-read.js, scripts/competitors-scan.js) are manual-run tools that print a graceful warning and keep the mock data. So nothing customer-facing is degraded. NOTE also that the route was ALREADY non-functional before the rotation for an unrelated reason: data/places.json photos[] holds local media/real/*.jpg paths, not Google photo resource names, so the proxy built an invalid places.googleapis.com URL every time (that is why it 502'd rather than 404'd while a key was present). TWO HONEST OPTIONS: (A) DECOMMISSION \u2014 delete the photo route + the photos[] plumbing, since nothing calls it and the data shape was never right; (B) ENABLE \u2014 mint a places.googleapis.com-restricted key in a prestige-scoped project AND fix places.json to carry real Google photo resource names. (A) is the smaller, more truthful change. Either way it is Steve's call, tracked on credential-desk CR-mu35iqm5."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11851.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11851.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..f10c5e6c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11851.json
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:12:15.695Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "title": "ENV-LEAK RECURRENCE: 18 fanned-out claude windows share dead parent's CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID (197653ee.../PID 42588), explaining the masterdot 'none' bucket",
+    "project": "infra",
+    "agent": "masterdot",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:12:38.261Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "agent": "masterdot",
+    "text": "CONFIRMED live recurrence of memory 'iterm-relaunched-from-claude-leaks-child-session-env' (2026-09-15). All 18 windows in the masterdot TK-11841 none-bucket audit (ttys000,004,006,008,010,011,012,015,016,018,019,020,021,022,023,025,026,027 / pids 39845,56053,40659,40778,42322,42983,73825,69934,75985,2321,2842,16799,16578,16470,16200,6274,9494,28315) share the IDENTICAL CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID=197653ee-088c-4906-84e7-b0657a1e1b55 and CLAUDE_PID=42588 in their env (verified via ps eww), even though each has its OWN distinct TERM_SESSION_ID/ITERM_SESSION_ID (w0t0..w21t0, sequential window numbers = one fan-out burst). PID 42588 (the original session that spawned/relaunched these 18 iTerm windows) is confirmed DEAD (ps -p 42588 returns nothing). Effect: every child inherited a stale/shared session identity instead of generating its own \u2014 this is almost certainly WHY none of them can paint a dot (any dot-setter that resolves 'my own session/tty' via CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID gets a collision or points at a dead session)."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:12:38.987Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "agent": "masterdot",
+    "text": "Despite the dotless state, 17/18 sessions ARE genuinely alive and working \u2014 not silently stalled. tk show on all 17 ticketed sessions (the 18th, ttys004/pid56053, is a bare 'claude' with no TK_AGENT \u2014 likely the origin/dispatcher window of this same fan-out burst, w0t0p0) shows 'updated' timestamps within the last ~10 minutes matching each process's actual runtime, with real substantive tk log entries being written live during this investigation. Ticket status breakdown: 10 doing, 3 blocked (TK-11723,TK-11715,TK-11397 - legitimately gated on DTD+Cody+Steve, not silent stalls), 3 done (TK-11759,TK-11633,TK-11298 - marked done ~14:02-14:03 PDT, processes still alive at near-zero CPU in sleeping state, consistent with running the mandated /cs+/compact self-close sequence, not stuck), 1 open (TK-11615). No error/crash/unanswered-question signatures found in any transcript-adjacent evidence."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:12:39.740Z",
+    "type": "action",
+    "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "agent": "masterdot",
+    "text": "Cross-link: TK-11831 (itself one of these 18, pid 42322/ttys010) is ALREADY diagnosing a RELATED but DISTINCT mechanism for the same symptom class \u2014 'iTerm2 at 130-150% CPU with 59 live sessions, every AppleScript caller queues (dot scanner 90-180s), terminal_api unavailable x57 at peak, fleet-wide dot-tool degradation.' Both bugs likely compound: (1) this env-ID-leak means a session cannot even correctly self-identify its own tty for dot-painting, and (2) TK-11831's CPU/AppleScript overload means even a correctly-identified dot-paint call may queue/fail under load. RECOMMENDATION (not fired \u2014 draft only): run a recolor sweep that resolves color via TTY/PID directly rather than each session's own env-based self-report (e.g. /dotall or /green from a session NOT in this affected batch) once TK-11831's CPU pressure eases, to force-correct all 18 dots rather than waiting on each session's own (structurally broken) self-report."
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:24:05.131Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "masterdot",
+    "text": "CORRECTION after contrarian re-check (independently re-verified 2026-09-16 21:3x): the cited memory 'iterm-relaunched-from-claude-leaks-child-session-env' does NOT apply \u2014 its trigger var CLAUDE_CODE_CHILD_SESSION is ABSENT from the actual env of these 18 processes (checked ps eww on pid 39845 + 56053, full env dump, no CLAUDE_CODE_CHILD_SESSION key at all). Also confirmed the .zprofile fix for that bug shipped 09:58:39 today, hours before this 13:46-14:00 burst -- so even if it were that bug, these windows should have been immune. What IS confirmed real (verified via ps -o command= argv-only, ruling out the ps-eww argv/env confusion the contrarian flagged): all 18 genuinely share CLAUDE_PID=42588, CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID=197653ee-088c-4906-84e7-b0657a1e1b55, CLAUDE_CODE_MESSAGING_TOKEN=57ac27a94..., and CLAUDE_CODE_MESSAGING_SOCKET=/tmp/cc-socks/42588.sock as genuine environment (not argv) -- and PID 42588 is confirmed dead. This is a DIFFERENT, previously-uncatalogued mechanism: a mass fan-out dispatcher (likely /abramstasks or /iterm-style, opening 18 new iTerm windows each pre-loaded with a distinct claude --model opus '<prompt>' invocation) opened these windows WITHOUT clearing the dispatching session's own CLAUDE_PID/CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID/messaging env before launch, so each child inherited the DISPATCHER's identity wholesale instead of minting its own. This matches colordots.sh's own documented risk verbatim (comment at ~L16-17: a session that 'inherits CLAUDE_PID, resolves to the parent's ttys, and carries every CLAUDE_* var incl. the bridge id' is 'indistinguishable from a pane-less subagent') -- terminal_status.py's paint-rail very plausibly refuses to paint any session whose own PID doesn't match its inherited CLAUDE_PID, exactly because that signature is how a REAL subagent looks (by design, a subagent's CLAUDE_PID legitimately equals its parent's PID). A top-level, independently-dispatched window that merely inherited a stale value looks identical to that check and gets the same (structurally correct, but here misapplied) refusal. NET: the underlying THEORY (shared/stale identity blocks self-paint) survives and is now evidence-backed without the ps-eww ambiguity; the CITATION to the child-session-leak memory was wrong and is retracted. Root cause is really 'the fan-out dispatcher doesn't scrub CLAUDE_PID/CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID/CLAUDE_CODE_MESSAGING_* before opening each new iTerm window' -- fix belongs in whichever skill ran this burst (needs identifying; candidates: abramstasks, iterm, ticketmaster-driven dispatch). Recolor-sweep recommendation (TTY/PID-based, not self-report) stands."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11852.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11852.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..067f8062
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11852.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:14:46.202Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+    "title": "model-arena: gemma3:12b missing from Mac2 ollama \u2014 daily battles running short-handed",
+    "project": "model-arena",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11723",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:15:00.811Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11723",
+    "text": "Split out of TK-11723 (cron revival) as a genuinely separate degradation \u2014 surfaced by the NEW wrapper WARN line that TK-11723 added, which is exactly what that line exists for. model-arena battles the roster qwen3-14b + gemma3-12b + hermes3-8b (Mac2 ollama :11434) + qwen25-7b (Mac1 192.168.1.133). LIVE Mac2 tags: qwen2.5vl:7b, hermes3:8b, qwen3:14b \u2014 gemma3:12b is GONE. It was present as recently as 2026-09-13 (it was that day's aiPick), so it was removed/evicted in the same window the server died. /api/models reports available:false for gemma3-12b, hf-qwen-coder-32b, muse. Today's recovery battle logged done:2. IMPACT (why this is not cosmetic): the ELO/win-rate ledger is the entire product, and a contender silently absent from the field biases every subsequent rating \u2014 rows look clean (partial:false) while the contest was short. NOT auto-fixed: 'ollama pull gemma3:12b' is ~8GB and this box has a documented disk-CRITICAL history (memory mac2-disk-critical-root-cause-janitor), so a blind pull is not in the bounded/no-externality tier. NEXT: check free space, confirm gemma3:12b is still the intended contender (vs deliberately retired like muse was per TK-10980), then pull or drop it from the roster in server.js so the WARN stops firing on a model nobody wants."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11853.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11853.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..e01628ad
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11853.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:17:06.479Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+    "title": "gcp: replacement Places key fFIs has NO application restriction + no measured billing cap \u2014 same exposure class the TK-11615 leak had",
+    "project": "govarbitrage",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11615",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:17:22.961Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11615",
+    "text": "Spun out of TK-11615 so that ticket can close on its actual scope (the LEAK) without overstating 'no billing liability'. WHAT IS TRUE: key 9e623eb9 'nationalrealestate Places New (rotated 2026-09-14b)' in project gmail-at-agentabrams (132844455726) is correctly scoped by API \u2014 apiTargets=['places.googleapis.com'] only, which is already better than the leaked key it replaced (that one also carried the legacy places-backend grant). WHAT IS MISSING, verified via 'api-keys describe': browserKeyRestrictions / serverKeyRestrictions / androidKeyRestrictions / iosKeyRestrictions are ALL ABSENT. No IP allowlist, no referrer lock. So possession of the string = unrestricted Places calls billed to billingAccounts/01A01B-D7A5E3-97AC4F \u2014 the same property that made the TK-11615 leak expensive-if-abused. THREE CANDIDATE CONTROLS, none yet applied: (1) APPLICATION RESTRICTION \u2014 add a serverKeyRestrictions IP allowlist. CAUTION, this is the one that can break prod: the key is consumed from BOTH Mac2 (launchd com.steve.usre-hourly) and Kamatera (root cron), so the allowlist must carry BOTH egress IPs, and Mac2's is a residential IP that may not be static. Get the IP set wrong and the hourly Places loop dies silently \u2014 verify with the unbilled 4xx probe after applying, not by assuming. (2) SERVER-SIDE QUOTA CAP on places.googleapis.com. Today the ONLY cap is client-side (PLACES_MONTHLY_CAP=1500 in nationalrealestate), which an attacker holding the key does not honour. (3) BILLING BUDGET + ALERT \u2014 currently NOT-MEASURED, not absent: billingbudgets.googleapis.com is not enabled on the project so the list call errors out. I deliberately did not enable it (config change on a live project). All three are changes to a LIVE production credential / project and are GATED \u2014 nothing here auto-fires."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11856.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11856.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..36f85280
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11856.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:17:56.379Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+    "title": "57 of 71 counter-based launchd jobs share the TK-11298 0-byte-stdout shape (liveness on an untrustworthy counter)",
+    "project": "cron-fire-canary",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11298",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:18:24.640Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11298",
+    "text": "Spun out of TK-11298 (dw-staged-active-snapshot), which was the THIRD instance of this exact shape \u2014 codex-yoloforever and la-data-refresh were fixed the same way earlier. Filing rather than expanding TK-11298's scope: each job needs its own artifact decision, and one of those decisions is a false-green trap (see below).\n\nMEASURED, not estimated: of 300 asserted jobs, 71 have artifact_source='none' \u2014 no artifact at all \u2014 so cron-fire-canary's liveness for them falls back to the RAW RUNS COUNTER, the signal its own design doc calls untrustworthy (resets on reload; ate 77/98 false positives when trusted raw). 57 of those 71 share the identical cause: the plist DECLARES a StandardOutPath, the file EXISTS, and it is 0 BYTES \u2014 because the job's script redirects its own output somewhere else, so discoverArtifact() correctly rejects it. Staleness of that 0-byte file ranges 1d to 105d (daily-overnight-skus).\n\nConsequence is two-sided, same as TK-11298: noisy warn/recover churn from transient blips, AND a genuine death resting on a resettable counter.\n\nTHE TRAP, and the reason this is not a mechanical sweep: do NOT point a job's artifact at whatever file it happens to rewrite. On TK-11298 the obvious candidate (data/staged-snapshot.json) was written BEFORE the rsync push, so it would have read FRESH while prod was stale \u2014 and 28 of that job's 61 measured failures were push-side, i.e. exactly the class the obvious choice would have hidden. The correct artifact is written AFTER the last side effect that matters. Per job, ask: 'if this file is fresh, what have I actually proven?'\n\nSuggested approach: triage the 57 into (a) has a real post-side-effect artifact -> ARTIFACT_OVERRIDES entry, (b) needs the script to write a small post-success heartbeat first (the TK-11298 pattern), (c) genuinely has no meaningful artifact -> leave counter-based and say so explicitly. Each change ships with a negative test (TK-11431 rule 3); test/staged-active-snapshot-artifact.test.mjs is a working template, including the assertion that re-pointing at the pre-side-effect file makes the suite RED.\n\nFull 57-job list with staleness is reproducible from data/manifest.json + the plists; the one-off script is in TK-11298's session."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11857.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11857.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..d1c01565
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11857.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:18:20.924Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+    "title": "TK-11357 residuals: shared price-integrity gate fail-opens + 2 guards uncommitted in the nested scripts repo",
+    "project": "designerwallcoverings",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11357",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:18:52.278Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11357",
+    "text": "Carved out of TK-11357 so that ticket can close without dropping these. All four were line-verified today against SOURCE (not against a prior agent's prose) by a dedicated verify node, after vp-engineering wrote on 09-14T23:32 that the non-blocking also-fixes 'appear addressed across 2fafce86/854aaa3f/1619e165 but I have not line-verified each'. Two of six were NOT addressed.\n\nR1 \u2014 orderable===true FAIL-OPEN in the SHARED gate. price-integrity-gate.ts:422 (v.role==='sellable' && v.orderable === true && ...) and :439 (v.orderable === true && !(price > 0)). Strict === means a non-boolean orderable (1, 'true', undefined) SKIPS the Class-C $0 block rather than failing closed - the exact inverse of CLAUDE.md's 'an unmeasured input is never PASS'. LATENT not live: all 5 call sites were enumerated (shopify.ts:1040/1047, add-sample-variant-schumacher.ts:203, import-queue-runner.js:117, batch-import-jobs.ts:785) and every one passes a strict boolean today. Not fixed unilaterally because it changes shared-gate semantics on a judgment call - needs @vp-engineering's intended semantics. Suggested: treat non-boolean as orderable (fail CLOSED) + a negative test.\n\nR2 \u2014 negative-price gate branch is UNREACHABLE and its green test is itself the false green. price.replace(/[^0-9.]/g,'') at shopify.ts:824, shopify.ts:1010 and batch-import-jobs.ts:761 strips the minus BEFORE the VariantCheck is constructed, so price-integrity-gate.ts:441 (class C negative-price) can never fire from any production caller. __tests__/price-integrity-gate.test.ts:132 'test 8' passes against a hand-constructed -5, proving the branch's arithmetic and never that production can enter it. Textbook CLAUDE.md TK-11431 amendment 3 (a positive-only test on a detector proves nothing). Fix is a real design call - detect the sign BEFORE the strip, or stop stripping - so it needs the owner, not a drive-by.\n\nR3 \u2014 two guards exist ONLY in a working tree, in a repo whose main lacks them. ~/Projects/Designer-Wallcoverings/scripts is its OWN nested git repo and is the innermost repo governing the versa files. Its main has 0 hits for metafieldsDelete and 0 for 'TITLE MISMATCH'; all three versa files show dirty there. So 'git checkout -- .' inside scripts/ silently reverts BOTH dwc-sync.mjs:30/:59-65 (the true-inverse rollback) AND archive-dupes.mjs:49-61 - and that second one is the guard standing between a stale product id and an IRREVERSIBLE archive of the wrong live product. Only committed copies are on the OUTER repo's branch tk11786-review-fixes, which is not an ancestor of outer main. Same class I just fixed for the 5 sweeps in the sibling shopify/ nested repo (commit e0ee104) - this is the same bug one directory over.\n\nR4 \u2014 productType still hardcoded. The weight-guard fix is real, but the Shopify PRODUCT record is still created productType:'Wallcovering' at shopify.ts:847 on the single-product path (the batch path at :809 uses the real type). A Fabric now gets the correct 1.0lb weight but is still STORED as Wallcovering.\n\nALSO NOTED, not part of this ticket: all 9 outer-repo TK-11357/11403/11539 commits (25dadd6f 624ad3ff e0bf2137 2fafce86 854aaa3f 674994ec 87cf6ccc 1619e165 93f6b2e6) are committed-off-default - not ancestors of outer main - and outer main has diverged in BOTH directions (it carries 3c1e11e9 which the branch lacks), so no fast-forward exists. Landing them is a merge decision for Steve/@vp-dw-commerce, not something to do silently: last time this came up Steve made it an explicit informed call because it drags in other tickets' commits."
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11858.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11858.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..509c40bf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11858.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:20:32.979Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+    "title": "Cost authority conflict: ~1,621 ACTIVE products store OUR RETAIL as cost_price (stamped, so counted COVERED); 2,408 map-vs-stamp disagreements >10% with no precedence rule",
+    "project": "dw",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:20:54.895Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "text": "SPLIT OUT OF TK-11427 (session 5, 2026-09-16). Measured read-only against the local dw_unified mirror; nothing was written.\n\nTHE DEFECT, two layers.\n\nLAYER 1 \u2014 NO PRECEDENCE RULE. dw-price-integrity-gate counts a product COVERED if (a) its dw_sku/sku resolves through the hand-verified price-finder cost map, OR (b) it carries a provenance-stamped cost_source with a cost. That OR has no tie-break. Of 14,898 ACTIVE products where BOTH authorities exist: 12,306 agree, 2,592 disagree, 2,408 disagree by >10%, and on 2,376 of those the MAP is the lower number. A consumer reading 'covered' can get either value.\n\nLAYER 2 \u2014 AND ONE SIDE IS PROVABLY WRONG. The disagreement is systematic, not drift: map/stamp is EXACTLY 0.5525 (= 0.65*0.85, the inverse of the DW markup 1/0.65/0.85 = 1.81) on EVERY row for Designtex 279/279, Innovations USA 19/19, Thibaut 1/1, and as the median for Malibu Wallpaper 1,467. Two decisive checks, no external plane needed because both numbers are our own:\n  * Designtex DWDX-220018 \u2014 map cost 25.00; stamped cost_price 45.25; 25.00/0.65/0.85 = 45.25 EXACTLY. The stamp is our SELL price.\n  * Malibu DWQW-60936 \u2014 stamped cost_price 185.30 == wallquest_catalog.price_dw 185.30, and the WallQuest cost-map entry's own note reads verbatim 'price_retail holds cost; price_dw is our retail'.\nCONFIRMED COUNTS with that exact signature: Designtex 279/279 \u00b7 Malibu 1,322/1,507 \u00b7 Innovations USA 19 \u00b7 Thibaut 1 = ~1,621 ACTIVE products whose cost_price is our own retail, ~1.81x too high, each wearing a real-looking cost_source.\n\nWHY THE EXISTING GUARD MISSED IT. The gate already refuses to count an UNATTRIBUTED cost (cost_price with NULL cost_source) and its own source comment cites TK-11410 finding wallquest-family cost_price loaded with RETAIL as the reason. The guard was built around provenance PRESENCE, not cost CORRECTNESS \u2014 so it catches a cost with no source string and is structurally blind to a wrong cost that has one. Malibu is that same wallquest family, still carrying retail as cost five months later, now WITH a source string and therefore counted as covered.\n\nHARM. Cost overstated ~1.81x makes margin read PESSIMISTIC (the safe direction for not selling below cost) but it destroys the below-cost SIGNAL: a product priced at our retail reads as zero-margin, so a genuinely below-cost product is indistinguishable from a normal one. That is exactly the condition TK-11427 exists to make knowable.\n\nNOT DONE HERE, and why: (1) choosing which authority wins is a precedence decision with money consequences across 2,408 products; (2) clearing/correcting cost_price on ~1,621 live rows is a canonical-catalog write and is GATED. Kravet is a separate, opposite case (4 products, ratio 3.71-12.56, map OVERSTATES) and needs its own look.\n\nSUGGESTED ORDER: (a) decide precedence (proposal: the hand-verified cost map WINS over a stamp wherever both exist, since the map is the reviewed artifact); (b) make the gate report a stamp that contradicts the map as NOT-MEASURED rather than covered \u2014 that is a read-only detector change and needs no catalog write; (c) only then consider the gated data fix. Step (b) alone removes the false green.\n@vp-dw-commerce"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11859.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11859.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ecded20c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11859.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:22:45.115Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+    "title": "Cost backlog / JOIN-REPAIR class: 18 vendors, 6,243 ACTIVE products hold a cost-ish column that joins to NOTHING live (0 reachable)",
+    "project": "dw",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:23:12.537Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "text": "SPLIT OUT OF TK-11427 (session 5, 2026-09-16). Sizes refreshed TODAY by scripts/cost-source-triage.mjs (read-only): COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN = 18 vendors, 6,243 ACTIVE products, 0 reachable by any existing join. These vendors HAVE a cost-ish column with data; the join key to live products is broken, so nothing resolves.\n\nWORKED EXAMPLE, already verified end-to-end this session \u2014 Osborne & Little. The cost-map entry is TABLE_MODE, so coverage keys on osborne_catalog.dw_sku: populated on 787/14,107 rows, and its 214 live matches are ALL non-ACTIVE (a stale generation). It therefore resolves 0 of 602 ACTIVE. Repointing to a cost_sql joining on mfr_sku lifts it 0 -> 58, verified 55/58 exact against live Shopify with no fan-out. Memo: pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11427-osborne-join-repair.md.\n\nMETHOD THAT WORKS (from that example): (1) compare the catalog's join column against BOTH sp.sku and sp.mfr_sku, since live SKUs often carry a vendor suffix (-OSB) while mfr_sku is clean; (2) prove the alternate key is unique in the catalog among priced rows and produces no fan-out (join rows == distinct products); (3) check for CROSS-VENDOR collision on that key and vendor-scope the SQL (one 'Designer Wallcoverings' product shares an mfr_sku with osborne_catalog \u2014 an unscoped join would have leaked it); (4) verify the WHOLE resolved set against live Shopify, not a 3-row sample \u2014 widening from 3 to 58 is what exposed the EUR-71203 divergence.\n\nTRAPS: a join repair is a cost-authority change on a live vendor and is GATED. And per TK-11858, resolving MORE products through the map can put the map into conflict with an existing stamped cost_source \u2014 check for both authorities before assuming a lift is pure gain.\n@vp-dw-commerce"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11860.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11860.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..f83450e3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11860.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:22:45.517Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
+    "title": "Cost backlog / VERIFY-THE-COLUMN class: 26 vendors, 12,852 ACTIVE (10,704 already joinable) need external-plane proof their cost column is cost, not retail",
+    "project": "dw",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:23:13.882Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "text": "SPLIT OUT OF TK-11427 (session 5, 2026-09-16). Sizes refreshed TODAY by scripts/cost-source-triage.mjs (read-only): STRONG_CANDIDATE = 26 vendors, 12,852 ACTIVE, 10,704 already reachable by an existing join. This is the UNBLOCKED bucket \u2014 the join works, the column has data; what is missing is proof that the column means COST.\n\nLargest, with the join that already works: Jeffrey Stevens 2,652/2,654 \u00b7 Hollywood Wallcoverings 2,039/3,561 \u00b7 Malibu Wallpaper 1,637/3,822 \u00b7 Rebel Walls 1,199/3,373 \u00b7 Mind the Gap 830/1,019 \u00b7 Anna French 651/790 \u00b7 Knoll 622/622 \u00b7 Tres Tintas 601/601 \u00b7 Sandberg 557/743 \u00b7 1838 Wallcoverings 451/456 \u00b7 Scalamandre 418/418 \u00b7 Graham & Brown 403/405 \u00b7 Fabricut 274/276 \u00b7 Newwall 251/251 \u00b7 Stout 180/180.\n\nTHE METHOD THAT HAS WORKED TWICE (Carnegie, Quadrille): search info@ Gmail for '<vendor> (net OR \"price list\" OR discount)', find a rep quoting a SPECIFIC SKU at '$X net', then look that SKU up in the vendor's catalog table. A rep's own written net quote IS the external plane.\n\nREAD THIS BEFORE TOUCHING ANY OF THEM \u2014 the caveat is no longer theoretical. Almost every column above is named price_retail, and the triage tiers columns BY NAME, which is shape-based reasoning (it is what produced the TK-11566 Maharam false alarm). TK-11858 established TODAY, from our own arithmetic, that a retail-vs-cost mix-up is live at scale right now: ~1,621 ACTIVE products carry our own RETAIL in cost_price, including Malibu \u2014 which is in the list above. So treat every entry here as UNPROVEN until a vendor-external document says otherwise.\n\nALSO: for any vendor whose basis ends up 'retail', check vendor_registry.discount_confirmed FIRST. Per TK-11612/TK-11817 there is a 2026-04-13 same-minute bulk stamp of discount_confirmed=TRUE with EMPTY notes across 44 vendors \u2014 an artifact, not a confirmation. An unconfirmed discount coalesces to 0% and makes net_cost identical to the vendor's own price.\n@vp-dw-commerce"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11861.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11861.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..4f1b360b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/TK-11861.json
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+[
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:23:46.114Z",
+    "type": "create",
+    "id": "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
+    "title": "Phillipe Romano cost model: 13,066 ACTIVE products (23% of the whole cost-unknown population) under one house umbrella spanning 232 SKU prefixes \u2014 needs per-sub-brand cost sourcing, not a SQL join",
+    "project": "dw",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "body": ""
+  },
+  {
+    "ts": "2026-09-16T21:23:46.505Z",
+    "type": "comment",
+    "id": "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
+    "kind": "comment",
+    "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+    "text": "SPLIT OUT OF TK-11427 (session 5, 2026-09-16). Phillipe Romano is the single largest cost-unknown vendor on the catalog: 13,066 ACTIVE products, 0 resolvable through the cost map today. That is ~23% of the 56,382 cost-UNKNOWN population \u2014 the biggest single lever left, and the reason it is filed separately rather than left inside a backlog ticket.\n\nWHY IT IS NOT A JOIN PROBLEM. Phillipe Romano is a DW HOUSE PRIVATE LABEL, not a vendor we buy from under that name. It is an umbrella over sub-brands with genuinely different economics \u2014 Command54, RIGO, Greenland (cork), MDC and others \u2014 each sourced from a different upstream at a different cost basis. There is no single vendor price list that could cover it. Measured today: 232 distinct SKU prefixes under the one vendor name.\n\nWHAT THE TRIAGE SAYS: phillipe_romano_catalog.price_retail joins to only 1,082 of 13,066 (8.3%) via ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku, and per TK-11858 a column named price_retail cannot be assumed to be cost \u2014 that exact mix-up is live on this catalog right now.\n\nKNOWN SUB-BRAND ANCHORS ALREADY ESTABLISHED ELSEWHERE, worth reusing rather than re-deriving: Greenland/cork is $59.50/yd in 6-yard increments per the greenland-scraper-manager skill; Los Angeles Fabrics / Justin David (a sibling per-yard line) was solved via a Steve-supplied price list + a confirmed 15% discount and is already in the cost map at 1,516 products. MDC is covered separately by the dw-mdc-margin-canary, which reports NOT_MEASURED because no verified MDC cost exists anywhere (the portal exposes no pricing).\n\nSUGGESTED SHAPE: decompose by SKU prefix into sub-brand cohorts, size each, and source cost per cohort \u2014 the smallest cohorts with a known upstream (cork, per-yard fabric) are likely quick wins; the rest need rep/invoice sourcing. Do NOT attempt a single blanket cost model for the umbrella.\n@vp-dw-commerce"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/arena-models.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/arena-models.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..094b1c99
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/arena-models.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+auth required
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/canonical-final.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/canonical-final.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..28615175
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/canonical-final.json
@@ -0,0 +1,158 @@
+{
+  "at": "2026-09-16T22:30:46.241Z",
+  "rows": [
+    {
+      "position": 1,
+      "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+      "status": "blocked",
+      "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:11:25.544Z",
+      "blocker": {
+        "type": "technical_dependency",
+        "condition": "Heuristic report does not establish authoritative vendor/table identity, successful zero-result queries, or priced-row join yield; no verified repair target yet.",
+        "next_action": "Use retained18-row offline review to verify table identities and read-only joins including errors, prices, uniqueness and cross-vendor scope; draft any cost-authority change for Steve.",
+        "owner": "vp-dw-commerce",
+        "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:11:22.771Z",
+        "steve_one_action": false
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 2,
+      "id": "TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has",
+      "status": "blocked",
+      "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:53:35.558Z",
+      "blocker": {
+        "type": "steve_action",
+        "condition": "Reviewed local removal patch prepared; active-source application and target-specific activation lack exact approval.",
+        "next_action": "Steve APPROVE/REVISE/BLOCK pending-approval/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md; revalidate source/data and prove actual photo journey after approved activation.",
+        "owner": "steve",
+        "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T21:53:33.121Z",
+        "steve_one_action": false
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 3,
+      "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+      "status": "open",
+      "assignee": "yoloforever-loop",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T19:57:49.691Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 4,
+      "id": "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+      "status": "blocked",
+      "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:00:26.113Z",
+      "blocker": {
+        "type": "steve_action",
+        "condition": "Gemma restoration needs intended-roster confirmation and scoped download approval against fresh capacity/headroom; current8percentWARN.",
+        "next_action": "Review pending-approval/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md; confirm intent and capacity before any pull.",
+        "owner": "steve",
+        "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:00:23.986Z",
+        "steve_one_action": false
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 5,
+      "id": "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
+      "status": "blocked",
+      "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:14:58.780Z",
+      "blocker": {
+        "type": "technical_dependency",
+        "condition": "Actual upstream/SKU acquisition costs and current prefix census remain unmeasured;59.50 is sellingprice evidence only.",
+        "next_action": "Obtain dated vendor-external cost evidence and current prefix identity/census, then propose gated cohort-specific cost mapping; source-anchor manifest retained.",
+        "owner": "vp-dw-commerce",
+        "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:14:56.270Z",
+        "steve_one_action": false
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 6,
+      "id": "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
+      "status": "blocked",
+      "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:18:36.000Z",
+      "blocker": {
+        "type": "technical_dependency",
+        "condition": "26candidate vendors lack external price-basis/unit/currency/date/discount/table-identity proof in this pass;10704keymatches are not verified costs.",
+        "next_action": "Use retained per-vendor evidence-request manifest to gather SKU/cohort-matched vendorproof; no external send authorized; costmap adoption remains gated.",
+        "owner": "vp-dw-commerce",
+        "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:18:33.080Z",
+        "steve_one_action": false
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 7,
+      "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11851",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:27:45.364Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 8,
+      "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11848",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:28:01.897Z",
+      "blocker": {
+        "type": "steve_action",
+        "condition": "Isolated detector fix verified; installing into scheduled watcher and actualsecond-daemon proof lack exactapproval. Fullwatch may invoke forbidden Claude runtime.",
+        "next_action": "Review pending-approval/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md; approve scopedsourceapplication and separately safe operationalproof; never run wholewatch under currentruntime prohibition.",
+        "owner": "steve",
+        "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:24:08.862Z",
+        "steve_one_action": false
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 9,
+      "id": "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11858",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:27:52.473Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 10,
+      "id": "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11853",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:28:30.486Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 11,
+      "id": "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11847",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:28:00.946Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 12,
+      "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+      "status": "open",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11831",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T19:39:15.334Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 13,
+      "id": "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11857",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:26:47.418Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 14,
+      "id": "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11856",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:27:14.275Z"
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 15,
+      "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+      "status": "doing",
+      "assignee": "night-TK-11846",
+      "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:28:11.865Z"
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-join-mismatch.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-join-mismatch.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..720cf044
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-join-mismatch.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"summary": {"generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z", "ticket": "TK-11427", "active_products_total": 91167, "vendors_with_active": 170, "covered_vendors": 32, "buckets": [{"state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 26, "active_products": 12852, "reachable_products": 10704}, {"state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 13, "active_products": 24623, "reachable_products": 4389}, {"state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "vendors": 18, "active_products": 6243, "reachable_products": 0}, {"state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "vendors": 81, "active_products": 10735, "reachable_products": 0}]}, "report": [{"vendor": "Phillipe Romano", "active": 13066, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1082}, "join_pct": 8.3}], "join_pct": 8.3, "reachable": 1082}, {"vendor": "Carnegie", "active": 4147, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Malibu Wallpaper", "active": 3822, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1637}, "join_pct": 42.8}], "join_pct": 42.8, "reachable": 1637}, {"vendor": "Clarke And Clarke", "active": 3567, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings", "active": 3561, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2040}, "join_pct": 57.3}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 57.3, "reachable": 2039}, {"vendor": "Phillip Jeffries", "active": 3392, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Walls", "active": 3373, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1199}, "join_pct": 35.5}, {"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1172}, "join_pct": 34.7}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1014}, "join_pct": 30.1}], "join_pct": 35.5, "reachable": 1199}, {"vendor": "Thibaut", "active": 3101, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Brunschwig & Fils", "active": 2737, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens", "active": 2654, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4991}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 1}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2652}, "join_pct": 99.9}], "join_pct": 99.9, "reachable": 2652}, {"vendor": "Kravet", "active": 2601, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Koroseal", "active": 2449, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Gaston Y Daniela", "active": 2148, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Lee Jofa", "active": 2026, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Los Angeles Fabrics", "active": 1821, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "China Seas", "active": 1776, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Maharam", "active": 1429, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Coordonn\u00e9", "active": 1428, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "coordonne_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3676}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 136}, "join_pct": 9.5}], "join_pct": 9.5, "reachable": 136}, {"vendor": "Harlequin", "active": 1257, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Cole & Son", "active": 1238, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Sanderson", "active": 1221, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "GP & J Baker", "active": 1191, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Mind the Gap", "active": 1019, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "mindthegap_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1040}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 2}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 830}, "join_pct": 81.5}], "join_pct": 81.5, "reachable": 830}, {"vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings", "active": 978, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Wallpaper", "active": 942, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0.1}], "join_pct": 1.5, "reachable": 14}, {"vendor": "DW Bespoke Studio", "active": 925, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zoffany", "active": 902, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Anna French", "active": 790, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "anna_french_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 731}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 469}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 651}, "join_pct": 82.4}], "join_pct": 82.4, "reachable": 651}, {"vendor": "Sandberg", "active": 743, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sandberg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 948}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}, {"table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 945}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}], "join_pct": 75, "reachable": 557}, {"vendor": "Pierre Frey", "active": 722, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designtex", "active": 703, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wolf Gordon", "active": 688, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Morris & Co.", "active": 686, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PS Removable Wallpaper", "active": 681, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Surface Stick", "active": 639, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Knoll", "active": 622, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "knoll_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806", "cost_columns": [{"col": "orig_cost_price", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 622}, {"vendor": "Maya Romanoff", "active": 617, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Osborne & Little", "active": 602, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Tres Tintas", "active": 601, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "tres_tintas_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1556}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 601}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 601}, {"vendor": "Romo", "active": 585, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Elitis", "active": 579, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designers Guild", "active": 568, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 145}, "join_pct": 25.5}], "join_pct": 25.5, "reachable": 145}, {"vendor": "William Morris", "active": 522, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fentucci", "active": 514, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.2}], "join_pct": 1.2, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Fentucci Naturals", "active": 504, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Arte International", "active": 489, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings", "active": 456, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "w1838_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 404}, {"col": "maxwell_price", "populated": 332}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 332}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 332}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 451}, "join_pct": 98.9}], "join_pct": 98.9, "reachable": 451}, {"vendor": "Versace", "active": 454, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "versace_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 158}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 157}, "join_pct": 34.6}], "join_pct": 34.6, "reachable": 157}, {"vendor": "Quadrille", "active": 454, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Alan Campbell", "active": 434, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Nina Campbell", "active": 433, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "nina_campbell_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 275}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 3}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}, {"table": "nina_campbell_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172723", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 238}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}], "join_pct": 1.4, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre", "active": 418, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 418}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 418}, {"vendor": "Graham & Brown", "active": 405, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "graham_brown_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 2020}, {"col": "dw_retail_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 312}, {"col": "vendor_retail_price", "populated": 132}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 403}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "graham_brown_murals", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 36}, {"col": "price_per_sqft", "populated": 36}, {"col": "member_price_per_sqm", "populated": 36}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 99.5, "reachable": 403}, {"vendor": "Glitter Walls", "active": 405, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glitter_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 121}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "British Walls", "active": 351, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "CMO Paris", "active": 344, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "AS Creation", "active": 327, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mulberry", "active": 317, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fabricut", "active": 276, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fabricut_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "vendor_msrp", "populated": 1263}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1263}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 274}, "join_pct": 99.3}], "join_pct": 99.3, "reachable": 274}, {"vendor": "Suncloth", "active": 254, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Newwall", "active": 251, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newwall_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8713}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 6276}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 251}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 251}, {"vendor": "Groundworks", "active": 237, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Home Couture", "active": 229, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Innovations USA", "active": 202, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "innovations_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_source", "populated": 221}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 220}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 182}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku", "matched": 160}, "join_pct": 79.2}], "join_pct": 79.2, "reachable": 160}, {"vendor": "Plains", "active": 181, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Stout Textiles", "active": 180, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "stout_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 180}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 180}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 180}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 180}, {"vendor": "De Gournay", "active": 172, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ronald Redding", "active": 167, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Novasuede", "active": 166, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Majilite", "active": 160, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Brand McKenzie", "active": 155, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 37}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 118}, "join_pct": 76.1}, {"table": "brand_mckenzie_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 110}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 76.1, "reachable": 118}, {"vendor": "Artmura", "active": 144, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ralph Lauren", "active": 140, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper", "active": 140, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Donghia", "active": 125, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "donghia_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 167}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 124}, "join_pct": 99.2}], "join_pct": 99.2, "reachable": 124}, {"vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings", "active": 116, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newmor_sku_reconcile", "cost_columns": [{"col": "live_price", "populated": 542}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 116}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 116}, {"vendor": "Marburg", "active": 112, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "marburg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 2559}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 96}, "join_pct": 85.7}], "join_pct": 85.7, "reachable": 96}, {"vendor": "Ultrasuede", "active": 109, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Laura Ashley Wallpaper", "active": 107, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mid Century Modern", "active": 106, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hospitality Wallcoverings", "active": 98, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PR Faux Leather", "active": 97, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "LA Walls", "active": 94, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Charles Burger", "active": 79, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Christian Lacroix Europe", "active": 77, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Nobilis", "active": 74, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Primo Leathers", "active": 72, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sister Parish", "active": 71, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Threads", "active": 71, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "LEED Walls", "active": 68, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Pixels", "active": 59, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glambeads by DW", "active": 58, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Daisy Bennett", "active": 58, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_cost", "populated": 64}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 52}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 63}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Luxury Murals", "active": 56, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "MC Escher Wallpaper", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steve Abrams Studios", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Missoni Wallpaper", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Madagascar Walls", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Anthology", "active": 48, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Retro Walls", "active": 48, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Lincrusta", "active": 47, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "lincrusta_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 47}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 45}, "join_pct": 95.7}], "join_pct": 95.7, "reachable": 45}, {"vendor": "FallingStar Studio", "active": 42, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sancar", "active": 42, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sancar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3418}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 42}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 42}, {"vendor": "Cloth and Paper", "active": 41, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "quadrille_house_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost_price", "populated": 1928}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 40}, "join_pct": 97.6}], "join_pct": 97.6, "reachable": 40}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection", "active": 40, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Apartment Wallpaper", "active": 38, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Home", "active": 37, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Marimekko Exclusive", "active": 35, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection UK", "active": 29, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glass Beaded", "active": 29, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glass_bead_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 717}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Franquemont London", "active": 26, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "franquemont_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "roll_price", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 26}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 26}, {"vendor": "Natural Paint", "active": 26, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana", "active": 26, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 15}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Phyllis Morris", "active": 24, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius Europe", "active": 21, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Contrado", "active": 15, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "contrado_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 11}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hand Crafted", "active": 15, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Traditional Whimsy", "active": 13, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Acoustical", "active": 13, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 4}, "join_pct": 30.8}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 30.8, "reachable": 4}, {"vendor": "Witch & Watchman", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "SUGARBOO", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Backdrop", "active": 9, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Innovations", "active": 8, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wallpaper NYC", "active": 6, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius at DW", "active": 5, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Andrew Martin", "active": 5, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "andrew_martin_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 185}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 3}, "join_pct": 60}], "join_pct": 60, "reachable": 3}, {"vendor": "Architectural Wallcoverings", "active": 4, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Baker Lifestyle", "active": 4, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "baker_lifestyle_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 74}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 74}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 25}], "join_pct": 25, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Black Edition", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Malibu", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Malibu Walls", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Holland and Sherry", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Peg Norriss", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sacha Walckhoff", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Clarke and Clarke", "active": 3, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "clarke_clarke_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 578}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Caroline Cecil Textiles", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Villa Nova", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zinc Textile", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Patty Madden", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Design", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_map_authoritative", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "map_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 4522}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Atomic 50 Ceilings", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kirkby Design", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Couture", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_master_price", "cost_columns": [{"col": "map_price", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4685}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Winfield Thybony", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scion", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Linherr Hollingsworth", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Exclusive Wallpaper", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steven Abrams Photography", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DWHD", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Studio Ditte", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "studio_printworks_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_sample", "populated": 383}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 383}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Emiliana Parati", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Farrow & Ball", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "farrow_ball_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_gbp", "populated": 545}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "farrow_ball_paints", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_usd", "populated": 301}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "G P & J Baker", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Happy Menocal", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Architectural Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Morris and Company", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Milton & King", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "A.S. Cr\u00e9ation", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mark Alexander", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dedar", "active": 1, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "dedar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 46}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Studio", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ananbo", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dupenny", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebecca Moses", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sara Bergqvist", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sarah Bartholomew", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Celerie Kemble", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "catchii_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 670}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-malformed.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-malformed.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..edb1a247
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-malformed.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{invalid
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-replay.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-replay.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..c7fcc564
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-replay.json
@@ -0,0 +1,1464 @@
+{
+  "schema_version": 1,
+  "ticket": "TK-11860",
+  "correlation_id": "yf2139-i6-execute",
+  "kind": "OFFLINE_EVIDENCE_REQUEST_MANIFEST",
+  "created_at": "2026-09-16T22:19:56.950309+00:00",
+  "source": {
+    "path": "/private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/column-manifest/input-snapshot.json",
+    "sha256": "fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a",
+    "generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z"
+  },
+  "historical_totals": {
+    "vendors": 26,
+    "active_products": 12852,
+    "distinct_product_sku_key_matches": 10704
+  },
+  "limitations": [
+    "Key-match counts do not require a populated price on the joined row; column population counts are separate measures.",
+    "Candidate selection includes registry/name heuristics; table identity and cost meaning require evidence.",
+    "The source generator swallows query errors; this report does not prove query success or exhaustive identity resolution.",
+    "Metadata-shaped column names and existing discount stamps are not price/net-cost proof.",
+    "No external evidence was fetched or sent; no current costs, coverage lift or adoption are established."
+  ],
+  "vendors": [
+    {
+      "vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 3561,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 2039,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings",
+        "active": 3561,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "hollywood_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 5893
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 2039
+            },
+            "join_pct": 57.3
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "hollywood_price_audit_log",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "new_price",
+                "populated": 102
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "old_price",
+                "populated": 98
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 57.3,
+        "reachable": 2039
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 2654,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 2652,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens",
+        "active": 2654,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 4991
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost",
+                "populated": 1
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 2652
+            },
+            "join_pct": 99.9
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 99.9,
+        "reachable": 2652
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Mind the Gap",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 1019,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 830,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Mind the Gap",
+        "active": 1019,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "mindthegap_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 1040
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 2
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 830
+            },
+            "join_pct": 81.5
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 81.5,
+        "reachable": 830
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Anna French",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 790,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 651,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Anna French",
+        "active": 790,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "anna_french_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "cost",
+                "populated": 731
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 469
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 651
+            },
+            "join_pct": 82.4
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 82.4,
+        "reachable": 651
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Sandberg",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 743,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 557,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Sandberg",
+        "active": 743,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "sandberg_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 948
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 557
+            },
+            "join_pct": 75
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 945
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 557
+            },
+            "join_pct": 75
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 75,
+        "reachable": 557
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Knoll",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 622,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 622,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Knoll",
+        "active": 622,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "knoll_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 622
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 622
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "orig_cost_price",
+                "populated": 622
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 622
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 622
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Tres Tintas",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 601,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 601,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Tres Tintas",
+        "active": 601,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "tres_tintas_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 1556
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 601
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 601
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 456,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 451,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings",
+        "active": 456,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "w1838_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 404
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "maxwell_price",
+                "populated": 332
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "master_cost",
+                "populated": 332
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 332
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 451
+            },
+            "join_pct": 98.9
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 98.9,
+        "reachable": 451
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Scalamandre",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 418,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 418,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Scalamandre",
+        "active": 418,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "scalamandre_pillows",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 1512
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 1512
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 418
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "scalamandre_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 5002
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 416
+            },
+            "join_pct": 99.5
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 4996
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 416
+            },
+            "join_pct": 99.5
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 418
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Graham & Brown",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 405,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 403,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Graham & Brown",
+        "active": 405,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "graham_brown_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "retail_price",
+                "populated": 2020
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "dw_retail_price",
+                "populated": 809
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost_price",
+                "populated": 809
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "master_cost",
+                "populated": 312
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "vendor_retail_price",
+                "populated": 132
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 403
+            },
+            "join_pct": 99.5
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "graham_brown_murals",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "retail_price",
+                "populated": 36
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft",
+                "populated": 36
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "member_price_per_sqm",
+                "populated": 36
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 99.5,
+        "reachable": 403
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Fabricut",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 276,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 274,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Fabricut",
+        "active": 276,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "fabricut_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "vendor_msrp",
+                "populated": 1263
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 1263
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 274
+            },
+            "join_pct": 99.3
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 99.3,
+        "reachable": 274
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Newwall",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 251,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 251,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Newwall",
+        "active": 251,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "newwall_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 8713
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 6276
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 251
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 251
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Innovations USA",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 202,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 160,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [
+        {
+          "table": "innovations_catalog",
+          "column": "price_source",
+          "flag": "METADATA_SHAPED_NOT_COST_PROOF"
+        }
+      ],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Innovations USA",
+        "active": 202,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "innovations_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_source",
+                "populated": 221
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 220
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 182
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku",
+              "matched": 160
+            },
+            "join_pct": 79.2
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 79.2,
+        "reachable": 160
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Stout Textiles",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 180,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 180,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Stout Textiles",
+        "active": 180,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "stout_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 180
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 180
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 180
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 180
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Brand McKenzie",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 155,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 118,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Brand McKenzie",
+        "active": 155,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 167
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 37
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 118
+            },
+            "join_pct": 76.1
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "brand_mckenzie_products",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price",
+                "populated": 110
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 76.1,
+        "reachable": 118
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Donghia",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 125,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 124,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Donghia",
+        "active": 125,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "donghia_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 167
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 167
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 124
+            },
+            "join_pct": 99.2
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 99.2,
+        "reachable": 124
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 116,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 116,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [
+        {
+          "table": "newmor_sku_reconcile",
+          "column": "live_price",
+          "flag": "LIVE_PRICE_UNPROVEN_AS_ACQUISITION_COST"
+        }
+      ],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings",
+        "active": 116,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "newmor_sku_reconcile",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "live_price",
+                "populated": 542
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 116
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 116
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Marburg",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 112,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 96,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Marburg",
+        "active": 112,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "marburg_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 2559
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 96
+            },
+            "join_pct": 85.7
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 85.7,
+        "reachable": 96
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Lincrusta",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 47,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 45,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Lincrusta",
+        "active": 47,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "lincrusta_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 47
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 45
+            },
+            "join_pct": 95.7
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 95.7,
+        "reachable": 45
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Sancar",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 42,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 42,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Sancar",
+        "active": 42,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "sancar_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 3418
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 42
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 42
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Cloth and Paper",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 41,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 40,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Cloth and Paper",
+        "active": 41,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "quadrille_house_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "cost_price",
+                "populated": 1928
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 40
+            },
+            "join_pct": 97.6
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 97.6,
+        "reachable": 40
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Franquemont London",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 26,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 26,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Franquemont London",
+        "active": 26,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "franquemont_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "roll_price",
+                "populated": 26
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 26
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 26
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Andrew Martin",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 5,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 3,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Andrew Martin",
+        "active": 5,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "andrew_martin_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 185
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 3
+            },
+            "join_pct": 60
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 60,
+        "reachable": 3
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Kravet Design",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 2,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 2,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [
+        {
+          "table": "kravet_catalog",
+          "column": "price_effective_date",
+          "flag": "METADATA_SHAPED_NOT_COST_PROOF"
+        }
+      ],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Kravet Design",
+        "active": 2,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "kravet_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 9494
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 9494
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost_price",
+                "populated": 8592
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_effective_date",
+                "populated": 8221
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail_new",
+                "populated": 8191
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 2
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "kravet_map_authoritative",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "retail_price",
+                "populated": 4522
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "map_price",
+                "populated": 4522
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "whls_cost",
+                "populated": 4522
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 2
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price",
+                "populated": 14030
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost",
+                "populated": 26
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 2
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 2
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Kravet Couture",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 2,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 2,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [
+        {
+          "table": "kravet_catalog",
+          "column": "price_effective_date",
+          "flag": "METADATA_SHAPED_NOT_COST_PROOF"
+        }
+      ],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Kravet Couture",
+        "active": 2,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "kravet_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 9494
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 9494
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost_price",
+                "populated": 8592
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_effective_date",
+                "populated": 8221
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail_new",
+                "populated": 8191
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 2
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price",
+                "populated": 14030
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost",
+                "populated": 26
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku",
+              "matched": 2
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "kravet_master_price",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "map_price",
+                "populated": 13726
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "whls_cost",
+                "populated": 13726
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "retail_price",
+                "populated": 4685
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 2
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 2
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Dedar",
+      "cost_semantics": "UNPROVEN",
+      "external_evidence_status": "NOT_VERIFIED_IN_THIS_PASS",
+      "active_products_reported": 1,
+      "distinct_product_sku_key_matches_reported": 1,
+      "column_population_is_separate_from_join_counts": true,
+      "flags": [],
+      "evidence_requirements": {
+        "sku": "Vendor-external SKU matched to the exact candidate catalog row and live product identity; no SKU is invented here.",
+        "unit": "Quoted purchase unit and catalog unit, pack/roll dimensions and conversion evidence if different.",
+        "currency": "Explicit acquisition-cost currency and documented conversion basis if needed.",
+        "effective_date": "Document date, price effective date and any expiry/supersession evidence.",
+        "basis": "Dated vendor quote, invoice or authoritative list identifying net/trade/list basis; a column name or our sell price is insufficient.",
+        "discount_proof": "If list/retail basis, documented vendor discount and scope; registry stamp alone or a default0% is insufficient.",
+        "table_identity": "Prove each proposed table belongs to this upstream/vendor/cohort; retained candidate names are hypotheses.",
+        "population": "For the proposed cost column, establish populated positive values on joined rows, uniqueness/fan-out, cross-vendor scope and captured query errors."
+      },
+      "acquired_external_evidence": null,
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Dedar",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "dedar_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 46
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku",
+              "matched": 1
+            },
+            "join_pct": 100
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 100,
+        "reachable": 1
+      }
+    }
+  ],
+  "source_ticket_status": "UNRESOLVED_EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED",
+  "next_dependency": "Obtain vendor-external cost evidence and identity/cardinality proof; any adoption into the cost map remains gated."
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-summary.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-summary.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6d9b86ae
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/column-summary.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"summary": {"generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z", "ticket": "TK-11427", "active_products_total": 91167, "vendors_with_active": 170, "covered_vendors": 32, "buckets": [{"state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 26, "active_products": 12852, "reachable_products": 10705}, {"state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 13, "active_products": 24623, "reachable_products": 4389}, {"state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "vendors": 18, "active_products": 6243, "reachable_products": 0}, {"state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "vendors": 81, "active_products": 10735, "reachable_products": 0}]}, "report": [{"vendor": "Phillipe Romano", "active": 13066, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1082}, "join_pct": 8.3}], "join_pct": 8.3, "reachable": 1082}, {"vendor": "Carnegie", "active": 4147, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Malibu Wallpaper", "active": 3822, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1637}, "join_pct": 42.8}], "join_pct": 42.8, "reachable": 1637}, {"vendor": "Clarke And Clarke", "active": 3567, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings", "active": 3561, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2039}, "join_pct": 57.3}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 57.3, "reachable": 2039}, {"vendor": "Phillip Jeffries", "active": 3392, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Walls", "active": 3373, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1199}, "join_pct": 35.5}, {"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1172}, "join_pct": 34.7}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1014}, "join_pct": 30.1}], "join_pct": 35.5, "reachable": 1199}, {"vendor": "Thibaut", "active": 3101, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Brunschwig & Fils", "active": 2737, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens", "active": 2654, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4991}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 1}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2652}, "join_pct": 99.9}], "join_pct": 99.9, "reachable": 2652}, {"vendor": "Kravet", "active": 2601, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Koroseal", "active": 2449, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Gaston Y Daniela", "active": 2148, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Lee Jofa", "active": 2026, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Los Angeles Fabrics", "active": 1821, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "China Seas", "active": 1776, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Maharam", "active": 1429, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Coordonn\u00e9", "active": 1428, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "coordonne_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3676}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 136}, "join_pct": 9.5}], "join_pct": 9.5, "reachable": 136}, {"vendor": "Harlequin", "active": 1257, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Cole & Son", "active": 1238, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Sanderson", "active": 1221, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "GP & J Baker", "active": 1191, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Mind the Gap", "active": 1019, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "mindthegap_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1040}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 2}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 830}, "join_pct": 81.5}], "join_pct": 81.5, "reachable": 830}, {"vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings", "active": 978, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Wallpaper", "active": 942, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0.1}], "join_pct": 1.5, "reachable": 14}, {"vendor": "DW Bespoke Studio", "active": 925, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zoffany", "active": 902, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Anna French", "active": 790, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "anna_french_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 731}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 469}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 651}, "join_pct": 82.4}], "join_pct": 82.4, "reachable": 651}, {"vendor": "Sandberg", "active": 743, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sandberg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 948}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}, {"table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 945}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}], "join_pct": 75, "reachable": 557}, {"vendor": "Pierre Frey", "active": 722, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designtex", "active": 703, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wolf Gordon", "active": 688, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Morris & Co.", "active": 686, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PS Removable Wallpaper", "active": 681, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Surface Stick", "active": 639, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Knoll", "active": 622, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "knoll_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806", "cost_columns": [{"col": "orig_cost_price", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 622}, {"vendor": "Maya Romanoff", "active": 617, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Osborne & Little", "active": 602, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Tres Tintas", "active": 601, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "tres_tintas_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1556}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 601}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 601}, {"vendor": "Romo", "active": 585, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Elitis", "active": 579, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designers Guild", "active": 568, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 145}, "join_pct": 25.5}], "join_pct": 25.5, "reachable": 145}, {"vendor": "William Morris", "active": 522, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fentucci", "active": 514, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.2}], "join_pct": 1.2, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Fentucci Naturals", "active": 504, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Arte International", "active": 489, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings", "active": 456, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "w1838_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 404}, {"col": "maxwell_price", "populated": 332}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 332}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 332}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 451}, "join_pct": 98.9}], "join_pct": 98.9, "reachable": 451}, {"vendor": "Versace", "active": 454, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "versace_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 158}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 157}, "join_pct": 34.6}], "join_pct": 34.6, "reachable": 157}, {"vendor": "Quadrille", "active": 454, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Alan Campbell", "active": 434, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Nina Campbell", "active": 433, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "nina_campbell_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 275}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 3}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}, {"table": "nina_campbell_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172723", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 238}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}], "join_pct": 1.4, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre", "active": 418, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 418}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 418}, {"vendor": "Graham & Brown", "active": 405, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "graham_brown_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 2020}, {"col": "dw_retail_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 312}, {"col": "vendor_retail_price", "populated": 132}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 403}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "graham_brown_murals", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 36}, {"col": "price_per_sqft", "populated": 36}, {"col": "member_price_per_sqm", "populated": 36}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 99.5, "reachable": 403}, {"vendor": "Glitter Walls", "active": 405, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glitter_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 121}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "British Walls", "active": 351, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "CMO Paris", "active": 344, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "AS Creation", "active": 327, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mulberry", "active": 317, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fabricut", "active": 276, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fabricut_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "vendor_msrp", "populated": 1263}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1263}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 274}, "join_pct": 99.3}], "join_pct": 99.3, "reachable": 274}, {"vendor": "Suncloth", "active": 254, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Newwall", "active": 251, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newwall_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8713}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 6276}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 251}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 251}, {"vendor": "Groundworks", "active": 237, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Home Couture", "active": 229, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Innovations USA", "active": 202, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "innovations_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_source", "populated": 221}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 220}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 182}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku", "matched": 160}, "join_pct": 79.2}], "join_pct": 79.2, "reachable": 160}, {"vendor": "Plains", "active": 181, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Stout Textiles", "active": 180, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "stout_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 180}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 180}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 180}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 180}, {"vendor": "De Gournay", "active": 172, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ronald Redding", "active": 167, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Novasuede", "active": 166, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Majilite", "active": 160, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Brand McKenzie", "active": 155, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 37}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 118}, "join_pct": 76.1}, {"table": "brand_mckenzie_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 110}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 76.1, "reachable": 118}, {"vendor": "Artmura", "active": 144, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ralph Lauren", "active": 140, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper", "active": 140, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Donghia", "active": 125, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "donghia_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 167}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 124}, "join_pct": 99.2}], "join_pct": 99.2, "reachable": 124}, {"vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings", "active": 116, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newmor_sku_reconcile", "cost_columns": [{"col": "live_price", "populated": 542}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 116}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 116}, {"vendor": "Marburg", "active": 112, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "marburg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 2559}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 96}, "join_pct": 85.7}], "join_pct": 85.7, "reachable": 96}, {"vendor": "Ultrasuede", "active": 109, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Laura Ashley Wallpaper", "active": 107, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mid Century Modern", "active": 106, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hospitality Wallcoverings", "active": 98, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PR Faux Leather", "active": 97, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "LA Walls", "active": 94, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Charles Burger", "active": 79, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Christian Lacroix Europe", "active": 77, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Nobilis", "active": 74, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Primo Leathers", "active": 72, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sister Parish", "active": 71, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Threads", "active": 71, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "LEED Walls", "active": 68, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Pixels", "active": 59, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glambeads by DW", "active": 58, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Daisy Bennett", "active": 58, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_cost", "populated": 64}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 52}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 63}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Luxury Murals", "active": 56, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "MC Escher Wallpaper", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steve Abrams Studios", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Missoni Wallpaper", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Madagascar Walls", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Anthology", "active": 48, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Retro Walls", "active": 48, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Lincrusta", "active": 47, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "lincrusta_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 47}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 45}, "join_pct": 95.7}], "join_pct": 95.7, "reachable": 45}, {"vendor": "FallingStar Studio", "active": 42, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sancar", "active": 42, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sancar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3418}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 42}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 42}, {"vendor": "Cloth and Paper", "active": 41, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "quadrille_house_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost_price", "populated": 1928}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 40}, "join_pct": 97.6}], "join_pct": 97.6, "reachable": 40}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection", "active": 40, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Apartment Wallpaper", "active": 38, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Home", "active": 37, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Marimekko Exclusive", "active": 35, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection UK", "active": 29, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glass Beaded", "active": 29, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glass_bead_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 717}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Franquemont London", "active": 26, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "franquemont_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "roll_price", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 26}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 26}, {"vendor": "Natural Paint", "active": 26, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana", "active": 26, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 15}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Phyllis Morris", "active": 24, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius Europe", "active": 21, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Contrado", "active": 15, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "contrado_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 11}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hand Crafted", "active": 15, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Traditional Whimsy", "active": 13, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Acoustical", "active": 13, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 4}, "join_pct": 30.8}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 30.8, "reachable": 4}, {"vendor": "Witch & Watchman", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "SUGARBOO", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Backdrop", "active": 9, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Innovations", "active": 8, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wallpaper NYC", "active": 6, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius at DW", "active": 5, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Andrew Martin", "active": 5, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "andrew_martin_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 185}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 3}, "join_pct": 60}], "join_pct": 60, "reachable": 3}, {"vendor": "Architectural Wallcoverings", "active": 4, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Baker Lifestyle", "active": 4, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "baker_lifestyle_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 74}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 74}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 25}], "join_pct": 25, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Black Edition", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Malibu", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Malibu Walls", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Holland and Sherry", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Peg Norriss", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sacha Walckhoff", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Clarke and Clarke", "active": 3, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "clarke_clarke_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 578}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Caroline Cecil Textiles", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Villa Nova", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zinc Textile", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Patty Madden", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Design", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_map_authoritative", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "map_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 4522}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Atomic 50 Ceilings", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kirkby Design", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Couture", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_master_price", "cost_columns": [{"col": "map_price", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4685}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Winfield Thybony", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scion", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Linherr Hollingsworth", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Exclusive Wallpaper", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steven Abrams Photography", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DWHD", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Studio Ditte", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "studio_printworks_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_sample", "populated": 383}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 383}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Emiliana Parati", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Farrow & Ball", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "farrow_ball_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_gbp", "populated": 545}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "farrow_ball_paints", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_usd", "populated": 301}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "G P & J Baker", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Happy Menocal", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Architectural Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Morris and Company", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Milton & King", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "A.S. Cr\u00e9ation", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mark Alexander", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dedar", "active": 1, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "dedar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 46}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Studio", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ananbo", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dupenny", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebecca Moses", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sara Bergqvist", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sarah Bartholomew", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Celerie Kemble", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "catchii_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 670}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-addendum.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-addendum.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ce9d973c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-addendum.json
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+{
+  "schema_version": 1,
+  "correlation_id": "yf2139-cody-addendum",
+  "timestamp": "2026-09-16T22:33:52.517139+00:00",
+  "scope": "Read-only post-review drift addendum; no new execution",
+  "status": "complete",
+  "original_artifact_acceptance": "RETAINED: six isolated/preparation artifacts remain accepted within original scope",
+  "current_operational_outcome": "PARTIAL / UNVERIFIED; installed unchanged assertion no longer holds",
+  "observations": {
+    "original_review_at": "2026-09-16T22:26:28.486409+00:00",
+    "peer_claim_at": "2026-09-16T22:28:01.897Z",
+    "source_ticket_status": "doing",
+    "source_assignee": "night-TK-11848",
+    "installed_head": "a7e005c255e46255f9eb9b633af9502d03a66657",
+    "installed_sha256": "02dd224e0abce69ea444a985849d5b20f4f99807b9ec10bb0e5f689584ffcce7",
+    "isolated_candidate_sha256": "65a0ea8b3829d8f20e8fc5dcdee50912f1d02141d3d7958d9ef0d4671037f9fd",
+    "empirical_assertion": "FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT",
+    "memo_pending_exists": false,
+    "memo_done_path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/_done/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md"
+  },
+  "interpretation": [
+    "The isolated candidate and prior point-in-time checks remain valid; later peer mutation does not retroactively fail them.",
+    "Any final unchanged-source claim must be time-qualified and superseded by the detected installed drift.",
+    "Installed parser line matches the prepared change, with extra comments, but no operational success, authorization or lifecycle proof follows from textual equivalence.",
+    "Moving a memo to _done is not evidence of Steve approval or successful operational verification. The captured ticket still carries its existing approval blocker and an obsolete pending-memo path.",
+    "Canonical source8 is now doing under night-TK-11848; preserve peer ownership and reconcile evidence instead of overwriting or closing."
+  ],
+  "collector_incident": "Parent reported initial duplicate-status TypeError corrected before final collection; reviewed final collector evidence retains real drift as FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT/PARTIAL, not PASS. This reviewer did not rerun the collector.",
+  "requirements": [
+    "Final report explicitly records peer drift and operational PARTIAL/UNVERIFIED.",
+    "Root reconciles source8 owner, memo disposition and actual approval/operational proof before any activation or closure claim.",
+    "Existing source gates and whole-watch/Claude prohibition remain in force."
+  ],
+  "critical_paths_skipped": [
+    "whole watcher execution",
+    "real second-daemon lifecycle",
+    "activation authority and peer operational verification"
+  ],
+  "reviewer_actions": [
+    "Direct guard/env read",
+    "Read supplied three final artifacts and prior proof",
+    "Read-only installed HEAD/hash and isolated candidate hash",
+    "Verify pending memo absent and moved memo present",
+    "Write only final-addendum.json and additive coordinator log"
+  ],
+  "cost_guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+  "DTD_ZERO_COST": "1",
+  "provider_spend_usd": 0,
+  "source_mutation_by_reviewer": false,
+  "operational_blessing": false,
+  "next_action": "Retain isolated artifact acceptance; reconcile peer ownership and approval evidence while publishing only a PARTIAL operational outcome."
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-proof.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ca74c47c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
+{
+  "schema_version": 1,
+  "correlation_id": "yf2139-cody",
+  "status": "complete",
+  "scope": "Independent review of six offline/preparation increments and final accounting only",
+  "timestamp": "2026-09-16T22:26:28.486409+00:00",
+  "reviewer_count": 1,
+  "inline_lenses": [
+    "Engineer",
+    "Designer",
+    "User",
+    "Skeptic",
+    "Strategist"
+  ],
+  "debate_completed": true,
+  "votes": {
+    "SHIP IT": 5
+  },
+  "verdict": "SHIP IT",
+  "operational_authorization": false,
+  "source_operational_outcomes": "UNVERIFIED",
+  "source_closures_claimed": 0,
+  "execution_slots": 6,
+  "execution_order": [
+    2,
+    4,
+    1,
+    5,
+    6,
+    8
+  ],
+  "ordering_deviation_disclosed": true,
+  "initial_evidence": "initial-proof.json",
+  "second_evidence": "second-proof.json",
+  "watch_evidence": "watch-proof.json",
+  "reproduced_defects": [
+    {
+      "defect": "Final disposition8 stale in-progress wording and obsolete citations",
+      "status": "CORRECTED_BY_ROOT",
+      "independent_recheck": "PASS completed isolated candidate with watch-parent-proof and handoff citations; activation/real-second-daemon SKIPs retained"
+    }
+  ],
+  "must_fix_preparation_defects_remaining": [],
+  "source_mutations_by_reviewer": false,
+  "commit_by_reviewer": null,
+  "cost_guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+  "DTD_ZERO_COST": "1",
+  "provider_spend_usd": 0,
+  "terminal_status": "Parent owns; reviewer did not paint",
+  "retention": "All reviewer fixtures retained under cody/; no deletion",
+  "parent_acceptance": "PENDING independent root acceptance, final DTD and durable persistence",
+  "next_action": "Finalize empirical verification and durable evidence with six preparation slots, zero source closures, explicit ordering deviation and all activation/vendor-evidence gates preserved",
+  "reviewed_accounting_hashes": {
+    "dispositions.json": "4440c91fd5e3891192c0cda1cfc76a786a9f810be80e2db629e5c6419d8151c6",
+    "execution-order.json": "cb02767c8fd2e20d3badbd4911841793504aa8f82a872190f2c8bf99000ad0ba"
+  }
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-review.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-review.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..64b59204
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-review.md
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+# CONTRARIAN PANEL — six preparation increments and final accounting
+
+**Verdict: SHIP IT — preparation artifacts only.** One independent Codex reviewer used five distinct inline critic lenses under the tiny-target exception. This is not five independent agents and does not authorize activation or source-ticket closure.
+
+**The five critics:**
+- Engineer — Exact patch scope, reverse patch, nine Watchtower checks, six audit tests, source hashes and manifest replay all survive independent poking. Vote SHIP IT.
+- Designer — The reports visibly distinguish canonical from superseded anchors, sell price from acquisition cost, and historical counts from current measurements. No new rendered UI to judge. Vote SHIP IT.
+- User — Approval memos name the concrete action and preconditions; the original stale Watchtower disposition was confusing and is now corrected with actual evidence links. Vote SHIP IT.
+- Skeptic — The hardest paths are explicitly SKIP: activation, real second daemon, authenticated model availability and actual vendor-cost evidence. Nobody gets to replace those words with done. Vote SHIP IT.
+- Strategist — Six preparation slots produced useful reviewable artifacts, but zero source closures. The ordering mistake is recorded instead of being rewritten as perfect execution. Vote SHIP IT for the honest scoped result.
+
+**The three holes that survived debate, ranked:**
+1. Operational proof is still missing. The Watchtower parser works on controlled fixtures and the current single daemon, while real second-daemon behavior and full escalation remain untested; photo activation and future Google-reference behavior also remain unresolved. These are gated operational gaps, not hidden preparation defects.
+2. Acquisition-cost authority still does not exist in this evidence. The 1,082 PR key matches, 474 populated catalog rows, and 10,704 strong-candidate key matches are distinct historical measurements. Current cost, join identity/cardinality and cohort coverage remain unverified. The manifests say so.
+3. Execution order departed from queue rank: positions 2 and 4 were prepared before position 1 after process liveness was mistaken for active task ownership. Later canonical parent status corrected that assumption. execution-order.json preserves the actual [2,4,1,5,6,8] sequence and prevention rule; this historical deviation cannot be retroactively fixed.
+
+**The lazy shortcut you hoped we would not notice:** The first final disposition still said "Slot6 isolated detector candidate and tests in progress" and cited old planning evidence despite the completed candidate. That was reproduced, sent to root, corrected by root, and independently re-read. There is no remaining preparation blocker. Equally, "PASS offline artifact journey" must keep its accompanying "source issue remains unresolved."
+
+**Sameness:** Shared evidence schemas are appropriate here. The artifacts solve six distinct preparation needs; repeated UNKNOWN/UNVERIFIED labels are accurate boundaries, not six claims of operational progress.
+
+**Where the critics disagreed:** Strategist holds the strongest dissent: calling six preparations a repaired fleet or improved cost coverage would be fiction. Engineer agrees about operations but rejects withholding acceptance from correctly scoped, reproducible preparation. User initially held FIX FIRST for stale position8 accounting and conceded only after the corrected record and evidence links were independently verified. Skeptic refuses to let the fixture tests stand in for real lifecycle proof. All five converge on artifact-only acceptance.
+
+**Vote tally:** 5 SHIP IT → **SHIP IT for reviewed preparation artifacts only.** No source closure or activation authorization.
+
+**The bar:** Reproducible local checks, exact source provenance and retained originals, useful negative tests, corrected final accounting, and explicit gates at every untested operational boundary. The six reviewed artifacts clear that bar. The corrected TemporaryDirectory fixture cleanup is historical; current retained tests show no ongoing cleanup fault.
+
+**Evidence:** initial-proof.json, initial-tests.log, second-proof.json, watch-proof.json, final-proof.json and the retained fixtures/replays under cody/. Independent checks include exact photo handler removal, syntax and byte-exact reversal; six real audit CLI tests (only fixture placement redirected into reviewer-owned storage); report regeneration; captured model tags/roster and401/WARN limitations; ten exact quotations/three hashes;26-row manifest replay and three negative inputs; nine literal Watchtower assignment/threshold checks; exact one-line source diff; installed watcher byte identity; final 15-position accounting and six actual slots. The whole watcher was never invoked, no second daemon started, no source changed, no provider API used, no terminal painted. Guard directly verified ZERO_COST_REQUIRED / DTD_ZERO_COST=1.
+
+**Do this now:** Root should finish final empirical verification and durable evidence persistence while keeping six preparation slots, zero source closures, the ordering deviation and all operational gates explicit.
+
+**One sentence:** The preparations finally earn a pass; selling that pass as six fixed problems would undo the best part of this work—its honesty.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/initial-proof.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/initial-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7d9dc4c8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/initial-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+{
+  "task_id": "yf2139-cody",
+  "phase": "initial",
+  "cost_guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+  "checks": {
+    "prestige_artifact_hashes": "PASS",
+    "prestige_exact_handler_removal_latent_mapping_preserved": "PASS; latent Google refs require separate decision, as disclosed",
+    "prestige_syntax_reverse_patch": "PASS",
+    "join_six_real_tests": "PASS; only fixture placement overridden to owned review directory; tests and CLI logic unchanged",
+    "join_retained_report_replay": "PASS",
+    "model_retained_claim_boundaries": "PASS; model absent from captured tags, capacity WARN and authentication limitation explicit"
+  },
+  "source_outcome": "UNVERIFIED; gated operational outcomes excluded"
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/initial-review.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/initial-review.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9b28b9ba
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/initial-review.md
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
+# Initial contrarian review — yf2139-cody
+
+Scope: three tiny preparation artifacts. One independent Codex reviewer used five distinct inline lenses; no claim of five independent agents. Whole-result verdict is deferred pending the remaining batch. Cost guard was read directly: ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and DTD_ZERO_COST=1. Only Cody evidence artifacts and the required coordination ticket log changed.
+
+## Five critics
+- Engineer: the exact photo handler removal reverses byte-for-byte, syntax passes, and all six audit CLI tests pass. SHIP IT for these preparation artifacts.
+- Designer: the memo/report hierarchy puts provenance, unresolved status, and the next dependency in view; no rendered UI was introduced. SHIP IT for these preparation artifacts.
+- User: a future Google photo reference still maps to the removed URL; the handoff explicitly says so. This is an activation constraint, not an undisclosed defect in the scoped patch. SHIP IT for preparation only.
+- Skeptic: the model memo distinguishes captured tags from authenticated availability, and audit output never upgrades zero reachability into proof of missing costs. SHIP IT for preparation only.
+- Strategist: three polished artifacts still resolve zero operational problems. Hold execution until the stated dependencies land; do not invent a preparation defect merely to sound tough. SHIP IT for the reviewed artifacts.
+
+## Three holes that survived debate, ranked by operational impact
+1. Photo activation remains unverified: preserved Google-reference mapping can still issue the removed proxy URL. Seven local files are the current supported state, not a permanent invariant. Require the recorded approval and post-activation checks; do not claim Google-reference compatibility.
+2. Model restoration remains unverified: captured unauthenticated availability was 401 and capacity is WARN at 8 percent. The memo correctly requires intended-roster confirmation, quantified headroom, scoped approval, and later authenticated proof.
+3. Cost joins remain unverified: retained counts are 18 vendors / 6,243 products / zero reported reachable, with 3 associations / 4,371 products identity-unproven. Swallowed SQL failures and independent population counts prevent cost/join correctness claims.
+
+These are disclosed gated operational gaps. No must-fix defect in the present preparation artifacts was reproduced.
+
+## Lazy shortcut
+The shortcut would be quoting "PASS offline artifact journey" and dropping the adjacent "source issue remains unresolved." The artifact itself does not take that shortcut.
+
+## Sameness
+Each artifact addresses a different dependency: photo route removal, model capacity/roster decision, and retained join evidence. No fake variety or duplicate deliverable defect found.
+
+## Debate and dissent
+The User initially objects to latent photo mapping. Engineer narrows acceptance to the approved preparation scope and Skeptic confirms the limitation is explicit. User concedes a preparation blocker is unwarranted. Strategist holds the strongest dissent: a passing document is not a resolved source ticket. All five agree to keep that boundary.
+
+## Vote and bar
+5 SHIP IT votes for these three preparation artifacts only. Whole-batch decision pending. A-grade here means a reproducible, source-preserving artifact with accurate uncertainty, approval boundaries, and retained rollback evidence; these reviewed surfaces clear that bar.
+
+## Evidence
+initial-proof.json and initial-tests.log: independently checked artifact SHA-256s, exact handler-only removal, candidate syntax, byte-identical reverse patch, real CLI tests with fixture placement redirected only into Cody-owned retained directories, report regeneration against the pinned snapshot, captured model tags/roster, and memo limitation text. Corrected TemporaryDirectory cleanup is historical; the current harness retains fixtures and has no ongoing cleanup defect. No provider call, runtime activation, database access, source edit, status change, or terminal painting.
+
+## Do this now
+Complete the remaining artifact review and preserve the operational-unverified boundary in the final report.
+
+One sentence: These preparations earn acceptance; declaring any underlying problem fixed would still be fiction.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-1/input.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-1/input.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..99ab1bbb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-1/input.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"summary": {"generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z", "ticket": "TK-11427", "active_products_total": 91167, "vendors_with_active": 170, "covered_vendors": 32, "buckets": [{"state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 26, "active_products": 12852, "reachable_products": 10704}, {"state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 13, "active_products": 24623, "reachable_products": 4389}, {"state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "vendors": 18, "active_products": 6243, "reachable_products": 0}, {"state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "vendors": 81, "active_products": 10735, "reachable_products": 0}]}, "report": [{"vendor": "Phillipe Romano", "active": 13066, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1082}, "join_pct": 8.3}], "join_pct": 8.3, "reachable": 1082}, {"vendor": "Carnegie", "active": 4147, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Malibu Wallpaper", "active": 3822, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1637}, "join_pct": 42.8}], "join_pct": 42.8, "reachable": 1637}, {"vendor": "Clarke And Clarke", "active": 3567, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings", "active": 3561, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2039}, "join_pct": 57.3}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 57.3, "reachable": 2039}, {"vendor": "Phillip Jeffries", "active": 3392, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "changed_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Walls", "active": 3373, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1199}, "join_pct": 35.5}, {"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1172}, "join_pct": 34.7}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1014}, "join_pct": 30.1}], "join_pct": 35.5, "reachable": 1199}, {"vendor": "Thibaut", "active": 3101, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Brunschwig & Fils", "active": 2737, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens", "active": 2654, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4991}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 1}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2652}, "join_pct": 99.9}], "join_pct": 99.9, "reachable": 2652}, {"vendor": "Kravet", "active": 2601, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Koroseal", "active": 2449, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Gaston Y Daniela", "active": 2148, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Lee Jofa", "active": 2026, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Los Angeles Fabrics", "active": 1821, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "China Seas", "active": 1776, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Maharam", "active": 1429, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Coordonn\u00e9", "active": 1428, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "coordonne_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3676}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 136}, "join_pct": 9.5}], "join_pct": 9.5, "reachable": 136}, {"vendor": "Harlequin", "active": 1257, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Cole & Son", "active": 1238, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Sanderson", "active": 1221, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "GP & J Baker", "active": 1191, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Mind the Gap", "active": 1019, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "mindthegap_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1040}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 2}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 830}, "join_pct": 81.5}], "join_pct": 81.5, "reachable": 830}, {"vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings", "active": 978, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Wallpaper", "active": 942, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0.1}], "join_pct": 1.5, "reachable": 14}, {"vendor": "DW Bespoke Studio", "active": 925, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zoffany", "active": 902, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Anna French", "active": 790, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "anna_french_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 731}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 469}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 651}, "join_pct": 82.4}], "join_pct": 82.4, "reachable": 651}, {"vendor": "Sandberg", "active": 743, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sandberg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 948}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}, {"table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 945}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}], "join_pct": 75, "reachable": 557}, {"vendor": "Pierre Frey", "active": 722, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designtex", "active": 703, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wolf Gordon", "active": 688, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Morris & Co.", "active": 686, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PS Removable Wallpaper", "active": 681, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Surface Stick", "active": 639, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Knoll", "active": 622, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "knoll_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806", "cost_columns": [{"col": "orig_cost_price", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 622}, {"vendor": "Maya Romanoff", "active": 617, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Osborne & Little", "active": 602, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Tres Tintas", "active": 601, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "tres_tintas_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1556}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 601}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 601}, {"vendor": "Romo", "active": 585, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Elitis", "active": 579, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designers Guild", "active": 568, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 145}, "join_pct": 25.5}], "join_pct": 25.5, "reachable": 145}, {"vendor": "William Morris", "active": 522, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fentucci", "active": 514, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.2}], "join_pct": 1.2, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Fentucci Naturals", "active": 504, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Arte International", "active": 489, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings", "active": 456, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "w1838_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 404}, {"col": "maxwell_price", "populated": 332}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 332}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 332}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 451}, "join_pct": 98.9}], "join_pct": 98.9, "reachable": 451}, {"vendor": "Versace", "active": 454, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "versace_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 158}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 157}, "join_pct": 34.6}], "join_pct": 34.6, "reachable": 157}, {"vendor": "Quadrille", "active": 454, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Alan Campbell", "active": 434, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Nina Campbell", "active": 433, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "nina_campbell_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 275}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 3}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}, {"table": "nina_campbell_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172723", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 238}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}], "join_pct": 1.4, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre", "active": 418, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 418}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 418}, {"vendor": "Graham & Brown", "active": 405, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "graham_brown_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 2020}, {"col": "dw_retail_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 312}, {"col": "vendor_retail_price", "populated": 132}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 403}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "graham_brown_murals", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 36}, {"col": "price_per_sqft", "populated": 36}, {"col": "member_price_per_sqm", "populated": 36}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 99.5, "reachable": 403}, {"vendor": "Glitter Walls", "active": 405, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glitter_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 121}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "British Walls", "active": 351, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "CMO Paris", "active": 344, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "AS Creation", "active": 327, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mulberry", "active": 317, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fabricut", "active": 276, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fabricut_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "vendor_msrp", "populated": 1263}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1263}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 274}, "join_pct": 99.3}], "join_pct": 99.3, "reachable": 274}, {"vendor": "Suncloth", "active": 254, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Newwall", "active": 251, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newwall_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8713}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 6276}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 251}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 251}, {"vendor": "Groundworks", "active": 237, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Home Couture", "active": 229, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Innovations USA", "active": 202, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "innovations_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_source", "populated": 221}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 220}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 182}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku", "matched": 160}, "join_pct": 79.2}], "join_pct": 79.2, "reachable": 160}, {"vendor": "Plains", "active": 181, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Stout Textiles", "active": 180, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "stout_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 180}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 180}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 180}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 180}, {"vendor": "De Gournay", "active": 172, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ronald Redding", "active": 167, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Novasuede", "active": 166, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Majilite", "active": 160, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Brand McKenzie", "active": 155, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 37}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 118}, "join_pct": 76.1}, {"table": "brand_mckenzie_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 110}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 76.1, "reachable": 118}, {"vendor": "Artmura", "active": 144, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ralph Lauren", "active": 140, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper", "active": 140, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Donghia", "active": 125, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "donghia_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 167}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 124}, "join_pct": 99.2}], "join_pct": 99.2, "reachable": 124}, {"vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings", "active": 116, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newmor_sku_reconcile", "cost_columns": [{"col": "live_price", "populated": 542}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 116}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 116}, {"vendor": "Marburg", "active": 112, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "marburg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 2559}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 96}, "join_pct": 85.7}], "join_pct": 85.7, "reachable": 96}, {"vendor": "Ultrasuede", "active": 109, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Laura Ashley Wallpaper", "active": 107, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mid Century Modern", "active": 106, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hospitality Wallcoverings", "active": 98, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PR Faux Leather", "active": 97, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "LA Walls", "active": 94, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Charles Burger", "active": 79, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Christian Lacroix Europe", "active": 77, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Nobilis", "active": 74, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Primo Leathers", "active": 72, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sister Parish", "active": 71, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Threads", "active": 71, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "LEED Walls", "active": 68, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Pixels", "active": 59, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glambeads by DW", "active": 58, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Daisy Bennett", "active": 58, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_cost", "populated": 64}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 52}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 63}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Luxury Murals", "active": 56, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "MC Escher Wallpaper", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steve Abrams Studios", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Missoni Wallpaper", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Madagascar Walls", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Anthology", "active": 48, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Retro Walls", "active": 48, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Lincrusta", "active": 47, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "lincrusta_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 47}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 45}, "join_pct": 95.7}], "join_pct": 95.7, "reachable": 45}, {"vendor": "FallingStar Studio", "active": 42, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sancar", "active": 42, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sancar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3418}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 42}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 42}, {"vendor": "Cloth and Paper", "active": 41, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "quadrille_house_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost_price", "populated": 1928}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 40}, "join_pct": 97.6}], "join_pct": 97.6, "reachable": 40}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection", "active": 40, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Apartment Wallpaper", "active": 38, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Home", "active": 37, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Marimekko Exclusive", "active": 35, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection UK", "active": 29, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glass Beaded", "active": 29, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glass_bead_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 717}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Franquemont London", "active": 26, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "franquemont_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "roll_price", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 26}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 26}, {"vendor": "Natural Paint", "active": 26, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana", "active": 26, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 15}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Phyllis Morris", "active": 24, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius Europe", "active": 21, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Contrado", "active": 15, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "contrado_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 11}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hand Crafted", "active": 15, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Traditional Whimsy", "active": 13, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Acoustical", "active": 13, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 4}, "join_pct": 30.8}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 30.8, "reachable": 4}, {"vendor": "Witch & Watchman", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "SUGARBOO", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Backdrop", "active": 9, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Innovations", "active": 8, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wallpaper NYC", "active": 6, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius at DW", "active": 5, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Andrew Martin", "active": 5, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "andrew_martin_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 185}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 3}, "join_pct": 60}], "join_pct": 60, "reachable": 3}, {"vendor": "Architectural Wallcoverings", "active": 4, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Baker Lifestyle", "active": 4, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "baker_lifestyle_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 74}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 74}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 25}], "join_pct": 25, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Black Edition", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Malibu", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Malibu Walls", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Holland and Sherry", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Peg Norriss", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sacha Walckhoff", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Clarke and Clarke", "active": 3, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "clarke_clarke_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 578}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Caroline Cecil Textiles", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Villa Nova", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zinc Textile", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Patty Madden", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Design", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_map_authoritative", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "map_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 4522}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Atomic 50 Ceilings", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kirkby Design", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Couture", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_master_price", "cost_columns": [{"col": "map_price", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4685}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Winfield Thybony", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scion", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Linherr Hollingsworth", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Exclusive Wallpaper", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steven Abrams Photography", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DWHD", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Studio Ditte", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "studio_printworks_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_sample", "populated": 383}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 383}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Emiliana Parati", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Farrow & Ball", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "farrow_ball_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_gbp", "populated": 545}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "farrow_ball_paints", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_usd", "populated": 301}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "G P & J Baker", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Happy Menocal", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Architectural Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Morris and Company", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Milton & King", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "A.S. Cr\u00e9ation", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mark Alexander", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dedar", "active": 1, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "dedar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 46}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Studio", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ananbo", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dupenny", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebecca Moses", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sara Bergqvist", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sarah Bartholomew", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Celerie Kemble", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "catchii_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 670}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-2/input.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-2/input.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..edb1a247
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-2/input.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{invalid
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-3/input.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-3/input.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ea8819c5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-3/input.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"summary": {"generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z", "ticket": "TK-11427", "active_products_total": 91167, "vendors_with_active": 170, "covered_vendors": 32, "buckets": [{"state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 26, "active_products": 12852, "reachable_products": 10704}, {"state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 13, "active_products": 24623, "reachable_products": 4389}, {"state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "vendors": 18, "active_products": 6243, "reachable_products": 0}, {"state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "vendors": 81, "active_products": 10735, "reachable_products": 0}]}, "report": [{"vendor": "Phillipe Romano", "active": 13066, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1082}, "join_pct": 8.3}], "join_pct": 8.3, "reachable": 1082}, {"vendor": "Carnegie", "active": 4147, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Malibu Wallpaper", "active": 3822, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1637}, "join_pct": 42.8}], "join_pct": 42.8, "reachable": 1637}, {"vendor": "Clarke And Clarke", "active": 3567, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings", "active": 3561, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2039}, "join_pct": 57.3}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 57.3, "reachable": 2039}, {"vendor": "Phillip Jeffries", "active": 3392, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Walls", "active": 3373, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1199}, "join_pct": 35.5}, {"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1172}, "join_pct": 34.7}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1014}, "join_pct": 30.1}], "join_pct": 35.5, "reachable": 1199}, {"vendor": "Thibaut", "active": 3101, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Brunschwig & Fils", "active": 2737, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens", "active": 2654, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4991}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 1}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2652}, "join_pct": 99.9}], "join_pct": 99.9, "reachable": 2652}, {"vendor": "Kravet", "active": 2601, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Koroseal", "active": 2449, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Gaston Y Daniela", "active": 2148, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Lee Jofa", "active": 2026, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Los Angeles Fabrics", "active": 1821, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "China Seas", "active": 1776, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Maharam", "active": 1429, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Coordonn\u00e9", "active": 1428, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "coordonne_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3676}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 136}, "join_pct": 9.5}], "join_pct": 9.5, "reachable": 136}, {"vendor": "Harlequin", "active": 1257, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Cole & Son", "active": 1238, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Sanderson", "active": 1221, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "GP & J Baker", "active": 1191, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Mind the Gap", "active": 1019, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "mindthegap_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1040}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 2}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 830}, "join_pct": 81.5}], "join_pct": 81.5, "reachable": 830}, {"vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings", "active": 978, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Wallpaper", "active": 942, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0.1}], "join_pct": 1.5, "reachable": 14}, {"vendor": "DW Bespoke Studio", "active": 925, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zoffany", "active": 902, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Anna French", "active": 790, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "anna_french_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 731}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 469}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 651}, "join_pct": 82.4}], "join_pct": 82.4, "reachable": 651}, {"vendor": "Sandberg", "active": 743, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sandberg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 948}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}, {"table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 945}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}], "join_pct": 75, "reachable": 557}, {"vendor": "Pierre Frey", "active": 722, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designtex", "active": 703, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wolf Gordon", "active": 688, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Morris & Co.", "active": 686, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PS Removable Wallpaper", "active": 681, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Surface Stick", "active": 639, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Knoll", "active": 622, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "knoll_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806", "cost_columns": [{"col": "orig_cost_price", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 622}, {"vendor": "Maya Romanoff", "active": 617, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Osborne & Little", "active": 602, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Tres Tintas", "active": 601, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "tres_tintas_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1556}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 601}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 601}, {"vendor": "Romo", "active": 585, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Elitis", "active": 579, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designers Guild", "active": 568, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 145}, "join_pct": 25.5}], "join_pct": 25.5, "reachable": 145}, {"vendor": "William Morris", "active": 522, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fentucci", "active": 514, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.2}], "join_pct": 1.2, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Fentucci Naturals", "active": 504, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Arte International", "active": 489, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings", "active": 456, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "w1838_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 404}, {"col": "maxwell_price", "populated": 332}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 332}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 332}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 451}, "join_pct": 98.9}], "join_pct": 98.9, "reachable": 451}, {"vendor": "Versace", "active": 454, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "versace_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 158}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 157}, "join_pct": 34.6}], "join_pct": 34.6, "reachable": 157}, {"vendor": "Quadrille", "active": 454, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Alan Campbell", "active": 434, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Nina Campbell", "active": 433, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "nina_campbell_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 275}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 3}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}, {"table": "nina_campbell_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172723", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 238}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}], "join_pct": 1.4, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre", "active": 418, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 418}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 418}, {"vendor": "Graham & Brown", "active": 405, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "graham_brown_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 2020}, {"col": "dw_retail_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 312}, {"col": "vendor_retail_price", "populated": 132}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 403}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "graham_brown_murals", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 36}, {"col": "price_per_sqft", "populated": 36}, {"col": "member_price_per_sqm", "populated": 36}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 99.5, "reachable": 403}, {"vendor": "Glitter Walls", "active": 405, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glitter_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 121}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "British Walls", "active": 351, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "CMO Paris", "active": 344, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "AS Creation", "active": 327, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mulberry", "active": 317, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fabricut", "active": 276, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fabricut_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "vendor_msrp", "populated": 1263}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1263}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 274}, "join_pct": 99.3}], "join_pct": 99.3, "reachable": 274}, {"vendor": "Suncloth", "active": 254, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Newwall", "active": 251, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newwall_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8713}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 6276}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 251}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 251}, {"vendor": "Groundworks", "active": 237, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Home Couture", "active": 229, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Innovations USA", "active": 202, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "innovations_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_source", "populated": 221}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 220}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 182}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku", "matched": 160}, "join_pct": 79.2}], "join_pct": 79.2, "reachable": 160}, {"vendor": "Plains", "active": 181, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Stout Textiles", "active": 180, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "stout_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 180}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 180}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 180}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 180}, {"vendor": "De Gournay", "active": 172, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ronald Redding", "active": 167, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Novasuede", "active": 166, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Majilite", "active": 160, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Brand McKenzie", "active": 155, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 37}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 118}, "join_pct": 76.1}, {"table": "brand_mckenzie_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 110}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 76.1, "reachable": 118}, {"vendor": "Artmura", "active": 144, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ralph Lauren", "active": 140, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper", "active": 140, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Donghia", "active": 125, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "donghia_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 167}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 124}, "join_pct": 99.2}], "join_pct": 99.2, "reachable": 124}, {"vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings", "active": 116, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newmor_sku_reconcile", "cost_columns": [{"col": "live_price", "populated": 542}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 116}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 116}, {"vendor": "Marburg", "active": 112, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "marburg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 2559}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 96}, "join_pct": 85.7}], "join_pct": 85.7, "reachable": 96}, {"vendor": "Ultrasuede", "active": 109, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Laura Ashley Wallpaper", "active": 107, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mid Century Modern", "active": 106, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hospitality Wallcoverings", "active": 98, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PR Faux Leather", "active": 97, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "LA Walls", "active": 94, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Charles Burger", "active": 79, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Christian Lacroix Europe", "active": 77, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Nobilis", "active": 74, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Primo Leathers", "active": 72, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sister Parish", "active": 71, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Threads", "active": 71, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "LEED Walls", "active": 68, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Pixels", "active": 59, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glambeads by DW", "active": 58, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Daisy Bennett", "active": 58, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_cost", "populated": 64}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 52}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 63}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Luxury Murals", "active": 56, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "MC Escher Wallpaper", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steve Abrams Studios", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Missoni Wallpaper", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Madagascar Walls", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Anthology", "active": 48, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Retro Walls", "active": 48, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Lincrusta", "active": 47, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "lincrusta_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 47}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 45}, "join_pct": 95.7}], "join_pct": 95.7, "reachable": 45}, {"vendor": "FallingStar Studio", "active": 42, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sancar", "active": 42, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sancar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3418}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 42}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 42}, {"vendor": "Cloth and Paper", "active": 41, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "quadrille_house_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost_price", "populated": 1928}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 40}, "join_pct": 97.6}], "join_pct": 97.6, "reachable": 40}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection", "active": 40, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Apartment Wallpaper", "active": 38, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Home", "active": 37, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Marimekko Exclusive", "active": 35, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection UK", "active": 29, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glass Beaded", "active": 29, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glass_bead_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 717}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Franquemont London", "active": 26, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "franquemont_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "roll_price", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 26}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 26}, {"vendor": "Natural Paint", "active": 26, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana", "active": 26, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 15}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Phyllis Morris", "active": 24, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius Europe", "active": 21, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Contrado", "active": 15, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "contrado_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 11}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hand Crafted", "active": 15, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Traditional Whimsy", "active": 13, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Acoustical", "active": 13, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 4}, "join_pct": 30.8}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 30.8, "reachable": 4}, {"vendor": "Witch & Watchman", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "SUGARBOO", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Backdrop", "active": 9, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Innovations", "active": 8, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wallpaper NYC", "active": 6, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius at DW", "active": 5, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Andrew Martin", "active": 5, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "andrew_martin_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 185}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 3}, "join_pct": 60}], "join_pct": 60, "reachable": 3}, {"vendor": "Architectural Wallcoverings", "active": 4, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Baker Lifestyle", "active": 4, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "baker_lifestyle_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 74}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 74}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 25}], "join_pct": 25, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Black Edition", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Malibu", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Malibu Walls", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Holland and Sherry", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Peg Norriss", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sacha Walckhoff", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Clarke and Clarke", "active": 3, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "clarke_clarke_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 578}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Caroline Cecil Textiles", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Villa Nova", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zinc Textile", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Patty Madden", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Design", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_map_authoritative", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "map_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 4522}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Atomic 50 Ceilings", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kirkby Design", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Couture", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_master_price", "cost_columns": [{"col": "map_price", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4685}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Winfield Thybony", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scion", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Linherr Hollingsworth", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Exclusive Wallpaper", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steven Abrams Photography", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DWHD", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Unreviewed Association", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "studio_printworks_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_sample", "populated": 383}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 383}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Emiliana Parati", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Farrow & Ball", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "farrow_ball_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_gbp", "populated": 545}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "farrow_ball_paints", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_usd", "populated": 301}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "G P & J Baker", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Happy Menocal", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Architectural Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Morris and Company", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Milton & King", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "A.S. Cr\u00e9ation", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mark Alexander", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dedar", "active": 1, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "dedar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 46}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Studio", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ananbo", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dupenny", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebecca Moses", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sara Bergqvist", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sarah Bartholomew", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Celerie Kemble", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "catchii_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 670}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-4/review.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-4/review.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..be221a07
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-4/review.json
@@ -0,0 +1,743 @@
+{
+  "schema_version": 1,
+  "ticket": "TK-11859",
+  "correlation_id": "yf2139-i4-execute",
+  "kind": "OFFLINE_SNAPSHOT_REVIEW",
+  "source": {
+    "path": "/private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/join-audit/input-snapshot.json",
+    "sha256": "fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a",
+    "generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z"
+  },
+  "reviewed_at": "2026-09-16T22:15:28.535114+00:00",
+  "original_totals": {
+    "vendors": 18,
+    "active_products": 6243,
+    "reported_reachable_products": 0
+  },
+  "review_totals": {
+    "unproven_table_identity_vendors": 3,
+    "unproven_table_identity_products": 4371,
+    "remaining_unverified_vendors": 15,
+    "remaining_unverified_products": 1872
+  },
+  "attempted_key_pairs": [
+    [
+      "dw_sku",
+      "sku"
+    ],
+    [
+      "dw_sku",
+      "dw_sku"
+    ],
+    [
+      "mfr_sku",
+      "mfr_sku"
+    ],
+    [
+      "mfr_sku",
+      "sku"
+    ],
+    [
+      "shopify_id",
+      "shopify_id"
+    ],
+    [
+      "sku",
+      "sku"
+    ]
+  ],
+  "limitations": [
+    "Candidate tables combine registry declarations and name heuristics; the retained report does not record which origin selected a table.",
+    "The generator tries only the six catalog-to-product key pairs listed here; it does not exhaust possible identity mappings.",
+    "The generator catches SQL errors and continues without retaining error details; zero reachability does not prove successful zero-result queries.",
+    "Join reachability counts distinct product SKUs without requiring a populated positive candidate cost value on the joined row. Column population is measured independently.",
+    "Cross-name table associations require identity evidence. They are not proven false matches; the remaining candidates are also unverified.",
+    "This snapshot proves neither absent cost nor broken joins, cost semantics, current coverage, or a safe repair. No new database or external verification was performed."
+  ],
+  "rows": [
+    {
+      "vendor": "Phillip Jeffries",
+      "active_products": 3392,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Phillip Jeffries",
+        "active": 3392,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "phillipe_romano_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 474
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings",
+      "active_products": 978,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings",
+        "active": 978,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "designers_guild_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 23
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Morris & Co.",
+      "active_products": 686,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Morris & Co.",
+        "active": 686,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "morris_feed_pricing",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "trade_usd",
+                "populated": 1162
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Fentucci Naturals",
+      "active_products": 504,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Fentucci Naturals",
+        "active": 504,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "fentucci_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price",
+                "populated": 85
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "cost",
+                "populated": 84
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Glitter Walls",
+      "active_products": 405,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Glitter Walls",
+        "active": 405,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "glitter_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 121
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper",
+      "active_products": 140,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper",
+        "active": 140,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 82
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Daisy Bennett",
+      "active_products": 58,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Daisy Bennett",
+        "active": 58,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_cost",
+                "populated": 64
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "cost",
+                "populated": 52
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "daisy_bennett_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 63
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Glass Beaded",
+      "active_products": 29,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Glass Beaded",
+        "active": 29,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "glass_bead_products",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price",
+                "populated": 717
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana",
+      "active_products": 26,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana",
+        "active": 26,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 15
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Contrado",
+      "active_products": 15,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Contrado",
+        "active": 15,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "contrado_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 11
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 8
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Clarke and Clarke",
+      "active_products": 3,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Clarke and Clarke",
+        "active": 3,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "clarke_clarke_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 578
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Studio Ditte",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Studio Ditte",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "studio_printworks_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_sample",
+                "populated": 383
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 383
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Farrow & Ball",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Farrow & Ball",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "farrow_ball_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_gbp",
+                "populated": 545
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "farrow_ball_paints",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_usd",
+                "populated": 301
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Morris and Company",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Morris and Company",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "morris_feed_pricing",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "trade_usd",
+                "populated": 1162
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Roberto Cavalli",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Roberto Cavalli",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 82
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Rebel Studio",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Rebel Studio",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "rebel_walls_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 4123
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 449
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_retail",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_commercial",
+                "populated": 3958
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "rebelwalls_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 4382
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_retail",
+                "populated": 4133
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_per_sqft_commercial",
+                "populated": 3958
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "scalamandre_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 5002
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "scalamandre_pillows",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 1512
+              },
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 1512
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          },
+          {
+            "table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_trade",
+                "populated": 4996
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe",
+      "active_products": 1,
+      "reported_reachable_products": 0,
+      "review_status": "UNVERIFIED",
+      "original_row": {
+        "vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe",
+        "active": 1,
+        "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN",
+        "candidates": [
+          {
+            "table": "catchii_catalog",
+            "cost_columns": [
+              {
+                "col": "price_retail",
+                "populated": 670
+              }
+            ],
+            "best_join": {
+              "key": null,
+              "matched": 0
+            },
+            "join_pct": 0
+          }
+        ],
+        "join_pct": 0,
+        "reachable": 0
+      }
+    }
+  ],
+  "next_dependency": "Obtain vendor/table identity and actual read-only join evidence, including errors, priced-row scope, uniqueness and cross-vendor collisions; any repair remains gated.",
+  "implementation_changes": "None to source, costs, joins, coverage or production."
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-4/review.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-4/review.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ba5fc89f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-4/review.md
@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
+# TK-11859 offline candidate review
+
+Source snapshot: 2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z
+SHA-256: `fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a`
+
+Retained totals: 18 vendors / 6,243 active products / 0 reported reachable.
+Three associations affecting 4,371 products need table identity evidence. Remaining 15 vendors / 1,872 products also remain unverified.
+
+| Vendor | Active | Reported reachable | Review status | Candidate tables |
+|---|---:|---:|---|---|
+| Phillip Jeffries | 3392 | 0 | UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY | phillipe_romano_catalog |
+| Designer Wallcoverings | 978 | 0 | UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY | designers_guild_catalog |
+| Morris & Co. | 686 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | morris_feed_pricing |
+| Fentucci Naturals | 504 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | fentucci_catalog |
+| Glitter Walls | 405 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | glitter_catalog |
+| Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper | 140 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | roberto_cavalli_catalog |
+| Daisy Bennett | 58 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | daisy_bennett_v2_stage, daisy_bennett_v2_catalog, daisy_bennett_catalog |
+| Glass Beaded | 29 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | glass_bead_products |
+| Dolce & Gabbana | 26 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | dolce_gabbana_catalog |
+| Contrado | 15 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | contrado_catalog, contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453 |
+| Clarke and Clarke | 3 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | clarke_clarke_catalog |
+| Studio Ditte | 1 | 0 | UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY | studio_printworks_catalog |
+| Farrow & Ball | 1 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | farrow_ball_catalog, farrow_ball_paints |
+| Morris and Company | 1 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | morris_feed_pricing |
+| Roberto Cavalli | 1 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | roberto_cavalli_catalog |
+| Rebel Studio | 1 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | rebel_walls_catalog, rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084, rebelwalls_catalog |
+| Scalamandre Fabrics | 1 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | scalamandre_catalog, scalamandre_pillows, scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726 |
+| Catchii Netherlands Europe | 1 | 0 | UNVERIFIED | catchii_catalog |
+
+Attempted catalog → product keys: `dw_sku → sku`, `dw_sku → dw_sku`, `mfr_sku → mfr_sku`, `mfr_sku → sku`, `shopify_id → shopify_id`, `sku → sku`
+
+- Candidate tables combine registry declarations and name heuristics; the retained report does not record which origin selected a table.
+- The generator tries only the six catalog-to-product key pairs listed here; it does not exhaust possible identity mappings.
+- The generator catches SQL errors and continues without retaining error details; zero reachability does not prove successful zero-result queries.
+- Join reachability counts distinct product SKUs without requiring a populated positive candidate cost value on the joined row. Column population is measured independently.
+- Cross-name table associations require identity evidence. They are not proven false matches; the remaining candidates are also unverified.
+- This snapshot proves neither absent cost nor broken joins, cost semantics, current coverage, or a safe repair. No new database or external verification was performed.
+
+Obtain vendor/table identity and actual read-only join evidence, including errors, priced-row scope, uniqueness and cross-vendor collisions; any repair remains gated.
+
+Preparation only; the source ticket remains unresolved.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-5/input.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-5/input.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b76228d6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-5/input.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"summary": {"generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z", "ticket": "TK-11427", "active_products_total": 91167, "vendors_with_active": 170, "covered_vendors": 32, "buckets": [{"state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 26, "active_products": 12852, "reachable_products": 10704}, {"state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 13, "active_products": 24623, "reachable_products": 4389}, {"state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "vendors": 18, "active_products": 6243, "reachable_products": 0}, {"state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "vendors": 81, "active_products": 10735, "reachable_products": 0}]}, "report": [{"vendor": "Phillipe Romano", "active": 13066, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1082}, "join_pct": 8.3}], "join_pct": 8.3, "reachable": 1082}, {"vendor": "Carnegie", "active": 4147, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Malibu Wallpaper", "active": 3822, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1637}, "join_pct": 42.8}], "join_pct": 42.8, "reachable": 1637}, {"vendor": "Clarke And Clarke", "active": 3567, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings", "active": 3561, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2039}, "join_pct": 57.3}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 57.3, "reachable": 2039}, {"vendor": "Phillip Jeffries", "active": 3392, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Walls", "active": 3373, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1199}, "join_pct": 35.5}, {"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1172}, "join_pct": 34.7}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1014}, "join_pct": 30.1}], "join_pct": 35.5, "reachable": 1199}, {"vendor": "Thibaut", "active": 3101, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Brunschwig & Fils", "active": 2737, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens", "active": 2654, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4991}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 1}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2652}, "join_pct": 99.9}], "join_pct": 99.9, "reachable": 2652}, {"vendor": "Kravet", "active": 2601, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Koroseal", "active": 2449, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Gaston Y Daniela", "active": 2148, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Lee Jofa", "active": 2026, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Los Angeles Fabrics", "active": 1821, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "China Seas", "active": 1776, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Maharam", "active": 1429, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Coordonn\u00e9", "active": 1428, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "coordonne_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3676}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 136}, "join_pct": 9.5}], "join_pct": 9.5, "reachable": 136}, {"vendor": "Harlequin", "active": 1257, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Cole & Son", "active": 1238, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Sanderson", "active": 1221, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "GP & J Baker", "active": 1191, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Mind the Gap", "active": 1019, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "mindthegap_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1040}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 2}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 830}, "join_pct": 81.5}], "join_pct": 81.5, "reachable": 830}, {"vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings", "active": 978, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Wallpaper", "active": 942, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0.1}], "join_pct": 1.5, "reachable": 14}, {"vendor": "DW Bespoke Studio", "active": 925, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zoffany", "active": 902, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Anna French", "active": 790, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "anna_french_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 731}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 469}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 651}, "join_pct": 82.4}], "join_pct": 82.4, "reachable": 651}, {"vendor": "Sandberg", "active": 743, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sandberg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 948}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}, {"table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 945}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}], "join_pct": 75, "reachable": 557}, {"vendor": "Pierre Frey", "active": 722, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designtex", "active": 703, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wolf Gordon", "active": 688, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Morris & Co.", "active": 686, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PS Removable Wallpaper", "active": 681, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Surface Stick", "active": 639, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Knoll", "active": 622, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "knoll_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806", "cost_columns": [{"col": "orig_cost_price", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 622}, {"vendor": "Maya Romanoff", "active": 617, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Osborne & Little", "active": 602, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Tres Tintas", "active": 601, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "tres_tintas_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1556}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 601}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 601}, {"vendor": "Romo", "active": 585, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Elitis", "active": 579, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designers Guild", "active": 568, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 145}, "join_pct": 25.5}], "join_pct": 25.5, "reachable": 145}, {"vendor": "William Morris", "active": 522, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fentucci", "active": 514, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.2}], "join_pct": 1.2, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Fentucci Naturals", "active": 504, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Arte International", "active": 489, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings", "active": 456, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "w1838_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 404}, {"col": "maxwell_price", "populated": 332}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 332}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 332}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 451}, "join_pct": 98.9}], "join_pct": 98.9, "reachable": 451}, {"vendor": "Versace", "active": 454, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "versace_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 158}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 157}, "join_pct": 34.6}], "join_pct": 34.6, "reachable": 157}, {"vendor": "Quadrille", "active": 454, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Alan Campbell", "active": 434, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Nina Campbell", "active": 433, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "nina_campbell_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 275}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 3}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}, {"table": "nina_campbell_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172723", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 238}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}], "join_pct": 1.4, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre", "active": 418, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 418}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 418}, {"vendor": "Graham & Brown", "active": 405, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "graham_brown_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 2020}, {"col": "dw_retail_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 312}, {"col": "vendor_retail_price", "populated": 132}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 403}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "graham_brown_murals", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 36}, {"col": "price_per_sqft", "populated": 36}, {"col": "member_price_per_sqm", "populated": 36}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 99.5, "reachable": 403}, {"vendor": "Glitter Walls", "active": 405, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glitter_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 121}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "British Walls", "active": 351, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "CMO Paris", "active": 344, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "AS Creation", "active": 327, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mulberry", "active": 317, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fabricut", "active": 276, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fabricut_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "vendor_msrp", "populated": 1263}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1263}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 274}, "join_pct": 99.3}], "join_pct": 99.3, "reachable": 274}, {"vendor": "Suncloth", "active": 254, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Newwall", "active": 251, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newwall_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8713}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 6276}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 251}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 251}, {"vendor": "Groundworks", "active": 237, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Home Couture", "active": 229, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Innovations USA", "active": 202, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "innovations_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_source", "populated": 221}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 220}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 182}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku", "matched": 160}, "join_pct": 79.2}], "join_pct": 79.2, "reachable": 160}, {"vendor": "Plains", "active": 181, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Stout Textiles", "active": 180, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "stout_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 180}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 180}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 180}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 180}, {"vendor": "De Gournay", "active": 172, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ronald Redding", "active": 167, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Novasuede", "active": 166, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Majilite", "active": 160, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Brand McKenzie", "active": 155, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 37}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 118}, "join_pct": 76.1}, {"table": "brand_mckenzie_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 110}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 76.1, "reachable": 118}, {"vendor": "Artmura", "active": 144, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ralph Lauren", "active": 140, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper", "active": 140, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Donghia", "active": 125, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "donghia_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 167}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 124}, "join_pct": 99.2}], "join_pct": 99.2, "reachable": 124}, {"vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings", "active": 116, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newmor_sku_reconcile", "cost_columns": [{"col": "live_price", "populated": 542}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 116}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 116}, {"vendor": "Marburg", "active": 112, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "marburg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 2559}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 96}, "join_pct": 85.7}], "join_pct": 85.7, "reachable": 96}, {"vendor": "Ultrasuede", "active": 109, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Laura Ashley Wallpaper", "active": 107, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mid Century Modern", "active": 106, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hospitality Wallcoverings", "active": 98, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PR Faux Leather", "active": 97, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "LA Walls", "active": 94, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Charles Burger", "active": 79, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Christian Lacroix Europe", "active": 77, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Nobilis", "active": 74, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Primo Leathers", "active": 72, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sister Parish", "active": 71, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Threads", "active": 71, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "LEED Walls", "active": 68, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Pixels", "active": 59, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glambeads by DW", "active": 58, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Daisy Bennett", "active": 58, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_cost", "populated": 64}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 52}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 63}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Luxury Murals", "active": 56, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "MC Escher Wallpaper", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steve Abrams Studios", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Missoni Wallpaper", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Madagascar Walls", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Anthology", "active": 48, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Retro Walls", "active": 48, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Lincrusta", "active": 47, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "lincrusta_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 47}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 45}, "join_pct": 95.7}], "join_pct": 95.7, "reachable": 45}, {"vendor": "FallingStar Studio", "active": 42, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sancar", "active": 42, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sancar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3418}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 42}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 42}, {"vendor": "Cloth and Paper", "active": 41, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "quadrille_house_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost_price", "populated": 1928}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 40}, "join_pct": 97.6}], "join_pct": 97.6, "reachable": 40}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection", "active": 40, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Apartment Wallpaper", "active": 38, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Home", "active": 37, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Marimekko Exclusive", "active": 35, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection UK", "active": 29, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glass Beaded", "active": 29, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glass_bead_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 717}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Franquemont London", "active": 26, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "franquemont_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "roll_price", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 26}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 26}, {"vendor": "Natural Paint", "active": 26, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana", "active": 26, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 15}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Phyllis Morris", "active": 24, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius Europe", "active": 21, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Contrado", "active": 15, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "contrado_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 11}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hand Crafted", "active": 15, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Traditional Whimsy", "active": 13, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Acoustical", "active": 13, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 4}, "join_pct": 30.8}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 30.8, "reachable": 4}, {"vendor": "Witch & Watchman", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "SUGARBOO", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Backdrop", "active": 9, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Innovations", "active": 8, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wallpaper NYC", "active": 6, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius at DW", "active": 5, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Andrew Martin", "active": 5, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "andrew_martin_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 185}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 3}, "join_pct": 60}], "join_pct": 60, "reachable": 3}, {"vendor": "Architectural Wallcoverings", "active": 4, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Baker Lifestyle", "active": 4, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "baker_lifestyle_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 74}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 74}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 25}], "join_pct": 25, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Black Edition", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Malibu", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Malibu Walls", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Holland and Sherry", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Peg Norriss", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sacha Walckhoff", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Clarke and Clarke", "active": 3, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "clarke_clarke_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 578}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Caroline Cecil Textiles", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Villa Nova", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zinc Textile", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Patty Madden", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Design", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_map_authoritative", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "map_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 4522}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Atomic 50 Ceilings", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kirkby Design", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Couture", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_master_price", "cost_columns": [{"col": "map_price", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4685}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Winfield Thybony", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scion", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Linherr Hollingsworth", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Exclusive Wallpaper", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steven Abrams Photography", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DWHD", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Studio Ditte", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "studio_printworks_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_sample", "populated": 383}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 383}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Emiliana Parati", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Farrow & Ball", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "farrow_ball_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_gbp", "populated": 545}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "farrow_ball_paints", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_usd", "populated": 301}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "G P & J Baker", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Happy Menocal", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Architectural Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Morris and Company", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Milton & King", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "A.S. Cr\u00e9ation", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mark Alexander", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dedar", "active": 1, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "dedar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 46}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Studio", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ananbo", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dupenny", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebecca Moses", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sara Bergqvist", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sarah Bartholomew", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Celerie Kemble", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "catchii_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 670}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-6/input.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-6/input.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b518aa15
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/join-test-6/input.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"summary": {"generated_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z", "ticket": "TK-11427", "active_products_total": 91167, "vendors_with_active": 170, "covered_vendors": 32, "buckets": [{"state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 26, "active_products": 12852, "reachable_products": 10704}, {"state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "vendors": 13, "active_products": 24623, "reachable_products": 4389}, {"state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "vendors": 18, "active_products": 6244, "reachable_products": 0}, {"state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "vendors": 81, "active_products": 10735, "reachable_products": 0}]}, "report": [{"vendor": "Phillipe Romano", "active": 13066, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1082}, "join_pct": 8.3}], "join_pct": 8.3, "reachable": 1082}, {"vendor": "Carnegie", "active": 4147, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Malibu Wallpaper", "active": 3822, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1637}, "join_pct": 42.8}], "join_pct": 42.8, "reachable": 1637}, {"vendor": "Clarke And Clarke", "active": 3567, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Wallcoverings", "active": 3561, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2039}, "join_pct": 57.3}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 57.3, "reachable": 2039}, {"vendor": "Phillip Jeffries", "active": 3392, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "phillipe_romano_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 474}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Walls", "active": 3373, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1199}, "join_pct": 35.5}, {"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1172}, "join_pct": 34.7}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1014}, "join_pct": 30.1}], "join_pct": 35.5, "reachable": 1199}, {"vendor": "Thibaut", "active": 3101, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Brunschwig & Fils", "active": 2737, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Jeffrey Stevens", "active": 2654, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "jeffrey_stevens_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4991}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 1}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2652}, "join_pct": 99.9}], "join_pct": 99.9, "reachable": 2652}, {"vendor": "Kravet", "active": 2601, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Koroseal", "active": 2449, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Gaston Y Daniela", "active": 2148, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Lee Jofa", "active": 2026, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Los Angeles Fabrics", "active": 1821, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "China Seas", "active": 1776, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Maharam", "active": 1429, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Coordonn\u00e9", "active": 1428, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "coordonne_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3676}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 136}, "join_pct": 9.5}], "join_pct": 9.5, "reachable": 136}, {"vendor": "Harlequin", "active": 1257, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Cole & Son", "active": 1238, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Sanderson", "active": 1221, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "GP & J Baker", "active": 1191, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Mind the Gap", "active": 1019, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "mindthegap_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1040}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 2}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 830}, "join_pct": 81.5}], "join_pct": 81.5, "reachable": 830}, {"vendor": "Designer Wallcoverings", "active": 978, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Wallpaper", "active": 942, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 14}, "join_pct": 1.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 0.1}], "join_pct": 1.5, "reachable": 14}, {"vendor": "DW Bespoke Studio", "active": 925, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zoffany", "active": 902, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Anna French", "active": 790, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "anna_french_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 731}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 469}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 651}, "join_pct": 82.4}], "join_pct": 82.4, "reachable": 651}, {"vendor": "Sandberg", "active": 743, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sandberg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 948}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}, {"table": "sandberg_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172725", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 945}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 557}, "join_pct": 75}], "join_pct": 75, "reachable": 557}, {"vendor": "Pierre Frey", "active": 722, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designtex", "active": 703, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wolf Gordon", "active": 688, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Morris & Co.", "active": 686, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PS Removable Wallpaper", "active": 681, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Surface Stick", "active": 639, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Knoll", "active": 622, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "knoll_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "knoll_price_backup_20260806", "cost_columns": [{"col": "orig_cost_price", "populated": 622}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 622}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 622}, {"vendor": "Maya Romanoff", "active": 617, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Osborne & Little", "active": 602, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Tres Tintas", "active": 601, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "tres_tintas_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1556}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 601}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 601}, {"vendor": "Romo", "active": 585, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Elitis", "active": 579, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Designers Guild", "active": 568, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "designers_guild_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 23}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 145}, "join_pct": 25.5}], "join_pct": 25.5, "reachable": 145}, {"vendor": "William Morris", "active": 522, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fentucci", "active": 514, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.2}], "join_pct": 1.2, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Fentucci Naturals", "active": 504, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "fentucci_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 85}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 84}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Arte International", "active": 489, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "1838 Wallcoverings", "active": 456, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "w1838_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 404}, {"col": "maxwell_price", "populated": 332}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 332}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 332}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 451}, "join_pct": 98.9}], "join_pct": 98.9, "reachable": 451}, {"vendor": "Versace", "active": 454, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "versace_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 158}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 157}, "join_pct": 34.6}], "join_pct": 34.6, "reachable": 157}, {"vendor": "Quadrille", "active": 454, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Alan Campbell", "active": 434, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Nina Campbell", "active": 433, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "nina_campbell_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 275}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 3}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}, {"table": "nina_campbell_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172723", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 238}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 6}, "join_pct": 1.4}], "join_pct": 1.4, "reachable": 6}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre", "active": 418, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 418}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 416}, "join_pct": 99.5}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 418}, {"vendor": "Graham & Brown", "active": 405, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "graham_brown_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 2020}, {"col": "dw_retail_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 809}, {"col": "master_cost", "populated": 312}, {"col": "vendor_retail_price", "populated": 132}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 403}, "join_pct": 99.5}, {"table": "graham_brown_murals", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 36}, {"col": "price_per_sqft", "populated": 36}, {"col": "member_price_per_sqm", "populated": 36}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 99.5, "reachable": 403}, {"vendor": "Glitter Walls", "active": 405, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glitter_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 121}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "British Walls", "active": 351, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "CMO Paris", "active": 344, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "AS Creation", "active": 327, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mulberry", "active": 317, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Fabricut", "active": 276, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "fabricut_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "vendor_msrp", "populated": 1263}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1263}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 274}, "join_pct": 99.3}], "join_pct": 99.3, "reachable": 274}, {"vendor": "Suncloth", "active": 254, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Newwall", "active": 251, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newwall_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8713}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 6276}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 251}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 251}, {"vendor": "Groundworks", "active": 237, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Home Couture", "active": 229, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Innovations USA", "active": 202, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "innovations_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_source", "populated": 221}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 220}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 182}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.dw_sku", "matched": 160}, "join_pct": 79.2}], "join_pct": 79.2, "reachable": 160}, {"vendor": "Plains", "active": 181, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Stout Textiles", "active": 180, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "stout_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 180}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 180}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 180}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 180}, {"vendor": "De Gournay", "active": 172, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ronald Redding", "active": 167, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Novasuede", "active": 166, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Majilite", "active": 160, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Brand McKenzie", "active": 155, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "brand_mckenzie_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 37}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 118}, "join_pct": 76.1}, {"table": "brand_mckenzie_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 110}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 76.1, "reachable": 118}, {"vendor": "Artmura", "active": 144, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ralph Lauren", "active": 140, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli Wallpaper", "active": 140, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Donghia", "active": 125, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "donghia_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 167}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 167}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 124}, "join_pct": 99.2}], "join_pct": 99.2, "reachable": 124}, {"vendor": "Newmor Wallcoverings", "active": 116, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "newmor_sku_reconcile", "cost_columns": [{"col": "live_price", "populated": 542}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 116}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 116}, {"vendor": "Marburg", "active": 112, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "marburg_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 2559}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 96}, "join_pct": 85.7}], "join_pct": 85.7, "reachable": 96}, {"vendor": "Ultrasuede", "active": 109, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Laura Ashley Wallpaper", "active": 107, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mid Century Modern", "active": 106, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hospitality Wallcoverings", "active": 98, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "PR Faux Leather", "active": 97, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "LA Walls", "active": 94, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Charles Burger", "active": 79, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Christian Lacroix Europe", "active": 77, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Nobilis", "active": 74, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Primo Leathers", "active": 72, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sister Parish", "active": 71, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Threads", "active": 71, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "LEED Walls", "active": 68, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Pixels", "active": 59, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glambeads by DW", "active": 58, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Daisy Bennett", "active": 58, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_stage", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_cost", "populated": 64}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_v2_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost", "populated": 52}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "daisy_bennett_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 63}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Luxury Murals", "active": 56, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "MC Escher Wallpaper", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steve Abrams Studios", "active": 50, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Missoni Wallpaper", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Madagascar Walls", "active": 49, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Anthology", "active": 48, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Retro Walls", "active": 48, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Lincrusta", "active": 47, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "lincrusta_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 47}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 45}, "join_pct": 95.7}], "join_pct": 95.7, "reachable": 45}, {"vendor": "FallingStar Studio", "active": 42, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sancar", "active": 42, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "sancar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3418}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 42}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 42}, {"vendor": "Cloth and Paper", "active": 41, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "quadrille_house_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "cost_price", "populated": 1928}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 40}, "join_pct": 97.6}], "join_pct": 97.6, "reachable": 40}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection", "active": 40, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Apartment Wallpaper", "active": 38, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Home", "active": 37, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Marimekko Exclusive", "active": 35, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Graduate Collection UK", "active": 29, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Glass Beaded", "active": 29, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "glass_bead_products", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 717}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Franquemont London", "active": 26, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "franquemont_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "roll_price", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 26}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 26}, {"vendor": "Natural Paint", "active": 26, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dolce & Gabbana", "active": 26, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "dolce_gabbana_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 15}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Phyllis Morris", "active": 24, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius Europe", "active": 21, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Contrado", "active": 15, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "contrado_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 11}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "contrado_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172453", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 8}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hand Crafted", "active": 15, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Traditional Whimsy", "active": 13, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Hollywood Acoustical", "active": 13, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "hollywood_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 5893}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 4}, "join_pct": 30.8}, {"table": "hollywood_price_audit_log", "cost_columns": [{"col": "new_price", "populated": 102}, {"col": "old_price", "populated": 98}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 30.8, "reachable": 4}, {"vendor": "Witch & Watchman", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "SUGARBOO", "active": 10, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Backdrop", "active": 9, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Innovations", "active": 8, "state": "COVERED"}, {"vendor": "Wallpaper NYC", "active": 6, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zeuxis Parrhasius at DW", "active": 5, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Andrew Martin", "active": 5, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "andrew_martin_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 185}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 3}, "join_pct": 60}], "join_pct": 60, "reachable": 3}, {"vendor": "Architectural Wallcoverings", "active": 4, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Baker Lifestyle", "active": 4, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "baker_lifestyle_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 74}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 74}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 25}], "join_pct": 25, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Black Edition", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Malibu", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Malibu Walls", "active": 3, "state": "PARTIAL_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "malibu_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 3551}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 33.3}], "join_pct": 33.3, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Holland and Sherry", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Peg Norriss", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sacha Walckhoff", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Clarke and Clarke", "active": 3, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "clarke_clarke_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 578}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Caroline Cecil Textiles", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Villa Nova", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Zinc Textile", "active": 3, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Patty Madden", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Design", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_map_authoritative", "cost_columns": [{"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "map_price", "populated": 4522}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 4522}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Atomic 50 Ceilings", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kirkby Design", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Kravet Couture", "active": 2, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "kravet_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 9494}, {"col": "cost_price", "populated": 8592}, {"col": "price_effective_date", "populated": 8221}, {"col": "price_retail_new", "populated": 8191}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_dwkk_variant_map", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price", "populated": 14030}, {"col": "cost", "populated": 26}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.dw_sku=sp.sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}, {"table": "kravet_master_price", "cost_columns": [{"col": "map_price", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "whls_cost", "populated": 13726}, {"col": "retail_price", "populated": 4685}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 2}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 2}, {"vendor": "Winfield Thybony", "active": 2, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scion", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Linherr Hollingsworth", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DW Exclusive Wallpaper", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Steven Abrams Photography", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "DWHD", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Studio Ditte", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "studio_printworks_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_sample", "populated": 383}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 383}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Emiliana Parati", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Farrow & Ball", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "farrow_ball_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_gbp", "populated": 545}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "farrow_ball_paints", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_usd", "populated": 301}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "G P & J Baker", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Happy Menocal", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Architectural Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Morris and Company", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "morris_feed_pricing", "cost_columns": [{"col": "trade_usd", "populated": 1162}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Milton & King", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "A.S. Cr\u00e9ation", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Mark Alexander", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dedar", "active": 1, "state": "STRONG_CANDIDATE", "candidates": [{"table": "dedar_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 46}], "best_join": {"key": "ct.mfr_sku=sp.mfr_sku", "matched": 1}, "join_pct": 100}], "join_pct": 100, "reachable": 1}, {"vendor": "Roberto Cavalli", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "roberto_cavalli_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 82}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebel Studio", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "rebel_walls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4123}, {"col": "price_trade", "populated": 449}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog_premerge_tk10084", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "rebelwalls_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 4382}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_nonwoven", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_peelstick", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_retail", "populated": 4133}, {"col": "price_per_sqft_commercial", "populated": 3958}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Ananbo", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Dupenny", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Rebecca Moses", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sara Bergqvist", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Sarah Bartholomew", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Celerie Kemble", "active": 1, "state": "NO_COST_TABLE", "candidates": [], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Scalamandre Fabrics", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "scalamandre_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 5002}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_pillows", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 1512}, {"col": "price_retail", "populated": 1512}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}, {"table": "scalamandre_catalog_prebackfill_bak_20260901172726", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_trade", "populated": 4996}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}, {"vendor": "Catchii Netherlands Europe", "active": 1, "state": "COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN", "candidates": [{"table": "catchii_catalog", "cost_columns": [{"col": "price_retail", "populated": 670}], "best_join": {"key": null, "matched": 0}, "join_pct": 0}], "join_pct": 0, "reachable": 0}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/prestige-rollback/server.js b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/prestige-rollback/server.js
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..2e8a2863
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/prestige-rollback/server.js
@@ -0,0 +1,910 @@
+'use strict';
+/**
+ * Prestige Car Wash (PCW) — one Express app serving:
+ *   - the public marketing site (/, /services, /contact)
+ *   - the Basic-Auth growth admin (/admin) + its bucket APIs (/api/admin/*)
+ *
+ * Data source: data/*.json snapshots (Postgres is an optional future upgrade; the
+ * schema in scripts/db-init.sql mirrors these files). Everything the front-end needs
+ * comes through /api/* so the same catalog powers both the public page and the admin.
+ */
+require('dotenv').config();
+const fs = require('fs');
+const path = require('path');
+const express = require('express');
+const helmet = require('helmet');
+
+const app = express();
+const PORT = process.env.PORT || 9808;
+const ADMIN_USER = process.env.ADMIN_USER || 'admin';
+const ADMIN_PASS = process.env.ADMIN_PASS || 'DW2024!';
+const DATA = path.join(__dirname, 'data');
+
+// ---- helpers ---------------------------------------------------------------
+const readJSON = (f, fallback) => {
+  try { return JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(path.join(DATA, f), 'utf8')); }
+  catch { return fallback; }
+};
+// Re-read on each request so admin edits / script runs show up without a restart.
+const services     = () => readJSON('services.json', []);
+const competitors  = () => readJSON('competitors.json', []);
+const suggestions  = () => readJSON('suggestions.json', []);
+const holidays     = () => readJSON('holidays.json', []);
+const directories  = () => readJSON('directories.json', []);
+const ads          = () => readJSON('ads.json', []);
+const bestTimes    = () => readJSON('best-times.json', {});
+const places       = () => readJSON('places.json', {});
+const socialTpl    = () => readJSON('social-templates.json', { platforms: [], hashtag_sets: {}, templates: [] });
+const promos       = () => readJSON('promos.json', { promos: [] });
+
+// Mask a secret to a "present (…last4)" descriptor — never returns the value.
+const maskEnv = (key) => {
+  const v = process.env[key];
+  if (!v) return { key, present: false, hint: '' };
+  return { key, present: true, hint: '…' + String(v).slice(-4) };
+};
+
+// ---- middleware ------------------------------------------------------------
+app.use(helmet({
+  contentSecurityPolicy: {
+    directives: {
+      defaultSrc: ["'self'"],
+      scriptSrc: ["'self'", "'unsafe-inline'"],
+      // inline event-handler attributes (onclick=, onerror=) are a separate directive;
+      // Helmet defaults it to 'none'. The site/admin use inline handlers (house style,
+      // Basic-Auth admin, no user-generated content) so allow them explicitly.
+      scriptSrcAttr: ["'unsafe-inline'"],
+      styleSrc: ["'self'", "'unsafe-inline'", 'https://fonts.googleapis.com'],
+      fontSrc: ["'self'", 'https://fonts.gstatic.com', 'data:'],
+      imgSrc: ["'self'", 'data:', 'https:'],
+      mediaSrc: ["'self'", 'data:', 'blob:'],
+      connectSrc: ["'self'"]
+    }
+  }
+}));
+app.use(express.json());
+
+// Basic Auth gate for /admin and /api/admin/*
+function requireAdmin(req, res, next) {
+  const hdr = req.headers.authorization || '';
+  const [scheme, encoded] = hdr.split(' ');
+  if (scheme === 'Basic' && encoded) {
+    const [u, p] = Buffer.from(encoded, 'base64').toString().split(':');
+    if (u === ADMIN_USER && p === ADMIN_PASS) return next();
+  }
+  res.set('WWW-Authenticate', 'Basic realm="Prestige Admin"').status(401).send('Auth required');
+}
+app.use('/admin', requireAdmin);
+app.use('/api/admin', requireAdmin);
+
+// ---- sort (shared by public services grid) --------------------------------
+function sortServices(list, mode) {
+  const arr = [...list];
+  const byTitle = (a, b) => String(a.name).localeCompare(String(b.name));
+  switch (mode) {
+    case 'title':      return arr.sort(byTitle);
+    case 'price-asc':  return arr.sort((a, b) => (a.price || 0) - (b.price || 0) || byTitle(a, b));
+    case 'price-desc': return arr.sort((a, b) => (b.price || 0) - (a.price || 0) || byTitle(a, b));
+    case 'duration':   return arr.sort((a, b) => (a.duration_min || 0) - (b.duration_min || 0) || byTitle(a, b));
+    case 'featured':
+    default:           return arr.sort((a, b) => ((b.featured ? 1 : 0) - (a.featured ? 1 : 0)) || (a.sort_order || 99) - (b.sort_order || 99));
+  }
+}
+
+// Price bands for the left filter panel.
+const priceBand = (p) => p <= 25 ? 'Under $25' : p <= 60 ? '$25–$60' : p <= 150 ? '$60–$150' : '$150+';
+
+// ---- public API ------------------------------------------------------------
+app.get('/api/health', (req, res) => {
+  res.json({
+    ok: true, service: 'prestige-car-wash', port: PORT,
+    counts: {
+      services: services().length, competitors: competitors().length,
+      suggestions: suggestions().length, holidays: holidays().length,
+      directories: directories().length, ads: ads().length,
+      promos: (promos().promos || []).length
+    },
+    ts: new Date().toISOString()
+  });
+});
+
+app.get('/api/services', (req, res) => {
+  let list = services().map(s => ({ ...s, price_band: priceBand(s.price || 0) }));
+  const { category, band, q } = req.query;
+  if (category) list = list.filter(s => s.category === category);
+  if (band) list = list.filter(s => s.price_band === band);
+  if (q) {
+    const needle = String(q).toLowerCase();
+    list = list.filter(s => [s.name, s.blurb, s.category].join(' ').toLowerCase().includes(needle));
+  }
+  res.json(sortServices(list, req.query.sort));
+});
+
+// Facet counts for the left panel — each dimension counted over the OTHER active filters.
+app.get('/api/facets', (req, res) => {
+  const base = services().map(s => ({ ...s, price_band: priceBand(s.price || 0) }));
+  const tally = (rows, key) => rows.reduce((m, r) => (m[r[key]] = (m[r[key]] || 0) + 1, m), {});
+  const applyExcept = (except) => base.filter(s =>
+    (except === 'category' || !req.query.category || s.category === req.query.category) &&
+    (except === 'band' || !req.query.band || s.price_band === req.query.band)
+  );
+  res.json({
+    category: tally(applyExcept('category'), 'category'),
+    band: tally(applyExcept('band'), 'price_band')
+  });
+});
+
+app.get('/api/best-times', (req, res) => res.json(bestTimes()));
+// Emit ready-to-use photo/video URLs so the client is format-agnostic:
+// Google photo refs → the proxy route; local paths (real business photos) → direct.
+app.get('/api/places', (req, res) => {
+  const p = places();
+  const photo_urls = (p.photos || []).map((ph, i) =>
+    /^places\//.test(ph) ? `/api/places/photo/${i}` : '/' + String(ph).replace(/^\//, ''));
+  const videos = (p.videos || []).map(v => ({
+    ...v,
+    src: '/' + String(v.src || '').replace(/^\//, ''),
+    poster: v.poster ? '/' + String(v.poster).replace(/^\//, '') : ''
+  }));
+  res.json({ ...p, photo_urls, videos });
+});
+
+// ---- admin bucket APIs -----------------------------------------------------
+app.get('/api/admin/competitors', (req, res) => res.json(competitors()));
+app.get('/api/admin/suggestions', (req, res) => res.json(suggestions()));
+app.get('/api/admin/holidays', (req, res) => res.json(holidays()));
+app.get('/api/admin/directories', (req, res) => res.json(directories()));
+app.get('/api/admin/ads', (req, res) => res.json(ads()));
+app.get('/api/admin/services', (req, res) => res.json(services()));
+app.get('/api/admin/best-times', (req, res) => res.json(bestTimes()));
+app.get('/api/admin/places', (req, res) => res.json(places()));
+
+// ---- Socials: create + post from ONE place (draft-only; never auto-posts) --
+// Media library: every image/video under /media (incl. media/real/), each video
+// paired with its poster image (svc-<stem>.png or <stem>-poster.jpg) so the
+// composer can preview + attach any asset. Read-only scan of the media dir.
+const MEDIA_DIR = path.join(__dirname, 'media');
+function mediaLibrary() {
+  const walk = (dir, prefix) => {
+    let out = [];
+    let entries; try { entries = fs.readdirSync(dir, { withFileTypes: true }); } catch { return out; }
+    for (const e of entries) {
+      if (e.isDirectory()) { out = out.concat(walk(path.join(dir, e.name), prefix + e.name + '/')); continue; }
+      const ext = path.extname(e.name).toLowerCase();
+      const kind = ['.mp4', '.mov', '.webm'].includes(ext) ? 'video'
+        : ['.png', '.jpg', '.jpeg', '.webp', '.gif'].includes(ext) ? 'image' : null;
+      if (!kind) continue;
+      out.push({ name: e.name, stem: e.name.replace(/\.[^.]+$/, ''), kind, url: '/media/' + prefix + e.name });
+    }
+    return out;
+  };
+  const all = walk(MEDIA_DIR, '');
+  const imgByStem = {};
+  all.filter(m => m.kind === 'image').forEach(m => { imgByStem[m.stem] = m.url; });
+  all.forEach(m => { if (m.kind === 'video') m.poster = imgByStem[m.stem] || imgByStem[m.stem + '-poster'] || ''; });
+  // Hide poster stills that only exist to back a video (keep genuine standalone photos).
+  const videoStems = new Set(all.filter(m => m.kind === 'video').map(m => m.stem));
+  return all
+    .filter(m => !(m.kind === 'image' && (videoStems.has(m.stem) || videoStems.has(m.stem.replace(/-poster$/, '')))))
+    .sort((a, b) => a.name.localeCompare(b.name));
+}
+app.get('/api/admin/media', (req, res) => res.json(mediaLibrary()));
+app.get('/api/admin/social/templates', (req, res) => res.json(socialTpl()));
+
+// ---- Promos: HyperFrames-generated brand films -----------------------------
+// Curated, first-class list of the finished brand videos (distinct from the raw
+// svc-* service clips in the media library). Repo-relative src/poster are
+// normalized to absolute /media URLs so the client stays format-agnostic; any
+// promo whose file is missing on disk is flagged (ready=false) rather than
+// served as a broken <video>. mm:ss is precomputed for the card badge.
+const abs = (p) => '/' + String(p || '').replace(/^\//, '');
+const mmss = (s) => { const sec=Math.max(0,parseInt(s,10)||0); return `${Math.floor(sec/60)}:${String(sec%60).padStart(2,'0')}`; };
+app.get('/api/admin/promos', (req, res) => {
+  const list = (promos().promos || []).map(p => {
+    const rel = String(p.src || '').replace(/^\//, '');
+    const ready = rel ? fs.existsSync(path.join(__dirname, rel)) : false;
+    return {
+      ...p,
+      src: abs(p.src),
+      poster: p.poster ? abs(p.poster) : '',
+      duration_label: p.duration_sec ? mmss(p.duration_sec) : '',
+      ready
+    };
+  });
+  res.json(list);
+});
+
+// Save a composed post as a DRAFT (append-only). This NEVER posts to any network —
+// the front-end deep-links into each platform's native composer for the human to post.
+app.post('/api/admin/social/draft', (req, res) => {
+  const b = req.body || {};
+  const draft = {
+    id: 'sd-' + Date.now().toString(36),
+    caption: cap(b.caption, 2200),
+    platforms: Array.isArray(b.platforms) ? b.platforms.slice(0, 12).map(p => cap(p, 40)) : [],
+    asset: b.asset ? { url: cap(b.asset.url, 300), kind: cap(b.asset.kind, 12), name: cap(b.asset.name, 160) } : null,
+    scheduled_for: cap(b.scheduled_for, 40),
+    created_at: new Date().toISOString(), status: 'draft'
+  };
+  if (!draft.caption && !draft.asset) return res.status(400).json({ ok: false, error: 'need a caption or an asset' });
+  try {
+    const dir = path.join(__dirname, 'reports');
+    fs.mkdirSync(dir, { recursive: true });
+    fs.appendFileSync(path.join(dir, 'social-drafts.jsonl'), JSON.stringify(draft) + '\n');
+  } catch { return res.status(500).json({ ok: false, error: 'could not save draft' }); }
+  res.json({ ok: true, draft });
+});
+app.get('/api/admin/social/drafts', (req, res) => {
+  try {
+    const raw = fs.readFileSync(path.join(__dirname, 'reports', 'social-drafts.jsonl'), 'utf8').trim();
+    res.json(raw ? raw.split('\n').map(l => JSON.parse(l)).reverse() : []);
+  } catch { res.json([]); }
+});
+
+// Credentials tab — presence + last-4 only. NEVER returns secret values.
+app.get('/api/admin/credentials', (req, res) => {
+  const keys = [
+    { key: 'GEMINI_API_KEY', label: 'Nano Banana (Gemini image)', purpose: 'Generate service stills' },
+    { key: 'REPLICATE_API_TOKEN', label: 'SeeDance (Replicate)', purpose: 'Generate wash/wax video clips' },
+    { key: 'GOOGLE_PLACES_API_KEY', label: 'Google Places (read)', purpose: 'Live hours/reviews/photos — gated setup' },
+    { key: 'PCW_PLACE_ID', label: 'Google Place ID', purpose: 'Which listing to read' },
+    { key: 'DATABASE_URL', label: 'Postgres', purpose: 'Optional data backend' }
+  ];
+  res.json(keys.map(k => ({ ...maskEnv(k.key), label: k.label, purpose: k.purpose })));
+});
+
+// "Update Google Place" — draft-write: returns a prefilled Google Business Profile URL.
+// No direct API write (owner OAuth + API approval deferred). Front-end opens this in a new tab.
+app.post('/api/admin/place/draft-update', (req, res) => {
+  const { field } = req.body || {};
+  res.json({
+    ok: true, mode: 'draft',
+    message: `Draft update for "${field || 'listing'}" — opens Google Business Profile prefilled.`,
+    url: 'https://business.google.com/edit/l/' + (process.env.PCW_PLACE_ID || '')
+  });
+});
+
+// Simple per-IP rate limiter for the public form (prevents spam / unbounded lead file).
+const _hits = new Map();
+function rateLimit(max, windowMs) {
+  return (req, res, next) => {
+    const ip = req.ip || req.connection.remoteAddress || 'unknown';
+    const now = Date.now();
+    const arr = (_hits.get(ip) || []).filter(t => now - t < windowMs);
+    if (arr.length >= max) return res.status(429).json({ ok: false, error: 'Too many requests — try again shortly.' });
+    arr.push(now); _hits.set(ip, arr);
+    next();
+  };
+}
+const cap = (s, n) => String(s || '').slice(0, n);
+
+// Contact / booking lead — saved locally + optional webhook notify (env-gated).
+// NOTIFY_WEBHOOK (Slack/Discord/Zapier URL) gives leads a real notification path;
+// without it the lead is captured in the admin Leads tab. No mass email (that stays gated).
+app.post('/api/contact', rateLimit(5, 10 * 60 * 1000), (req, res) => {
+  const b = req.body || {};
+  const OK_MSG = "Thanks! We'll follow up to confirm your booking — usually within a few hours.";
+  // Honeypot: a hidden field real users never see. Field name is a NON-demographic token
+  // (b_confirm) so password managers / mobile autofill won't populate it for a real user and
+  // silently drop their lead. If it's filled it's a bot — fake success (no retry), drop it,
+  // but LOG the drop so a false-positive is auditable instead of an invisible lost booking.
+  if (b.b_confirm) { console.warn('[honeypot] dropped submission ip=%s name=%s', req.ip, cap(b.name, 60)); return res.json({ ok: true, message: OK_MSG }); }
+  const name = cap(b.name, 120).trim();
+  const phone = cap(b.phone, 40).trim();
+  const email = cap(b.email, 160).trim();
+  const emailOk = !email || /^[^\s@]+@[^\s@]+\.[^\s@]+$/.test(email);
+  const phoneOk = !phone || phone.replace(/\D/g, '').length >= 7;
+  // Validate with human-readable errors so a real lead is never silently lost to a bad submit.
+  if (name.length < 2) return res.status(400).json({ ok: false, error: 'Please enter your name.' });
+  if (!phone && !email) return res.status(400).json({ ok: false, error: 'Please leave a phone number or email so we can reach you.' });
+  if (!emailOk) return res.status(400).json({ ok: false, error: 'That email address doesn’t look right — please double-check it.' });
+  if (!phoneOk) return res.status(400).json({ ok: false, error: 'That phone number looks too short — please double-check it.' });
+  const lead = {
+    id: 'ld_' + Date.now().toString(36) + Math.random().toString(36).slice(2, 6),
+    name, phone, email, vehicle: cap(b.vehicle, 120), service: cap(b.service, 120),
+    preferred: cap(b.preferred, 120), message: cap(b.message, 1000),
+    created_at: new Date().toISOString(), source: 'web-form'
+  };
+  // Duplicate-submit guard: if the same person (name + phone + email + message) already
+  // landed within the last 2 minutes, treat it as a double-click — succeed without saving twice.
+  try {
+    const lp = path.join(__dirname, 'reports', 'leads.jsonl');
+    if (fs.existsSync(lp)) {
+      const recent = fs.readFileSync(lp, 'utf8').trim().split('\n').slice(-25);
+      const now = Date.now();
+      const dup = recent.some(l => { try { const o = JSON.parse(l); return (now - new Date(o.created_at).getTime() < 120000) && o.name === name && (o.phone || '') === phone && (o.email || '') === email && (o.message || '') === lead.message; } catch { return false; } });
+      if (dup) return res.json({ ok: true, message: "Thanks — we’ve already got your request and we’ll follow up shortly." });
+    }
+  } catch { /* if the dedupe read fails, fall through and save (never block a real lead) */ }
+  try {
+    const dir = path.join(__dirname, 'reports');
+    fs.mkdirSync(dir, { recursive: true });
+    fs.appendFileSync(path.join(dir, 'leads.jsonl'), JSON.stringify(lead) + '\n');
+  } catch (e) { return res.status(500).json({ ok: false, error: 'could not save lead' }); }
+  // Fire-and-forget notification if a webhook is configured.
+  if (process.env.NOTIFY_WEBHOOK) {
+    fetch(process.env.NOTIFY_WEBHOOK, {
+      method: 'POST', headers: { 'Content-Type': 'application/json' },
+      body: JSON.stringify({ text: `🚗 New Prestige lead: ${lead.name} (${lead.phone || lead.email}) — ${lead.service || 'general'}${lead.message ? ' · ' + lead.message : ''}` })
+    }).catch(() => {});
+  }
+  res.json({ ok: true, message: "Thanks! We'll follow up to confirm your booking — usually within a few hours." });
+});
+
+// Lead pipeline status — kept in a SEPARATE json map (keyed by lead id, or created_at for
+// legacy leads) so the append-only leads.jsonl log is never rewritten. dtd:C 2026-07-26.
+const LEAD_STATUSES = ['new', 'contacted', 'booked', 'won', 'lost'];
+const leadStatusPath = () => path.join(__dirname, 'reports', 'lead-status.json');
+function readLeadStatus() { try { return JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(leadStatusPath(), 'utf8')); } catch { return {}; } }
+
+// Admin: view captured leads, each merged with its pipeline status (default 'new').
+app.get('/api/admin/leads', (req, res) => {
+  try {
+    const raw = fs.readFileSync(path.join(__dirname, 'reports', 'leads.jsonl'), 'utf8').trim();
+    const st = readLeadStatus();
+    const leads = raw ? raw.split('\n').map(l => JSON.parse(l)) : [];
+    leads.forEach(l => { l.status = st[l.id || l.created_at] || 'new'; });
+    res.json(leads.reverse());
+  } catch { res.json([]); }
+});
+
+// Admin: export all leads (+ pipeline status) as CSV for offline follow-up / records.
+app.get('/api/admin/leads.csv', (req, res) => {
+  let leads = [];
+  try {
+    const raw = fs.readFileSync(path.join(__dirname, 'reports', 'leads.jsonl'), 'utf8').trim();
+    const st = readLeadStatus();
+    leads = raw ? raw.split('\n').map(l => { try { return JSON.parse(l); } catch { return null; } }).filter(Boolean) : [];
+    leads.forEach(l => { l.status = st[l.id || l.created_at] || 'new'; });
+    leads.reverse();
+  } catch { /* empty export is still a valid CSV */ }
+  const cols = ['created_at', 'name', 'phone', 'email', 'vehicle', 'service', 'preferred', 'message', 'status'];
+  const esc = v => {
+    let s = String(v == null ? '' : v);
+    if (/^[=+\-@]/.test(s)) s = "'" + s;                          // neutralize CSV/formula injection
+    return /[",\n\r]/.test(s) ? '"' + s.replace(/"/g, '""') + '"' : s;
+  };
+  const out = [cols.join(',')].concat(leads.map(l => cols.map(c => esc(l[c])).join(','))).join('\r\n') + '\r\n';
+  const day = new Date().toISOString().slice(0, 10);
+  res.setHeader('Content-Type', 'text/csv; charset=utf-8');
+  res.setHeader('Content-Disposition', `attachment; filename="prestige-leads-${day}.csv"`);
+  res.send(out);
+});
+
+// Admin: advance a lead through the pipeline (new → contacted → booked/won/lost).
+app.post('/api/admin/lead-status', (req, res) => {
+  const { id, status } = req.body || {};
+  if (!id || !LEAD_STATUSES.includes(status)) return res.status(400).json({ ok: false, error: 'id + valid status required' });
+  try {
+    const st = readLeadStatus(); st[id] = status;
+    fs.mkdirSync(path.join(__dirname, 'reports'), { recursive: true });
+    fs.writeFileSync(leadStatusPath(), JSON.stringify(st, null, 2));
+    res.json({ ok: true, id, status });
+  } catch { res.status(500).json({ ok: false, error: 'could not save status' }); }
+});
+
+// ── Self-hosted, privacy-friendly analytics-lite (DTD 2026-07-27) ──────────────────────
+// First-party AGGREGATE counts ONLY — no cookies, no IP, no per-user data — so it needs no
+// consent banner and stores nothing we can't stand behind. Gives the owner the denominator
+// (views) behind their lead counts => a real, honestly-measured conversion rate. NOT GA.
+const ANALYTICS_EVENTS = ['pageview', 'form_start', 'form_submit'];
+const analyticsPath = () => path.join(__dirname, 'reports', 'analytics.json');
+function readAnalytics() { try { return JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(analyticsPath(), 'utf8')); } catch { return {}; } }
+const dayKeyLA = () => new Date().toLocaleDateString('en-CA', { timeZone: 'America/Los_Angeles' }); // YYYY-MM-DD, shop tz
+
+// Public beacon. Whitelisted events only; unknown events are silently ignored (204, no error
+// surface). Aggregate increment only — never stores anything about who the visitor is.
+app.post('/api/track', rateLimit(60, 60 * 1000), (req, res) => {
+  const ev = String((req.body || {}).event || '');
+  if (!ANALYTICS_EVENTS.includes(ev)) return res.status(204).end();
+  try {
+    const a = readAnalytics(); const day = dayKeyLA();
+    a[day] = a[day] || {}; a[day][ev] = (a[day][ev] || 0) + 1;
+    const days = Object.keys(a).sort();                       // keep the file bounded (last 120 days)
+    if (days.length > 120) for (const d of days.slice(0, days.length - 120)) delete a[d];
+    fs.mkdirSync(path.join(__dirname, 'reports'), { recursive: true });
+    // Atomic write (temp + rename) so a partial/concurrent write can never leave a corrupt
+    // analytics.json that a reader would choke on.
+    const tmp = analyticsPath() + '.tmp';
+    fs.writeFileSync(tmp, JSON.stringify(a));
+    fs.renameSync(tmp, analyticsPath());
+  } catch { /* analytics must NEVER break a page — swallow */ }
+  res.status(204).end();
+});
+
+// Admin: aggregate analytics (today / last 7 days / all-time + honest conversion rate).
+app.get('/api/admin/analytics', (req, res) => {
+  const a = readAnalytics();
+  const sum = keys => keys.reduce((o, d) => { const b = a[d] || {}; ANALYTICS_EVENTS.forEach(e => o[e] = (o[e] || 0) + (b[e] || 0)); return o; }, {});
+  const allDays = Object.keys(a).sort();
+  const last7 = []; for (let i = 0; i < 7; i++) { const d = new Date(); d.setDate(d.getDate() - i); last7.push(d.toLocaleDateString('en-CA', { timeZone: 'America/Los_Angeles' })); }
+  const conv = t => t.pageview ? Math.round((t.form_submit || 0) / t.pageview * 1000) / 10 : 0; // submits per 100 views
+  const t7 = sum(last7), tot = sum(allDays);
+  res.json({
+    today: sum([dayKeyLA()]), last7: t7, total: tot,
+    conversion7: conv(t7), conversionTotal: conv(tot),
+    series: allDays.slice(-14).map(d => ({ date: d, ...ANALYTICS_EVENTS.reduce((o, e) => (o[e] = (a[d] || {})[e] || 0, o), {}) }))
+  });
+});
+
+// Public: HONEST "typical wait" estimate derived from the demand model.
+// It is NOT a live queue count — it's a transparent function of best-times.json
+// demand for the current weekday, always labeled as an estimate, so we never
+// display a number we can't verify (the places.json data-honesty rule). dtd:A 2026-07-26.
+app.get('/api/wait', (req, res) => {
+  const days = ((bestTimes() || {}).traffic || {}).by_day || [];
+  // Weekday in the shop's LOCAL tz (LA) — the server clock is UTC, so a Friday-evening
+  // CA visitor must not be shown Saturday's level. (contrarian gate, 2026-07-26)
+  const dayName = new Date().toLocaleDateString('en-US', { timeZone: 'America/Los_Angeles', weekday: 'short' });
+  const today = days.find(d => d.day === dayName);
+  const demand = today ? Math.max(1, Math.min(5, Number(today.demand) || 3)) : 3;
+  // Report the demand LEVEL the data actually measures — a qualitative busy-ness, NOT a
+  // fabricated minute count we can't verify (Steve's data-honesty rule).
+  const LEVELS = { 1: ['Quiet', 'little to no wait'], 2: ['Quiet', 'little to no wait'], 3: ['Moderate', 'a short wait is typical'], 4: ['Busy', 'expect a wait'], 5: ['Very busy', 'expect a longer wait'] };
+  const [level, phrase] = LEVELS[demand];
+  res.json({
+    level, phrase, demand, day: dayName,
+    estimate: true,
+    basis: 'Based on typical demand for this day — not a live queue count'
+  });
+});
+
+// ---- static + clean URLs ---------------------------------------------------
+// Google Place photo proxy — fetches photo media with the server-side key and streams
+// it, so the key never reaches the browser. Cached to avoid re-billing on every view.
+app.get('/api/places/photo/:i', async (req, res) => {
+  const key = process.env.GOOGLE_PLACES_API_KEY;
+  const name = (places().photos || [])[parseInt(req.params.i, 10)];
+  if (!key || !name) return res.status(404).end();
+  const w = Math.min(1600, Math.max(100, parseInt(req.query.w, 10) || 800));
+  try {
+    const r = await fetch(`https://places.googleapis.com/v1/${name}/media?maxWidthPx=${w}&key=${key}`);
+    if (!r.ok) return res.status(502).end();
+    res.set('Content-Type', r.headers.get('content-type') || 'image/jpeg');
+    res.set('Cache-Control', 'public, max-age=86400');
+    res.end(Buffer.from(await r.arrayBuffer()));
+  } catch { res.status(502).end(); }
+});
+
+// Inline SVG favicon (avoids a 404 on the browser's automatic request).
+app.get('/favicon.svg', (req, res) => res.type('image/svg+xml').send(
+  '<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 32 32"><rect width="32" height="32" rx="7" fill="#0a84ff"/><text x="16" y="22" font-size="18" text-anchor="middle">🚗</text></svg>'));
+app.get('/favicon.ico', (req, res) => res.redirect(302, '/favicon.svg'));
+app.use('/media', express.static(path.join(__dirname, 'media')));
+app.get(/^\/(.+)\.html$/, (req, res) => res.redirect(301, '/' + req.params[0]));
+
+// LocalBusiness (AutoWash) JSON-LD for local SEO — built LIVE from data/places.json so it
+// can never drift from the visible name/address/phone/hours (Google cross-checks NAP).
+// Server-rendered into <head> so crawlers see it without executing JS. dtd:B 2026-07-26.
+// We only emit fields we can verify — NO aggregateRating (unverified) and NO geo (no lat/lng).
+const DOW = { Mon: 'Monday', Tue: 'Tuesday', Wed: 'Wednesday', Thu: 'Thursday', Fri: 'Friday', Sat: 'Saturday', Sun: 'Sunday' };
+const DOW_ORDER = ['Mon', 'Tue', 'Wed', 'Thu', 'Fri', 'Sat', 'Sun'];
+function to24(t) {
+  const m = String(t).match(/(\d{1,2}):(\d{2})\s*(AM|PM)/i);
+  if (!m) return null;
+  let h = +m[1]; const ap = m[3].toUpperCase();
+  if (ap === 'PM' && h !== 12) h += 12;
+  if (ap === 'AM' && h === 12) h = 0;
+  return String(h).padStart(2, '0') + ':' + m[2];
+}
+function parseHoursLine(line) {
+  const times = String(line).match(/\d{1,2}:\d{2}\s*[AP]M/gi);
+  if (!times || times.length < 2) return null;
+  const opens = to24(times[0]), closes = to24(times[1]);
+  const dayPart = String(line).split(/\s+\d/)[0].trim();
+  const dr = dayPart.split(/[–—-]/).map(s => s.trim());
+  let days = [];
+  if (dr.length === 2) { const a = DOW_ORDER.indexOf(dr[0]), b = DOW_ORDER.indexOf(dr[1]); if (a >= 0 && b >= 0) days = DOW_ORDER.slice(a, b + 1); }
+  else if (DOW[dr[0]]) days = [dr[0]];
+  if (!days.length || !opens || !closes) return null;
+  return { '@type': 'OpeningHoursSpecification', dayOfWeek: days.map(d => DOW[d]), opens, closes };
+}
+// Canonical serving origin. prestige.agentabrams.com is the PERMANENT public home for this
+// build (Steve 2026-07-27: the prestigehandcarwash.com apex does not exist — agentabrams only).
+// All self-referential SEO (canonical, og:url, sitemap, article URLs, entity url) points here.
+const SITE_ORIGIN = 'https://prestige.agentabrams.com';
+function siteOrigin() { return (SITE_ORIGIN || '').replace(/\/$/, ''); }
+function buildJsonLd() {
+  const p = places();
+  if (!p || !p.name) return null;
+  const ld = { '@context': 'https://schema.org', '@type': 'AutoWash', name: p.name };
+  if (p.legal_name && p.legal_name !== p.name) ld.alternateName = p.legal_name;
+  if (siteOrigin()) ld.url = siteOrigin();
+  if (p.phone) ld.telephone = p.phone;
+  if (p.address) {
+    const parts = p.address.split(',').map(s => s.trim());
+    const addr = { '@type': 'PostalAddress', addressCountry: 'US' };
+    if (parts[0]) addr.streetAddress = parts[0];
+    if (parts[1]) addr.addressLocality = parts[1];
+    if (parts[2]) { const sz = parts[2].match(/([A-Z]{2})\s*(\d{5})/); if (sz) { addr.addressRegion = sz[1]; addr.postalCode = sz[2]; } }
+    ld.address = addr;
+  }
+  const hrs = (p.hours || []).map(parseHoursLine).filter(Boolean);
+  if (hrs.length) ld.openingHoursSpecification = hrs;
+  const ig = p.instagram ? (/^https?:\/\//.test(p.instagram) ? p.instagram : `https://instagram.com/${String(p.instagram).replace(/^@/, '')}`) : null;
+  const same = [ig, p.yelp_url].filter(Boolean);
+  if (same.length) ld.sameAs = same;
+  // Service catalog with REAL prices (only where a numeric price exists — quote-only
+  // services list the Service without a fabricated price). Strengthens rich results.
+  const svc = (services() || []).filter(s => s && s.name);
+  if (svc.length) {
+    ld.hasOfferCatalog = {
+      '@type': 'OfferCatalog', name: 'Car Wash & Detailing Services',
+      itemListElement: svc.map(s => {
+        const offer = { '@type': 'Offer', itemOffered: { '@type': 'Service', name: s.name } };
+        if (s.blurb) offer.itemOffered.description = s.blurb;
+        if (s.price != null && !isNaN(Number(s.price))) { offer.price = Number(s.price); offer.priceCurrency = 'USD'; }
+        return offer;
+      })
+    };
+  }
+  return ld;
+}
+// Booking-objection FAQ — the SINGLE SOURCE for both the on-page accordion (/api/faqs)
+// and the FAQPage JSON-LD, so visible text and structured data can never drift. Every
+// answer is a verifiable operational commitment the business already makes on-site
+// (data-honesty rule: no invented durations, prices, or ratings). Framed as the exact
+// objections that stall a booking — folds the /dtd "D" dissent (friction reduction) into A.
+function faqs() {
+  return [
+    { q: 'Do you actually hand wash, or is it an automatic tunnel?',
+      a: 'Every car is hand washed using the two-bucket method with a foam cannon — no automatic tunnel and no brushes, so no swirl marks. It is safe for ceramic-coated, matte, and PPF-wrapped finishes.' },
+    { q: 'Is the pricing really flat, or will I get upsold?',
+      a: 'The price on the sign is the price you pay. There is no commission-driven wax-and-polish pressure — pick a service and that is the cost. The full price list is on the Services page.' },
+    { q: 'What happens if it rains right after my wash?',
+      a: 'If it rains within 48 hours of your wash, your next basic wash is on us — just come back.' },
+    { q: 'Do you clean the back seats and door jambs?',
+      a: 'Yes. Every seat is touched and door jambs are included on every wash, always. If we miss a spot, we re-do it free.' },
+    { q: 'I am sensitive to fragrances — is there an option?',
+      a: 'Yes, a fragrance-free option is available on request. Just note it when you book.' },
+    { q: 'Do you offer full detailing and ceramic coating?',
+      a: 'Yes — alongside the hand wash we offer full-service detailing and 9H ceramic coating. See the Services page for current options and flat pricing.' },
+    { q: 'Which neighborhoods do you serve?',
+      a: 'We serve the San Fernando Valley — including Sherman Oaks, Encino, Van Nuys, Studio City, Northridge, Reseda, Tarzana, Woodland Hills, and North Hollywood.' },
+    { q: 'How do I book, and how soon will I hear back?',
+      a: 'Send a request from the Book / Contact page with your vehicle and preferred time. We follow up to confirm — usually within a few hours during business hours. No pressure, no upsell.' }
+  ];
+}
+// Persistent mobile action bar — injected into customer pages so the primary CTA (Book)
+// and a click-to-call are always one thumb-tap away on phones (where most Valley car-wash
+// traffic is). CSS-only visibility (<=640px), no JS. The tel: number comes from the REAL
+// places().phone (single source, no fabrication); the Call button is omitted if no phone.
+function mobileBar(pagePath) {
+  const p = places() || {};
+  let d = String(p.phone || '').replace(/\D/g, '');
+  if (d.length === 11 && d[0] === '1') d = d.slice(1);
+  const tel = d.length === 10 ? '+1' + d : (d ? '+' + d : '');
+  const call = tel ? `<a class="mbar-btn call" href="tel:${tel}" aria-label="Call ${(p.name || 'Prestige Car Wash').replace(/"/g, '')}">📞 Call</a>` : '';
+  // On the contact page the form IS the booking action, so scroll to it (#f) rather than
+  // self-linking to the top of the page and losing any half-filled form state.
+  const bookHref = pagePath === '/contact' ? '#f' : '/contact';
+  return `<style>
+.mbar{display:none}
+@media(max-width:640px){
+  body{padding-bottom:74px}
+  .mbar{display:flex;position:fixed;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;z-index:80;gap:10px;padding:10px 12px calc(10px + env(safe-area-inset-bottom,0px));background:rgba(11,15,22,.93);backdrop-filter:blur(10px);border-top:1px solid var(--line)}
+  .mbar-btn{flex:1;text-align:center;padding:13px 10px;border-radius:12px;font-weight:800;font-size:15px;text-decoration:none;display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;gap:6px}
+  .mbar .call{background:transparent;color:var(--ink);border:1px solid var(--line)}
+  .mbar .book{background:linear-gradient(135deg,var(--brand),var(--brand2));color:#001018}
+}</style>
+<div class="mbar" aria-label="Quick actions">${call}<a class="mbar-btn book" href="${bookHref}">Book a Wash →</a></div>`;
+}
+// Honest "find & review us" trust block — links to the REAL, verified off-site profiles
+// from places() (Google Maps, Yelp, Instagram). Deliberately shows NO star number: ratings
+// drift and would go stale on-page, so we route to the authoritative live profile instead
+// (data-honesty rule — never display a number we can't keep verifiably current). Only a
+// profile with a real non-empty value is rendered (no dead links). Server-rendered so the
+// off-site authority links ship in the crawler HTML.
+function trustBlockHtml() {
+  const p = places() || {};
+  const esc = s => String(s == null ? '' : s).replace(/&/g, '&amp;').replace(/"/g, '&quot;').replace(/</g, '&lt;').replace(/>/g, '&gt;');
+  const btn = (href, label, cls) => href
+    ? `<a class="${cls}" href="${esc(href)}" target="_blank" rel="noopener" style="text-decoration:none">${esc(label)}</a>` : '';
+  const igHandle = p.instagram ? '@' + String(p.instagram).replace(/^https?:\/\/(www\.)?instagram\.com\//i, '').replace(/\/+$/, '').replace(/^@/, '') : '';
+  const igUrl = p.instagram ? (/^https?:\/\//.test(p.instagram) ? p.instagram : 'https://instagram.com/' + String(p.instagram).replace(/^@/, '')) : '';
+  const links = [
+    btn(p.maps_query, '📍 Find us on Google Maps', 'btn'),
+    btn(p.yelp_url, '⭐ Read reviews on Yelp', 'btn ghost'),
+    btn(igUrl, '📸 ' + igHandle, 'btn ghost')
+  ].filter(Boolean);
+  if (!links.length) return '';
+  // Review-SOLICITATION CTA routes to Google's write-review dialog — and ONLY when a real
+  // Google place_id is present (currently empty). We deliberately do NOT solicit on Yelp
+  // (Yelp's "Don't Ask for Reviews" policy filters solicited reviews into "not recommended",
+  // burying exactly what we'd be trying to grow), and we never point "leave a review" at a
+  // bare search URL or a guessed id. So the CTA stays gated on a verified place_id and simply
+  // appears once it's set — the "Read reviews on Yelp" link above stays (finding ≠ soliciting).
+  const pid = /^[A-Za-z0-9_-]{20,}$/.test(String(p.place_id || '')) ? p.place_id : '';
+  const reviewHref = pid ? `https://search.google.com/local/writereview?placeid=${encodeURIComponent(pid)}` : '';
+  const cta = reviewHref ? `<div style="margin-top:16px">${btn(reviewHref, 'Leave us a review on Google →', 'btn')}</div>` : '';
+  return `<div style="display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;gap:12px;align-items:center">${links.join('')}</div>${cta}`;
+}
+function buildFaqLd() {
+  const list = faqs();
+  if (!list.length) return null;
+  return {
+    '@context': 'https://schema.org', '@type': 'FAQPage',
+    mainEntity: list.map(f => ({
+      '@type': 'Question', name: f.q,
+      acceptedAnswer: { '@type': 'Answer', text: f.a }
+    }))
+  };
+}
+// Server-rendered accordion HTML from the SAME faqs() source. Injected into the #faqList
+// placeholder (see pageHtml) so the visible FAQ ships in the crawler-received HTML and
+// MATCHES the FAQPage JSON-LD — Google requires structured data to reflect visible content
+// (client-only rendering risks a manual action). Native <details> means zero JS needed.
+function faqHtml() {
+  const esc = s => String(s == null ? '' : s).replace(/&/g, '&amp;').replace(/</g, '&lt;').replace(/>/g, '&gt;');
+  return faqs().map((f, i) => `
+    <details class="faq"${i === 0 ? ' open' : ''} style="border:1px solid var(--line);border-radius:12px;margin-bottom:10px;background:var(--panel)">
+      <summary style="cursor:pointer;padding:15px 18px;font-weight:700;font-size:16px;display:flex;justify-content:space-between;gap:12px;align-items:center">
+        <span>${esc(f.q)}</span><span class="faq-mk" aria-hidden="true" style="color:var(--mut);font-weight:800;font-size:20px">+</span>
+      </summary>
+      <div style="padding:0 18px 16px;color:var(--mut);font-size:15px;line-height:1.55">${esc(f.a)}</div>
+    </details>`).join('');
+}
+// ── Evergreen car-care guides (DTD iteration 5) ────────────────────────────────────────
+// Genuinely useful, HONEST top-of-funnel content: established detailing best-practice
+// guidance phrased as advice (no fabricated statistics, no invented studies). Rendered
+// server-side so it's fully crawlable, with BlogPosting + BreadcrumbList JSON-LD and
+// internal links into services/booking. GUIDE_DATE is the real publish date.
+const GUIDE_DATE = '2026-07-26';
+function guides() {
+  return [
+    {
+      slug: 'how-often-to-wash-a-ceramic-coated-car',
+      title: 'How Often Should You Wash a Ceramic-Coated Car?',
+      description: 'A ceramic coating changes the maintenance math. Here is a sensible wash rhythm that protects the coating without over-washing.',
+      dek: 'A coating is slick and sacrificial — but it still needs the right care to keep beading and looking its best.',
+      sections: [
+        { h: 'The short answer', p: 'For a daily-driven coated car, every two weeks is a sensible default. Stretch it if the car lives in a garage; tighten it after rain, road grime, or bird droppings — droppings are acidic and can etch even a coated surface if left to bake in the sun.' },
+        { h: 'Why gentle washing matters more, not less', p: 'A coating makes dirt easier to remove, but automatic tunnel brushes still drag grit across the surface and dull the gloss over time. A gentle two-bucket hand wash with a pH-neutral soap preserves the coating’s hydrophobic behavior far longer than a tunnel ever will.' },
+        { h: 'What to avoid', p: 'Skip strong degreasers and high-alkaline wheel chemicals on coated paint — they strip the coating’s top layer. And never let water spot-dry in direct sun; the dissolved minerals bond to the coating and are a pain to remove.' },
+        { h: 'When to top it up', p: 'If water stops beading and starts sheeting flat, the coating is asking for help. A spray-on SiO2 booster applied after a wash restores hydrophobicity between professional maintenance visits.' }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      slug: 'hand-wash-vs-automatic-tunnel',
+      title: 'Hand Wash vs. Automatic Tunnel: What Is Actually Safe for Your Paint',
+      description: 'Automatic tunnels are fast and cheap — but here is what they do to your clear coat, and why hand washing is gentler.',
+      dek: 'The difference comes down to one thing: grit, and whether it gets dragged across your paint.',
+      sections: [
+        { h: 'Where tunnel washes go wrong', p: 'Tunnels recirculate water and run stiff brushes or cloth strips that have already touched every car before yours. The grit they carry is exactly what puts fine swirl marks and hairline scratches into a clear coat.' },
+        { h: 'Why two-bucket hand washing is gentler', p: 'Two buckets — one of clean soapy water, one to rinse the mitt — let grit drop out of circulation instead of going back onto the paint. A foam cannon lifts and floats dirt off the surface before the mitt ever touches it.' },
+        { h: 'The finishes that cannot take a tunnel', p: 'Ceramic coatings, matte and satin paint, and paint protection film (PPF) can all be dulled, hazed, or lifted at the edges by automated equipment. For any of these, hand washing is the safe default.' },
+        { h: 'The honest trade-off', p: 'Tunnels win on speed and price per wash. If your car is a daily beater, that may be all you need. If you care about the finish — or you have invested in a coating, a wrap, or a fresh repaint — hand washing pays for itself in preserved gloss and resale value.' }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      slug: 'protecting-matte-and-ppf-finishes',
+      title: 'Protecting Matte and PPF Finishes: A Care Guide',
+      description: 'Matte paint and paint protection film need different care than glossy clear coat. Here is how to keep them looking right.',
+      dek: 'The wrong product on a matte finish is a mistake you cannot polish out — so it pays to know the rules.',
+      sections: [
+        { h: 'Matte is a different animal', p: 'Matte and satin clear coats get their look from a micro-textured surface that scatters light. Anything that fills or polishes that texture — wax, sealant, polish, or a buffer — creates permanent shiny spots that can only be corrected with a refinish.' },
+        { h: 'How to wash matte safely', p: 'Hand wash only, with a matte-specific (wax-free) pH-neutral shampoo, a soft mitt, and straight-line motions rather than circles. Dry with a clean microfiber or a filtered-air blower instead of dragging a towel across the texture.' },
+        { h: 'Caring for PPF', p: 'Paint protection film is tough, but its edges can trap dirt and lift if scrubbed hard. Keep the edges clean, avoid blasting high-pressure water straight at the seams, and skip cutting compounds. Many modern films are self-healing — light swirls vanish in the sun or after a warm rinse.' },
+        { h: 'What we do', p: 'Our hand wash is matte- and PPF-safe by default: no automatic brushes, never any wax on matte, and a fragrance-free option on request. Tell us what your car is wearing and we will treat it accordingly.' }
+      ]
+    }
+  ];
+}
+function _e(s) { return String(s == null ? '' : s).replace(/&/g, '&amp;').replace(/"/g, '&quot;').replace(/</g, '&lt;').replace(/>/g, '&gt;'); }
+function guideLayout(title, description, bodyHtml) {
+  return `<!doctype html><html lang="en"><head>
+<meta charset="utf-8"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1">
+<title>${_e(title)}</title>
+<meta name="description" content="${_e(description)}">
+<link rel="preconnect" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com">
+<link href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Inter:wght@400;600;700;800;900&display=swap" rel="stylesheet">
+<link rel="stylesheet" href="/assets/pcw.css">
+</head><body>
+<nav class="nav"><div class="wrap row">
+  <div class="brand"><span class="mk">🚗</span><div>Prestige<br><small>Car Wash · SFV</small></div></div>
+  <button class="hamb" aria-label="Menu" aria-expanded="false" onclick="var o=document.getElementById('lnk').classList.toggle('open');this.setAttribute('aria-expanded',o)">☰</button>
+  <div class="links" id="lnk"><a href="/">Home</a><a href="/services">Services</a><a href="/guides" class="on">Guides</a><a class="btn" href="/contact">Book a Wash</a></div>
+</div></nav>
+${bodyHtml}
+<footer class="foot"><div class="wrap">© 2026 Prestige Car Wash · San Fernando Valley, CA · <a href="/services">Services</a> · <a href="/guides">Guides</a> · <a href="/contact">Book</a></div></footer>
+</body></html>`;
+}
+function guideCtaHtml() {
+  return `<div class="card" style="max-width:760px;margin:26px auto 0"><div class="body" style="text-align:center">
+    <div class="ttl" style="font-size:20px">Want it done right, by hand?</div>
+    <div class="blurb">We hand wash every car — coating-, matte-, and PPF-safe — with no upsell pressure.</div>
+    <div style="margin-top:12px;display:flex;gap:10px;justify-content:center;flex-wrap:wrap">
+      <a class="btn" href="/contact">Book a Wash</a><a class="btn ghost" href="/services">See Services &amp; Pricing</a>
+    </div>
+  </div></div>`;
+}
+function guideArticleHtml(g) {
+  const secs = g.sections.map(s => `<h2>${_e(s.h)}</h2>\n<p>${_e(s.p)}</p>`).join('\n');
+  return `<article class="section"><div class="wrap" style="max-width:760px">
+    <div style="margin-bottom:10px"><a href="/guides" style="color:var(--mut);font-size:13px">← Car-care guides</a></div>
+    <span class="pill">Car-care guide</span>
+    <h1>${_e(g.title)}</h1>
+    <p class="lead">${_e(g.dek)}</p>
+    ${secs}
+    ${guideCtaHtml()}
+  </div></article>`;
+}
+function guideIndexHtml() {
+  const cards = guides().map(g => `<a class="card" href="/guides/${_e(g.slug)}" style="text-decoration:none;color:inherit"><div class="body">
+      <div class="cat">Car-care guide</div>
+      <div class="ttl">${_e(g.title)}</div>
+      <div class="blurb">${_e(g.description)}</div>
+      <div style="margin-top:8px;color:var(--brand);font-weight:700;font-size:14px">Read →</div>
+    </div></a>`).join('');
+  return `<section class="section"><div class="wrap">
+    <span class="pill">Guides</span>
+    <h1>Car-care guides</h1>
+    <p class="sub">Straight, no-nonsense advice on keeping your car’s finish looking its best — from the crew that hand washes them.</p>
+    <div class="grid" style="--cols:3">${cards}</div>
+  </div></section>`;
+}
+function buildArticleLd(g, canonicalUrl) {
+  const name = (places() || {}).name || 'Prestige Car Wash';
+  const ld = {
+    '@context': 'https://schema.org', '@type': 'BlogPosting',
+    headline: g.title, description: g.description,
+    datePublished: GUIDE_DATE, dateModified: GUIDE_DATE,
+    author: { '@type': 'Organization', name }, publisher: { '@type': 'Organization', name },
+    articleSection: 'Car care'
+  };
+  if (canonicalUrl) ld.mainEntityOfPage = canonicalUrl;
+  return ld;
+}
+function buildBreadcrumbLd(items) {
+  return {
+    '@context': 'https://schema.org', '@type': 'BreadcrumbList',
+    itemListElement: items.map((it, i) => ({ '@type': 'ListItem', position: i + 1, name: it.name, item: it.url }))
+  };
+}
+// Open Graph / Twitter tags for the homepage — reuses the page's own <title> and meta
+// description so social previews stay in sync with on-page SEO. og:image is a real asset.
+function buildSocialTags(html, pagePath) {
+  // Bail if the HTML already carries og: tags OR a canonical (e.g. added directly to the
+  // file) so we never inject a duplicate that makes Facebook/Google flag the markup.
+  if (/property=["']og:title["']/i.test(html) || /<link\b[^>]*\brel=["']canonical["']/i.test(html)) return '';
+  const p = places() || {};
+  const base = siteOrigin();
+  const url = base ? base + (pagePath || '') : '';   // page-specific canonical + og:url
+  const title = (html.match(/<title>([^<]*)<\/title>/i) || [])[1] || p.name || 'Prestige Car Wash';
+  // Attribute-order-independent description extraction, with a real fallback (never a
+  // blank social card). Handles both name-first and content-first, single or double quotes.
+  const descMatch = html.match(/<meta\b[^>]*\bname=["']description["'][^>]*\bcontent=["']([^"']*)["']/i)
+                 || html.match(/<meta\b[^>]*\bcontent=["']([^"']*)["'][^>]*\bname=["']description["']/i);
+  const desc = (descMatch || [])[1] || `${p.name || 'Prestige Car Wash'} — no-pressure flat pricing, two-bucket hand wash, detailing & ceramic coating in the San Fernando Valley.`;
+  const img = base ? base + '/media/svc-full-service.png' : '';
+  const esc = s => String(s).replace(/&/g, '&amp;').replace(/"/g, '&quot;').replace(/</g, '&lt;');
+  // Individual guide articles are og:type "article"; everything else is a "website".
+  const ogType = /^\/guides\/.+/.test(pagePath || '') ? 'article' : 'website';
+  const tags = [
+    ['og:type', ogType], ['og:site_name', p.name || 'Prestige Car Wash'],
+    ['og:title', title], ['og:description', desc], url && ['og:url', url], img && ['og:image', img],
+    ['twitter:card', img ? 'summary_large_image' : 'summary'],
+    ['twitter:title', title], ['twitter:description', desc], img && ['twitter:image', img]
+  ].filter(Boolean);
+  const metas = tags.map(([k, v]) => k.startsWith('twitter')
+    ? `<meta name="${k}" content="${esc(v)}">`
+    : `<meta property="${k}" content="${esc(v)}">`).join('\n');
+  return (url ? `<link rel="canonical" href="${esc(url)}">\n` : '') + metas;
+}
+// Built fresh per request (sync file read + one string replace = microseconds) so the
+// injected JSON-LD/OG NEVER drift from live places.json — a stale NAP is the exact thing
+// Google penalizes, which would defeat the point of injecting it. (contrarian gate, 2026-07-26)
+// GA4 gtag snippet — injected on the customer pages ONLY when GA_MEASUREMENT_ID is set
+// (a valid G-XXXX id). No-op until then, so this is safe to ship before the id exists.
+// Admin (internal) is intentionally NOT tracked as customer traffic.
+function gaSnippet() {
+  const id = process.env.GA_MEASUREMENT_ID;
+  if (!id || !/^G-[A-Z0-9]{6,}$/.test(id)) return '';
+  return `\n<script async src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=${id}"></script>` +
+         `\n<script>window.dataLayer=window.dataLayer||[];function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);}gtag('js',new Date());gtag('config','${id}');</script>`;
+}
+// Shared page decorator: takes a full HTML string and injects the FAQ/trust placeholders,
+// the mobile bar, OG/canonical tags, JSON-LD, and the GA snippet. Used by BOTH file-backed
+// pages (pageHtml) and server-generated pages (the /guides articles), so head/injection logic
+// lives in exactly one place.
+function decorate(html, pagePath, ld) {
+  // Fill the FAQ accordion server-side so the visible content is in the crawler-received
+  // HTML and matches the FAQPage JSON-LD. Only touches a page that carries the placeholder.
+  if (html.includes('id="faqList"')) {
+    html = html.replace(/(<div id="faqList"[^>]*>)\s*(<\/div>)/, (m, open, close) => open + faqHtml() + close);
+  }
+  // Fill the honest find-&-review trust block server-side (real off-site profile links).
+  // If there are no real profiles to show, strip the WHOLE section so a heading never floats
+  // over an empty body (graceful degradation, per contrarian).
+  if (html.includes('id="findReview"')) {
+    const tb = trustBlockHtml();
+    if (tb) html = html.replace(/(<div id="findReview"[^>]*>)\s*(<\/div>)/, (m, open, close) => open + tb + close);
+    else html = html.replace(/<section class="section" id="findreview">[\s\S]*?<\/section>/, '');
+  }
+  // Persistent mobile Book/Call bar on every customer page (guard against double-inject).
+  if (!/class="mbar"/.test(html)) html = html.replace('</body>', mobileBar(pagePath) + '\n</body>');
+  // Admin ↔ live-view toggle: on customer pages show a "🔧 Admin" pill ONLY if this browser
+  // carries the pcw.admin flag (set when the admin visits /admin). Invisible to real customers;
+  // gives the logged-in admin a one-tap way back to the admin from any live page.
+  html = html.replace('</body>', `<script>(function(){try{if(localStorage.getItem('pcw.admin')!=='1')return;var a=document.createElement('a');a.href='/admin';a.textContent='🔧 Admin view';a.title='Switch to admin view';a.setAttribute('aria-label','Switch to admin view');a.style.cssText='position:fixed;left:12px;bottom:12px;z-index:95;background:#12100e;color:#c6a765;font:700 11px/1 system-ui,-apple-system,sans-serif;letter-spacing:.1em;text-transform:uppercase;padding:9px 13px;border-radius:6px;text-decoration:none;box-shadow:0 6px 18px rgba(0,0,0,.45);border:1px solid rgba(198,167,101,.45)';document.body.appendChild(a);}catch(e){}})();</script>\n</body>`);
+  let inject = buildSocialTags(html, pagePath);
+  // Perf: preconnect to the font-file origin (pages already preconnect googleapis; the actual
+  // WOFF2 files come from gstatic, so this shaves a round-trip on first paint). Dedup-guarded.
+  if (!/fonts\.gstatic\.com/.test(html)) inject += '\n<link rel="preconnect" href="https://fonts.gstatic.com" crossorigin>';
+  // ld may be a single JSON-LD object OR an array of them (e.g. AutoWash + FAQPage on the
+  // homepage). Emit one <script> per object; escape "<" so the JSON can't break out of the tag.
+  for (const obj of [].concat(ld || []).filter(Boolean)) {
+    inject += `\n<script type="application/ld+json">${JSON.stringify(obj).replace(/</g, '\\u003c')}</script>`;
+  }
+  inject += gaSnippet();
+  // First-party pageview beacon (analytics-lite) — sendBeacon so it never blocks paint; the
+  // /api/track endpoint only increments an aggregate counter (no cookie/IP/PII). Customer
+  // pages only (admin isn't served through decorate, so the owner's own visits aren't counted).
+  inject += `\n<script>(function(){try{var b=JSON.stringify({event:'pageview'});if(navigator.sendBeacon){navigator.sendBeacon('/api/track',new Blob([b],{type:'application/json'}))}else{fetch('/api/track',{method:'POST',headers:{'Content-Type':'application/json'},body:b,keepalive:true})}}catch(e){}})();</script>`;
+  return html.replace('</head>', inject + '\n</head>');
+}
+function pageHtml(file, pagePath, ld) {
+  return decorate(fs.readFileSync(path.join(__dirname, 'public', file), 'utf8'), pagePath, ld);
+}
+const sendPage = (res, file, pagePath, ld) => {
+  // If tag INJECTION throws, still serve the raw page (graceful degradation). If the file
+  // itself is unreadable, sendFile's callback guarantees a clean 500 — never a hung response.
+  try { res.type('html').send(pageHtml(file, pagePath, ld)); }
+  catch { res.sendFile(path.join(__dirname, 'public', file), err => { if (err && !res.headersSent) res.status(500).end(); }); }
+};
+// FAQ list for the on-page accordion — same source the homepage FAQPage schema is built from.
+app.get('/api/faqs', (req, res) => res.json(faqs()));
+// Homepage carries BOTH the AutoWash business schema and the FAQPage schema (the FAQ is
+// visibly rendered on the page below, which is what makes the FAQPage markup legitimate).
+app.get('/', (req, res) => sendPage(res, 'index.html', '', [buildJsonLd(), buildFaqLd()]));
+app.get('/services', (req, res) => sendPage(res, 'services.html', '/services', null));
+app.get('/contact', (req, res) => sendPage(res, 'contact.html', '/contact', null));
+// Car-care guides — server-generated (shares the decorate() pipeline: OG/canonical/GA/mobile bar).
+app.get('/guides', (req, res) => {
+  try {
+    const html = guideLayout('Car-Care Guides — Prestige Car Wash',
+      'Honest, practical car-care guides from a San Fernando Valley hand-wash & detail shop: ceramic-coating care, hand wash vs. tunnel, and matte & PPF protection.',
+      guideIndexHtml());
+    res.type('html').send(decorate(html, '/guides', null));
+  } catch { res.status(500).end(); }
+});
+app.get('/guides/:slug', (req, res) => {
+  const g = guides().find(x => x.slug === req.params.slug);
+  const base = siteOrigin();
+  if (!g) {
+    const nf = guideLayout('Guide Not Found — Prestige Car Wash', 'That guide could not be found.',
+      `<section class="section"><div class="wrap"><h1>Guide not found</h1><p class="sub">That guide may have moved. <a href="/guides">Browse all car-care guides →</a></p></div></section>`);
+    return res.status(404).type('html').send(decorate(nf, '/guides', null));
+  }
+  const canonical = base ? base + '/guides/' + g.slug : '';
+  const ld = [
+    buildArticleLd(g, canonical),
+    buildBreadcrumbLd([
+      { name: 'Home', url: base || '/' },
+      { name: 'Guides', url: (base || '') + '/guides' },
+      { name: g.title, url: canonical || ('/guides/' + g.slug) }
+    ])
+  ];
+  try {
+    res.type('html').send(decorate(guideLayout(g.title + ' — Prestige Car Wash', g.description, guideArticleHtml(g)), '/guides/' + g.slug, ld));
+  } catch { res.status(500).end(); }
+});
+
+// XML sitemap generated from the public URL — kept in one place, no static file to drift.
+app.get('/sitemap.xml', (req, res) => {
+  const base = siteOrigin();
+  if (!base) return res.status(404).end();
+  const urls = ['/', '/services', '/contact', '/guides', ...guides().map(g => '/guides/' + g.slug)];
+  const xml = '<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>\n<urlset xmlns="http://www.sitemaps.org/schemas/sitemap/0.9">\n' +
+    urls.map(u => `  <url><loc>${base}${u}</loc></url>`).join('\n') + '\n</urlset>';
+  res.type('application/xml').send(xml);
+});
+
+app.use(express.static(path.join(__dirname, 'public'), { extensions: ['html'] }));
+
+app.listen(PORT, () => {
+  console.log(`[prestige-car-wash] http://localhost:${PORT}  (admin: /admin)`);
+  if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'production' && !process.env.ADMIN_PASS) {
+    console.warn('⚠ SECURITY: running in production with the DEFAULT admin password. Set ADMIN_PASS in .env before exposing this host.');
+  }
+});
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/second-proof.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/second-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b81b3306
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/second-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+{
+  "correlation": "yf2139-cody",
+  "scope": "second preparation batch",
+  "pr_source_hashes": "PASS3",
+  "pr_exact_quotations": 10,
+  "pr_historical_row_and_null_unknowns": "PASS",
+  "column_real_cli_replay": "PASS",
+  "column_all26_original_rows_and_requirements": "PASS",
+  "column_negative_malformed_summary_join_mismatch": "PASS",
+  "source_bytes_unchanged": "PASS",
+  "must_fix_preparation_defects": [],
+  "source_outcomes": "UNVERIFIED",
+  "whole_batch_review": "PENDING Watchtower"
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/second-review.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/second-review.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..e73a6baf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/second-review.md
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
+# Second preparation batch — yf2139-cody
+
+Cost guard rechecked directly: ZERO_COST_REQUIRED, DTD_ZERO_COST=1. One independent reviewer, five distinct inline lenses; final whole-batch verdict still deferred for Watchtower.
+
+- Engineer: ten source quotations and three SHA-256s match; the manifest CLI replays all 26 original rows and rejects malformed JSON, summary drift and top-join mismatch. SHIP IT preparation.
+- Designer: anchor records separate canonical, legacy and historical claims; semantic labels distinguish sell price from acquisition cost and counts from evidence. SHIP IT preparation.
+- User: the eight evidence fields say exactly what is needed per vendor; no unsupported costs or live SKU counts are smuggled in. SHIP IT preparation.
+- Skeptic: "NOT_MEASURED does not mean absent" is the right boundary. Preserved 474 column rows and 1,082 key matches are explicitly separate populations, and 10,704 matches never become 10,704 proven costs. SHIP IT preparation.
+- Strategist: four prefix anchors cannot resolve 232 prefixes, and 26 requirement records cannot substitute for vendor evidence. The limitations admit both. SHIP IT preparation, no operational progress claim.
+
+Three remaining operational holes: (1) no dated acquisition-cost evidence; (2) no current cohort census or join-cardinality/identity proof; (3) four source anchors leave the broader prefix decomposition unfinished. None is hidden or claimed complete, so none is a must-fix preparation defect.
+
+Lazy shortcut to reject: counting "OFFLINE_EVIDENCE_REQUEST_MANIFEST" as acquired evidence. The null acquired_external_evidence fields prevent that misreading at the data level.
+
+Sameness: repeated evidence fields form a consistent schema and each record preserves a different actual vendor/candidate row. This is useful repetition, not fake alternatives.
+
+Debate: Strategist holds the strongest dissent that additional paperwork has diminishing value without vendor evidence. Engineer concedes the operational limitation but rejects blocking an accurate preparation deliverable. User and Skeptic agree: pending source outcomes remain explicit. Five SHIP IT votes for these two preparation artifacts only.
+
+A-grade bar: exact citations, historical totals and full original rows retained, explicit unknown values, real CLI and negative-boundary proof, and no invented cost authority. Independently passed; see second-proof.json and retained column replay/negative fixtures under cody/.
+
+Do this now: finish Watchtower review and report the remaining vendor-evidence dependency without claiming cost coverage improved.
+
+One sentence: The evidence requests are sound; the acquisition-cost evidence still has to exist.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-proof.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8be3e8ac
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+{
+  "correlation": "yf2139-cody",
+  "guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+  "DTD_ZERO_COST": "1",
+  "watch_literal_runner": "9PASS",
+  "watch_exact_one_line_change": "PASS",
+  "watch_installed_bytes_unchanged": "PASS",
+  "watch_bash_syntax": "PASS",
+  "watch_isolated_commit": "dfa2963a10f92bd675c40d39ef5071898ece883e",
+  "actual_second_daemon": "SKIP not authorized",
+  "whole_watch": "SKIP forbidden runtime, never invoked",
+  "execution_slots": 6,
+  "execution_order": [
+    2,
+    4,
+    1,
+    5,
+    6,
+    8
+  ],
+  "ordering_deviation_disclosed": true,
+  "source_operational_outcomes": "UNVERIFIED",
+  "provisional_preparation_defect": "Final disposition position8 in-progress wording stale; root notified to independently reproduce and correct",
+  "source_changes_by_reviewer": false
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/decoy_only.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/decoy_only.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a4bb4eea
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/decoy_only.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+node /safe/tk log TK-11848 peer PM2 God text
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/live-process-summary.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/live-process-summary.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..10bfad9e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/live-process-summary.json
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
+{
+  "command": "ps -axo command=",
+  "matched_command_prefixes": [
+    "PM2 v6.0.14: God Daemon"
+  ],
+  "count": 1,
+  "full_argv_retained": false
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/non_numeric_version.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/non_numeric_version.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..d45f32b6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/non_numeric_version.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+PM2 vbogus: God Daemon (/safe/.pm2)
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/old_decoy_false_positive.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/old_decoy_false_positive.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..c215b24d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/old_decoy_false_positive.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+user 100 0 0 PM2 v6.0.13: God Daemon (/safe/.pm2)
+user 200 0 0 node /safe/tk log peer PM2 God text
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/one.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/one.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6d8a85d1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/one.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+PM2 v6.0.13: God Daemon (/Users/example/.pm2)
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/one_plus_decoy.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/one_plus_decoy.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..2e406a6b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/one_plus_decoy.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+PM2 v6.0.13: God Daemon (/Users/example/.pm2)
+node /safe/tk log TK-11848 peer PM2 God text
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/results.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/results.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..0b22d935
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/results.json
@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
+{
+  "assignment": "GOD=$(ps -axo command= | grep -cE '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon')",
+  "threshold": "[ \"${GOD:-1}\" -gt 1 ] && NEW=\"$NEW pm2-god:$GOD\"",
+  "installed_errexit": false,
+  "checks": [
+    {
+      "name": "old_decoy_false_positive",
+      "count": 2,
+      "assignment_rc": 0,
+      "signal": " pm2-god:2",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "zero",
+      "count": 0,
+      "assignment_rc": 1,
+      "signal": "",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "decoy_only",
+      "count": 0,
+      "assignment_rc": 1,
+      "signal": "",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "one",
+      "count": 1,
+      "assignment_rc": 0,
+      "signal": "",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "one_plus_decoy",
+      "count": 1,
+      "assignment_rc": 0,
+      "signal": "",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "two",
+      "count": 2,
+      "assignment_rc": 0,
+      "signal": " pm2-god:2",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "two_plus_decoy",
+      "count": 2,
+      "assignment_rc": 0,
+      "signal": " pm2-god:2",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "non_numeric_version",
+      "count": 0,
+      "assignment_rc": 1,
+      "signal": "",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "live_current",
+      "count": 1,
+      "assignment_rc": 0,
+      "signal": "",
+      "continued": true,
+      "verdict": "PASS"
+    }
+  ],
+  "real_second_daemon": {
+    "verdict": "SKIP",
+    "reason": "Daemon lifecycle not authorized; fixtures are replay evidence only"
+  }
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/two.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/two.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..49de0511
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/two.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+PM2 v6.0.13: God Daemon (/Users/example/.pm2)
+PM2 v6.0.14: God Daemon (/safe/scratch)
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/two_plus_decoy.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/two_plus_decoy.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ed62232f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/two_plus_decoy.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+PM2 v6.0.13: God Daemon (/Users/example/.pm2)
+PM2 v6.0.13: God Daemon (/Users/example/.pm2)
+node /safe/tk log TK-11848 peer PM2 God text
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/zero.fixture.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/zero.fixture.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..c93e1fb2
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/watch-replay/zero.fixture.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+launchd
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cost-assessment/assessment.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cost-assessment/assessment.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..42d2f686
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cost-assessment/assessment.json
@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
+{
+  "status": "complete_assessment_only",
+  "task": "yf2139-cost-assess",
+  "finalizer": "root",
+  "chain": [
+    "root",
+    "cost_assessment"
+  ],
+  "zero_cost": {
+    "config": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+    "env": "DTD_ZERO_COST=1",
+    "paid_calls": 0
+  },
+  "ownership": {
+    "children_status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11427",
+    "children_actions_before_assessment": 0,
+    "parent": "TK-11427",
+    "parent_status": "done",
+    "parent_status_at": "2026-09-16T21:24:35.018Z",
+    "process": "PID2842 claude alive; does not prove work on any child",
+    "active_collision": "NOT_ESTABLISHED; creator assignment alone not active claim"
+  },
+  "source_paths": [
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/price-finder/data/cost-source-triage.json",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/price-finder/scripts/cost-source-triage.mjs",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/price-finder/data/cost-backlog-blockers.json",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11427-osborne-join-repair.md",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-13-TK-11427-vendor-trade-discounts-unlock-cost-backlog.md",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/greenland-scraper-manager/SKILL.md",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/rigo-scraper-manager/SKILL.md",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/dw-price-integrity-gate/report.mjs",
+    "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/dw-price-integrity-gate/data/latest.json"
+  ],
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "ticket": "TK-11859",
+      "correlation_id": "yf2139-cost-assess-11859",
+      "existing": "Osborne repair memo has exact SQL, 58 matches, three divergences, approval choices; no additional join memo located.",
+      "missing": "Bucket is not a verified repair worklist: three cross-name table associations account for 4371/6243; selection origin and query errors are discarded; no priced-row filter.",
+      "increment": "Offline 18-vendor review JSON preserving source hash/totals, flag Phillip Jeffries/phillipe_romano_catalog (3392), Designer Wallcoverings/designers_guild_catalog (978), Studio Ditte/studio_printworks_catalog (1) as table identity unproven; remaining 15/1872 stay unverified. Do not execute or propose a repaired SQL join from these aggregate data."
+    },
+    {
+      "ticket": "TK-11861",
+      "correlation_id": "yf2139-cost-assess-11861",
+      "existing": "Aggregate triage 13066 active; candidate table474 populated price_retail rows;1082 key matches; ticket cites232 prefixes but distribution absent in inspected data. Existing18-vendor discount memo incorrectly treats umbrella as one discount.",
+      "missing": "Cohort source evidence, especially false59.50 cost anchor: canonical Greenland skill labels59.50 Retail Price and Shopify variant price; old quote-only text is superseded and cannot establish present cost absence.",
+      "increment": "Offline prefix/source evidence manifest: canonical Cork- Greenland (legacy DWGL-), DWWL- RIGO, DWPP- MDC; distinguish selling price59.50 from verified acquisition cost; historical counts labeled historical/current counts unmeasured; cite exact skill lines. No invented cost/rate or232-cohort sizing."
+    },
+    {
+      "ticket": "TK-11860",
+      "correlation_id": "yf2139-cost-assess-11860",
+      "existing": "Current triage26 strong vendors12852 active10704 key matches; old blocker report from Sep13 plus18-vendor discount memo; explicit external net quote verification method.",
+      "missing": "Fresh verification worklist and evidence distinction. Ticket examples include Malibu/Rebel outside actual26-strong bucket. Column population and key match counts are independent; price_source and price_effective_date can pass cost-ish regex; Newmor live_price derived evidence, not vendor net.",
+      "increment": "Offline26-vendor evidence request manifest from actual current STRONG_CANDIDATE rows preserving table/column/population/key counts and classifying all cost semantics UNPROVEN; flag nonnumeric-metadata/derived-name candidates and stale Sep13 discount facts. One exact required proof per vendor: dated vendor quote/invoice or authoritative price-list basis, SKU/unit/currency/discount provenance. This prepares external lookup without performing it."
+    },
+    {
+      "ticket": "TK-11858",
+      "correlation_id": "yf2139-cost-assess-11858",
+      "existing": "Canonical ticket documents14898 both authorities,2408 disagreements>10%,1621 retail signature; examples Designtex25 vs45.25 and Osborne216 vs333. Latest gate JSON gives aggregate coverage only; report.mjs strips cost value from costmap union and ORs existence.",
+      "missing": "No standalone conflict row dataset or local reproducible no-precedence counterexample artifact located; choosing winner or modifying live detector semantics remains out of assessment scope.",
+      "increment": "Offline counterexample fixture/proposal JSON from ticket examples (Designtex25/45.25, Osborne216/333) and stated aggregate counts, labeled historical ticket evidence, expected conflict/unmeasured without choosing authority. Include necessary future extract contract for per-product id/vendor/map source+value/stamp source+value/unit/currency/date; no invented current rows and no gate rewrite."
+    }
+  ],
+  "proof": {
+    "risk": "R0",
+    "checks": [
+      "Read canonical tickets in requested order",
+      "Read current triage source and aggregate JSON",
+      "Read existing gated memos",
+      "Read direct canonical ticket event ownership",
+      "Read vendor source anchors",
+      "Read gate existing predicate"
+    ],
+    "skipped": [
+      "No DB queries",
+      "No live API evidence refresh",
+      "No implementation",
+      "No pricing authority choice"
+    ],
+    "rollback": "No source mutation; only assessment artifact and coordination logs"
+  }
+}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cycle-record.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cycle-record.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..0ca9b386
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cycle-record.json
@@ -0,0 +1,512 @@
+{
+  "timestamp": "2026-09-16T22:35:40.961841+00:00",
+  "cycle_id": "yf2139.YF57g8",
+  "coordinator_ticket": "TK-11287-drive-open-tickets-in-board-order-using",
+  "source_tickets": [
+    "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+    "TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has",
+    "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+    "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
+    "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
+    "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+    "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+    "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+    "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+    "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+    "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+    "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40"
+  ],
+  "ordered_dispositions": [
+    {
+      "position": 1,
+      "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+      "disposition": "execute-local",
+      "reason": "Implemented offline18-row audit;3/4371cross-name candidate identities UNPROVEN,15/1872unverified; source cost repair remains blocked on identity/priced join evidence and gated adoption.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "join-parent-proof.json",
+        "join-audit/verification/e2e-proof.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 2,
+      "id": "TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has",
+      "disposition": "prepared-gated",
+      "reason": "Narrow handler-only removal patch verified; preserve7 local photos; exact active application and target activation await Steve.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "prestige-parent-proof.json",
+        "prestige/review.dtOpeo/handoff.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 3,
+      "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+      "disposition": "no-safe-increment",
+      "reason": "Existing corrected disk/reclaim memos unchanged; fresh pure canary WARN8percent78GiB, negative UNKNOWN; no missing safe prep reproduced. Cleanup remains gated.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "existing-memos.json",
+        "disk-probe.log.txt",
+        "reread-11784.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 4,
+      "id": "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+      "disposition": "prepared-gated",
+      "reason": "Concrete roster/capacity memo verified; missing Gemma, WARN8percent78GiB; intended contender and scoped download approval required.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "model-parent-proof.json",
+        "model-prep/handoff.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 5,
+      "id": "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
+      "disposition": "prepared-gated",
+      "reason": "Verified prefix/source manifest corrects59.50 to sellingprice only; actual acquisitioncost/currentcohortcounts NOT_MEASURED, external vendorproof needed before any gated costmap adoption.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "pr-parent-proof.json",
+        "pr-anchors/source-anchors.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 6,
+      "id": "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
+      "disposition": "prepared-gated",
+      "reason": "Actual26-row evidence-request manifest verified;10704keymatches and populatedcolumncounts kept separate. Vendor-external costbasis/units/currency/date/discount/identity proof needed before gatedadoption.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "column-parent-proof.json",
+        "column-manifest/manifest.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 7,
+      "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+      "disposition": "owner-active",
+      "reason": "Related masterdot worker TK11841 PID94755 and terminal ownerTK11831 PID42322 active; identity diagnosis overlaps their surface; no dispatcher edits/repaint.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "owner-refresh.json",
+        "TK-11851.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 8,
+      "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+      "disposition": "execute-local",
+      "reason": "Completed isolated committed one-line detector candidate;9parent-replayed checks PASS, installedsource unchanged. Operational activation and real2daemon proof remain gated/SKIP; sourceblocked, no closure.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "watch-parent-proof.json",
+        "watchtower/review.uegK64/handoff.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 9,
+      "id": "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+      "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+      "reason": "Safe offline authority-conflict fixtures identified by DW owner; not executed after6slots. Monetary precedence and canonical price writes remain unapproved.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11858.json",
+        "queue-final-reread.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 10,
+      "id": "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+      "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+      "reason": "Missing concrete credential restriction/quota/budget plan deferred after6slots. Both-host egress and measured cap prerequisite; identity/project changes remain gated.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11853.json",
+        "queue-final-reread.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 11,
+      "id": "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+      "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+      "reason": "Missing concrete29-offer appeal triage/parity packet deferred after6slots. Console appeals and outwardpolicy submissions gated; no blanket appeal authorization.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11847.json",
+        "queue-final-reread.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 12,
+      "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+      "disposition": "external-blocked",
+      "reason": "Explicit sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 and conflicting consolidator supersession require reconciliation/handoff; related terminal worker remains present. No router write/re-enable.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11838.json",
+        "existing-memos.json",
+        "parent-owner-state.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 13,
+      "id": "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+      "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+      "reason": "Shared gate/negative-price/productType and nested-repo residual fixes need isolated owner-aware work; deferred after6slots. No existing dirty/source edits taken.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11857.json",
+        "queue-final-reread.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 14,
+      "id": "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+      "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+      "reason": "57-job artifact classification needs per-job post-side-effect proof; deferred after6slots. Live creatorprocess alone not used as activeownership evidence.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11856.json",
+        "queue-final-reread.json"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "position": 15,
+      "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+      "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+      "reason": "Shared Merchant read-name repair can be isolated and boundarytested; deferred after6slots. No Merchant Center write authorized.",
+      "evidence": [
+        "TK-11846.json",
+        "queue-final-reread.json"
+      ]
+    }
+  ],
+  "execution_slots_used": 6,
+  "execution_cap": 6,
+  "actual_implementation_progress": {
+    "local_code_candidates": 3,
+    "evidence_manifests": 2,
+    "capacity_approval_packet": 1,
+    "description": "Offline join audit; Prestige handler patch; isolated Watchtower parser commit; PR source manifest; actual26-vendor cost evidence requests; Gemma roster/capacity memo. These six increments resolve zero operational outcomes for this cycle.",
+    "operational_writes": 0,
+    "tickets_closed_by_cycle": 0
+  },
+  "monitoring": {
+    "assessed_entries": 15,
+    "gates_collisions_reads_count_as_implementation": false,
+    "empirical": {
+      "timestamp": "2026-09-16T22:32:05.121635+00:00",
+      "scope": "cycle empirical observations and unchanged boundaries, not operational source completion",
+      "checks": [
+        {
+          "check": "cost_controls",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+          "environment": "1",
+          "dynamic_missing_environment": "SKIP; control deliberately not unset"
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "prestige_existing_API_photo",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "status": 200,
+          "photos": 7,
+          "image_status": 200,
+          "source_unchanged": true,
+          "candidate_runtime": "SKIP gated"
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "ollama_tags",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "models": [
+            "qwen2.5vl:7b",
+            "hermes3:8b",
+            "qwen3:14b"
+          ],
+          "gemma_missing": true,
+          "interpretation": "Observation only; no restore claim"
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "arena_unauth_API",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "http_status": 401,
+          "authenticated_availability": "NOT_MEASURED"
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "real_disk_probe_and_negative",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "observations": [
+            {
+              "unit": "Mac2",
+              "reachable": true,
+              "free_pct": 8,
+              "free_gb": 79,
+              "size_gb": 887,
+              "verdict": "WARN"
+            },
+            {
+              "unit": "Negative",
+              "reachable": false,
+              "verdict": "UNKNOWN"
+            }
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "cost_snapshot_unchanged",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "sha256": "fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a"
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "installed_watchtower_unchanged",
+          "verdict": "FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT",
+          "baseline_head": "5659b951a5da820786da84bfd2079187e5f899a8",
+          "observed_head": "a7e005c255e46255f9eb9b633af9502d03a66657",
+          "external_owner_evidence": "external-owner-drift.json",
+          "full_watch_run": "SKIP forbidden escalation path"
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "existing_scheduler",
+          "verdict": "PASS",
+          "interval": 600,
+          "stopped": false,
+          "launchctl_registered": true
+        },
+        {
+          "check": "modified_UI_CTA_screenrecord",
+          "verdict": "SKIP",
+          "reason": "No activated or runnable modified web/UI surface; R0 patch only; existing local API/media exercised. Source operational outcomes remain unverified."
+        }
+      ],
+      "verdict": "PARTIAL: external-owner installed Watchtower drift; other scoped empirical checks recorded; operational critical paths SKIP and source tickets unresolved"
+    },
+    "peer_watchtower_status": "done",
+    "peer_watchtower_owner": "night-TK-11848",
+    "peer_claims_independently_certified": false
+  },
+  "action": "Retain reviewed local artifacts, record blockers, preserve peer ownership, exit bounded cycle",
+  "dtd_verdicts": {
+    "increment1": {
+      "verdict": "A",
+      "valid_tally": "5/5",
+      "dissent": "none; limitations and gates retained",
+      "votes": {
+        "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+        "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+        "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "qwen.txt": "VERDICT: A  \nPreparation is required to ensure compliance with hard gates and ZERO_COST constraints. A LOCAL patch artifact must isolate removal of the unused /api/places/photo/:i route while preserving local photo rendering logic and /api/places mapping, as confirmed by server.js analysis. An approval memo is necessary to document assumptions (e.g., no active dependencies on the removed route, local photo plumbing integrity) and flag any proposal changes. Source/data assumptions must be explicitly reproduced to avoid unintended deletions, and the absence of an existing ticket-specific approval memo necessitates this step. No credential/production changes are permitted, aligning with DTD_ZERO_COST=1 and local-only execution requirements.\n",
+        "codex.txt": "VERDICT: A\n\nCanonical reread confirms TK-11850 remains open and assigned to claude-run-11615; the checkout is clean at `59d77fc`. All seven photo entries resolve to existing local files, with zero Google references. Prepare removal only of the proxy handler and its accompanying comment, preserving `/api/places`, `photo_urls`, and `/media` rendering. This explicitly corrects the ticket\u2019s broader \u201cdelete photos plumbing\u201d proposal; future Google references would still map to the removed endpoint and require separate review. Artifact persistence is blocked by this session\u2019s read-only filesystem, so no patch or approval memo was saved, no ownership claimed, and no closure or execution performed.",
+        "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+        "root": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare exact patch with local image boundary preserved; execution remains gated.\n",
+        "ops": "VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the bounded local patch artifact and approval memo because canonical TK-11850 describes dormant cleanup with no current customer degradation, so creating a key adds credential scope and operational obligations without an established need. The ticket recommendation to delete photos plumbing is broader than the supplied source finding that /api/places maps local images; preserve that mapping and local rendering, and explicitly record the narrower proposal as a correction requiring review. Before proposing route removal, reproduce the local-versus-Google-reference mapping and data assumptions so latent proxy dependencies are surfaced rather than silently severed. Keep the active checkout, service, credentials, and data unchanged, attach evidence and a reversible patch for Steve to review, and retain the source ticket until any approved execution is separately verified.\n\nGuard evidence: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1. Read complete a2a-contract and dtd skills and canonical TK-11850 with tk show. Codex voter only; no Claude runtime, external model APIs, or provider spend. Correlation: yf2139-i1-ops.\n",
+        "risk": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare the local patch and approval memo because this permits review without introducing credential exposure, spending authority, or a customer-facing change. The canonical TK-11850 record confirms a dormant key-dependent route and manual scripts, but its earlier suggestion to delete photos plumbing is broader than the present bounded increment: preserve local-photo rendering and /api/places mapping, verify current source/data and references, and explicitly report any Google-reference mapping left pointing at the proposed removed route. The patch must remain an artifact, with no active checkout edits, credential creation, deployment, ticket closure, or assertion that customer behavior is unchanged without evidence. B crosses the credential gate unnecessarily; C leaves authorized low-risk preparation undone.\n\nGuard evidence: independently read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read complete a2a-contract/SKILL.md and dtd/SKILL.md and reread canonical ticket with tk show TK-11850. No other voter outputs read. Provider spend: $0; no Claude runtime or paid APIs.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i1-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Remaining gate: Steve approval for any active/customer-facing/credential execution. Safest next action: parent independently review artifact and prepare the bounded proposal.\n"
+      },
+      "cost_usd": 0
+    },
+    "increment2": {
+      "verdict": "A",
+      "valid_tally": "5/5",
+      "dissent": "none; limitations and gates retained",
+      "votes": {
+        "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+        "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+        "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "qwen.txt": "VERDICT: A  \nPreparation only: A local approval memo is required to restore gemma3:12b, contingent on Steve confirming its intended use and approving the ~8GB download against a fresh disk preflight. The memo must document source roster/tag evidence (e.g., server.js inclusion of gemma3:12b, /api/tags listing qwen2.5vl:7b, hermes3:8b, qwen3:14b) and downstream partial-rating risks (e.g., Mac2 canary WARN8percent78GiB, missing-input UNKNOWN returns). No pull/roster changes or battle actions are permitted without explicit Steve-gated authorization. Existing ticket-specific memo absence is noted, and runtime output files remain isolated but dirty. Model production restart/roster mutation remains under Steve\u2019s control. Codex CLI/local endpoints enforce ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 guardrails. No closure actions are taken.\n",
+        "codex.txt": "VERDICT: A\n\nTK-11852 \u00b7 cycle yf2139.YF57g8 \u2014 Approval memo draft: Restore `gemma3:12b` only after Steve confirms it remains intended and approves the ~8GB download against a fresh Mac2 disk preflight. [Source roster](/Users/macstudio3/Projects/model-arena/server.js:78) includes it; supplied `/api/tags` observations list only `qwen2.5vl:7b`, `hermes3:8b`, and `qwen3:14b`. Disk helper reported `WARN8percent78GiB`; missing-input test returned `UNKNOWN`. Arena `/api/models` returned unauthenticated 401, so availability remains unverified. Missing contenders risk incomplete battle coverage and partial ratings. Creator11723 was absent from the supplied exact owner scan; canonical source remains open. Preserve `ZERO_COST_REQUIRED=1`; no pull, restart, roster change, battle, or closure. Runtime outputs remain untouched. Local memo persistence is blocked by this session\u2019s read-only filesystem; this draft was not saved.",
+        "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+        "root": "VERDICT: A\nEvidence-based gated restoration proposal preserves roster intent and disk safety.\n",
+        "ops": "VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the local approval memo because the current source roster and reported live tags show a configuration-versus-capacity discrepancy, but neither proves whether gemma3:12b was deliberately retired. A blind roughly 8GB pull would consume scarce disk on a host with a disk-critical history, while deleting the contender would change the meaning of future ratings without a confirmed product decision. The memo should present the roster/tag evidence, distinguish the historical ticket claim about /api/models from the present unauthenticated 401, explain the risk of apparently complete ratings from a reduced field, and ask Steve to confirm roster intent before any restoration. If restoration is approved, require a fresh disk preflight with capacity headroom for download and extraction; neither this memo nor the existing WARN reading authorizes a pull, battle, restart, live roster edit, or ticket closure.\n\nGuard evidence: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1 again for this increment; canonical TK-11852 read using tk show. Codex only, no external provider calls, spend $0. Correlation: yf2139-i2-ops.\n",
+        "risk": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare the approval memo because the missing intended contender can bias subsequent ratings, but neither a model download nor a live roster removal is authorized. Preserve the distinction between directly observed Ollama tags and source roster evidence, historical ticket observations, and the presently unverified authenticated API availability field. The reported 78 GiB free does not nullify the 8-percent disk warning or prove that an approximately 8 GB download plus transient storage is safe under concurrent workloads; require a fresh capacity check and Steve confirmation that gemma3:12b remains intended before any pull. Record the partial-rating risk and require post-approval verification of model availability and participant completeness before claiming recovery. B spends storage and changes runtime state without approval; C changes contest semantics without confirming retirement intent.\n\nGuard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment2-question.txt and reread canonical TK-11852 with tk show. Required a2a-contract and dtd skills were read in full earlier in this same delegated session. No other voter outputs read. Provider spend $0; no paid API or Claude runtime.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i2-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Remaining gates: confirmation of intended contender and approval for download or live roster mutation. Safest next action: parent independently inspect this vote and prepare a factual local approval memo, without closing the source ticket.\n"
+      },
+      "cost_usd": 0
+    },
+    "increment3": {
+      "verdict": "A",
+      "valid_votes_seen": 5,
+      "votes": {
+        "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+        "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+        "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "qwen.txt": "VERDICT: A  \nThe correct action is to prepare the isolated detector fix as specified, replacing `argv grep` with `ps -axo command=` to ensure accurate detection of the PM2 daemon process (`^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon`). This avoids invoking `watch.sh` (which risks unauthorized Claude interactions or state alterations) and adheres to the prohibition against modifying scheduled scripts or starting/stoping PM2. Testing with decoy text and command fixtures at the parser-to-alert threshold ensures robustness without compromising the $0 guard/env or source integrity. The proposed fix from vp-operations aligns with the ticket\u2019s requirement to avoid real second-daemon operational proof pending approval, while maintaining HEAD5659b95\u2019s clean state and avoiding scheduled writer collisions.\n",
+        "codex.txt": "VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare an isolated, committed one-line detector fix from clean HEAD `5659b95` for TK-11848, cycle `yf2139.YF57g8`, using `ps -axo command=` and anchored `^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon`. Independently verify live single-daemon detection, decoy rejection, and zero/one/two-daemon fixtures through the parser-to-alert threshold; include replay/negative tests and an activation memo. Preserve the $0 guard/env. Do not invoke `watch.sh`, Claude, paid endpoints, daemon lifecycle operations, sends, or installed-script changes. Explicitly **SKIP real second-daemon operational proof pending approval**; keep the source ticket open and live scheduled activation gated.",
+        "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+        "root": "VERDICT: A\nIsolate and prove parser boundary now; operational activation and real second-daemon proof stay gated.\n",
+        "ops": "VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare and commit the isolated detector fix because process-command anchoring directly addresses the documented false alarm while leaving the active scheduled watcher untouched. Read the original script to preserve its actual shell/error semantics, and make the zero-daemon fixture verify both the resulting count and whether grep -c returning status 1 can prematurely terminate the caller; one/two-daemon fixtures must drive the real parser-to-alert threshold rather than a separately invented interpretation. Use read-only live process output to confirm the current genuine daemon spelling and prove decoy command arguments do not count. Keep activation and a real second-daemon lifecycle test explicitly unperformed and gated: fixture success validates the bounded patch, not the complete operational repair, so the source ticket remains open until authorized real-path proof is accepted.\n\nDirect guard evidence: /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1. Canonical TK-11848 reread; installed watch.sh not invoked, no daemon/source action or delegation. Provider spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i3-ops.\n",
+        "risk": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare the isolated committed detector fix and activation memo because the canonical evidence identifies an argv-text false positive and the anchored command-column match directly addresses it without executing the installed watcher. The replay must exercise the actual parser-to-alert threshold with zero, one, and two daemon fixtures plus embedded decoy text, and verify the zero-match exit behavior: grep -cE prints 0 but returns status 1, which can abort scripts under errexit instead of producing the intended alert. Inspect the actual shell options and threshold logic, report any necessary deviation from the proposed one-line scope, and validate the local live single-daemon measurement independently. Fixture success cannot establish the real second-daemon operational path; label that critical check skipped and retain the source ticket open pending authorized lifecycle testing and scheduled activation. B risks Claude execution, sends, and runtime mutation; C leaves a concrete, authorized correction unprepared.\n\nGuard evidence: freshly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment3-question.txt and canonical TK-11848 with tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills were read earlier in the same delegated session. No other votes read; no watch.sh execution. Provider spend $0, no Claude runtime or paid API.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i3-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Gates retained: installed script activation, daemon lifecycle, sends, and actual second-daemon proof. Safest next action: parent independently review the vote and prepare the isolated patch and bounded evidence, with source completion explicitly withheld.\n"
+      },
+      "cost_usd": 0,
+      "dissent": "none among received votes",
+      "rejected_details": []
+    },
+    "increment4": {
+      "verdict": "A",
+      "valid_votes_seen": 5,
+      "votes": {
+        "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+        "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+        "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "qwen.txt": "VERDICT: A  \n**Option A: Create a reusable OFFLINE audit script and retain JSON/Markdown artifacts**  \n\nThe task requires generating a **reusable OFFLINE audit script** from the existing `cost-source-triage.json` artifact, preserving metadata (`source_hash`, `generated_at`, and original totals: 18/6243/0). The script must:  \n1. **Enumerate 18 COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN rows**\u2014columns with no valid join relationships, which may indicate data integrity gaps or orphaned entries. These rows are preserved without modification.  \n2. **Mark three cross-name table candidates** as `UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY` (e.g., `Phillip Jeffries->phillipe_romano_catalog3392`, `Designer Wallcoverings->designers_guild_catalog978`, `Studio Ditte->studio_printworks_catalog1`), explicitly noting their impact on 4371 products. These are flagged due to **heuristic mismatches** (e.g., name variations, catalog ID discrepancies) but not inferred as proven.  \n3. **Document six key attempts** to resolve these mismatches (e.g., fuzzy matching, catalog ID alignment, metadata cross-referencing) and **silent SQL errors** (e.g., uncaught join failures, missing constraints).  \n4. **Avoid priced-row filtering** to ensure no assumptions about reachability or cost coverage are made.  \n\nThe script must **test real artifacts** (e.g., valid `cost-source-triage.json`) and **malformed/mismatched inputs** (e.g., invalid catalog IDs, missing hashes) to validate robustness. No DB/API queries, cost-map edits, or canonical/customer mutations are permitted.  \n\n**Key Heuristics**:  \n- **Cross-name candidates** are flagged due to name variations (e.g., \"Phillip Jeffries\" vs. \"phillipe_romano_catalog3392\") or catalog ID mismatches, suggesting potential ownership gaps.  \n- **Zero reachability** is not proven absent explicit cost or join validation, aligning with the \"no priced-row filtering\" constraint.  \n- **Arithmetic verification** (18/6243 + 4371) ensures consistency with prior generator output (parent TK11427).  \n\nThis approach adheres to the requirement for **independent root verification** and avoids ownership claims beyond the audit scope. The script is isolated, artifact-based, and compliant with $0 guard/env constraints.\n",
+        "codex.txt": "VERDICT: A\n\nCreate the isolated offline audit, preserving source hash, generated_at, all 18 rows and original 18/6243/0 totals. Mark the three cross-name candidates UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY (4,371 products); the other 15 remain unproven. Heuristic table selection, six attempted keys, swallowed SQL errors and no priced-row filtering cannot establish absent cost or broken joins. Require real-input validation and malformed/mismatched-input rejection. Creator process activity does not prove child ownership. This is preparation only, with no coverage lift or source closure.\n\nExecution is blocked by this session\u2019s read-only filesystem: no script or retained artifacts were created, and no tests were run.",
+        "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+        "root": "VERDICT: A\nCorrect the evidence classification without inventing cost facts or touching pricing.\n",
+        "ops": "VERDICT: A\n\nCreate the isolated offline audit because retaining the original report and separating heuristic evidence from proven table identity is the most useful bounded correction before any live cost-authority work. Preserve the input hash, generated_at, all 18 rows, and original 18/6243/0 totals; mark the three named cross-table candidates UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY with their combined 4371-product impact without implying the other 15 identities are verified. The output must explain that six attempted join keys, swallowed SQL errors, and missing priced-row filtering cannot establish either absent cost or a broken authoritative join; do not silently reclassify historical zero reachability as a trustworthy measurement. Fail explicitly on malformed or structurally mismatched input and retain real-artifact evidence, while keeping source ownership unchanged and all DB, API, cost-map, pricing, and customer changes outside scope. The live creator process does not prove current ownership of this child task, but the independent offline output also avoids competing with that process.\n\nGuard evidence: independently read config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and environment DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11859 reread. This artifact and its ticket log are the only writes; no other ballots, source edits, APIs, database calls, or paid providers. Cost $0. Correlation yf2139-i4-ops.\n",
+        "risk": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare the offline audit and retained artifacts because the source classification overstates what heuristic table selection and six attempted keys can establish. Preserve 18 vendors, 6243 active products, and 0 reported reachable as original report values with source hash and generated_at, not fresh canonical findings. Mark the three named cross-name associations UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY affecting 4371 products; name differences alone establish neither a valid association nor a definitive mismatch, and the other 15 associations remain unverified. Record that silently caught SQL errors, limited key attempts, and absent priced-row filtering prevent the reported zero from proving absent costs or a broken join. Validate expected schema, class count, numeric totals, and malformed/mismatched rejection before emitting conclusions; avoid any implicit cost-coverage lift or repair authorization. B would change live cost authority on insufficient evidence; C leaves a misleading repair premise uncorrected.\n\nGuard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment4-question.txt and canonical TK-11859 via tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills were read earlier in this delegated session. No other ballots read. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API query, or source mutation.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i4-risk\nStatus: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edits or commit. Residual uncertainty: all 18 candidate table identities and live cost reachability require separate verification; the saved report cannot establish present canonical state. Remaining gates: any cost-map, price-source, canonical, or customer mutation. Safest next action: parent independently inspect this vote and prepare the offline evidence correction, keeping TK-11859 open.\n"
+      },
+      "cost_usd": 0,
+      "dissent": "none among received votes",
+      "rejected_details": [
+        "Qwen invented fuzzy matching/key examples and table suffix numbers in increment4; use literal generator KEYS and tables only"
+      ]
+    },
+    "increment5": {
+      "decision": "A",
+      "tally": "5/5valid",
+      "dissent": "none",
+      "votes": {
+        "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+        "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+        "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "qwen.txt": "**VERDICT: A**  \n\n**Paragraph:**  \nOption A is the correct choice because it aligns with the canonical definitions and audit requirements. The ticket claim incorrectly treats Greenland59.50 as a cost, but the canonical skill explicitly identifies it as a **Yard variant/Retail Price**, not a cost. This necessitates marking **SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE** and rejecting the use of Greenland59.50 as a cost (invalidating Option B). Older quote-only notes are explicitly superseded, ensuring no outdated data influences current wholesale absence claims. By preparing an **offline source-anchor manifest** with exact bounded increments, canonical terms (e.g., Cork-legacy DWGL-, DWWL-=RIGO, DWPP-=MDC), and source file hashes, the integrity of Phillipe Romano\u2019s cost sourcing is preserved. Acquisition cost and cohort counts are correctly marked **NOT_MEASURED**, avoiding invented decomposition prefixes (e.g., \"invented232prefix\"). Retaining **PR13066** as active and isolating key-matched rows from catalog rows ensures compliance with cardinality proof requirements. No edits to DB/API/customer/price-map systems are permitted, and the parent\u2019s independent verification of scraper-manager skills confirms the isolated additive evidence. Option C (no correction) would perpetuate the erroneous ticket claim, while Option B conflates retail price with cost. Thus, **A** is the only valid path to rectify the claim and uphold data accuracy.\n",
+        "codex.txt": "**VERDICT: A.** Prepare only an isolated, additive offline source-anchor manifest with file hashes and exact cited lines: canonical `Cork-` (legacy `DWGL-`), `DWWL-` = RIGO, and `DWPP-` = MDC. The complete Greenland skill explicitly labels $59.50 as Yard variant/Retail Price: **SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE**; superseded quote-only notes cannot establish current wholesale absence. Acquisition cost and cohort counts remain **NOT_MEASURED**, with no invented 232-prefix decomposition. Preserve reported 13,066 active and 1,082 key-matched separately from 474 populated catalog rows; infer no count bound without cardinality proof. Keep execution Codex/local-only, $0, with environment guards and no DB/API/customer/source/price-map edits. Creator-parent completion establishes no active child claim; this evidence increment does not complete cost sourcing.",
+        "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+        "root": "VERDICT: A\nSource-anchor correction prevents sell-price-to-cost confusion without creating cost authority.\n",
+        "ops": "VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the offline source-anchor manifest because correcting a sell-price-versus-acquisition-cost assumption is necessary before the proposed cost model can be reviewed responsibly. Preserve canonical prefix provenance, exact cited source lines and file hashes, explicitly classify 59.50 as SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE, and leave acquisition cost and unsampled cohort counts NOT_MEASURED; superseded quote-only language supplies historical context but cannot prove current wholesale absence. Keep 13,066 active products, 1,082 key matches, and 474 populated candidate catalog rows as separately labeled report measurements, since join fan-out, uniqueness, row predicates and distinct-product cardinality have not been proved, and do not invent a decomposition for the claimed 232 prefixes. This additive manifest advances a concrete correction without competing with creator work or changing canonical cost authority; subsequent sourcing, live reads, pricing changes and source-ticket closure remain outside this decision.\n\nGuard evidence: directly reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11861 reread. No DB/API/source edits, claims, other ballots, terminal painting, Claude runtime or delegation. Provider spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i5-ops.\n",
+        "risk": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare the offline source-anchor manifest because the ticket risks turning a documented retail selling price into acquisition cost across a private-label umbrella. Cite and hash the canonical sources for Cork- (legacy DWGL-), DWWL-, and DWPP- without claiming those anchors exhaust or size the reported 232 prefixes. Label 59.50 SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE, acquisition cost and current cohort counts NOT_MEASURED, and superseded quote-only notes historical rather than proof of present wholesale absence. Retain the reported 13066 active products, 1082 key matches, and 474 populated catalog rows as distinct measurements: without uniqueness, fan-out, priced-row, and key-domain proof, their relationship establishes neither priced yield nor a product-count bound. The artifact corrects evidence interpretation only; any acquisition-cost authority or source closure requires separate verification. B risks propagating an unsupported cost; C preserves a material misconception.\n\nGuard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment5-question.txt and canonical TK-11861 via tk show; no other ballots. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills previously read in this delegated session. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API queries, or source edits.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i5-risk\nStatus: complete (independent decision vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Residual risk: current acquisition costs, cohort distribution, join cardinality, and priced coverage remain unmeasured. Remaining gates: any source/price-map/canonical/customer mutation. Safest next action: parent independently verify source anchors and construct the isolated additive manifest when the preceding increment permits; do not claim a coverage lift or close TK-11861.\n"
+      },
+      "cost_usd": 0,
+      "operational_authority": false
+    },
+    "increment6": {
+      "decision": "A",
+      "tally": "5/5valid",
+      "dissent": "none",
+      "votes": {
+        "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+        "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+        "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+        "qwen.txt": "**VERDICT: A**  \n\n**Paragraph:**  \nOption **A** is the only viable path to ensure compliance with the declared-sourcing requirements while preserving data integrity and avoiding unproven assumptions. Preparing an **offline evidence-request manifest** for the **ACTUAL26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows** explicitly enforces the need for **SKU-matched vendor-external quotes/invoices**, **unit/currency/date alignment**, and **evidence-backed discounts**\u2014all critical to validate cost mappings without relying on unverified metadata (e.g., `price_source/price_effective_date` or `Newmor live_price`). By **preserving candidate table/key/populated-column counts and key-match counts separately**, the process avoids conflating data completeness with cost reachability, which is explicitly disallowed.  \n\nStructural/total validation of the **real artifact** and **malformed data** ensures no DB/API/source/cost-map edits are made, preserving the original state of the **cost-source-triage.json** and **historical totals26/12852/10704**. This aligns with the requirement to **block external cost evidence** until verified, preventing premature financial measurement/coverage lifts. While **B** (turning 10704 keymatched into verifiedcost) and **C** (leaving correction undone) may appear expedient, they risk unproven cost assertions or data stagnation. **A** ensures the **ticket remains blocked** until external evidence is formally submitted, maintaining governance and preventing gated adoption without rigorous validation. The **$0guard/env/Codexlocal** context further reinforces the need for artifact-only processing, avoiding any environmental dependencies. Thus, **A** is the only choice that satisfies all constraints: **no edits, no unproven metadata, and strict evidence requirements**.\n",
+        "codex.txt": "**VERDICT: A.** Independently read the generator and actual 26 rows; historical totals reconcile to **26 / 12,852 / 10,704**, generated `2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z`. Prepare only the offline manifest, retaining source SHA-256 and every candidate table, key, populated-column count, and key-match count separately. The generator matches keys without requiring populated prices and swallows query errors; names and discount stamps prove neither priced-row reachability nor net cost. Flag `price_source`/`price_effective_date` as metadata-shaped and Newmor `live_price` as unproven. Require declared vendor/table provenance, SKU-matched vendor-external quote/invoice, unit, currency, effective date, and evidence-backed discount before mapping. Include structural/total validation and malformed-input rejection. No sends, DB/API/source/cost-map edits, fresh financial measurement, or coverage lift; preserve $0/env/Codex-local constraints. TK-11860 stays blocked pending external evidence and later gated adoption.",
+        "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+        "root": "VERDICT: A\nActual26-row evidence manifest is concrete safe prep; no cost assertion from shape or join.\n",
+        "ops": "VERDICT: A\n\nPrepare the offline evidence-request manifest from the report's literal 26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows rather than the ticket's mixed illustrative vendor list, preserving source hash, timestamp and historical 26/12852/10704 totals. Keep populated-column counts and key-match counts separate: the generator's unrestricted key matching and swallowed query errors do not prove populated priced-row reachability, verified net acquisition cost, or a trustworthy coverage lift. Explicitly flag metadata-shaped price_source and price_effective_date columns and unproven derived live_price evidence; for every candidate require a SKU-matched vendor-external quote, invoice or authoritative price basis, dated unit/currency terms, and documented discount provenance where applicable. Structural and total-validation failures must stop generation rather than silently drop rows, while the resulting manifest prepares a precise sourcing request without querying live systems, sending messages, adopting prices, or closing the source ticket.\n\nGuard evidence: directly reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11860 read. Own this vote file and required source log only. No other ballots, source edits or claims, DB/API calls, external messages, paid endpoints or Claude runtime. Spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i6-ops.\n",
+        "risk": "VERDICT: A\nPrepare the offline evidence-request manifest from the actual 26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows because the ticket currently conflates matched keys, populated columns, and verified acquisition costs, and its example vendor list diverges from that artifact. Preserve source hash/generated_at and historical 26/12852/10704 totals, with candidate identity, key-match counts, and each populated-column count kept separate. Neither 10704 key matches nor column population proves their intersection, priced reachability, join uniqueness, or net-cost semantics; swallowed query errors further limit the report. Mark price_source and price_effective_date metadata-shaped rather than confirmed price values, leave Newmor live_price unproven, and require SKU-matched vendor-external evidence with unit, currency, effective date, price basis, and any evidence-backed discount before adoption. One example SKU can support an evidence request but cannot automatically validate every row or vendor-wide discount. B converts unverified matches into financial authority; C preserves a misleading readiness claim.\n\nGuard evidence: freshly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment6-question.txt and canonical TK-11860 with tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills previously read in the same delegated session. No other ballots read. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API query, or external message.\nCorrelation: yf2139-i6-risk\nStatus: complete (independent decision vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit, claim, or commit. Residual risk: all financial semantics, current measurements, priced-row reachability, and vendor-wide applicability remain unverified. Remaining gates: external messaging and later cost-map/canonical/customer adoption. Safest next action: parent independently inspect vote and prepare structurally validated source-faithful requests; do not claim cost coverage or source completion, and retain the external-evidence dependency.\n"
+      },
+      "cost_usd": 0,
+      "operational_authority": false
+    }
+  },
+  "cody": {
+    "verdict": "SHIP IT isolated preparation artifacts; operational PARTIAL / UNVERIFIED",
+    "top_fix": "Reproduced stale position8 report corrected; final external-owner drift retained as FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT",
+    "evidence": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/cody/final-addendum.json"
+  },
+  "final_dtd_verdict": "HOLD-FOR-STEVE",
+  "final_dtd_tally": "5/5 valid",
+  "tests_evidence": {
+    "report": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/REPORT.md",
+    "join_tests": 6,
+    "watchtower_checks": 9,
+    "other_evidence": [
+      "prestige-parent-proof.json",
+      "model-parent-proof.json",
+      "pr-parent-proof.json",
+      "column-parent-proof.json",
+      "empirical-final.json"
+    ],
+    "source_critical_paths": "SKIP or unresolved; no source completion claim"
+  },
+  "next_seed": "Fresh canonical queue and ownership check. Reconcile peer Watchtower closure evidence; cost-authority conflict TK11858 only if not owned by another active worker. No new implementation after six slots.",
+  "gated_memos": [
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md",
+      "sha256": "c2b345515c007293bf407e108134426a34748afe69b77af394e8c24a961625c1",
+      "state": "pending_approval",
+      "copy": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md",
+      "sha256": "34c462e4a20182ed14d2ac5b62058d6e6d6af919128ebfbcc05cb74e4381a2bf",
+      "state": "pending_approval",
+      "copy": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/_done/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md",
+      "sha256": "907658b8314ef432fa21105dee5db70c9c21577bd5924df24c4eb498418adfb6",
+      "state": "moved_done_by_other_worker_claims_unverified",
+      "copy": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md"
+    }
+  ],
+  "existing_memos": [
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md",
+      "exists": true,
+      "sha256": "b0ccba428030d8b4760a319c3e80023e9677d6453d4f23b2b3e129ed8bdae7b3"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11821-mac2-disk-reclaim-2026-09-16.md",
+      "exists": true,
+      "sha256": "7bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11837-color-columns-python-api-pivot.md",
+      "exists": true,
+      "sha256": "a7d7cfeb5983a93df549491497a97de9dff9816d033d16b006979f3add25ca9f"
+    }
+  ],
+  "cost": {
+    "provider_api_usd": 0,
+    "codex_cli_usage": "not independently metered",
+    "guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+    "DTD_ZERO_COST": "1",
+    "controls_changed": false
+  },
+  "deviations": {
+    "execution_order": {
+      "execution_cap": 6,
+      "execution_order": [
+        {
+          "slot": 1,
+          "position": 2,
+          "ticket": "TK-11850",
+          "decision": 1
+        },
+        {
+          "slot": 2,
+          "position": 4,
+          "ticket": "TK-11852",
+          "decision": 2
+        },
+        {
+          "slot": 3,
+          "position": 1,
+          "ticket": "TK-11859",
+          "decision": 4
+        },
+        {
+          "slot": 4,
+          "position": 5,
+          "ticket": "TK-11861",
+          "decision": 5
+        },
+        {
+          "slot": 5,
+          "position": 6,
+          "ticket": "TK-11860",
+          "decision": 6
+        },
+        {
+          "slot": 6,
+          "position": 8,
+          "ticket": "TK-11848",
+          "decision": 3
+        }
+      ],
+      "order_deviation": "Initial cost-owner-active classification relied on live creator process. Subsequent canonical parent status showed DONE; process alone did not prove child ownership. Positions2and4 preparation occurred before correcting position1; later execution held until positions1,5,6 were assessed and prepared. This ordering deviation is recorded, not described as strict execution order.",
+      "prevent_recurrence": "Check canonical parent/source ownership and recent ticket activity before treating process liveness as a collision. Isolated local prep can remain safe."
+    },
+    "fixture_retention": "Initial join test harness cleanup violated retention; corrected to retained fresh dirs and independently retested; no source/prod deletion",
+    "evidence_collector": "Duplicate argument corrected; rerun exposed real external source drift, not hidden"
+  },
+  "scheduler": {
+    "existing_interval_seconds": 600,
+    "changed": false,
+    "STOPPED": false
+  },
+  "correlation_id": "yf2139-final"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..800ba42b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+{"unit":"Mac2","reachable":true,"free_pct":8,"free_gb":78,"size_gb":887,"verdict":"WARN"}
+{"unit":"Negative","reachable":false,"verdict":"UNKNOWN"}
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.sh b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.sh
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6f868a01
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/disk-probe.sh
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+WARN_PCT=12
+CRIT_PCT=7
+probe_unit(){ # args: label  df-command...
+  local label="$1"; shift
+  local line; line="$("$@" 2>/dev/null | awk 'NR==2{print}')"
+  if [ -z "$line" ]; then
+    echo "{\"unit\":\"$label\",\"reachable\":false,\"verdict\":\"UNKNOWN\"}"; return
+  fi
+  # df -k columns: Filesystem Size Used Avail Capacity ... ; sizes in 1K blocks
+  local used avail size freepct freegb sizegb verdict
+  used=$(echo "$line"  | awk '{print $3}')
+  avail=$(echo "$line" | awk '{print $4}')
+  [ -z "$used" ] && used=0; [ -z "$avail" ] && avail=0
+  size=$((used+avail))
+  if [ "$size" -le 0 ]; then echo "{\"unit\":\"$label\",\"reachable\":false,\"verdict\":\"UNKNOWN\"}"; return; fi
+  freepct=$(( avail*100/size ))
+  freegb=$(( avail/1024/1024 ))
+  sizegb=$(( size/1024/1024 ))
+  if   [ "$freepct" -lt "$CRIT_PCT" ]; then verdict="CRITICAL"
+  elif [ "$freepct" -lt "$WARN_PCT" ]; then verdict="WARN"
+  else verdict="OK"; fi
+  echo "{\"unit\":\"$label\",\"reachable\":true,\"free_pct\":$freepct,\"free_gb\":$freegb,\"size_gb\":$sizegb,\"verdict\":\"$verdict\"}"
+}
+
+probe_unit Mac2 df -k /System/Volumes/Data
+probe_unit Negative false
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/dispositions.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/dispositions.json
index 8cdda24c..eea7eabf 100644
--- a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/dispositions.json
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/dispositions.json
@@ -2,11 +2,11 @@
   {
     "position": 1,
     "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
-    "disposition": "external-blocked",
-    "reason": "PROVISIONAL reassessment: creator process exists but parentTK11427 is done21:24Z; active-source ownership not proven. Domain owner assessing existing artifacts and first safe preparation before final disposition.",
+    "disposition": "execute-local",
+    "reason": "Implemented offline18-row audit;3/4371cross-name candidate identities UNPROVEN,15/1872unverified; source cost repair remains blocked on identity/priced join evidence and gated adoption.",
     "evidence": [
-      "TK-11859.json",
-      "owner-processes.json"
+      "join-parent-proof.json",
+      "join-audit/verification/e2e-proof.json"
     ]
   },
   {
@@ -26,7 +26,7 @@
     "reason": "Existing corrected disk/reclaim memos unchanged; fresh pure canary WARN8percent78GiB, negative UNKNOWN; no missing safe prep reproduced. Cleanup remains gated.",
     "evidence": [
       "existing-memos.json",
-      "disk-probe.log",
+      "disk-probe.log.txt",
       "reread-11784.json"
     ]
   },
@@ -43,21 +43,21 @@
   {
     "position": 5,
     "id": "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
-    "disposition": "external-blocked",
-    "reason": "PROVISIONAL reassessment: creator process exists but parentTK11427 is done21:24Z; active-source ownership not proven. Domain owner assessing existing artifacts and first safe preparation before final disposition.",
+    "disposition": "prepared-gated",
+    "reason": "Verified prefix/source manifest corrects59.50 to sellingprice only; actual acquisitioncost/currentcohortcounts NOT_MEASURED, external vendorproof needed before any gated costmap adoption.",
     "evidence": [
-      "owner-refresh.json",
-      "TK-11861.json"
+      "pr-parent-proof.json",
+      "pr-anchors/source-anchors.json"
     ]
   },
   {
     "position": 6,
     "id": "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
-    "disposition": "external-blocked",
-    "reason": "PROVISIONAL reassessment: creator process exists but parentTK11427 is done21:24Z; active-source ownership not proven. Domain owner assessing existing artifacts and first safe preparation before final disposition.",
+    "disposition": "prepared-gated",
+    "reason": "Actual26-row evidence-request manifest verified;10704keymatches and populatedcolumncounts kept separate. Vendor-external costbasis/units/currency/date/discount/identity proof needed before gatedadoption.",
     "evidence": [
-      "owner-refresh.json",
-      "TK-11860.json"
+      "column-parent-proof.json",
+      "column-manifest/manifest.json"
     ]
   },
   {
@@ -69,5 +69,86 @@
       "owner-refresh.json",
       "TK-11851.json"
     ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 8,
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "disposition": "execute-local",
+    "reason": "Completed isolated committed one-line detector candidate;9parent-replayed checks PASS, installedsource unchanged. Operational activation and real2daemon proof remain gated/SKIP; sourceblocked, no closure.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "watch-parent-proof.json",
+      "watchtower/review.uegK64/handoff.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 9,
+    "id": "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+    "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+    "reason": "Safe offline authority-conflict fixtures identified by DW owner; not executed after6slots. Monetary precedence and canonical price writes remain unapproved.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11858.json",
+      "queue-final-reread.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 10,
+    "id": "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+    "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+    "reason": "Missing concrete credential restriction/quota/budget plan deferred after6slots. Both-host egress and measured cap prerequisite; identity/project changes remain gated.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11853.json",
+      "queue-final-reread.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 11,
+    "id": "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+    "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+    "reason": "Missing concrete29-offer appeal triage/parity packet deferred after6slots. Console appeals and outwardpolicy submissions gated; no blanket appeal authorization.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11847.json",
+      "queue-final-reread.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 12,
+    "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+    "disposition": "external-blocked",
+    "reason": "Explicit sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 and conflicting consolidator supersession require reconciliation/handoff; related terminal worker remains present. No router write/re-enable.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11838.json",
+      "existing-memos.json",
+      "parent-owner-state.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 13,
+    "id": "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+    "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+    "reason": "Shared gate/negative-price/productType and nested-repo residual fixes need isolated owner-aware work; deferred after6slots. No existing dirty/source edits taken.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11857.json",
+      "queue-final-reread.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 14,
+    "id": "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+    "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+    "reason": "57-job artifact classification needs per-job post-side-effect proof; deferred after6slots. Live creatorprocess alone not used as activeownership evidence.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11856.json",
+      "queue-final-reread.json"
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 15,
+    "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+    "disposition": "deferred-execution-cap",
+    "reason": "Shared Merchant read-name repair can be isolated and boundarytested; deferred after6slots. No Merchant Center write authorized.",
+    "evidence": [
+      "TK-11846.json",
+      "queue-final-reread.json"
+    ]
   }
 ]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b8590e3b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.json
@@ -0,0 +1,84 @@
+{
+  "timestamp": "2026-09-16T22:32:05.121635+00:00",
+  "scope": "cycle empirical observations and unchanged boundaries, not operational source completion",
+  "checks": [
+    {
+      "check": "cost_controls",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "guard": "ZERO_COST_REQUIRED",
+      "environment": "1",
+      "dynamic_missing_environment": "SKIP; control deliberately not unset"
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "prestige_existing_API_photo",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "status": 200,
+      "photos": 7,
+      "image_status": 200,
+      "source_unchanged": true,
+      "candidate_runtime": "SKIP gated"
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "ollama_tags",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "models": [
+        "qwen2.5vl:7b",
+        "hermes3:8b",
+        "qwen3:14b"
+      ],
+      "gemma_missing": true,
+      "interpretation": "Observation only; no restore claim"
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "arena_unauth_API",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "http_status": 401,
+      "authenticated_availability": "NOT_MEASURED"
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "real_disk_probe_and_negative",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "observations": [
+        {
+          "unit": "Mac2",
+          "reachable": true,
+          "free_pct": 8,
+          "free_gb": 79,
+          "size_gb": 887,
+          "verdict": "WARN"
+        },
+        {
+          "unit": "Negative",
+          "reachable": false,
+          "verdict": "UNKNOWN"
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "cost_snapshot_unchanged",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "sha256": "fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a"
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "installed_watchtower_unchanged",
+      "verdict": "FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT",
+      "baseline_head": "5659b951a5da820786da84bfd2079187e5f899a8",
+      "observed_head": "a7e005c255e46255f9eb9b633af9502d03a66657",
+      "external_owner_evidence": "external-owner-drift.json",
+      "full_watch_run": "SKIP forbidden escalation path"
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "existing_scheduler",
+      "verdict": "PASS",
+      "interval": 600,
+      "stopped": false,
+      "launchctl_registered": true
+    },
+    {
+      "check": "modified_UI_CTA_screenrecord",
+      "verdict": "SKIP",
+      "reason": "No activated or runnable modified web/UI surface; R0 patch only; existing local API/media exercised. Source operational outcomes remain unverified."
+    }
+  ],
+  "verdict": "PARTIAL: external-owner installed Watchtower drift; other scoped empirical checks recorded; operational critical paths SKIP and source tickets unresolved"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.py b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.py
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..0d16d309
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-final.py
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+import json, hashlib, pathlib, subprocess, urllib.request, urllib.error, os, plistlib, datetime
+ROOT=pathlib.Path(__file__).parent
+checks=[]
+def add(name,verdict,**kw):checks.append(dict(check=name,verdict=verdict,**kw))
+def get(url):
+ try:
+  with urllib.request.urlopen(url,timeout=10) as r:return r.status,r.read(),r.headers.get('Content-Type','')
+ except urllib.error.HTTPError as e:return e.code,e.read(),e.headers.get('Content-Type','')
+guard=pathlib.Path('/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode').read_text().strip()
+assert guard=='ZERO_COST_REQUIRED' and os.environ.get('DTD_ZERO_COST')=='1'
+add('cost_controls','PASS',guard=guard,environment='1',dynamic_missing_environment='SKIP; control deliberately not unset')
+src=pathlib.Path('/Users/macstudio3/Projects/prestige-car-wash/server.js')
+assert hashlib.sha256(src.read_bytes()).hexdigest()=='03776959d3f31aaec8235d5a1a23efcf6d375194bfcd0920ba507c5442330eaf'
+status,body,ct=get('http://127.0.0.1:9808/api/places'); assert status==200
+photos=json.loads(body)['photo_urls'];assert len(photos)==7 and all(x.startswith('/media/real/') for x in photos)
+s2,b2,c2=get('http://127.0.0.1:9808'+photos[0]);assert s2==200 and c2.startswith('image/')
+assert b2==(src.parent/photos[0].lstrip('/')).read_bytes()
+add('prestige_existing_API_photo','PASS',status=status,photos=len(photos),image_status=s2,source_unchanged=True,candidate_runtime='SKIP gated')
+s,b,c=get('http://127.0.0.1:11434/api/tags');assert s==200
+models=[x['name'] for x in json.loads(b)['models']]
+add('ollama_tags','PASS',models=models,gemma_missing='gemma3:12b' not in models,interpretation='Observation only; no restore claim')
+s,b,c=get('http://127.0.0.1:9758/api/models');add('arena_unauth_API','PASS' if s==401 else 'FAIL',http_status=s,authenticated_availability='NOT_MEASURED')
+r=subprocess.run(['bash',str(ROOT/'disk-probe.sh')],capture_output=True,text=True,check=True)
+rows=[json.loads(x) for x in r.stdout.splitlines() if x.strip()];assert rows[1]['verdict']=='UNKNOWN'
+add('real_disk_probe_and_negative','PASS',observations=rows)
+triage=pathlib.Path('/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/price-finder/data/cost-source-triage.json');h=hashlib.sha256(triage.read_bytes()).hexdigest();assert h=='fe1406dd96ec286e291373d363b0929a65d54bd5c0ff9542017e31a7b997151a'
+add('cost_snapshot_unchanged','PASS',sha256=h)
+watch=pathlib.Path('/Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/yoloforever-watchtower/watch.sh');base=json.loads((ROOT/'watchtower-baseline.json').read_text());unchanged=watch.read_bytes()==subprocess.check_output(['git','-C',str(watch.parent),'show',base['source_head']+':watch.sh'])
+add('installed_watchtower_unchanged','PASS' if unchanged else 'FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT',baseline_head=base['source_head'],observed_head=subprocess.check_output(['git','-C',str(watch.parent),'rev-parse','HEAD'],text=True).strip(),external_owner_evidence='external-owner-drift.json',full_watch_run='SKIP forbidden escalation path')
+pl=plistlib.loads(pathlib.Path('/Users/macstudio3/Library/LaunchAgents/com.steve.codex-yoloforever.plist').read_bytes());assert pl['StartInterval']==600
+stopped=pathlib.Path('/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/STOPPED').exists();assert not stopped
+lp=subprocess.run(['launchctl','print',f"gui/{os.getuid()}/com.steve.codex-yoloforever"],capture_output=True,text=True);assert lp.returncode==0
+add('existing_scheduler','PASS',interval=600,stopped=stopped,launchctl_registered=True)
+add('modified_UI_CTA_screenrecord','SKIP',reason='No activated or runnable modified web/UI surface; R0 patch only; existing local API/media exercised. Source operational outcomes remain unverified.')
+out={'timestamp':datetime.datetime.now(datetime.timezone.utc).isoformat(),'scope':'cycle empirical observations and unchanged boundaries, not operational source completion','checks':checks,'verdict':'PARTIAL: external-owner installed Watchtower drift; other scoped empirical checks recorded; operational critical paths SKIP and source tickets unresolved'}
+(ROOT/'empirical-final.json').write_text(json.dumps(out,indent=2));print(json.dumps(out,indent=2))
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-harness-correction.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-harness-correction.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..15ae49db
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/empirical-harness-correction.json
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+{
+  "at": "2026-09-16T22:31:19.812681+00:00",
+  "reproduced": "TypeError duplicate status argument in final evidence collector after successful first API checks",
+  "fix": "Rename local collector parameter verdict; no changed source/application behavior",
+  "rerun": "Completed: other read-only checks PASS, Watchtower changed by another owner FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT; overall PARTIAL"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/execution-order.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/execution-order.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..4de84a8f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/execution-order.json
@@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
+{
+  "execution_cap": 6,
+  "execution_order": [
+    {
+      "slot": 1,
+      "position": 2,
+      "ticket": "TK-11850",
+      "decision": 1
+    },
+    {
+      "slot": 2,
+      "position": 4,
+      "ticket": "TK-11852",
+      "decision": 2
+    },
+    {
+      "slot": 3,
+      "position": 1,
+      "ticket": "TK-11859",
+      "decision": 4
+    },
+    {
+      "slot": 4,
+      "position": 5,
+      "ticket": "TK-11861",
+      "decision": 5
+    },
+    {
+      "slot": 5,
+      "position": 6,
+      "ticket": "TK-11860",
+      "decision": 6
+    },
+    {
+      "slot": 6,
+      "position": 8,
+      "ticket": "TK-11848",
+      "decision": 3
+    }
+  ],
+  "order_deviation": "Initial cost-owner-active classification relied on live creator process. Subsequent canonical parent status showed DONE; process alone did not prove child ownership. Positions2and4 preparation occurred before correcting position1; later execution held until positions1,5,6 were assessed and prepared. This ordering deviation is recorded, not described as strict execution order.",
+  "prevent_recurrence": "Check canonical parent/source ownership and recent ticket activity before treating process liveness as a collision. Isolated local prep can remain safe."
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/existing-memos.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/existing-memos.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..31d44e1b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/existing-memos.json
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+[
+  {
+    "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md",
+    "exists": true,
+    "sha256": "b0ccba428030d8b4760a319c3e80023e9677d6453d4f23b2b3e129ed8bdae7b3"
+  },
+  {
+    "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11821-mac2-disk-reclaim-2026-09-16.md",
+    "exists": true,
+    "sha256": "7bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1"
+  },
+  {
+    "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11837-color-columns-python-api-pivot.md",
+    "exists": true,
+    "sha256": "a7d7cfeb5983a93df549491497a97de9dff9816d033d16b006979f3add25ca9f"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/external-owner-drift.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/external-owner-drift.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..03ad359a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/external-owner-drift.json
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+{
+  "at": "2026-09-16T22:32:04.381528+00:00",
+  "verdict": "DRIFT_EXTERNAL_OWNER",
+  "baseline": "5659b951a5da820786da84bfd2079187e5f899a8",
+  "observed_head": "a7e005c255e46255f9eb9b633af9502d03a66657",
+  "observed_sha256": "02dd224e0abce69ea444a985849d5b20f4f99807b9ec10bb0e5f689584ffcce7",
+  "source_ticket": {
+    "position": 8,
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "status": "doing",
+    "assignee": "night-TK-11848",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:28:01.897Z",
+    "blocker": {
+      "type": "steve_action",
+      "condition": "Isolated detector fix verified; installing into scheduled watcher and actualsecond-daemon proof lack exactapproval. Fullwatch may invoke forbidden Claude runtime.",
+      "next_action": "Review pending-approval/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md; approve scopedsourceapplication and separately safe operationalproof; never run wholewatch under currentruntime prohibition.",
+      "owner": "steve",
+      "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:24:08.862Z",
+      "steve_one_action": false
+    }
+  },
+  "diff": "diff --git a/watch.sh b/watch.sh\nindex 38a5942..155401d 100755\n--- a/watch.sh\n+++ b/watch.sh\n@@ -24,7 +24,12 @@ TS=\"$(date -u +%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ)\"\n log_ledger () { printf '%s\\n' \"$1\" >> \"$LEDGER\"; }\n \n # --- 1. pm2 God daemon count (fracture guard) ---\n-GOD=$(ps aux | grep -E 'PM2.*God' | grep -v grep | wc -l | tr -d ' ')\n+# Anchor to the real daemon title on the command field only. The old\n+# `ps aux | grep 'PM2.*God'` matched any peer process whose full argv text\n+# mentioned PM2 and God (e.g. a claude tk-log line), inflating the count and\n+# firing a false pm2-god:2 (TK-11848). `ps -axo command=` yields the command\n+# field alone; the anchor `^PM2 v<ver>: God Daemon` matches only the daemon.\n+GOD=$(ps -axo command= | grep -cE '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon')\n \n # --- 2. fleet-health-rollup: current FAIL skill set ---\n ROLL=\"$(node \"$ROLLUP\" 2>/dev/null)\"\n",
+  "cycle_action": "Read-only observation. Do not overwrite, reset, claim, activate, or certify the other worker change. Isolated artifact remains independently verified; source operational result unverified."
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-dtd.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-dtd.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b7b6b80a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-dtd.json
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+{
+  "decision": "HOLD-FOR-STEVE",
+  "confidence": "high",
+  "tally": "5/5 valid",
+  "votes": {
+    "exo.txt": "[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]\n",
+    "claude.txt": "VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE\nAccept verified local preparation and retain source blockers; exhausted cap and absent operational approval prohibit activation. External cost evidence also remains required. Exit cleanly with scheduler unchanged.\n",
+    "kimi.txt": "[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+    "heretic.txt": "[ERR heretic]\n",
+    "grok.txt": "[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 \u2014 paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]\n",
+    "qwen.txt": "HOLD-FOR-STEVE  \nThe decision to retain verified local artifacts while logging unresolved external dependencies aligns with the unverified source outcomes and absence of operational approval. Despite Cody\u2019s acceptance of preparation artifacts and the correction of execution deviations, critical evidence (activation/real two-daemon path, vendor cost) remains untested or gated, and no approval memos are currently valid. Proceeding with SHIP or FIX-THEN-SHIP risks operational instability without resolved dependencies, while KILL discards potentially valuable local increments. HOLD-FOR-STEVE ensures artifacts are preserved for future resolution, adheres to the unverified state of evidence, and avoids premature activation, maintaining compliance with the scheduler\u2019s cycle boundaries and ZERO_COST_REQUIRED constraints.\n",
+    "codex.txt": "VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE\n\nRetain the verified local artifacts and three approval memos, log unresolved external evidence and approval dependencies, perform no activation, and exit normally. All six execution slots are exhausted and all 15 entries assessed; preparation acceptance does not establish operational approval. Source outcomes remain UNVERIFIED, and activation, the real two-daemon path, and vendor cost evidence remain untested or gated. Preserve the disclosed execution-order deviation and corrected fixture-cleanup history. Leave the existing 600-second scheduler unchanged, with a fresh queue for the next cycle and verified zero-cost controls retained.",
+    "muse.txt": "[disabled \u2014 muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]\n",
+    "ops": "VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE\n\nRetain the six verified local preparations, record the unresolved approval and external-evidence dependencies, and end this bounded cycle normally because all six execution slots are exhausted and no operational activation is currently authorized. The independent reviewer's acceptance establishes preparation quality only: source outcomes remain UNVERIFIED, and live activation, the real second-daemon path and vendor acquisition-cost evidence still lack the necessary approval or proof. Preserve the disclosed ordering correction and historical fixture-cleanup violation alongside its correction rather than rewriting them as compliant history, retain all artifacts and three approval memos, and let the existing unchanged 600-second scheduler obtain a fresh queue for the next cycle. Neither SHIP nor FIX-THEN-SHIP can manufacture missing authority, and discarding useful verified work would lose the reviewable result without resolving any blocker.\n\nGuard proof: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1 before work; neither control changed. Codex only; provider spend $0; no operational action, external message, delegation, terminal paint or other artifact mutation. Correlation yf2139-final-ops, source TK-11287.\n",
+    "risk": "VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE\nRetain the verified local preparation artifacts, record the outstanding approval and external-evidence dependencies, and exit this bounded cycle normally without activation. All six execution slots are exhausted; the supplied evidence supports preparation acceptance while explicitly leaving source outcomes, vendor acquisition-cost proof, and the real two-daemon operational path unverified or gated. Cody acceptance does not confer operational authority, and neither another implementation increment nor discarding useful preparations resolves the missing approval. Preserve the disclosed execution-order deviation and corrected fixture-cleanup history, keep source tickets unresolved, and let the existing scheduler obtain a fresh queue without changing its controls.\n\nGuard proof: independently read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode immediately before voting; exact output ZERO_COST_REQUIRED. Independently read printenv DTD_ZERO_COST; exact output 1. Controls unchanged. Decision grounded in supplied final-question.txt; provider spend $0, no Claude runtime or paid API. Correlation yf2139-final-risk; status complete for independent final-disposition vote only. Owned artifact: /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/final-risk-vote.txt. No operational authorization, activation, source closure, delegation, or terminal paint.\n"
+  },
+  "valid_voters": [
+    "claude.txt",
+    "qwen.txt",
+    "codex.txt",
+    "ops",
+    "risk"
+  ],
+  "dissent": "No voting dissent. Cody: preparation acceptance resolves zero operational outcomes.",
+  "unsupported_claims_rejected": [
+    "Qwen statement no approval memos are valid is unsupported; three concrete drafts exist but none confers approval."
+  ],
+  "cost_usd": 0,
+  "operational_authority": false,
+  "root_cody_accounting_hash_check": "PASS"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-ops-vote.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-ops-vote.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..12af4b34
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-ops-vote.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE
+
+Retain the six verified local preparations, record the unresolved approval and external-evidence dependencies, and end this bounded cycle normally because all six execution slots are exhausted and no operational activation is currently authorized. The independent reviewer's acceptance establishes preparation quality only: source outcomes remain UNVERIFIED, and live activation, the real second-daemon path and vendor acquisition-cost evidence still lack the necessary approval or proof. Preserve the disclosed ordering correction and historical fixture-cleanup violation alongside its correction rather than rewriting them as compliant history, retain all artifacts and three approval memos, and let the existing unchanged 600-second scheduler obtain a fresh queue for the next cycle. Neither SHIP nor FIX-THEN-SHIP can manufacture missing authority, and discarding useful verified work would lose the reviewable result without resolving any blocker.
+
+Guard proof: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1 before work; neither control changed. Codex only; provider spend $0; no operational action, external message, delegation, terminal paint or other artifact mutation. Correlation yf2139-final-ops, source TK-11287.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b187fffe
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Final forced choice for a bounded unattended Codex-only cycle. Pick exactly one: SHIP (activate operational changes now), FIX-THEN-SHIP (another safe implementation increment then activate), HOLD-FOR-STEVE (retain verified local artifacts, log unresolved external evidence/approval dependencies, no activation, exit normally), KILL (discard the preparations). Six execution slots are exhausted; all 15 supplied entries assessed. Six local increments: Prestige route-removal patch preserving seven local photos; missing Gemma capacity/roster memo; offline 18-vendor join audit; PR selling-price versus acquisition-cost source manifest; 26-vendor column evidence requests; isolated committed Watchtower daemon detector one-line fix, 9 boundary checks passing. Source outcomes remain UNVERIFIED; activation/real two-daemon path/vendor cost evidence untested or gated. Cody independent reviewer used five inline lenses, accepted all preparation artifacts SHIP IT, corrected stale position8 reporting; this is not operational approval. Three approval memos prepared. No current approval for these operational changes. Actual execution order was positions2,4,1,5,6,8 after correcting mistaken live-parent ownership evidence; deviation disclosed. Initial fixture-cleanup violation corrected to retained mktemp directories and tests rerun; history disclosed. No source closures or production writes. Decision scope is final operational disposition, not a new approval debate or permission to apply. Existing 600-second scheduler remains, next cycle gets fresh queue. Cost controls verified DTD_ZERO_COST=1 and canonical guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED. Use only supplied evidence; do not invent details. Begin VERDICT: <exact choice>, then one paragraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-risk-vote.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-risk-vote.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9de6c718
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-risk-vote.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE
+Retain the verified local preparation artifacts, record the outstanding approval and external-evidence dependencies, and exit this bounded cycle normally without activation. All six execution slots are exhausted; the supplied evidence supports preparation acceptance while explicitly leaving source outcomes, vendor acquisition-cost proof, and the real two-daemon operational path unverified or gated. Cody acceptance does not confer operational authority, and neither another implementation increment nor discarding useful preparations resolves the missing approval. Preserve the disclosed execution-order deviation and corrected fixture-cleanup history, keep source tickets unresolved, and let the existing scheduler obtain a fresh queue without changing its controls.
+
+Guard proof: independently read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode immediately before voting; exact output ZERO_COST_REQUIRED. Independently read printenv DTD_ZERO_COST; exact output 1. Controls unchanged. Decision grounded in supplied final-question.txt; provider spend $0, no Claude runtime or paid API. Correlation yf2139-final-risk; status complete for independent final-disposition vote only. Owned artifact: /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/final-risk-vote.txt. No operational authorization, activation, source closure, delegation, or terminal paint.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-root-vote.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-root-vote.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..24f8a052
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/final-root-vote.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE
+Accept verified local preparation and retain source blockers; exhausted cap and absent operational approval prohibit activation. External cost evidence also remains required. Exit cleanly with scheduler unchanged.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/finalize-evidence.py b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/finalize-evidence.py
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..16597c8d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/finalize-evidence.py
@@ -0,0 +1,67 @@
+from pathlib import Path
+import json,shutil,hashlib,datetime
+p=Path(__file__).parent;d=Path('/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8');d.mkdir(exist_ok=True)
+for x in p.iterdir():
+ if x.is_file() and x.suffix in ('.json','.py','.sh','.txt','.log') and x.name not in ('owner-processes.json','canonical.json'):
+  name=x.name+'.txt' if x.suffix=='.log' else x.name
+  shutil.copy2(x,d/name)
+for name in ('cody','join-audit','pr-anchors','column-manifest','model-prep','prestige','cost-assessment'):
+ shutil.copytree(p/name,d/name,dirs_exist_ok=True,ignore=shutil.ignore_patterns('.git','__pycache__','*.log'))
+for pathfile in p.glob('*dtd-path'):
+ src=Path(pathfile.read_text().strip());target=d/'panels'/pathfile.stem;target.mkdir(parents=True,exist_ok=True)
+ for x in src.glob('*.txt'):shutil.copy2(x,target/x.name)
+for name in ('disk-probe.log','join-parent-tests.log','zero-cost-preflight.log'):
+ shutil.copy2(p/name,d/(name+'.txt'))
+# Rewrite only durable report references to tracked retained logs.
+a=json.loads((d/'dispositions.json').read_text())
+for r in a:r['evidence']=[x+'.txt' if x.endswith('.log') else x for x in r['evidence']]
+(d/'dispositions.json').write_text(json.dumps(a,indent=2))
+memodir=Path('/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval');memo=[]
+for n in ('TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md','TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md','TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md'):
+ src=memodir/n
+ if not src.exists():src=memodir/'_done'/n
+ assert src.exists(),src
+ target=d/'memos-final'/n;target.parent.mkdir(exist_ok=True);shutil.copy2(src,target)
+ memo.append({'path':str(src),'sha256':hashlib.sha256(src.read_bytes()).hexdigest(),'state':'moved_done_by_other_worker_claims_unverified' if src.parent.name=='_done' else 'pending_approval','copy':str(target)})
+(d/'memo-retention.json').write_text(json.dumps(memo,indent=2))
+cor=json.loads((p/'empirical-harness-correction.json').read_text());cor['rerun']='Completed: other read-only checks PASS, Watchtower changed by another owner FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT; overall PARTIAL';(d/'empirical-harness-correction.json').write_text(json.dumps(cor,indent=2))
+rows='\n'.join(f"| {r['position']} | {r['id'].split('-')[0]}-{r['id'].split('-')[1]} | {r['disposition']} | {r['reason']} |" for r in a)
+report='''# Bounded cycle yf2139.YF57g8
+
+Final DTD: **HOLD-FOR-STEVE**, 5/5 valid votes. Cody: **SHIP IT for preparation artifacts only**, five inline lenses from one independent reviewer. Six execution slots used; all 15 supplied entries assessed. No operational source outcome completed or ticket closed by this cycle. Provider API spend $0; Codex usage was not independently metered.
+
+## Actual implementation and evidence
+
+- TK-11859: built retained offline audit of all 18 join candidates. Six boundary tests passed. Three candidate table identities remain unproven (4,371 historical active products); all candidates still need actual cost/join proof.
+- TK-11850: staged a narrow photo-route removal patch preserving the seven local photos. Parent syntax, exact patch, unchanged source and existing API/media checks passed. Modified application runtime, CTA and screenrecord SKIP; activation is gated.
+- TK-11852: prepared roster/capacity decision memo. Real tags show Gemma missing; authenticated arena availability NOT_MEASURED (unauthenticated request401). Disk probe WARN8%, final79GiB; negative probe UNKNOWN. No download or roster change.
+- TK-11861: verified ten exact source quotations across three source hashes. Greenland59.50 is selling-price evidence, not acquisition cost. Current cost/cohort measurements remain NOT_MEASURED.
+- TK-11860: generated the actual26-vendor evidence-request manifest, preserving key matches separately from populated columns; structural totals and malformed-input rejection passed. No external requests sent or costs adopted.
+- TK-11848: committed isolated detector candidate dfa2963a10f92bd675c40d39ef5071898ece883e. Parent and Cody independently replayed nine parser/threshold checks; real second-daemon and whole-watcher proof not performed by this cycle.
+
+## Final operational boundary: PARTIAL
+
+Final empirical verification caught **FAIL_EXTERNAL_DRIFT**: installed Watchtower changed from5659b95 to a7e005c after another worker claimed TK-11848. That worker moved the memo to `_done` and appended claims of activation and real-second-daemon testing. These are third-party claims, not this cycle's independently verified operational proof. This cycle did not install, revert, activate, rerun the full watcher, or recertify that change. The isolated candidate remains retained. Reconcile current ownership and evidence before further action. See [drift](external-owner-drift.json), [empirical checks](empirical-final.json), and [current source states](canonical-final.json).
+
+Other final checks passed: existing Prestige API+media, actual Ollama tags, arena unauth401, disk positive/negative probes, unchanged cost-input hash, cost controls, existing600-second launchd registration and absent STOPPED sentinel. Critical operational paths remain SKIP; this is not an E2E completion claim for source outcomes. Read-only assessments and gates count as zero implementation.
+
+## Ordered dispositions
+
+| Position | Source | Disposition | Evidence-backed reason |
+|---|---|---|---|
+'''+rows+'''
+
+## Deviations and reproduced corrections
+
+Actual execution order was positions **2,4,1,5,6,8**, not strict queue order. A live creator process was initially mistaken for active ownership; canonical parent status later showed DONE. Earlier cost preparation was then resumed before later execution. Future collision checks must include current source/parent ownership and activity, not process liveness alone. See execution-order.json.
+
+The first join-test harness deleted its own temporary fixtures; this violated the requested retention rule. It was corrected to fresh retained directories and tests were independently rerun. No source/production deletion occurred. Cody reproduced stale position8 reporting; root corrected it and Cody verified the correction. The final empirical collector had a duplicate-argument TypeError; its local parameter was corrected, then rerun caught the genuine external drift and retained that failure.
+
+## Retention and next cycle
+
+Three concrete memos were created; two remain pending and the Watchtower memo was moved to `_done` by another worker. [Memo paths/hashes](memo-retention.json). No authority is inferred from that move. Five cost/photo/model source tickets remain blocked; Watchtower was blocked by this cycle and subsequently claimed by a peer. Source statuses are point-in-time snapshots, not an ownership lock.
+
+The existing scheduler remains registered at600seconds; this cycle did not change it. Next seed is a fresh queue and owner-aware reconciliation, including cost-authority conflict TK-11858 if it is still safely available; several deferred items were claimed by other workers during finalization. No new coordination ticket was created. Terminal-status verification was refused by the headless ownership guard; no parent pane was force-painted.
+'''
+(d/'REPORT.md').write_text(report)
+print('Durable evidence copied',d)
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-ops.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-ops.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8815b259
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-ops.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Prepare the bounded local patch artifact and approval memo because canonical TK-11850 describes dormant cleanup with no current customer degradation, so creating a key adds credential scope and operational obligations without an established need. The ticket recommendation to delete photos plumbing is broader than the supplied source finding that /api/places maps local images; preserve that mapping and local rendering, and explicitly record the narrower proposal as a correction requiring review. Before proposing route removal, reproduce the local-versus-Google-reference mapping and data assumptions so latent proxy dependencies are surfaced rather than silently severed. Keep the active checkout, service, credentials, and data unchanged, attach evidence and a reversible patch for Steve to review, and retain the source ticket until any approved execution is separately verified.
+
+Guard evidence: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1. Read complete a2a-contract and dtd skills and canonical TK-11850 with tk show. Codex voter only; no Claude runtime, external model APIs, or provider spend. Correlation: yf2139-i1-ops.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-panel.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-panel.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a2767349
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-panel.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+DIR=/private/tmp/dtd-yf2139-i1.LPTRt0
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    707 Sep 16 14:46 codex.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     56 Sep 16 14:45 exo.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 14:45 grok.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     14 Sep 16 14:45 heretic.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 14:45 kimi.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     80 Sep 16 14:45 muse.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1152 Sep 16 14:45 question.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    748 Sep 16 14:46 qwen.txt
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..43d3ce7b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Ticket TK-11850, cycle yf2139.YF57g8, exact bounded increment. Choose A: prepare a reviewable LOCAL patch artifact and approval memo to remove only the unused credential-backed /api/places/photo/:i route, preserve local photo rendering and /api/places mapping; reproduce source/data assumptions and flag any proposal change. Do not alter active service checkout, credentials, data, or deploy. B: mint a key now. C: do no preparation. Source ticket says customer page uses /api/places and local media; photo route 404s with missing key. Parent found server.js maps local photos to local URLs and Google refs to proxy, so preserve local photo plumbing; do not blindly delete photos. No ticket-named owner process for creator11615 seen; independently reread canonical state before claim. Local repo clean. No existing ticket-specific approval memo found. Hard gates forbid credential/production/customer-facing execution; only local artifacts are authorized. Cost guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED, DTD_ZERO_COST=1; Codex CLI and local endpoints only. Pick exactly one option. Begin VERDICT: <option> then one paragraph. Scope is preparation, never source closure.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-risk.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-risk.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..2bde7376
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-risk.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare the local patch and approval memo because this permits review without introducing credential exposure, spending authority, or a customer-facing change. The canonical TK-11850 record confirms a dormant key-dependent route and manual scripts, but its earlier suggestion to delete photos plumbing is broader than the present bounded increment: preserve local-photo rendering and /api/places mapping, verify current source/data and references, and explicitly report any Google-reference mapping left pointing at the proposed removed route. The patch must remain an artifact, with no active checkout edits, credential creation, deployment, ticket closure, or assertion that customer behavior is unchanged without evidence. B crosses the credential gate unnecessarily; C leaves authorized low-risk preparation undone.
+
+Guard evidence: independently read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read complete a2a-contract/SKILL.md and dtd/SKILL.md and reread canonical ticket with tk show TK-11850. No other voter outputs read. Provider spend: $0; no Claude runtime or paid APIs.
+Correlation: yf2139-i1-risk
+Status: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Remaining gate: Steve approval for any active/customer-facing/credential execution. Safest next action: parent independently review artifact and prepare the bounded proposal.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-root.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-root.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..4458cf44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment1-root.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare exact patch with local image boundary preserved; execution remains gated.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-ops.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-ops.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..5f033cc8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-ops.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Prepare the local approval memo because the current source roster and reported live tags show a configuration-versus-capacity discrepancy, but neither proves whether gemma3:12b was deliberately retired. A blind roughly 8GB pull would consume scarce disk on a host with a disk-critical history, while deleting the contender would change the meaning of future ratings without a confirmed product decision. The memo should present the roster/tag evidence, distinguish the historical ticket claim about /api/models from the present unauthenticated 401, explain the risk of apparently complete ratings from a reduced field, and ask Steve to confirm roster intent before any restoration. If restoration is approved, require a fresh disk preflight with capacity headroom for download and extraction; neither this memo nor the existing WARN reading authorizes a pull, battle, restart, live roster edit, or ticket closure.
+
+Guard evidence: directly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1 again for this increment; canonical TK-11852 read using tk show. Codex only, no external provider calls, spend $0. Correlation: yf2139-i2-ops.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-panel.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-panel.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..4aaa567f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-panel.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+DIR=/private/tmp/dtd-yf2139-i2.YkiI4E
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    928 Sep 16 14:54 codex.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     56 Sep 16 14:53 exo.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 14:53 grok.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     14 Sep 16 14:53 heretic.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 14:53 kimi.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     80 Sep 16 14:53 muse.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1136 Sep 16 14:53 question.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    826 Sep 16 14:54 qwen.txt
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..aa5c384c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11852 exact bounded increment, cycle yf2139.YF57g8. Choose A: prepare a local approval memo for restoring missing gemma3:12b only after Steve confirms it remains intended and approves the ~8GB download against fresh disk preflight; document source roster/tag evidence and downstream partial-rating risk, no pull/roster change/battle. B: pull the model now. C: drop the contender from live roster now. Direct observations: /api/tags has qwen2.5vl:7b,hermes3:8b,qwen3:14b; source server.js includes gemma3:12b. Mac2 canary pure df helper reports WARN8percent78GiB; missing-input negative returns UNKNOWN. Arena GET /api/models returns401 unauthenticated, so API availability field not independently remeasured. Creator11723 process absent in current exact owner process scan; canonical source open. Runtime output files dirty but isolated new memo does not edit them. No existing ticket-specific memo found. Model download/production restart/roster mutation remain Steve-gated. Codex CLI/local endpoints only, guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1. Pick exactly one option, start VERDICT: <option> then paragraph. Preparation only; no closure.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-risk.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-risk.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b6fa574a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-risk.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare the approval memo because the missing intended contender can bias subsequent ratings, but neither a model download nor a live roster removal is authorized. Preserve the distinction between directly observed Ollama tags and source roster evidence, historical ticket observations, and the presently unverified authenticated API availability field. The reported 78 GiB free does not nullify the 8-percent disk warning or prove that an approximately 8 GB download plus transient storage is safe under concurrent workloads; require a fresh capacity check and Steve confirmation that gemma3:12b remains intended before any pull. Record the partial-rating risk and require post-approval verification of model availability and participant completeness before claiming recovery. B spends storage and changes runtime state without approval; C changes contest semantics without confirming retirement intent.
+
+Guard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment2-question.txt and reread canonical TK-11852 with tk show. Required a2a-contract and dtd skills were read in full earlier in this same delegated session. No other voter outputs read. Provider spend $0; no paid API or Claude runtime.
+Correlation: yf2139-i2-risk
+Status: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Remaining gates: confirmation of intended contender and approval for download or live roster mutation. Safest next action: parent independently inspect this vote and prepare a factual local approval memo, without closing the source ticket.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-root.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-root.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8ff98068
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment2-root.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Evidence-based gated restoration proposal preserves roster intent and disk safety.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-ops.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-ops.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7e880dcd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-ops.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Prepare and commit the isolated detector fix because process-command anchoring directly addresses the documented false alarm while leaving the active scheduled watcher untouched. Read the original script to preserve its actual shell/error semantics, and make the zero-daemon fixture verify both the resulting count and whether grep -c returning status 1 can prematurely terminate the caller; one/two-daemon fixtures must drive the real parser-to-alert threshold rather than a separately invented interpretation. Use read-only live process output to confirm the current genuine daemon spelling and prove decoy command arguments do not count. Keep activation and a real second-daemon lifecycle test explicitly unperformed and gated: fixture success validates the bounded patch, not the complete operational repair, so the source ticket remains open until authorized real-path proof is accepted.
+
+Direct guard evidence: /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1. Canonical TK-11848 reread; installed watch.sh not invoked, no daemon/source action or delegation. Provider spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i3-ops.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-panel.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-panel.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9c024129
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-panel.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+DIR=/private/tmp/dtd-yf2139-i3.jmCsyv
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    670 Sep 16 15:00 codex.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     56 Sep 16 15:00 exo.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:00 grok.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     14 Sep 16 15:00 heretic.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:00 kimi.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     80 Sep 16 15:00 muse.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1108 Sep 16 15:00 question.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    793 Sep 16 15:01 qwen.txt
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8ff42215
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11848 exact increment, cycle yf2139.YF57g8. A: prepare an isolated committed one-line detector fix plus replay/negative tests and an activation memo; replace whole argv grep with ps -axo command= and anchored ^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon. Independently test live ps single daemon, decoy text, zero/one/two daemon command fixtures at parser-to-alert threshold; do not invoke watch.sh (it can call Claude and send/alter state), do not start/stop PM2, do not modify installed scheduled script. Explicitly SKIP real second-daemon operational proof pending approval, never close source. B: run installed watch.sh or a new daemon now. C: leave missing concrete fix unprepared. Source watch.sh clean HEAD5659b95; ticket says owner watchtower left it untouched, proposed fix requested from vp-operations. Root read original grep and actual one-daemon command. Isolated new checkout avoids scheduled writer collision. User prohibits Claude runtime and paid endpoints. Gate applies to live scheduled activation, daemon lifecycle, sends. Choose exactly A/B/C; VERDICT line and one paragraph. $0 guard/env remain intact.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-risk.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-risk.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..d1fe17c6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-risk.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare the isolated committed detector fix and activation memo because the canonical evidence identifies an argv-text false positive and the anchored command-column match directly addresses it without executing the installed watcher. The replay must exercise the actual parser-to-alert threshold with zero, one, and two daemon fixtures plus embedded decoy text, and verify the zero-match exit behavior: grep -cE prints 0 but returns status 1, which can abort scripts under errexit instead of producing the intended alert. Inspect the actual shell options and threshold logic, report any necessary deviation from the proposed one-line scope, and validate the local live single-daemon measurement independently. Fixture success cannot establish the real second-daemon operational path; label that critical check skipped and retain the source ticket open pending authorized lifecycle testing and scheduled activation. B risks Claude execution, sends, and runtime mutation; C leaves a concrete, authorized correction unprepared.
+
+Guard evidence: freshly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment3-question.txt and canonical TK-11848 with tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills were read earlier in the same delegated session. No other votes read; no watch.sh execution. Provider spend $0, no Claude runtime or paid API.
+Correlation: yf2139-i3-risk
+Status: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Gates retained: installed script activation, daemon lifecycle, sends, and actual second-daemon proof. Safest next action: parent independently review the vote and prepare the isolated patch and bounded evidence, with source completion explicitly withheld.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-root.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-root.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9c7c8169
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment3-root.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Isolate and prove parser boundary now; operational activation and real second-daemon proof stay gated.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-ops.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-ops.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..f85f87bd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-ops.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Create the isolated offline audit because retaining the original report and separating heuristic evidence from proven table identity is the most useful bounded correction before any live cost-authority work. Preserve the input hash, generated_at, all 18 rows, and original 18/6243/0 totals; mark the three named cross-table candidates UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY with their combined 4371-product impact without implying the other 15 identities are verified. The output must explain that six attempted join keys, swallowed SQL errors, and missing priced-row filtering cannot establish either absent cost or a broken authoritative join; do not silently reclassify historical zero reachability as a trustworthy measurement. Fail explicitly on malformed or structurally mismatched input and retain real-artifact evidence, while keeping source ownership unchanged and all DB, API, cost-map, pricing, and customer changes outside scope. The live creator process does not prove current ownership of this child task, but the independent offline output also avoids competing with that process.
+
+Guard evidence: independently read config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and environment DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11859 reread. This artifact and its ticket log are the only writes; no other ballots, source edits, APIs, database calls, or paid providers. Cost $0. Correlation yf2139-i4-ops.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-panel.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-panel.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..5992656e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-panel.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+DIR=/private/tmp/dtd-yf2139-i4.r1VPgG
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    707 Sep 16 15:05 codex.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     56 Sep 16 15:04 exo.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:04 grok.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     14 Sep 16 15:04 heretic.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:04 kimi.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     80 Sep 16 15:04 muse.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1452 Sep 16 15:03 question.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   2205 Sep 16 15:04 qwen.txt
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..28aa9a82
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11859, supplied position1 reopened for ownership correction. Exact bounded increment choose A: create a reusable OFFLINE audit script and retained JSON/Markdown artifact from existing cost-source-triage.json ONLY; enumerate all18 COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN rows, preserve source hash/generated_at and original18/6243/0 totals, explicitly mark three cross-name table candidates (Phillip Jeffries->phillipe_romano_catalog3392; Designer Wallcoverings->designers_guild_catalog978; Studio Ditte->studio_printworks_catalog1) UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY affecting4371 products. Do not infer other15 are proven. Explain heuristic candidates, six key attempts, silent SQL errors, and no priced-row filtering mean zero reachability is not proven absent cost or proven broken join. Test real artifact plus malformed/mismatched input failure. No DB/API queries, no cost-map/price source edit or canonical/customer mutation. B: repair live joins based on this heuristic report. C: do no corrective preparation. Root independently read generator and verified18/6243 plus4371 arithmetic; parentTK11427 DONE21:24Z, live creator process alone is not child ownership proof, sources open creator-assigned. Active pricing/code untouched; new isolated artifact only. Prior provisional owner-active classification corrected. This is preparation, not cost coverage lift or source closure. $0 guard/env, Codex CLI/local endpoints only. Pick A/B/C, begin VERDICT: option then paragraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-risk.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-risk.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..63277c27
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-risk.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare the offline audit and retained artifacts because the source classification overstates what heuristic table selection and six attempted keys can establish. Preserve 18 vendors, 6243 active products, and 0 reported reachable as original report values with source hash and generated_at, not fresh canonical findings. Mark the three named cross-name associations UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY affecting 4371 products; name differences alone establish neither a valid association nor a definitive mismatch, and the other 15 associations remain unverified. Record that silently caught SQL errors, limited key attempts, and absent priced-row filtering prevent the reported zero from proving absent costs or a broken join. Validate expected schema, class count, numeric totals, and malformed/mismatched rejection before emitting conclusions; avoid any implicit cost-coverage lift or repair authorization. B would change live cost authority on insufficient evidence; C leaves a misleading repair premise uncorrected.
+
+Guard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment4-question.txt and canonical TK-11859 via tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills were read earlier in this delegated session. No other ballots read. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API query, or source mutation.
+Correlation: yf2139-i4-risk
+Status: complete (independent risk vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edits or commit. Residual uncertainty: all 18 candidate table identities and live cost reachability require separate verification; the saved report cannot establish present canonical state. Remaining gates: any cost-map, price-source, canonical, or customer mutation. Safest next action: parent independently inspect this vote and prepare the offline evidence correction, keeping TK-11859 open.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-root.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-root.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ab0fc237
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-root.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Correct the evidence classification without inventing cost facts or touching pricing.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-ops.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-ops.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..cf6c2365
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-ops.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Prepare the offline source-anchor manifest because correcting a sell-price-versus-acquisition-cost assumption is necessary before the proposed cost model can be reviewed responsibly. Preserve canonical prefix provenance, exact cited source lines and file hashes, explicitly classify 59.50 as SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE, and leave acquisition cost and unsampled cohort counts NOT_MEASURED; superseded quote-only language supplies historical context but cannot prove current wholesale absence. Keep 13,066 active products, 1,082 key matches, and 474 populated candidate catalog rows as separately labeled report measurements, since join fan-out, uniqueness, row predicates and distinct-product cardinality have not been proved, and do not invent a decomposition for the claimed 232 prefixes. This additive manifest advances a concrete correction without competing with creator work or changing canonical cost authority; subsequent sourcing, live reads, pricing changes and source-ticket closure remain outside this decision.
+
+Guard evidence: directly reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11861 reread. No DB/API/source edits, claims, other ballots, terminal painting, Claude runtime or delegation. Provider spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i5-ops.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-panel.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-panel.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9448a8c8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-panel.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+DIR=/private/tmp/dtd-yf2139-i5.D2j6c8
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel    857 Sep 16 15:07 codex.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     56 Sep 16 15:06 exo.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:06 grok.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     14 Sep 16 15:06 heretic.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:06 kimi.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     80 Sep 16 15:06 muse.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1131 Sep 16 15:06 question.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1444 Sep 16 15:07 qwen.txt
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..78502105
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11861 suppliedposition5 exact bounded increment after TK11859 audit. Choose A: prepare an OFFLINE source-anchor manifest for Phillipe Romano cost sourcing: canonical Cork- (legacy DWGL-), DWWL-=RIGO, DWPP-=MDC, source file hashes and exact cited lines. Correct ticket claim treating Greenland59.50 as cost: canonical skill explicitly calls it Yard variant/Retail Price, therefore SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE. Older quote-only notes are superseded and must not prove current wholesale absence. Mark acquisition cost NOT_MEASURED and cohort counts NOT_MEASURED, no invented232prefix decomposition. Retain report PR13066 active and1082 key-matched separately from474 populated catalog rows; cannot infer count bound without cardinality proof. No DB/API/customer/source/price-map edits. B: use59.50 as cork cost now. C: no correction. Parent independently read complete greenland-scraper-manager and rigo-scraper-manager skills and existing report. Creator parent done; no active child claim established. Isolated additive evidence only, source outcome not complete. Codex/localonly $0guard/env. Pick A/B/C; VERDICT plus paragraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-risk.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-risk.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..931fedab
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-risk.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare the offline source-anchor manifest because the ticket risks turning a documented retail selling price into acquisition cost across a private-label umbrella. Cite and hash the canonical sources for Cork- (legacy DWGL-), DWWL-, and DWPP- without claiming those anchors exhaust or size the reported 232 prefixes. Label 59.50 SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE, acquisition cost and current cohort counts NOT_MEASURED, and superseded quote-only notes historical rather than proof of present wholesale absence. Retain the reported 13066 active products, 1082 key matches, and 474 populated catalog rows as distinct measurements: without uniqueness, fan-out, priced-row, and key-domain proof, their relationship establishes neither priced yield nor a product-count bound. The artifact corrects evidence interpretation only; any acquisition-cost authority or source closure requires separate verification. B risks propagating an unsupported cost; C preserves a material misconception.
+
+Guard evidence: independently reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment5-question.txt and canonical TK-11861 via tk show; no other ballots. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills previously read in this delegated session. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API queries, or source edits.
+Correlation: yf2139-i5-risk
+Status: complete (independent decision vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit or commit. Residual risk: current acquisition costs, cohort distribution, join cardinality, and priced coverage remain unmeasured. Remaining gates: any source/price-map/canonical/customer mutation. Safest next action: parent independently verify source anchors and construct the isolated additive manifest when the preceding increment permits; do not claim a coverage lift or close TK-11861.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-root.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-root.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a2bc4974
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment5-root.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Source-anchor correction prevents sell-price-to-cost confusion without creating cost authority.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-ops.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-ops.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..125f2b16
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-ops.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Prepare the offline evidence-request manifest from the report's literal 26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows rather than the ticket's mixed illustrative vendor list, preserving source hash, timestamp and historical 26/12852/10704 totals. Keep populated-column counts and key-match counts separate: the generator's unrestricted key matching and swallowed query errors do not prove populated priced-row reachability, verified net acquisition cost, or a trustworthy coverage lift. Explicitly flag metadata-shaped price_source and price_effective_date columns and unproven derived live_price evidence; for every candidate require a SKU-matched vendor-external quote, invoice or authoritative price basis, dated unit/currency terms, and documented discount provenance where applicable. Structural and total-validation failures must stop generation rather than silently drop rows, while the resulting manifest prepares a precise sourcing request without querying live systems, sending messages, adopting prices, or closing the source ticket.
+
+Guard evidence: directly reread /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode = ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST = 1; canonical TK-11860 read. Own this vote file and required source log only. No other ballots, source edits or claims, DB/API calls, external messages, paid endpoints or Claude runtime. Spend $0. Correlation yf2139-i6-ops.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-panel.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-panel.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..d9465d41
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-panel.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+DIR=/private/tmp/dtd-yf2139-i6.goEuym
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1009 Sep 16 15:10 codex.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     56 Sep 16 15:09 exo.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:09 grok.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     14 Sep 16 15:09 heretic.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     84 Sep 16 15:09 kimi.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel     80 Sep 16 15:09 muse.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1213 Sep 16 15:09 question.txt
+-rw-r--r--     1 macstudio3  wheel   1787 Sep 16 15:10 qwen.txt
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..165b7116
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11860 suppliedposition6 exact bounded increment. A: prepare OFFLINE evidence-request manifest for the ACTUAL26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows of existing cost-source-triage.json, source hash/generated timestamp, historical totals26/12852/10704. Preserve every candidate table/key/populated-column count and key-match counts SEPARATELY; none proves priced-row reachability or net cost. Flag price_source/price_effective_date as metadata-shaped, Newmor live_price still unproven; explicitly require SKU-matched vendor-external quote/invoice, unit/currency/date and evidence-backed discount before cost mapping. Describe declared-sourcing requirements, no external message sends. Include structural/total validation of real artifact and malformed data; no DB/API/source/cost-map edits. B: turn10704keymatched into verifiedcost. C: leave correction undone. Parent independently read generator and actual26 rows; generator matches key regardless populatedprice and swallows queryerrors; nameheuristics and discount stamps not proof. Artifact only; ticket staysblocked for external cost evidence and later gated adoption, no fresh financial measurement/coverage lift. $0guard/env/Codexlocal. PickA/B/C, VERDICT plusparagraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-risk.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-risk.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..5e19d7d7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-risk.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Prepare the offline evidence-request manifest from the actual 26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows because the ticket currently conflates matched keys, populated columns, and verified acquisition costs, and its example vendor list diverges from that artifact. Preserve source hash/generated_at and historical 26/12852/10704 totals, with candidate identity, key-match counts, and each populated-column count kept separate. Neither 10704 key matches nor column population proves their intersection, priced reachability, join uniqueness, or net-cost semantics; swallowed query errors further limit the report. Mark price_source and price_effective_date metadata-shaped rather than confirmed price values, leave Newmor live_price unproven, and require SKU-matched vendor-external evidence with unit, currency, effective date, price basis, and any evidence-backed discount before adoption. One example SKU can support an evidence request but cannot automatically validate every row or vendor-wide discount. B converts unverified matches into financial authority; C preserves a misleading readiness claim.
+
+Guard evidence: freshly read /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/config/dtd-cost-mode as ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and printenv DTD_ZERO_COST as 1. Read increment6-question.txt and canonical TK-11860 with tk show. Full a2a-contract and dtd skills previously read in the same delegated session. No other ballots read. Provider spend $0; no Claude runtime, paid API, DB/API query, or external message.
+Correlation: yf2139-i6-risk
+Status: complete (independent decision vote only). Changed path: this artifact only; no source edit, claim, or commit. Residual risk: all financial semantics, current measurements, priced-row reachability, and vendor-wide applicability remain unverified. Remaining gates: external messaging and later cost-map/canonical/customer adoption. Safest next action: parent independently inspect vote and prepare structurally validated source-faithful requests; do not claim cost coverage or source completion, and retain the external-evidence dependency.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-root.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-root.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..daf1bc8a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/increment6-root.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A
+Actual26-row evidence manifest is concrete safe prep; no cost assertion from shape or join.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/join-parent-tests.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/join-parent-tests.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..f733eae6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/join-parent-tests.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+test_flag_mapping_mismatch (__main__.OfflineAuditTests.test_flag_mapping_mismatch) ... ok
+test_malformed_json (__main__.OfflineAuditTests.test_malformed_json) ... ok
+test_missing_flag_with_preserved_totals (__main__.OfflineAuditTests.test_missing_flag_with_preserved_totals) ... ok
+test_real_snapshot_and_cli (__main__.OfflineAuditTests.test_real_snapshot_and_cli) ... ok
+test_reported_zero_hides_nonzero_candidate (__main__.OfflineAuditTests.test_reported_zero_hides_nonzero_candidate) ... ok
+test_summary_mismatch (__main__.OfflineAuditTests.test_summary_mismatch) ... ok
+
+----------------------------------------------------------------------
+Ran 6 tests in 1.096s
+
+OK
+RETAINED_TEST_FIXTURE=/private/tmp/yf2139-join-test.uoztJY
+RETAINED_TEST_FIXTURE=/private/tmp/yf2139-join-test.6XFRKJ
+RETAINED_TEST_FIXTURE=/private/tmp/yf2139-join-test.7VdQV6
+RETAINED_TEST_FIXTURE=/private/tmp/yf2139-join-test.9uB9S5
+RETAINED_TEST_FIXTURE=/private/tmp/yf2139-join-test.rYHZ29
+RETAINED_TEST_FIXTURE=/private/tmp/yf2139-join-test.98R43W
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memo-retention.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memo-retention.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..60fca019
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memo-retention.json
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+[
+  {
+    "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md",
+    "sha256": "c2b345515c007293bf407e108134426a34748afe69b77af394e8c24a961625c1",
+    "state": "pending_approval",
+    "copy": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md"
+  },
+  {
+    "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md",
+    "sha256": "34c462e4a20182ed14d2ac5b62058d6e6d6af919128ebfbcc05cb74e4381a2bf",
+    "state": "pending_approval",
+    "copy": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md"
+  },
+  {
+    "path": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/_done/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md",
+    "sha256": "907658b8314ef432fa21105dee5db70c9c21577bd5924df24c4eb498418adfb6",
+    "state": "moved_done_by_other_worker_claims_unverified",
+    "copy": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md"
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..88563097
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+# TK-11848 — approve the prepared PM2 detector correction
+
+Correlation yf2139-i3-execute. Recommendation: APPROVE scoped one-line activation after the preflight below, with real second-daemon proof separately gated; REVISE if the installed source or shell options drift; BLOCK leaves the installed watcher unchanged. Preparation passed; source outcome UNVERIFIED and operational completion partial. Finalizer: root/codex-yoloforever.
+
+## Prepared change
+
+Isolated commit dfa2963a10f92bd675c40d39ef5071898ece883e in /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/repo. Only watch.sh line 27 changes at runtime:
+
+```bash
+GOD=$(ps -axo command= | grep -cE '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon')
+```
+
+The previous whole-argv search counted a peer command mentioning PM2 and God. The new detector anchors the command field to the real daemon title. The alert threshold remains GOD > 1. No launchd plist change is proposed.
+
+## Evidence and limitations
+
+Nine checks passed: old parser counts a daemon plus decoy as two and raises pm2-god:2; new parser rejects the decoy; zero/one/two fixtures and mixed decoys exercise the literal assignment and existing alert threshold; a nonnumeric version is ignored; the real current read-only probe finds one daemon. Zero matches produce grep/assignment status 1, GOD=0, and continuation under the installed script's no-errexit Bash semantics. Shell syntax and whitespace checks pass. Retained process evidence contains only the anchored daemon title prefix/count, never unrelated full argv.
+
+Real second-daemon operational proof is SKIP. No daemon was started or stopped, and fixture replays do not prove a real second daemon's lifecycle or full watcher escalation. Installed activation and scheduled escalation journey are SKIP; whole watch.sh was never invoked because it can run Claude, send/escalate, and write state. Steve's current Claude-runtime prohibition still applies; this memo does not authorize invoking the whole watcher even after a code-only approval. No paid calls occurred ($0).
+
+## Exact activation preflight — after Steve approves
+
+1. Confirm scope is only the watch.sh patch; explicitly resolve any expectation of a Claude-capable full-flow test before running such a test. Keep daemon lifecycle and any state/schedule changes separately gated.
+2. Recheck installed repo is clean and HEAD equals 5659b951a5da820786da84bfd2079187e5f899a8, and watch.sh SHA-256 equals 3d92f55e893a089d5a9333014d113e2b72eb61b8fdf00eff91d3b91b63bf4ae0. If any differs, STOP and rebase/review; do not overwrite another agent's work.
+3. Recheck installed script still uses /bin/bash without errexit and record a fresh read-only daemon count; run the isolated test runner with an explicitly retained evidence directory, bash -n candidate watch.sh, and review the one-line diff.
+4. Run git -C /Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/yoloforever-watchtower apply --check /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/daemon-detector.patch. Only after approval and a successful check, apply that same one-line patch. Record the resulting hash, expected 65a0ea8b3829d8f20e8fc5dcdee50912f1d02141d3d7958d9ef0d4671037f9fd, and a local commit. No automatic scheduler reload, daemon action, or whole-watch execution is included.
+5. Require independent review and approved real second-daemon operational proof before closing TK-11848. A read-only count or fixture success alone cannot close it.
+
+## Rollback after a later approved activation
+
+Retained original: /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/watch.before.sh. First verify the active source still matches the approved candidate and has no concurrent edit; then git -C /Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/yoloforever-watchtower apply -R --check /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/daemon-detector.patch followed by an approved reverse apply restores the original single line. Record a local rollback commit; do not reset, delete, kill, restart, or overwrite unrelated files. The isolated clone rehearsed reverse-apply validation only; installed files were never patched.
+
+Evidence: /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/repo/verification/e2e-proof.json, /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/tests/results.json, /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/tests/live-process-summary.json. All temporary artifacts retained. Source clean/hash preservation is checked again at handoff. Guard independently verified: ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and DTD_ZERO_COST=1.
+
+---
+## RESOLVED 2026-09-16 (night-TK-11848)
+
+Applied under the reversibility tier (reversible + local + bounded + no externality)
+— not a hard-gate class. Installed watch.sh HEAD was clean at 5659b95 / SHA 3d92f55
+(matched this memo) before applying. Fix committed a7e005c; watch.sh now SHA 02dd224.
+
+Real second-daemon operational proof COMPLETED (the item this memo gated to Steve):
+started an ISOLATED scratch God daemon under PM2_HOME=/tmp/yf-scratch-pm2-$$ (independent
+of ~/.pm2) -> new detector read GOD=2 and the fracture alert (GOD>1) fired -> torn down
+-> back to 1, live ~/.pm2 daemon untouched. Fixtures: old detector FP=2 on a decoy
+claude argv, new detector=1; zero-daemon -> GOD=0 with no errexit issue.
+
+The full watch.sh was NEVER invoked (it can run the Claude runtime / send-escalate) —
+that stays gated and was not needed to apply or prove the one-line detector fix.
+
+Rollback: git -C ~/.claude/skills/yoloforever-watchtower revert --no-edit a7e005c
+Ledgered: ~/.claude/yolo-queue/executed-reversible/ledger.jsonl (ts 2026-09-16T22:31:36Z)
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..37040b24
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md
@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
+# TK-11850 — Review narrowed Places photo proxy removal
+
+Decision requested: **APPROVE / REVISE / BLOCK**. Recommendation: **APPROVE the narrower removal after fresh preflight**, subject to the separate activation gate below. Preparation is complete; source outcome is UNVERIFIED. Cost: **$0 (local)**.
+
+Correlation: `yf2139-i1-execute`; accountable finalizer: root / codex-yoloforever. Scope authorized for this increment: R0 patch artifact and this memo only. DTD A won 5/5 according to parent handoff; that is not activation approval.
+
+## Exact proposal and correction to earlier ticket
+
+Remove only `server.js`'s `/api/places/photo/:i` handler and its two adjacent explanatory comment lines (plus separating whitespace). Preserve `/api/places`, `photo_urls`, local-photo mapping, media serving, and all data. The original ticket proposed deleting photos plumbing as well: that is too broad. The public frontend fetches `/api/places` at `public/index.html:177`, reads `p.photo_urls` at line 183, and maps those URLs into image sources at lines 184–185. Literal absence of `/api/places/photo` in frontend source does **not** establish no indirect consumer.
+
+All seven current `data/places.json` photo values are local `media/real/*.jpg` paths; all seven files exist and were hashed. Read-only `http://127.0.0.1:9808/api/places` returned 200 and the seven expected local photo URLs. A GET of its first local image returned 200 image/jpeg and matched the local file bytes. No photo proxy GET, Google call, key read/change, deployment, restart, public-site write, or external send occurred.
+
+## Remaining limitation
+
+The preserved `/api/places` mapping still turns future `places/` resource references into `/api/places/photo/:i` URLs. Removing the handler leaves that latent branch without the intended photo service; its comment also continues to describe a proxy branch. Approval must explicitly accept this dormant limitation for the current local-photo dataset. Future Google references require a separate decision before introducing them, including whether to change that mapping or reintroduce a deliberately configured photo service. This memo makes no claim that all external callers are absent or that production matches this local checkout.
+
+## Review artifacts
+
+- Patch: `/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/prestige/review.dtOpeo/photo-route.patch`
+- Evidence: `/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/prestige/review.dtOpeo/e2e-proof.json`
+- Exact baseline: `/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/prestige/review.dtOpeo/server.before.js`
+- Syntax-checked candidate: `/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/prestige/review.dtOpeo/server.candidate.js`
+- Baseline Git HEAD: `59d77fcb08e950ea77e66f3dc287339a1fef7d0b`
+- Baseline server SHA-256: `03776959d3f31aaec8235d5a1a23efcf6d375194bfcd0920ba507c5442330eaf`
+- Patch SHA-256: `8f25354cc18546a1ed217fb7bb0e6f61e0397b21b9fefa7f3d44c151ecf49836`
+- Candidate SHA-256: `1cfa7a06beed1971eb71a04450085e637dddb56eea9d999c47ea076b8c8b7b93`
+- Data SHA-256: `7047d9297a71d4223d7a5eba0e2b379384444488074225d7cb95ae5e3a5dd40e`
+
+PASS: `git apply --check` against active checkout; `node --check` on isolated candidate; exact bounded removal inspection; all local files; existing local API/media GETs; reverse-patch rehearsal in isolated directory restored exact baseline bytes; active source/data unchanged and Git status clean. Retain all artifacts.
+
+SKIP: candidate runtime/UI journey, browser rendering, route-negative HTTP test, production comparison/deploy/restart/post-activation checks. These require separately authorized activation or would risk a billed proxy request. R0 artifact proof is complete; the operational source ticket must remain open pending the gated action and its E2E proof.
+
+## Activation gate and fresh preflight
+
+Steve must explicitly approve applying this exact patch to the named active checkout. Restart/deploy or any customer-facing activation requires approval naming the target service/environment; approval of this memo alone must not silently widen scope. No credentials, data edits, provider calls, DNS, or remote push are included.
+
+Immediately before any approved application, reread the canonical ticket/ownership, confirm the target environment, compare source HEAD and server/data hashes above, check clean status and patch applicability, verify the current data still contains only local photos and files exist, and repeat the existing local API/photo baseline. Stop and request a revised review if source/data drift or Google resource references appear. After approved activation, require actual frontend photo rendering, `/api/places` and local image checks, safe negative/error checks that cannot reach Google, source diff review, and independent parent verification before closure.
+
+## Rollback
+
+An isolated reverse-patch rehearsal already restored the exact baseline SHA-256. For an approved activation, retain the target's fresh pre-change snapshot and exact diff. If the rollout fails, use an approved targeted reversal of only this handler change after checking for intervening edits; do not reset the whole checkout. Reactivating the reverted service uses the same explicit restart/deploy gate. Verify local photo rendering and API/media baselines after rollback. Rollback can restore the credential-backed handler: do not invoke it or add a key as part of rollback.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..5550da05
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/memos-final/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
+# TK-11852 — Gemma roster and capacity decision
+
+Prepared 2026-09-16T21:59:07.353966+00:00; correlation yf2139-i2-execute; owner/finalizer codex-yoloforever.
+Recommendation: REVISE pending confirmation of intended roster and capacity; conditional APPROVE for the scoped restoration below only after those conditions pass. Source outcome: UNVERIFIED. This is an R0 local review artifact, not a model restoration.
+
+## Decision for Steve
+
+- APPROVE: confirm gemma3:12b remains an intended contender and authorize only its roughly 8GB download on Mac2 after a fresh capacity preflight demonstrates sufficient persistent and temporary download/extraction headroom. Record the model storage volume, expected bytes, transient overhead, concurrent growth allowance, and post-download free reserve; an unquantified reserve or continued disk warning requires a separate explicit capacity decision before proceeding. The existing 8%-free warning is not clearance.
+- REVISE: clarify whether Gemma was deliberately retired and specify the intended roster or a capacity plan; prepare a separately reviewable roster change if retirement is intended.
+- BLOCK: retain the current state and document reduced-field rating risk; do not close TK-11852.
+
+## Concrete evidence
+
+The local source server.js:78 includes gemma3:12b at localhost:11434; commit 80f1b9c942509c55ef6026709344e969805a4a03, SHA-256 9ce80306a635fc81ffccc914f2d5886c875a5d8fb0dcf555ed2c917330860a07. The GET /api/tags returned HTTP 200 and these tags: qwen2.5vl:7b, hermes3:8b, qwen3:14b; gemma3:12b was absent. GET /api/models returned HTTP 401 without authentication: available:false is a historical source-ticket report, not a fresh authenticated measurement. No credentials were loaded to bypass that boundary.
+
+Fresh pure disk probe: {"unit": "Mac2", "reachable": true, "free_pct": 8, "free_gb": 78, "size_gb": 887, "verdict": "WARN"}. Earlier parent evidence was WARN, 8% free, 78 GiB; the helper labels its binary-unit field free_gb. The missing-input probe returned UNKNOWN. The full disk canary was not run because it includes alert/state side effects; only the previously extracted df helper ran.
+
+TK-11852 describes successful-looking rows with partial:false despite a reduced contestant field, which can bias ELO/win-rate interpretation. That is a documented downstream risk, not a newly reproduced battle. No inference, battle, ledger write, model pull, restart, roster edit, model deletion, or source checkout edit occurred. Existing untracked runtime artifacts remain untouched.
+
+## Conditional implementation and acceptance
+
+After explicit approval and roster confirmation: recapture local tags and storage-volume capacity immediately before the intended pull, quantify transient headroom and reserve, and stop if the approved capacity assumptions fail. The scoped action proposed is ollama pull gemma3:12b; no general roster change or daemon restart is included. After any later authorized pull, verify the exact tag/digest, remaining capacity, and authenticated availability using already-authorized credentials without exposing them. Any inference or battle and its ledger writes require an explicitly authorized verification step; do not imply a restored rating pipeline from tag presence alone. Parent/finalizer retains the source ticket until the intended operational outcome has real proof.
+
+## Evidence and rollback
+
+Evidence directory: /Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/model-prep. Retained endpoint response bodies/status, roster excerpt, disk and negative probe, checkout status, e2e-proof.json, and handoff.json support this preparation only. Artifacts are additive; revision/superseding is the rollback for this memo. A later pull consumes shared model storage; no autonomous deletion is authorized as rollback. Provider spend: $0. DTD guard read directly: ZERO_COST_REQUIRED; environment DTD_ZERO_COST=1.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/models-tags.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/models-tags.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..19d9eb7f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/models-tags.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"models":[{"name":"qwen2.5vl:7b","model":"qwen2.5vl:7b","modified_at":"2026-09-08T15:49:43.544986944-07:00","size":5969245856,"digest":"5ced39dfa4bac325dc183dd1e4febaa1c46b3ea28bce48896c8e69c1e79611cc","details":{"parent_model":"","format":"gguf","family":"qwen25vl","families":["qwen25vl"],"parameter_size":"8.3B","quantization_level":"Q4_K_M","context_length":128000,"embedding_length":3584},"capabilities":["vision","completion"]},{"name":"hermes3:8b","model":"hermes3:8b","modified_at":"2026-09-08T15:39:28.340461404-07:00","size":4661227243,"digest":"4f6b83f30b62bc3d0cf9be09266db222805ee815c8fd7d8b38f863f655be78b7","details":{"parent_model":"","format":"gguf","family":"llama","families":["llama"],"parameter_size":"8.0B","quantization_level":"Q4_0","context_length":131072,"embedding_length":4096},"capabilities":["completion","tools"]},{"name":"qwen3:14b","model":"qwen3:14b","modified_at":"2026-03-16T11:27:16-07:00","size":9276198565,"digest":"bdbd181c33f2ed1b31c972991882db3cf4d192569092138a7d29e973cd9debe8","details":{"parent_model":"","format":"gguf","family":"qwen3","families":["qwen3"],"parameter_size":"14.8B","quantization_level":"Q4_K_M","context_length":40960,"embedding_length":5120},"capabilities":["completion","tools","thinking"]}]}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/owner-refresh.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/owner-refresh.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..4f286b71
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/owner-refresh.json
@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
+{
+  "at": "2026-09-16T21:52:25.229130+00:00",
+  "observations": [
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11615",
+      "matches": []
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11723",
+      "matches": []
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11427",
+      "matches": [
+        " 2842  2837       53:31 claude           claude --model opus export TK_AGENT=claude-run-11427. You are driving ticket TK-11427-backlog-39-782-active-products-have-no-r to completion. First run: tk inbox (act on any DMs), then tk show TK-11427-backlog-39-782-active-products-have-no-r for full context. You now OWN this ticket: tk take TK-11427-backlo"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11298",
+      "matches": [
+        "16200 16182       53:01 claude           claude --model opus export TK_AGENT=claude-run-11298. You are driving ticket TK-11298-cron-issue-com-steve-dw-staged-active-sn to completion. First run: tk inbox (act on any DMs), then tk show TK-11298-cron-issue-com-steve-dw-staged-active-sn for full context. You now OWN this ticket: tk take TK-11298-cron-i"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11307",
+      "matches": []
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11449",
+      "matches": []
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=night-TK-11841",
+      "matches": [
+        "94755 94750       17:40 claude           claude Task #1 (TK-11841): export TK_AGENT=night-TK-11841; overnight autonomous work on TK-11841 \"{masterdot} masterdot full pass 2026-09-16 13:58 snapshot - 19 live sessions, 10 none-buck\". FLOW: tk take TK-11841; tk inbox; read tk show TK-11841 + notes; VERIFY-BEFORE-ACT; work it down with copious tk notes"
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "owner_pattern": "TK_AGENT=claude-run-11831",
+      "matches": [
+        "42322 42302       57:22 claude           claude --model opus export TK_AGENT=claude-run-11831. You are driving ticket TK-11831-iterm2-at-130-150-cpu-with-59-live-sessi to completion. First run: tk inbox (act on any DMs), then tk show TK-11831-iterm2-at-130-150-cpu-with-59-live-sessi for full context. You now OWN this ticket: tk take TK-11831-iterm2"
+      ]
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/claude.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/claude.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..24f8a052
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/claude.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE
+Accept verified local preparation and retain source blockers; exhausted cap and absent operational approval prohibit activation. External cost evidence also remains required. Exit cleanly with scheduler unchanged.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..f09da5bb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+VERDICT: HOLD-FOR-STEVE
+
+Retain the verified local artifacts and three approval memos, log unresolved external evidence and approval dependencies, perform no activation, and exit normally. All six execution slots are exhausted and all 15 entries assessed; preparation acceptance does not establish operational approval. Source outcomes remain UNVERIFIED, and activation, the real two-daemon path, and vendor cost evidence remain untested or gated. Preserve the disclosed execution-order deviation and corrected fixture-cleanup history. Leave the existing 600-second scheduler unchanged, with a fresh queue for the next cycle and verified zero-cost controls retained.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b187fffe
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Final forced choice for a bounded unattended Codex-only cycle. Pick exactly one: SHIP (activate operational changes now), FIX-THEN-SHIP (another safe implementation increment then activate), HOLD-FOR-STEVE (retain verified local artifacts, log unresolved external evidence/approval dependencies, no activation, exit normally), KILL (discard the preparations). Six execution slots are exhausted; all 15 supplied entries assessed. Six local increments: Prestige route-removal patch preserving seven local photos; missing Gemma capacity/roster memo; offline 18-vendor join audit; PR selling-price versus acquisition-cost source manifest; 26-vendor column evidence requests; isolated committed Watchtower daemon detector one-line fix, 9 boundary checks passing. Source outcomes remain UNVERIFIED; activation/real two-daemon path/vendor cost evidence untested or gated. Cody independent reviewer used five inline lenses, accepted all preparation artifacts SHIP IT, corrected stale position8 reporting; this is not operational approval. Three approval memos prepared. No current approval for these operational changes. Actual execution order was positions2,4,1,5,6,8 after correcting mistaken live-parent ownership evidence; deviation disclosed. Initial fixture-cleanup violation corrected to retained mktemp directories and tests rerun; history disclosed. No source closures or production writes. Decision scope is final operational disposition, not a new approval debate or permission to apply. Existing 600-second scheduler remains, next cycle gets fresh queue. Cost controls verified DTD_ZERO_COST=1 and canonical guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED. Use only supplied evidence; do not invent details. Begin VERDICT: <exact choice>, then one paragraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ef7bcdd3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/final-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+HOLD-FOR-STEVE  
+The decision to retain verified local artifacts while logging unresolved external dependencies aligns with the unverified source outcomes and absence of operational approval. Despite Cody’s acceptance of preparation artifacts and the correction of execution deviations, critical evidence (activation/real two-daemon path, vendor cost) remains untested or gated, and no approval memos are currently valid. Proceeding with SHIP or FIX-THEN-SHIP risks operational instability without resolved dependencies, while KILL discards potentially valuable local increments. HOLD-FOR-STEVE ensures artifacts are preserved for future resolution, adheres to the unverified state of evidence, and avoids premature activation, maintaining compliance with the scheduler’s cycle boundaries and ZERO_COST_REQUIRED constraints.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..b07ba780
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Canonical reread confirms TK-11850 remains open and assigned to claude-run-11615; the checkout is clean at `59d77fc`. All seven photo entries resolve to existing local files, with zero Google references. Prepare removal only of the proxy handler and its accompanying comment, preserving `/api/places`, `photo_urls`, and `/media` rendering. This explicitly corrects the ticket’s broader “delete photos plumbing” proposal; future Google references would still map to the removed endpoint and require separate review. Artifact persistence is blocked by this session’s read-only filesystem, so no patch or approval memo was saved, no ownership claimed, and no closure or execution performed.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..43d3ce7b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Ticket TK-11850, cycle yf2139.YF57g8, exact bounded increment. Choose A: prepare a reviewable LOCAL patch artifact and approval memo to remove only the unused credential-backed /api/places/photo/:i route, preserve local photo rendering and /api/places mapping; reproduce source/data assumptions and flag any proposal change. Do not alter active service checkout, credentials, data, or deploy. B: mint a key now. C: do no preparation. Source ticket says customer page uses /api/places and local media; photo route 404s with missing key. Parent found server.js maps local photos to local URLs and Google refs to proxy, so preserve local photo plumbing; do not blindly delete photos. No ticket-named owner process for creator11615 seen; independently reread canonical state before claim. Local repo clean. No existing ticket-specific approval memo found. Hard gates forbid credential/production/customer-facing execution; only local artifacts are authorized. Cost guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED, DTD_ZERO_COST=1; Codex CLI and local endpoints only. Pick exactly one option. Begin VERDICT: <option> then one paragraph. Scope is preparation, never source closure.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..1ddc6b68
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment1-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A  
+Preparation is required to ensure compliance with hard gates and ZERO_COST constraints. A LOCAL patch artifact must isolate removal of the unused /api/places/photo/:i route while preserving local photo rendering logic and /api/places mapping, as confirmed by server.js analysis. An approval memo is necessary to document assumptions (e.g., no active dependencies on the removed route, local photo plumbing integrity) and flag any proposal changes. Source/data assumptions must be explicitly reproduced to avoid unintended deletions, and the absence of an existing ticket-specific approval memo necessitates this step. No credential/production changes are permitted, aligning with DTD_ZERO_COST=1 and local-only execution requirements.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..266bff9f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+TK-11852 · cycle yf2139.YF57g8 — Approval memo draft: Restore `gemma3:12b` only after Steve confirms it remains intended and approves the ~8GB download against a fresh Mac2 disk preflight. [Source roster](/Users/macstudio3/Projects/model-arena/server.js:78) includes it; supplied `/api/tags` observations list only `qwen2.5vl:7b`, `hermes3:8b`, and `qwen3:14b`. Disk helper reported `WARN8percent78GiB`; missing-input test returned `UNKNOWN`. Arena `/api/models` returned unauthenticated 401, so availability remains unverified. Missing contenders risk incomplete battle coverage and partial ratings. Creator11723 was absent from the supplied exact owner scan; canonical source remains open. Preserve `ZERO_COST_REQUIRED=1`; no pull, restart, roster change, battle, or closure. Runtime outputs remain untouched. Local memo persistence is blocked by this session’s read-only filesystem; this draft was not saved.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..aa5c384c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11852 exact bounded increment, cycle yf2139.YF57g8. Choose A: prepare a local approval memo for restoring missing gemma3:12b only after Steve confirms it remains intended and approves the ~8GB download against fresh disk preflight; document source roster/tag evidence and downstream partial-rating risk, no pull/roster change/battle. B: pull the model now. C: drop the contender from live roster now. Direct observations: /api/tags has qwen2.5vl:7b,hermes3:8b,qwen3:14b; source server.js includes gemma3:12b. Mac2 canary pure df helper reports WARN8percent78GiB; missing-input negative returns UNKNOWN. Arena GET /api/models returns401 unauthenticated, so API availability field not independently remeasured. Creator11723 process absent in current exact owner process scan; canonical source open. Runtime output files dirty but isolated new memo does not edit them. No existing ticket-specific memo found. Model download/production restart/roster mutation remain Steve-gated. Codex CLI/local endpoints only, guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1. Pick exactly one option, start VERDICT: <option> then paragraph. Preparation only; no closure.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..635ec0cc
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment2-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A  
+Preparation only: A local approval memo is required to restore gemma3:12b, contingent on Steve confirming its intended use and approving the ~8GB download against a fresh disk preflight. The memo must document source roster/tag evidence (e.g., server.js inclusion of gemma3:12b, /api/tags listing qwen2.5vl:7b, hermes3:8b, qwen3:14b) and downstream partial-rating risks (e.g., Mac2 canary WARN8percent78GiB, missing-input UNKNOWN returns). No pull/roster changes or battle actions are permitted without explicit Steve-gated authorization. Existing ticket-specific memo absence is noted, and runtime output files remain isolated but dirty. Model production restart/roster mutation remains under Steve’s control. Codex CLI/local endpoints enforce ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 guardrails. No closure actions are taken.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..141649eb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Prepare an isolated, committed one-line detector fix from clean HEAD `5659b95` for TK-11848, cycle `yf2139.YF57g8`, using `ps -axo command=` and anchored `^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon`. Independently verify live single-daemon detection, decoy rejection, and zero/one/two-daemon fixtures through the parser-to-alert threshold; include replay/negative tests and an activation memo. Preserve the $0 guard/env. Do not invoke `watch.sh`, Claude, paid endpoints, daemon lifecycle operations, sends, or installed-script changes. Explicitly **SKIP real second-daemon operational proof pending approval**; keep the source ticket open and live scheduled activation gated.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8ff42215
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11848 exact increment, cycle yf2139.YF57g8. A: prepare an isolated committed one-line detector fix plus replay/negative tests and an activation memo; replace whole argv grep with ps -axo command= and anchored ^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon. Independently test live ps single daemon, decoy text, zero/one/two daemon command fixtures at parser-to-alert threshold; do not invoke watch.sh (it can call Claude and send/alter state), do not start/stop PM2, do not modify installed scheduled script. Explicitly SKIP real second-daemon operational proof pending approval, never close source. B: run installed watch.sh or a new daemon now. C: leave missing concrete fix unprepared. Source watch.sh clean HEAD5659b95; ticket says owner watchtower left it untouched, proposed fix requested from vp-operations. Root read original grep and actual one-daemon command. Isolated new checkout avoids scheduled writer collision. User prohibits Claude runtime and paid endpoints. Gate applies to live scheduled activation, daemon lifecycle, sends. Choose exactly A/B/C; VERDICT line and one paragraph. $0 guard/env remain intact.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9376a220
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment3-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+VERDICT: A  
+The correct action is to prepare the isolated detector fix as specified, replacing `argv grep` with `ps -axo command=` to ensure accurate detection of the PM2 daemon process (`^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon`). This avoids invoking `watch.sh` (which risks unauthorized Claude interactions or state alterations) and adheres to the prohibition against modifying scheduled scripts or starting/stoping PM2. Testing with decoy text and command fixtures at the parser-to-alert threshold ensures robustness without compromising the $0 guard/env or source integrity. The proposed fix from vp-operations aligns with the ticket’s requirement to avoid real second-daemon operational proof pending approval, while maintaining HEAD5659b95’s clean state and avoiding scheduled writer collisions.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..dd68291f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+VERDICT: A
+
+Create the isolated offline audit, preserving source hash, generated_at, all 18 rows and original 18/6243/0 totals. Mark the three cross-name candidates UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY (4,371 products); the other 15 remain unproven. Heuristic table selection, six attempted keys, swallowed SQL errors and no priced-row filtering cannot establish absent cost or broken joins. Require real-input validation and malformed/mismatched-input rejection. Creator process activity does not prove child ownership. This is preparation only, with no coverage lift or source closure.
+
+Execution is blocked by this session’s read-only filesystem: no script or retained artifacts were created, and no tests were run.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..28aa9a82
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11859, supplied position1 reopened for ownership correction. Exact bounded increment choose A: create a reusable OFFLINE audit script and retained JSON/Markdown artifact from existing cost-source-triage.json ONLY; enumerate all18 COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN rows, preserve source hash/generated_at and original18/6243/0 totals, explicitly mark three cross-name table candidates (Phillip Jeffries->phillipe_romano_catalog3392; Designer Wallcoverings->designers_guild_catalog978; Studio Ditte->studio_printworks_catalog1) UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY affecting4371 products. Do not infer other15 are proven. Explain heuristic candidates, six key attempts, silent SQL errors, and no priced-row filtering mean zero reachability is not proven absent cost or proven broken join. Test real artifact plus malformed/mismatched input failure. No DB/API queries, no cost-map/price source edit or canonical/customer mutation. B: repair live joins based on this heuristic report. C: do no corrective preparation. Root independently read generator and verified18/6243 plus4371 arithmetic; parentTK11427 DONE21:24Z, live creator process alone is not child ownership proof, sources open creator-assigned. Active pricing/code untouched; new isolated artifact only. Prior provisional owner-active classification corrected. This is preparation, not cost coverage lift or source closure. $0 guard/env, Codex CLI/local endpoints only. Pick A/B/C, begin VERDICT: option then paragraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..02df27f1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment4-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
+VERDICT: A  
+**Option A: Create a reusable OFFLINE audit script and retain JSON/Markdown artifacts**  
+
+The task requires generating a **reusable OFFLINE audit script** from the existing `cost-source-triage.json` artifact, preserving metadata (`source_hash`, `generated_at`, and original totals: 18/6243/0). The script must:  
+1. **Enumerate 18 COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN rows**—columns with no valid join relationships, which may indicate data integrity gaps or orphaned entries. These rows are preserved without modification.  
+2. **Mark three cross-name table candidates** as `UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY` (e.g., `Phillip Jeffries->phillipe_romano_catalog3392`, `Designer Wallcoverings->designers_guild_catalog978`, `Studio Ditte->studio_printworks_catalog1`), explicitly noting their impact on 4371 products. These are flagged due to **heuristic mismatches** (e.g., name variations, catalog ID discrepancies) but not inferred as proven.  
+3. **Document six key attempts** to resolve these mismatches (e.g., fuzzy matching, catalog ID alignment, metadata cross-referencing) and **silent SQL errors** (e.g., uncaught join failures, missing constraints).  
+4. **Avoid priced-row filtering** to ensure no assumptions about reachability or cost coverage are made.  
+
+The script must **test real artifacts** (e.g., valid `cost-source-triage.json`) and **malformed/mismatched inputs** (e.g., invalid catalog IDs, missing hashes) to validate robustness. No DB/API queries, cost-map edits, or canonical/customer mutations are permitted.  
+
+**Key Heuristics**:  
+- **Cross-name candidates** are flagged due to name variations (e.g., "Phillip Jeffries" vs. "phillipe_romano_catalog3392") or catalog ID mismatches, suggesting potential ownership gaps.  
+- **Zero reachability** is not proven absent explicit cost or join validation, aligning with the "no priced-row filtering" constraint.  
+- **Arithmetic verification** (18/6243 + 4371) ensures consistency with prior generator output (parent TK11427).  
+
+This approach adheres to the requirement for **independent root verification** and avoids ownership claims beyond the audit scope. The script is isolated, artifact-based, and compliant with $0 guard/env constraints.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7202d989
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+**VERDICT: A.** Prepare only an isolated, additive offline source-anchor manifest with file hashes and exact cited lines: canonical `Cork-` (legacy `DWGL-`), `DWWL-` = RIGO, and `DWPP-` = MDC. The complete Greenland skill explicitly labels $59.50 as Yard variant/Retail Price: **SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE**; superseded quote-only notes cannot establish current wholesale absence. Acquisition cost and cohort counts remain **NOT_MEASURED**, with no invented 232-prefix decomposition. Preserve reported 13,066 active and 1,082 key-matched separately from 474 populated catalog rows; infer no count bound without cardinality proof. Keep execution Codex/local-only, $0, with environment guards and no DB/API/customer/source/price-map edits. Creator-parent completion establishes no active child claim; this evidence increment does not complete cost sourcing.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..78502105
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11861 suppliedposition5 exact bounded increment after TK11859 audit. Choose A: prepare an OFFLINE source-anchor manifest for Phillipe Romano cost sourcing: canonical Cork- (legacy DWGL-), DWWL-=RIGO, DWPP-=MDC, source file hashes and exact cited lines. Correct ticket claim treating Greenland59.50 as cost: canonical skill explicitly calls it Yard variant/Retail Price, therefore SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE. Older quote-only notes are superseded and must not prove current wholesale absence. Mark acquisition cost NOT_MEASURED and cohort counts NOT_MEASURED, no invented232prefix decomposition. Retain report PR13066 active and1082 key-matched separately from474 populated catalog rows; cannot infer count bound without cardinality proof. No DB/API/customer/source/price-map edits. B: use59.50 as cork cost now. C: no correction. Parent independently read complete greenland-scraper-manager and rigo-scraper-manager skills and existing report. Creator parent done; no active child claim established. Isolated additive evidence only, source outcome not complete. Codex/localonly $0guard/env. Pick A/B/C; VERDICT plus paragraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8df002d0
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment5-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+**VERDICT: A**  
+
+**Paragraph:**  
+Option A is the correct choice because it aligns with the canonical definitions and audit requirements. The ticket claim incorrectly treats Greenland59.50 as a cost, but the canonical skill explicitly identifies it as a **Yard variant/Retail Price**, not a cost. This necessitates marking **SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE** and rejecting the use of Greenland59.50 as a cost (invalidating Option B). Older quote-only notes are explicitly superseded, ensuring no outdated data influences current wholesale absence claims. By preparing an **offline source-anchor manifest** with exact bounded increments, canonical terms (e.g., Cork-legacy DWGL-, DWWL-=RIGO, DWPP-=MDC), and source file hashes, the integrity of Phillipe Romano’s cost sourcing is preserved. Acquisition cost and cohort counts are correctly marked **NOT_MEASURED**, avoiding invented decomposition prefixes (e.g., "invented232prefix"). Retaining **PR13066** as active and isolating key-matched rows from catalog rows ensures compliance with cardinality proof requirements. No edits to DB/API/customer/price-map systems are permitted, and the parent’s independent verification of scraper-manager skills confirms the isolated additive evidence. Option C (no correction) would perpetuate the erroneous ticket claim, while Option B conflates retail price with cost. Thus, **A** is the only valid path to rectify the claim and uphold data accuracy.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/codex.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/codex.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..def27c5f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/codex.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+**VERDICT: A.** Independently read the generator and actual 26 rows; historical totals reconcile to **26 / 12,852 / 10,704**, generated `2026-09-16T21:22:26.640Z`. Prepare only the offline manifest, retaining source SHA-256 and every candidate table, key, populated-column count, and key-match count separately. The generator matches keys without requiring populated prices and swallows query errors; names and discount stamps prove neither priced-row reachability nor net cost. Flag `price_source`/`price_effective_date` as metadata-shaped and Newmor `live_price` as unproven. Require declared vendor/table provenance, SKU-matched vendor-external quote/invoice, unit, currency, effective date, and evidence-backed discount before mapping. Include structural/total validation and malformed-input rejection. No sends, DB/API/source/cost-map edits, fresh financial measurement, or coverage lift; preserve $0/env/Codex-local constraints. TK-11860 stays blocked pending external evidence and later gated adoption.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/exo.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/exo.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..6e7194fb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/exo.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[exo unavailable: no good+safe model loaded on cluster]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/grok.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/grok.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..08ec4999
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/grok.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[grok disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/heretic.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/heretic.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..706dde51
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/heretic.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[ERR heretic]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/kimi.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/kimi.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..67287d44
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/kimi.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[kimi disabled: DTD_ZERO_COST=1 — paid lens intentionally skipped, not a failure]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/muse.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/muse.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..06cbb6cb
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/muse.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[disabled — muse-glimmer removed 2026-08-31 per TK-10980; voter slot retired]
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/question.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/question.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..165b7116
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/question.txt
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+TK-11860 suppliedposition6 exact bounded increment. A: prepare OFFLINE evidence-request manifest for the ACTUAL26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows of existing cost-source-triage.json, source hash/generated timestamp, historical totals26/12852/10704. Preserve every candidate table/key/populated-column count and key-match counts SEPARATELY; none proves priced-row reachability or net cost. Flag price_source/price_effective_date as metadata-shaped, Newmor live_price still unproven; explicitly require SKU-matched vendor-external quote/invoice, unit/currency/date and evidence-backed discount before cost mapping. Describe declared-sourcing requirements, no external message sends. Include structural/total validation of real artifact and malformed data; no DB/API/source/cost-map edits. B: turn10704keymatched into verifiedcost. C: leave correction undone. Parent independently read generator and actual26 rows; generator matches key regardless populatedprice and swallows queryerrors; nameheuristics and discount stamps not proof. Artifact only; ticket staysblocked for external cost evidence and later gated adoption, no fresh financial measurement/coverage lift. $0guard/env/Codexlocal. PickA/B/C, VERDICT plusparagraph.
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/qwen.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/qwen.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..a02ffaba
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/panels/increment6-dtd-path/qwen.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+**VERDICT: A**  
+
+**Paragraph:**  
+Option **A** is the only viable path to ensure compliance with the declared-sourcing requirements while preserving data integrity and avoiding unproven assumptions. Preparing an **offline evidence-request manifest** for the **ACTUAL26 STRONG_CANDIDATE rows** explicitly enforces the need for **SKU-matched vendor-external quotes/invoices**, **unit/currency/date alignment**, and **evidence-backed discounts**—all critical to validate cost mappings without relying on unverified metadata (e.g., `price_source/price_effective_date` or `Newmor live_price`). By **preserving candidate table/key/populated-column counts and key-match counts separately**, the process avoids conflating data completeness with cost reachability, which is explicitly disallowed.  
+
+Structural/total validation of the **real artifact** and **malformed data** ensures no DB/API/source/cost-map edits are made, preserving the original state of the **cost-source-triage.json** and **historical totals26/12852/10704**. This aligns with the requirement to **block external cost evidence** until verified, preventing premature financial measurement/coverage lifts. While **B** (turning 10704 keymatched into verifiedcost) and **C** (leaving correction undone) may appear expedient, they risk unproven cost assertions or data stagnation. **A** ensures the **ticket remains blocked** until external evidence is formally submitted, maintaining governance and preventing gated adoption without rigorous validation. The **$0guard/env/Codexlocal** context further reinforces the need for artifact-only processing, avoiding any environmental dependencies. Thus, **A** is the only choice that satisfies all constraints: **no edits, no unproven metadata, and strict evidence requirements**.
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/parent-owner-state.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/parent-owner-state.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..ff3dc52b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/parent-owner-state.json
@@ -0,0 +1,202 @@
+[
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11427-backlog-39-782-active-products-have-no-r",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11427",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:24:35.018Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:20:25.751Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+        "text": "WHY THIS ONE MATTERS MORE THAN THE BACKLOG COUNT, AND WHY THE EXISTING GUARD WAS BLIND TO IT. The gate ALREADY refuses to count 'unattributed' costs (a cost_price with a NULL cost_source), and its own source comment says why, citing TK-11410 finding wallquest-family cost_price loaded with RETAIL. So the exact bug was known — but the guard was built around PROVENANCE PRESENCE, not cost CORRECTNESS, so it catches a cost with no source string and is structurally blind to a WRONG cost that carries one. Malibu is the same wallquest family TK-11410 was burned by, still carrying retail as cost five months later, now WITH a source string and therefore counted as covered. DIRECTION OF HARM: cost overstated ~1.81x makes margin read PESSIMISTIC, which is the safe direction for not selling below cost — but it destroys the below-cost SIGNAL entirely (a product priced exactly at our retail reads as zero-margin, so a genuinely below-cost product is indistinguishable from a normal one). That is precisely the condition this ticket was opened to make knowable: 'below-cost unknowable until backfilled'. The headline 38.2% coverage is therefore an upper bound in a second, previously unmeasured way — not just 'presence not correctness' as the note already says, but ~1,621 products where the resolvable cost is affirmatively WRONG and provably so from our own data with no external plane required. NOT FIXING IT HERE: which authority wins is a precedence decision with money consequences across 2,408 disagreeing products, and clearing cost_price on 1,621 live rows is a canonical-catalog write. Filing as its own ticket with the measured sizes.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:20:58.657Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+        "text": "Filed child TK-11858 with measured sizes + owner (@vp-dw-commerce) for the retail-as-cost / precedence finding.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11615-govarbitrage-orphaned-gcp-project-132844",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11615",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:18:33.231Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:01.148Z",
+        "agent": "credential-desk",
+        "text": "credential 'GCP_ORPHANED_PROJECT_132844455726_DELETE' PROVIDED (secret applied) via TK-11783-master-credentials-and-passwords-needed (CR-mu35mei1) — unblocked; may now close",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:14:58.820Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11615",
+        "text": "REPLACEMENT KEY PROVEN LIVE — $0, measured with a negative control, not inherited. I could NOT find the 2026-09-14 'quota 0/1500, live=true, 3 calls' tick in Mac2's ~/Library/Logs/usre-hourly.log (its live=true lines are old, at lines 8070-9284 of an 86k-line log, quota 115-127/1500 = the historical PRE-rotation run); that receipt was prod-side, so from Mac2 it was NOT-MEASURED and I refused to restate it as fact. Instead I re-ran the ticket's own vetted unbilled probe on the NEW key: POST places:searchText with a deliberately empty body. Rotated key 9e623eb9 -> HTTP 400 INVALID_ARGUMENT 'Empty text_query' (i.e. it PASSED Google's key-validation layer and failed only on my malformed body = accepted RIGHT NOW). Bogus-AIza control, identical request -> HTTP 400 'API key not valid. Please pass a valid API key.' The two responses differ, so the probe discriminates rather than returning 400 for everything. Both calls 4xx = UNBILLED = $0. Key string was piped from gcloud through a process-substitution curl --config; never echoed to stdout, never on argv, never written to disk. CONCLUSION: rotation is verified end-to-end from Mac2 — leaked key dead, replacement live and restricted to places.googleapis.com only.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11723-cron-issue-com-steve-model-arena-daily",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11723",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:16:46.596Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:15:01.968Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11723",
+        "text": "Residual finding split to TK-11852 (gemma3:12b absent from Mac2 ollama) rather than folded in — different failure, different fix, and an 8GB pull is outside the bounded tier on a box with disk-CRITICAL history.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:15:14.062Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11723",
+        "text": "FINAL VERIFICATION — 8/8 green: (1) pm2 model-arena online, restarts=0; (2) :9758 /api/models HTTP 200; (3) present in ~/.pm2/dump.pm2 (verified by re-reading the dump, so reboot-persistence is measured not assumed — com.PM2 LaunchAgent execs pm2-boot-serialize.sh resurrect at boot); (4) com.steve.model-arena-daily still loaded, next fire 07:15; (5) wrapper executable + bash -n clean + committed 614ac9a with a clean worktree; (6) yolo/daily-log.jsonl 48 -> 49 rows — today's battle 9b9ed3ebe477 'Living Cellular Garden' recovered, aiPick qwen3-14b; (7) wrapper's own verdict line reads OK exit=0; (8) negative test re-run POST-COMMIT still exits 3, still names the dependency, still blocks the battle. HONEST LIMIT: 09-14 and 09-15 accrual is UNRECOVERABLE — you cannot retroactively battle a past day; only 09-16 was recovered.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11841-masterdot-full-pass-2026-09-16-13-58-sna",
+    "status": "doing",
+    "assignee": "night-TK-11841",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:35:26.576Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:09:30.213Z",
+        "agent": "masterdot",
+        "text": "PINK sweep: ttys024/pid97243 label 'TK REQUIRED PARKED'. Verified NOT a ticket violation -- classic tk-required-fp-metric false-positive class: session ran under TK_AGENT=steve-live-5025 (exported in-session, not visible in bare ps args since launched as a plain interactive claude with no inline ticket prompt), and correctly a2a-DM'd the two ACTUAL owners (night-TK-11837, night-TK-11838) of the substantive 50x25/dot-screen-router tiling work rather than taking its own duplicate ticket. TK-11837=[done], TK-11838=[open] and actively owned elsewhere. This session's last action was a yellow-dot AskUserQuestion (router fix: let owners land it vs take over) that went unanswered; a stopped-session sweep repainted it pink per the stopped-session-run-color-dot rule. Nothing left for this tab -- its work is fully handed off. Recommend /pinkroll this tab (Steve executes). NOT opening a ticketless-green-style ticket for this per the task's hard rail -- it is legitimately tracked via a2a DM under TK-11837/11838.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:13:05.946Z",
+        "agent": "masterdot",
+        "text": "masterdot subagent (none-bucket, 18 assigned tabs) COMPLETE. Verdict: population growth 10->18 (heartbeat-stale, confirmed) is explained by a live mass ticket-dispatch burst (18 iTerm windows spawned ~13:46-14:00 PDT from dead parent PID 42588/session 197653ee) — NOT 8 new organic stalls. Classification: 17 FRESH-BENIGN-ACTIVE (verified via tk show — real, fresh tk-log activity within last ~10min on every ticketed session: 10 doing, 3 blocked-appropriately [TK-11723/11715/11397, gated on DTD+Cody+Steve], 3 done-and-self-closing [TK-11759/11633/11298, near-zero CPU, consistent with running mandated /cs+/compact]), 1 FRESH-BENIGN-DISPATCHER (ttys004/pid56053, bare 'claude' no TK_AGENT, likely w0t0p0 origin window of the same burst, no ticket activity attributable, not itself a violation per TK-11631). ZERO STALLED-NEEDS-STEVE and ZERO INCONCLUSIVE — no error/crash/unanswered-question signatures anywhere. ROOT CAUSE of the dotlessness (opened as TK-11851): ALL 18 share an IDENTICAL leaked CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ID from a dead parent process — confirmed live recurrence of the standing memory 'iterm-relaunched-from-claude-leaks-child-session-env'. This compounds with TK-11831 (itself one of the 18) which independently diagnoses AppleScript/terminal_api dot-tool degradation under 59-session CPU load. VERDICT ON HYPOTHESIS #1: YES, attention=2 is a real undercount — 3 blocked + 3 done-with-likely-gated-memos in this bucket alone are needs-Steve-eventually items totally invisible to the orange/yellow/purple/lightblue-only counter, PURELY because the dot-paint mechanism is structurally broken for this whole batch (env leak + CPU/AppleScript overload), not because work is being neglected — tickets ARE current. This is a genuine 'unmeasured input != PASS' case (TK-11431 amendment 1): the counter isn't lying about what it counted, but what it counts is the wrong signal for this population. RECOMMENDATION: a TTY/PID-based recolor sweep (not self-report) is needed to clear this bucket; individually-fresh sessions will NOT self-heal their own dot given the confirmed bug.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11831-iterm2-at-130-150-cpu-with-59-live-sessi",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11831",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:16:42.320Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:09:22.714Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11831",
+        "text": "R-extra SHIPPED (terminal-status 28cf4f6, reversible+local): cached discover()'s two ps enrichment calls, which ran on EVERY self-paint (every UserPromptSubmit + every Stop hook) x ~68 sessions = the 245%-aggregate-ps storm. VERIFY-BEFORE-ACT measured: enrichment cost 2.46s/paint at 18 live owners; and crucially 'just skip it' (TK-11835's cross-tty seam) is NOT available here -- full enrichment binds 13 tickets, skip binds 0, so skipping would silently unbind every tab. Fix = CACHE not SKIP: argv+env are IMMUTABLE per process, so a pid+start-time key is EXACT (start-time makes it pid-reuse-safe); only cache MISSES are ps'd, so a steady fleet makes ZERO enrichment ps calls. A/B vs HEAD alternating under live load 78-101 (n=8): ORIG mean 3.08s/worst 9.92s -> NEW mean 0.68s/worst 1.00s, bindings IDENTICAL 23==23 every iteration. Tail now BOUNDED (an earlier ORIG sample hit 40.9s) because there is no ps call left to spiral. Tests 41->45, all 3 injected mutations go RED (pid-reuse key, cache bypass, lossy env).",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:16:07.738Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11831",
+        "text": "CODEX-CHECK caught 4 real defects in the first cut (28cf4f6) — 2 of them WRONG-BINDING class, not just missed-cache; all fixed in c6b317d, each with a mutation-verified test. (1) STICKY NEGATIVE CACHE: a pid absent from ps output was cached as '' and never re-read, so ONE transient miss left a tab unbound for the full TTL — strictly WORSE than the uncached path, which retried next paint. Now only a CONCLUSIVE read is cached (argv: pid returned non-empty args; env: pid present AND args-prefix matched). (2) POISON OVERWRITE: ~68 processes RMW the file with no lock; os.replace gives an untearable READ but does not serialize RMW, so a slow writer merging onto its START-OF-PASS snapshot could blank a peer's learned entry = a wrong ticket binding. Now the merge re-reads at write time and NEVER downgrades (empty can't overwrite non-empty); values are immutable per process so concurrent writes are commutative and lock-free. (3) unvalidated cache values ({a:null} served as a hit differed from the uncached str) -> type-checked on read. (4) key now pid+start+RUNTIME so an exec'd pid misses. Plus 0600 perms (argv+TERM_SESSION_ID) and a corrected TTL comment (an all-hit pass writes nothing so does NOT refresh t; TTL is hygiene, not correctness). Tests 45->49; 7/7 mutations RED (pid-reuse key, cache bypass, lossy env, sticky negative, poison overwrite, stale-snapshot merge, unvalidated values), control GREEN. Re-measured A/B after hardening under load 44-62 (n=6): ORIG mean 1.79s/worst 3.74s -> NEW mean 0.64s/worst 0.91s, bindings diverged 0/6. Live CLI end-to-end: scan --json byte-identical cold/warm/warm2 (26 rows, 21 ticket-labelled). Ledgered to executed-reversible.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11357-zero-price-orderable-stopgap-scope-gap-1",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11357",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:29:38.421Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:20:45.045Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11357",
+        "text": "TWO FIXES LANDED + PROVEN (both reversible-local, source-only, no Shopify write, no push, no branch switch). FIX 1 — commit e0ee104 on the GOVERNING repo's main (~/Projects/Designer-Wallcoverings/shopify): committed the previously-UNCOMMITTED Fix B/D price-aware guard bodies on all 5 store-wide sweeps + the previously-UNTRACKED shared lib scripts/lib/inventory-stamp-guard.mjs, and restored action A's ALLOW_DEBUG_CLONE_WRITE hard-abort which had only ever existed in the outer duplicate-tracking repo. Staged exactly 6 paths in a tree with 917 other dirty files; verified all 6 clean post-commit and the other files untouched. Negative test: all 5 run without the env var -> exit 3 + 'ABORT: TK-11357 debug clone is not a write surface'; node --check passes on all 6. FIX 2 — commit ef068c8 (~/Projects/designerwallcoverings): rewrote tripwire.sh to an explicit honesty contract — partition ACTIONABLE (DENY+tracked) vs UNACTIONABLE (CONTINUE/untracked) BEFORE acting; an all-unactionable cohort now reports WARN 'CANNOT ACT', names the SKUs and points at the gated CONTINUE->DENY remedy instead of running a no-op apply; blast_radius is apply.mjs's REAL 'levels SET' count, never the detected count; ledger ONLY when a write actually happened, with an 'unremediated' field on partials; unparseable apply output or failed enumerate = NOT MEASURED/never PASS; and it now emits data/latest.json so the loop is visible. NEW SKILL ~/.claude/skills/zero-price-orderable-tripwire/ carries the heartbeat (fleet-health-rollup globs only ~/.claude/skills/*/data/latest.json, which is WHY a 3-day stuck loop was invisible). NEGATIVE TEST test-tripwire.sh: 7 cases / 22 assertions, all fixtures, 22/22 green; case 1 IS the injected fault (6 CONTINUE -> must be WARN + exit 2 + ZERO ledger lines), i.e. the precise thing the old script got wrong. Seam is behind --test, which the installed plist does not pass (ProgramArguments verified = [/bin/bash, tripwire.sh]) and which refuses without TRIPWIRE_TEST_DIR, redirecting ledger+heartbeat to a temp dir so a fixture run can never write a real receipt or green the panel. LIVE PROOF, before/after in one ledger: old script 21:11:24Z wrote blast_radius 6 (fabricated); new script 21:16:23Z against the SAME real cohort -> exit 2, verdict WARN, detected 6 / actionable 0 / unactionable 6 / levels_set 0, all six SKUs named, and NO ledger line at all. CONSUMER VERIFIED (not assumed): fleet-health-rollup now lists 'zero-price-orderable-tripwire verdict=WARN, status=WARN' with the new-skill marker and no unrecognized-verdict signal. Also PRE-EMPTED a contrarian hole myself: the 'levels SET' parse uses a regex over a UTF-8 arrow and the plist sets no LANG, so I tested it under LC_ALL=en_US.UTF-8, C, and unset — all three return the count correctly, so it will not silently degrade to NOT-MEASURED under launchd's minimal env.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:25:59.875Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11357",
+        "text": "CONTRARIAN GATE (Cody, separate reviewer, produced none of the work) VERDICT: FIX FIRST. I ACCEPT ALL THREE HOLES and have fixed them (commit 0a57a1d). His one-line summary is fair and I am recording it verbatim: 'you fixed the tripwire lying about success and shipped a tripwire that will now lie about failure - same bug, opposite direction, and your own test suite ran in the wrong locale to catch it.' HOLE 1, and it is MY OWN CORRECTION: I logged earlier that I had pre-empted the locale risk by testing the 'levels SET' regex under LC_ALL=en_US.UTF-8, C and unset, all returning the count. THAT VERIFICATION WAS INVALID. I ran it in my interactive shell where LANG=en_US.UTF-8 still leaked in, so it never reproduced launchd's environment. Cody re-ran it under 'env -i' - a genuinely bare env, which is what the plist gives since it has NO EnvironmentVariables block - and got rc=1, NO MATCH. I reproduced that myself before accepting: the regex's '.' matches ONE BYTE while the arrow is a THREE-BYTE UTF-8 sequence. Consequence had it shipped: the wrapper would have read NOT MEASURED on every real remediation forever - a permanent false WARN that trains the reader to ignore it, i.e. the same defect inverted. FIX: apply.mjs now emits stable ASCII counters LEVELS_SET:N / APPLY_ERRORS:N beside the pretty line and the wrapper keys off those. Cody was right that a fancier regex would have been a reskin of the disease - parsing prose for an OUTCOME is the identical proxy-signal mistake that caused the original bug. HOLE 2: apply.mjs already writes its own honest receipt (blast_radius = its real didSet) on every --apply, so my wrapper receipt was a DUPLICATE undo record for one write, currently unreachable only because hole 1 short-circuited it - 'two bugs cancelling each other out is not a design, it is luck'. FIX: the wrapper no longer ledgers at all; apply.mjs owns the receipt, the wrapper owns the verdict. HOLE 3, a regression I INTRODUCED: partitioning on tracked===true silently bucketed a row with a MISSING tracked field as unactionable, so my script would have REFUSED work the old one did. FIX: three buckets not two - a row missing inventory_policy or tracked is UNKNOWN, still ATTEMPTED (zeroing a $0 orderable variant is never harmful) but never able to yield PASS. Codex independently flagged this same risk. ALSO FROM CODEX: a write ACK is not a post-condition, so the script no longer claims PASS in the same pass as a write - it reports WARN 'not yet re-verified' and the NEXT run's enumerate re-tests the live predicate, PASSing only on an empty cohort. That makes the post-condition check free instead of doubling a 4-minute scan. AND MY COMMIT MESSAGE DISAGREED WITH ITSELF, correctly caught: the ledger holds 170 'OUTCOME tripwire fired' lines ever - 167 fabricated blast_radius 6 (09-14..09-16) plus 3 blast_radius 1255 from 09-11, an earlier and plausibly REAL bulk event I had folded into the count. '171 consecutive, blast_radius 6 every time' was wrong; the corrected figure is 167, and the substance is unchanged because apply.mjs's parallel honest log records zero real writes across that window. TESTS REBUILT to Cody's standard: 9 cases / 28 assertions, EVERY case executed under 'env -i' with no LANG, plus a dedicated regression case for hole 1 (apply prints only the unicode line -> must read NOT MEASURED, never a silent pass) and one for hole 3. 28/28 green. WHAT CODY CLEARED: commit e0ee104 scoped to exactly the 6 intended files in a 917-dirty-file shared tree; the line-2 guard insertion safe on all 5 scripts with node --check clean and the abort synchronous before any require; and the --test seam genuinely unreachable from the plist with the :? guard blocking any path to the real ledger/heartbeat.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11298-cron-issue-com-steve-dw-staged-active-sn",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11298",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:17:30.090Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:07:32.751Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11298",
+        "text": "TESTED codex hypothesis (b): DISPROVEN. Only 1 pair of starts <120s apart in 2042 runs (2026-09-13 09:49:22 -> 09:50:05, 43s) and runs complete in ~3-5s, so no overlap. Those two were independent failures (psql socket, then 'Network is unreachable'). Class B (8x) is therefore rsync exiting 0 WITHOUT leaving the .tmp - a per-run unique tmp name + post-push verify makes the mechanism moot and self-describing.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:17:28.168Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11298",
+        "text": "SHIPPED + VERIFIED. dw-staged-active-viewer 96f279a (script hardening) + cron-fire-canary affcf0e (artifact registration + negative test). Ledgered to executed-reversible with a one-command undo.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11307-mdc-phillipe-romano-type-ii-quotes-4728",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11307",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:10:58.903Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:08:59.775Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11307",
+        "text": "GOOGLE SAMPLE-TITLE sub-task VERIFIED LIVE + COMPLETE (its memo sat in _done/ with no EXECUTED banner, so I measured rather than assumed). Read all 945 proposed MDC offers straight from the Merchant API: OVERRIDDEN 945/945 ('Sample — <pattern> — Memo Swatch'), still-original 0, 404 0, NOT_MEASURED 0. So the $4.25-priced-$300-wallcovering price-mismatch exposure that motivated it is closed on the live feed. NOTE the read path: these are LEGACY bare-variant-id offers named en~US~<offerId>; _mc-read-v1.js getProduct() prepends 'online~' and returns HTTP 400 for every one of them — a wrong-name 400 is NOT_MEASURED and must never be read as 'no override'.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:14.453Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11307",
+        "text": "PUSH-SURFACE re-check (the 09-08 baseline said New Arrivals 0 / Trending 0, but that was BEFORE 8,120 products got tagged and the rotators rotate, so a stale zero would have been worthless). Live: 'New Arrivals at Designer' 2,000 products / 0 showroom; 'Trending Wallcovering Collection 2026' 500 and 2,000 products / 0 showroom. Real populations, not 0-of-0.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11449-gmc-feed-text-price-residuals-tobacco-po",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11449",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:12:43.108Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:07:52.800Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11449",
+        "text": "CODEX-CHECK RAN (CLAUDE.md rule) AND IT CHANGED WHAT I DID — recording the correction rather than the clean version. codex-check-path-health first: openai-codex still DOWN (HTTP 429 project_spend_limit_exceeded, same cap as 09-13, not transient); kimi + grok UP; and the kimi MCP env-shadow that bit the 09-13 session is now FIXED ('MCP env matches canonical ...JlRs'), so the MCP path worked this time. Ran the pass through Kimi (kimi-k3). Cost ~$0.018.\n\nIT CAUGHT TWO THINGS, ONE OF THEM DECISION-CHANGING:\n\n1. DECISION-CHANGING — MY MEASUREMENT WAS COHORT-BOUND. I proved 16 KNOWN offer ids are clean. That says NOTHING about whether the ACCOUNT still has tobacco_policy_violation offers: a 17th offer flagged after the 09-11 snapshot is structurally invisible to a re-read of the snapshot. Kimi also correctly noted my dw-archived-live-offer-canary corroboration is an ORPHAN canary, so novel_count=0 corroborates only the orphan workstream, NOT the tobacco one. It named this the weakest load-bearing link and it was right. CLOSED IT with an account-wide instrument (issueresolution aggregateProductStatuses, complete walk): account-wide tobacco_policy_violation = EXACTLY 1 product, which is the already-routed Saint Germain Hemp II. No 17th offer. Also ran the account-level issues endpoint Kimi asked for (its other unmeasured reading — an account-level tobacco warning suppressing serving while item issues read clean): accountIssues count = 0, HTTP 200. Both gaps now measured, not assumed.\n\n2. MY CAUSAL CLAIM WAS OVERSTATED AND SELF-UNDERMINING — I ACCEPT THE CORRECTION. I argued 'the flag survived the 09-11 re-crawl, so the clearing must be the appeal.' But this ticket's own doctrine is that policy-status transitions do NOT move lastUpdateDate — which makes timestamp stasis UNINFORMATIVE about Google-side re-evaluation between 09-13 and 09-16. I cannot exclude a batch re-review or a reviewer clearing lookalike items off appeal 1. Restating properly: the 09-14 appeal is the only LOGGED merchant-side intervening event and the timing is consistent with GMC appeal latency — CORRELATION, NOT PROOF. It does not change the close, because the close rests on CURRENT STATE (approved 6/6, zero item issues, landing parity), not on cause.\n\nA SECOND DATA POINT FOR THE TIMESTAMP NON-SIGNAL DOCTRINE, which Kimi spotted in my own history: appeal 1 read APPROVED in the console on 09-13 while its item still measured DISAPPROVED at 09:17Z that same day. So console-approval and item-status are LAGGY AND DECOUPLED in both directions. n is now 2. Anyone testing appeal landing should expect lag and re-read, not conclude failure on a single post-submit read.\n\nREJECTED ONE OF ITS READINGS, WITH THE REASON: Kimi asked me to confirm '6 approved contexts' is per-offer rather than 6-across-the-cohort (which would leave 30 unverified). It is PER-OFFER — the script derives ctx counts from each offer's own productStatus.destinationStatuses array, and every one of the 6 reports ctx_total=6. 36/36 contexts measured, not 6.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:57.713Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11449",
+        "text": "ACCOUNT-WIDE POLICY LOCATE — the completeness proof, not an inference. Kimi's challenge was that an aggregate COUNT of 1 doesn't prove that 1 is OUR product. Fair. So I located every policy-flagged offer by identity: complete products.list walk, 61,992 offers, walk_complete=true, filtered on the policy family. 35 hits. Evidence: data/tk11449-policy-locate.json.\n\nTHE TWO COUNTS THE AGGREGATE REPORTED ARE NOW NAMED:\n- DISAPPROVED|tobacco_policy_violation = 1, and it IS ours: 42511885860915 Saint Germain Hemp II (0 approved / 6 disapproved contexts) — the deliberately-not-appealed PJ showroom-only item, now re-filed to TK-11844. There is NO 17th tobacco offer. The cohort-bound gap is closed by identity, not by arithmetic.\n- DISAPPROVED|illegal_drugs_policy_violation = 1: shopify_US_6733036388403_40594972016691 'High Society - Metallic Marijuana Leaf Wallcovering' (0appr/6disa). NOT a false positive and NOT ours to appeal — the product is literally a marijuana-leaf design, so Google is right and it is correctly inert. Recording it so nobody 'fixes' it.\n\nAND A SIBLING DEFECT THE WALK SURFACED THAT NOBODY WAS LOOKING FOR — SAME ROOT SHAPE AS THIS TICKET'S TOBACCO BUG. 29 offers carry DISAPPROVED|legal_restrictions_policy_violation + NOT_IMPACTED|alcohol_policy_violation, and the pattern is unmistakable from the titles: Fasano CHAMPAGNE, Caorle CHAMPAGNE, Polignano CHAMPAGNE, Portovenere CHAMPAGNE, Termoli CHAMPAGNE, Follonica CHAMPAGNE, Fasano Champagne III... 'Champagne' is a COLORWAY NAME on grasscloth, and Google's classifier is reading it as an alcoholic beverage — precisely the way it read 'Hemp' as tobacco on the 6 this ticket just cleared by appeal. Same vendor (Fentucci Naturals), same false-positive mechanism, same remedy available.\n\nWHY THIS IS SHARPER THAN THE TOBACCO SIX WERE: 28 of the 35 policy-flagged offers read SERVING despite carrying a policy disapproval — i.e. these are NOT inert. Also filed: Vista Wine | Maharam (a real wine reference, likelier a true positive) and 4 guns_parts_policy_violation including 'Ova Prima Vp 1044 01 | Elitis'. I am NOT expanding this ticket to cover them — TK-11449's scope was the tobacco cohort and the 5 price offers, both now closed. Routing to its own ticket so it gets measured properly rather than being half-chased inside a closing one.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "id": "TK-11792-yoloforever-pre-check-re-escalates-uncha",
+    "status": "done",
+    "assignee": "night-TK-11792",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T02:25:08.760Z",
+    "last_actions": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T01:51:19.454Z",
+        "agent": "night-TK-11792",
+        "text": "yoloforever cycle-1 HARDENING (Cody FIX-FIRST, verified): Cody red-teamed the shipped fix against production and found the fingerprint's flat field list matched only 3/17 live failing canaries — 14 locked at fp:0, so a canary WORSENING while staying FAIL would never re-escalate (dangerous false-negative + trips the 'unmeasured != measured-zero' doctrine). Verified the claim against real latest.json, then fixed dedup.py: fingerprint() now recurses nested dicts + matches leaf names, widened to the counters the fleet actually emits (totals.new_fail, shopify.leaks, novel_under, sample_leaks, landmine_count, zero_price_orderable, ...). Now measures growth on 9/17 incl. the money-losing zero-price canaries; the 8 genuinely-counter-less ones stay fp:0 (set-delta + own CNCP/email alert). Excluded volatile/backlog fields so catalog churn can't re-spam. Negative-tested (nested 2->5 fires worse:; timestamp-only stays empty), re-seeded live -> FLAT-QUIET. Commit 0e1dbf5, ledgered. FINAL VERDICT: SHIP (fix verified end-to-end; documented tradeoff = 8 counter-less canaries suppress-and-rely-on-own-alert, the safe direction for a paid unattended gate).",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      },
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T02:25:08.760Z",
+        "agent": "night-TK-11792",
+        "text": "yoloforever cycle-2: shipped a --test negative-test seam on dedup.py (CLAUDE.md TK-11431 amendment 3 — a check must prove it goes RED on an injected fault). Extracted pure decide(); run_selftest() = 9 in-process cases (cold-start / steady-state-suppressed / top-level+nested growth->worse / timestamp-only no-respam / recovery-drop / recover->refail / seed / missing-json). Verified PASS 9/9, and the injected old-bug (always-escalate) correctly flips it to FAIL 3/9 exit1. Seam guarded behind --test; watch.sh never passes it. Commit follows 0e1dbf5.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..3e61f41e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/persistence-proof.json
@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
+{
+  "ledger": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/ledger.jsonl",
+  "cycle_id": "yf2139.YF57g8",
+  "exact_readback": "PASS",
+  "matches": 1,
+  "entry_sha256": "7eaac7617e1895247614a136b1d45ae6b7a6b144366d672e5bcad742c97665ca",
+  "ordered_queue_equality": "PASS15",
+  "all_disposition_evidence_present": true,
+  "source_correlation": "yf2139-final"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-final-reread.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-final-reread.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..043ad8be
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-final-reread.json
@@ -0,0 +1,239 @@
+[
+  {
+    "position": 1,
+    "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:11:25.544Z",
+    "blocker": {
+      "type": "technical_dependency",
+      "condition": "Heuristic report does not establish authoritative vendor/table identity, successful zero-result queries, or priced-row join yield; no verified repair target yet.",
+      "next_action": "Use retained18-row offline review to verify table identities and read-only joins including errors, prices, uniqueness and cross-vendor scope; draft any cost-authority change for Steve.",
+      "owner": "vp-dw-commerce",
+      "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:11:22.771Z",
+      "steve_one_action": false
+    },
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T22:11:22.768Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "Parent accepted offline audit:6tests and real retained CLI rerun PASS;18/6243 preserved,3cross-name associations4371 identityUNPROVEN, remaining15/1872 alsoUNVERIFIED. Sourceinput hash unchanged. Corrected initial fixture cleanup; retained mktemp replay. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/join-parent-proof.json. Execution slot3 local audit implementation; operational cost coverage0.",
+        "correlation_id": "yf2139-i4-accept"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 2,
+    "id": "TK-11850-prestige-car-wash-places-photo-route-has",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:53:35.558Z",
+    "blocker": {
+      "type": "steve_action",
+      "condition": "Reviewed local removal patch prepared; active-source application and target-specific activation lack exact approval.",
+      "next_action": "Steve APPROVE/REVISE/BLOCK pending-approval/TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md; revalidate source/data and prove actual photo journey after approved activation.",
+      "owner": "steve",
+      "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T21:53:33.121Z",
+      "steve_one_action": false
+    },
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:53:33.107Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "Parent accepted exact handler-only patch: apply-check, corrected candidate syntax, exact deletion and source unchanged PASS. Local preparation1, operational implementation0. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/prestige-parent-proof.json. Memo TK-11850-photo-route-decommission-yf2139.md. No closure.",
+        "correlation_id": "yf2139-i1-accept"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 3,
+    "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "yoloforever-loop",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T19:57:49.691Z",
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T19:57:49.691Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "correlation=yf1954-ops COMPLETE bounded read-only assessment: no-safe-increment. Canonical source open/yoloforever-loop; three existing memo hashes unchanged from accepted repairs, Source resolves, historical attribution/causal limitation retained. Fresh df WARN 8% 78.848GiB; scheduled12:51:41PDT WARN8percent78GiB. No further local defect reproduced; operational/restore/target safety UNVERIFIED. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1954.Dkx8oQ/ops.json and ops.md.0implementation/0slots/0newmemos/0closures; gates HELD, guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance pending.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 4,
+    "id": "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:00:26.113Z",
+    "blocker": {
+      "type": "steve_action",
+      "condition": "Gemma restoration needs intended-roster confirmation and scoped download approval against fresh capacity/headroom; current8percentWARN.",
+      "next_action": "Review pending-approval/TK-11852-gemma-roster-capacity-yf2139.md; confirm intent and capacity before any pull.",
+      "owner": "steve",
+      "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:00:23.986Z",
+      "steve_one_action": false
+    },
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T22:00:23.983Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "Parent accepted R0 memo and independent source-hash/tags/disk/401 limitations. DTD A5/5 final, no dissent.1localprep/0operational implementation. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/model-parent-proof.json; source outcome UNVERIFIED.",
+        "correlation_id": "yf2139-i2-accept"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 5,
+    "id": "TK-11861-phillipe-romano-cost-model-13-066-active",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:14:58.780Z",
+    "blocker": {
+      "type": "technical_dependency",
+      "condition": "Actual upstream/SKU acquisition costs and current prefix census remain unmeasured;59.50 is sellingprice evidence only.",
+      "next_action": "Obtain dated vendor-external cost evidence and current prefix identity/census, then propose gated cohort-specific cost mapping; source-anchor manifest retained.",
+      "owner": "vp-dw-commerce",
+      "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:14:56.270Z",
+      "steve_one_action": false
+    },
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T22:14:56.267Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "Parent independently verified10 exact source quotations and3unchanged hashes.59.50 explicitly SELL_PRICE_NOT_COST_EVIDENCE; canonicalCork-/legacyDWGL-,DWWLRIGO,DWPPMDC. Current costs/countsNOT_MEASURED. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/pr-parent-proof.json. Slot4 preparation only, no pricing writes.",
+        "correlation_id": "yf2139-i5-accept"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 6,
+    "id": "TK-11860-cost-backlog-verify-the-column-class-26",
+    "status": "blocked",
+    "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:18:36.000Z",
+    "blocker": {
+      "type": "technical_dependency",
+      "condition": "26candidate vendors lack external price-basis/unit/currency/date/discount/table-identity proof in this pass;10704keymatches are not verified costs.",
+      "next_action": "Use retained per-vendor evidence-request manifest to gather SKU/cohort-matched vendorproof; no external send authorized; costmap adoption remains gated.",
+      "owner": "vp-dw-commerce",
+      "evidence_at": "2026-09-16T22:18:33.080Z",
+      "steve_one_action": false
+    },
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T22:18:33.005Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "Parent verified real manifestCLI, all26original rows preserved, historical10704keymatches,3metadata flags/Newmor unproven, malformed and total mismatch rejected without output. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/column-parent-proof.json. Slot5 local preparation; no costcoverage lift or sourcewrite.",
+        "correlation_id": "yf2139-i6-accept"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 7,
+    "id": "TK-11851-env-leak-recurrence-18-fanned-out-claude",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "masterdot",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:24:05.131Z",
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:12:39.740Z",
+        "agent": "masterdot",
+        "text": "Cross-link: TK-11831 (itself one of these 18, pid 42322/ttys010) is ALREADY diagnosing a RELATED but DISTINCT mechanism for the same symptom class — 'iTerm2 at 130-150% CPU with 59 live sessions, every AppleScript caller queues (dot scanner 90-180s), terminal_api unavailable x57 at peak, fleet-wide dot-tool degradation.' Both bugs likely compound: (1) this env-ID-leak means a session cannot even correctly self-identify its own tty for dot-painting, and (2) TK-11831's CPU/AppleScript overload means even a correctly-identified dot-paint call may queue/fail under load. RECOMMENDATION (not fired — draft only): run a recolor sweep that resolves color via TTY/PID directly rather than each session's own env-based self-report (e.g. /dotall or /green from a session NOT in this affected batch) once TK-11831's CPU pressure eases, to force-correct all 18 dots rather than waiting on each session's own (structurally broken) self-report.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 8,
+    "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+    "status": "doing",
+    "assignee": "codex-yoloforever",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:18:41.338Z",
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T22:18:41.338Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "Execution slot6 FINAL: DTD A5/5 retaineddecision3, newly rereadcanonical and clean sourceHEAD5659b95. Isolated committed one-line daemon-count candidate with parser-boundary tests only. Installedwatch/schedules unchanged; no Claude/daemonstartstop; real2nddaemon proof SKIP/gated. Ticketnotclosed.",
+        "correlation_id": "yf2139-i3-start"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 9,
+    "id": "TK-11858-cost-authority-conflict-1-621-active-pro",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11427",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:05:20.720Z",
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T22:05:20.720Z",
+        "agent": "codex-cost-assessment",
+        "text": "yf2139-cost-assess-11858 READ-ONLY ASSESSMENT HANDOFF to root (no claim/status or implementation). Active collision NOT_ESTABLISHED: creator-assigned open ticket has no action claim; creator parent TK11427 done 2026-09-16T21:24:35Z; live PID2842 alone insufficient. Existing: Canonical ticket documents14898 both authorities,2408 disagreements>10%,1621 retail signature; examples Designtex25 vs45.25 and Osborne216 vs333. Latest gate JSON gives aggregate coverage only; report.mjs strips cost value from costmap union and ORs existence. Missing: No standalone conflict row dataset or local reproducible no-precedence counterexample artifact located; choosing winner or modifying live detector semantics remains out of assessment scope. Proposed bounded local increment, NOT executed: Offline counterexample fixture/proposal JSON from ticket examples (Designtex25/45.25, Osborne216/333) and stated aggregate counts, labeled historical ticket evidence, expected conflict/unmeasured without choosing authority. Include necessary future extract contract for per-product id/vendor/map source+value/stamp source+value/unit/currency/date; no invented current rows and no gate rewrite. ZERO_COST_REQUIRED + DTD_ZERO_COST=1 verified; no paid calls, DB, production, or cost-map writes. Evidence: /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/cost-assessment/assessment.json. Root must independently verify and decide before implementation.",
+        "correlation_id": "action-mu4nfx96-86175-xa7am3"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 10,
+    "id": "TK-11853-gcp-replacement-places-key-ffis-has-no-a",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11615",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:17:22.961Z",
+    "last_action": []
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 11,
+    "id": "TK-11847-gmc-alcohol-legal-restrictions-false-pos",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11449",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:11:45.082Z",
+    "last_action": []
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 12,
+    "id": "TK-11838-dot-screen-router-durable-anti-thrash-da",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "night-TK-11831",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T19:39:15.334Z",
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T19:39:15.334Z",
+        "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+        "text": "correlation=yf1928-router-monitor READ-ONLY ordered queue position2: canonical still open/night-TK11831 at18:46:40.985Z. Ticket worker PIDs66785/TK11838 and58420/TK11831 observed earlier this cycle, absent on19:38:37Z direct ps recheck; no productivity or abandonment inferred. Existing sole-writer screen1-columns-coord/TK11837 instruction preserved; TK11837 later carries conflicting auto-fit versus superseded-by-consolidator reports. Disposition external-blocked pending sole-owner reconciliation/handoff; no claim, router edit/re-enable, or closure. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/ownership.json and router-owner-events.json. Prior liveness assertion failed and was replaced with fresh explicit evidence;0implementation for this entry.",
+        "correlation_id": "action-mu4i8105-73052-ryzibh"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 13,
+    "id": "TK-11857-tk-11357-residuals-shared-price-integrit",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11357",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:18:52.278Z",
+    "last_action": []
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 14,
+    "id": "TK-11856-57-of-71-counter-based-launchd-jobs-shar",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11298",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:18:24.640Z",
+    "last_action": []
+  },
+  {
+    "position": 15,
+    "id": "TK-11846-gmc-titlefix-mc-read-v1-js-getproduct-40",
+    "status": "open",
+    "assignee": "claude-run-11307",
+    "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:10:43.250Z",
+    "last_action": [
+      {
+        "ts": "2026-09-16T21:10:40.425Z",
+        "agent": "claude-run-11307",
+        "text": "Found while verifying TK-11307's MDC Google sample titles. _mc-read-v1.js toV1Name() unconditionally prepends 'online~', producing accounts/<mid>/products/online~en~US~<offerId>. MDC's 945 offers are on the LEGACY bare-variant-id feed and are named en~US~<offerId> (no 'online~'), so getProduct() returns HTTP 400 '[name] Invalid' for every one — 12/12 in my first sample. Hitting the stored gmcName directly returned all 945 fine. RISK: a caller that treats a throw/400 as 'no override present' gets a clean-looking FALSE NEGATIVE on a compliance check. Fix shape: accept a full gmcName, or only prepend 'online~' when the id is not already a '<lang>~<country>~<id>' triple, and make a 400 loudly NOT_MEASURED rather than an absence. Read-only finding; nothing changed.",
+        "correlation_id": ""
+      }
+    ]
+  }
+]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-numbers.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-numbers.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..24dcd90d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/queue-numbers.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[11859, 11850, 11784, 11852, 11861, 11860, 11851, 11848, 11858, 11853, 11847, 11838, 11857, 11856, 11846]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11784.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11784.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..3ef6ff8e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11784.json
@@ -0,0 +1,142 @@
+{
+  "id": "TK-11784-yoloforever-autonomous-loop-dtd-cody-gat",
+  "title": "yoloforever autonomous loop — DTD+Cody gated, reversible-only, draft gated",
+  "project": "ops",
+  "agent": "yoloforever-loop",
+  "assignee": "yoloforever-loop",
+  "status": "open",
+  "status_since": "2026-09-15T20:56:55.270Z",
+  "kind": "task",
+  "schedule": {},
+  "parent_id": "",
+  "created_at": "2026-09-15T20:56:55.270Z",
+  "updated_at": "2026-09-16T19:57:49.691Z",
+  "comments": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T09:39:07.488Z",
+      "agent": "dot-supervisor",
+      "kind": "note",
+      "text": "[dot-supervisor/lightblue] Mac2 Data volume verified 98% used / 20GB free at 2%, trending down (28GB→24GB→23GB→20GB since 2026-09-15 20:58); reclaim memo 2026-09-15-mac2-disk-CRITICAL-reclaim.md + _BATCH-DISK-SAFE-RECLAIM.sh sit unapproved in pending-approval, and the session carries no ticket id (label says TK REQUIRED) though TK-11784 already owns this seed — blocked on Steve's disk-delete gate, not on agent work. — suggest: Steve runs the safe Tier-1 reclaim now (npm/uv/pi",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T11:09:49.125Z",
+      "agent": "night-TK-11819",
+      "kind": "note",
+      "text": "READ-ONLY corroboration (night-TK-11819, 4AM loop 2026-09-16T11:07, NOT taking ownership — this is a live loop): confirming your disk seed independently. /System/Volumes/Data = 926Gi, 868Gi used, 19Gi avail, 98% capacity (matches dot-supervisor's 20GB->trending-down reading). Reclaim stays Steve-gated (disk deletes) — memo + _BATCH-DISK-SAFE-RECLAIM.sh already drafted in pending-approval. No agent action from me; standing down on this ticket.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T15:51:15.048Z",
+      "agent": "masterdot-lightblue",
+      "kind": "comment",
+      "text": "masterdot-lightblue re-verify: the Mac2-disk-CRITICAL seed this ticket was tracking (yoloforever cycle1, 2026-09-15 20:58) is RESOLVED -- Steve fired dropdb stayclaim + ollama rm heretic at 15:41:19Z (logged under TK-11791), disk moved 18Gi/2%(CRITICAL)->66Gi/7.13%(WARN). Re-verified live via df just now, matches. Flagging here since this ticket's cycle-log still shows the CRITICAL framing as of the 11:09Z note.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ],
+  "actions": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-15T20:58:57.513Z",
+      "agent": "yoloforever-loop",
+      "text": "Cycle1 seed=Mac2 disk CRITICAL (3%/28GB). Routed read-only diag to vp-operations. Parallel prep: dead-plist cluster verified = gated installs not kickstarts (approval-invisibility/eas-asc-gap missing/DRAFT plist; dw-mdc-margin DRAFT by-design=drop).",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T00:33:49.814Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "yf0024-ops COMPLETE bounded READ-ONLY reassessment only, source outcome UNVERIFIED. Canonical open/assignee yoloforever-loop re-read before work; PID11381 absent, no exact-ticket process observed, no ownership transfer inferred. Fresh local Data volume df remains98% capacity/about24GiB available. Existing Sep12 TK11542 Steve-only disk-clear bundle and two Henry offload scripts retained/read/hashed; reclaim yield stale and scripts not run or safety-certified. No duplicate memo needed. Exact blocker: current owner handoff/specific cleanup authorization and current target reclaim evidence absent. Safest next: with owner/parent agreement refresh existing proposal for one exact reclaim target plus active-use evidence, then Steve approval before cleanup. Evidence /private/tmp/yf0024.GCwa1x/ops-assessment.json and .md; JSON/exact readback PASS, source recovery SKIP. Guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED verified; paidprovider$0,0execution slots,0implementation,0newmemos; no external calls,recursive scans,Claude,runtime/status/owner changes. No commit; parent acceptance pending. correlation=yf0024-ops",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T11:00:58.763Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1049-ops-correction COMPLETE local informational preparation only after finalDTD6/6 FIX-THEN-SHIP/KEEP. Reverified ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 and canonical open owner yoloforever-loop/activity09:39:07.488Z; ownership/status retained. New standalone correction /Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11784-disk-threshold-correction-yf1049.md sha256 bf9d732faa8a6e6e9033ea523d6054af764318533a9643a58ba6071802338ee0. R0 proof /private/tmp/yf1049.MPMeY4/ops-correction.json: exclusive-create/fsync/readback/arithmetic/original-hash unchanged PASS.54/926=5.8315%,7% requires64.82GiB under stated assumptions; no fresh measurement. Original linked/preserved; non-executable informational APPROVE/REVISE/BLOCK cannot approve operations; no duplicate cleanup ask.1local prep,0operational implementation,source outcomesUNVERIFIED. No actual reclaim/freshcanary/restore-safety certification; all cleanup/DB/model/offload/destructive gates HELD. No new ticket/Claude/paid endpoints/terminal paint. providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance,durable retention and commit pending; safest next independently verify correction and retain with parent monitoring receipt.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T15:51:45.446Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1548-ops NEW SOURCE FACTS read-only: current Mac2 Data df used=861887316KiB avail=69109700KiB capacity=93%; exact canary floor(avail*100/(used+avail))=7, verdict=WARN. Disk CRITICAL clearance proven at sample; WARN remains. Existing owner memo sha256=09827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b now reports Steve executed stayclaim deletion and Heretic removal at15:40Z; executed-reversible ledger lines83464-83465 corroborate. These are owner/Steve actions, not this loop implementation or further cleanup approval. Canary latest still15:21:28Z FAIL/2%/18GiB predates reclaim. Local Ollama /api/tags lacks qwen3.8-27b-heretic:latest; panel retains reference and ERR fallback, no pull/inference. Restore integrity, service and autonomous-loop recovery NOT certified. Canonical re-read immediately before append: open owner yoloforever-loop, prior activity11:09:49.125Z retained. Disposition no-safe-increment for this loop; further cleanup external-gated, runtime UNKNOWN.0implementation/0execution slots/providerUSD0. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1548.L231qV/ops.json and ops.md; parent acceptance pending.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T15:53:51.534Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1548-ops CORRECTION to15:51:45 source action: earlier read of disk canary latest showed15:21:28Z FAIL/Mac2 2%/18GiB; while this read-only assessment ran, scheduled canary updated latest at15:51:29Z to top-level WARN, Mac2 WARN7%/65GiB and other3 units OK. Re-read confirms15:51:29Z snapshot. Prior action incorrectly carried earlier stale wording across this concurrent update; temporal race now corrected in ops.json/ops.md. Point-in-time disk CRITICAL clearance remains proven and stored canary independently corroborates it; no canary run initiated by this child. Restore was not tested and is not required for disk-threshold claim. Canonical re-read: open owner yoloforever-loop unchanged; no status/owner change.0implementation/slots/providerUSD0, guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1 reverified.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T16:30:13.163Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1625-ops MONITORING ONLY: fresh Data df 853572312KiB used/77424704KiB available (73.838GiB), canary floor 8% WARN; scheduled 2026-09-16T09:21:30-07:00 independently Mac2 WARN8%/74GiB, other3 OK. Critical clearance persists; WARN remains; runtime/restore not certified. Guard exactly ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env DTD_ZERO_COST1. Source open owner yoloforever-loop retained. Existing cleanup gates and TK11821 unpushed-commit caution retained, no-safe-increment.0implementation/slots/providerUSD0, no operations/canary run/cleanup/terminal changes. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1625.p5jHYW/ops.json and ops.md; child receipt complete, parent independent acceptance pending. Safest next existing scheduled monitoring, exact approval before any additional cleanup.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T16:54:28.593Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1649-ops MATERIAL FACT monitoring: fresh Data volume 84.206GiB/9% WARN; stored canary 2026-09-16T09:51:31-07:00 corroborates WARN9%, previously8%. TK11821 proposal hash changed with reconciliation/backup claim plus retained bottom caution; no independent target/restore certification or additional cleanup permission. Source owner/status retained. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1649.VDC2S9/ops.json; zero operational implementation.",
+      "correlation_id": "yf1649-ops-source"
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T17:39:21.601Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1734-ops COMPLETE bounded read-only monitoring. Data df 82.177GiB/9% WARN; stored10:21:35-07:00 Mac2 WARN9%, othersOK. MATERIAL evidence-location change: original critical reclaim memo absent at pending root, exists pending-approval/_done/2026-09-15-mac2-disk-CRITICAL-reclaim.md with identical SHA25609827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b; two other memo hashes unchanged. Filing is not approval or proof of cleanup. Source open/yoloforever-loop preserved; no-safe-increment,0implementation,USD0. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1734.Jd4Mjc/ops.json and ops.md; runtime/restore checks SKIP outside monitoring; parent acceptance pending. Next independent path/hash verification and existing scheduled monitoring; exact cleanup scope still gated.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T18:50:23.778Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1840-disk MATERIAL monitoring change: actual installed disk canary probe now WARN8percent79GiB (earlier cycle sample WARN9percent79GiB); negative unreachable UNKNOWN, API401, three existing memo hashes unchanged. Source remains open/yoloforever-loop. No cleanup/operations/closure; current source outcomes UNVERIFIED. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1840.CgXUrC/empirical-final.json. Guard ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1;0implementation/0slots/USD0. Preserve exact cleanup approval gate.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:11:34.629Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1902-linkfix RESUME scoped local preparation after DTD5/5 A: repair only informational correction Source href by adding _done/, preserve all gate text and original memo. Canonical source open/yoloforever-loop re-read; owner/status retained. Before SHA256bf9d732faa8a6e6e9033ea523d6054af764318533a9643a58ba6071802338ee0; target hash verified. No cleanup or operational approval; guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1, providerUSD0.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:11:44.904Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1902-linkfix COMPLETE local documentation preparation only: changed ONE Source href in existing yf1049 correction to _done/2026-09-15-mac2-disk-CRITICAL-reclaim.md. E2E parsed Markdown destination exists/hash09827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b; exact one-link diff and all other bytes/original unchanged PASS. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1902.dMfJps/linkfix.json with before.md/after.md; ops.json/ops.md reconcile execute-local,1localprep,1of6slots,0operationalimplementation. Source stays open/yoloforever-loop; cleanup/DB/model/offload/destructive gates unchanged. GuardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1, providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance and retained-evidence commit pending; runtime/restore SKIP outside scope.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:14:15.163Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1902-parent-accept Parent independently verified scoped local preparation: existing correction Source href now resolves _done original SHA25609827d316e8004455b0493f2e15d8ec72f5604efacbf3409f330911ccf472a9b; exact one-href diff, all remaining correction bytes and gates preserved. Live correction SHA256b0ccba428030d8b4760a319c3e80023e9677d6453d4f23b2b3e129ed8bdae7b3. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1902.dMfJps/parent-link-proof.json and linkfix.json.1local-prep/1of6 slots,0operational implementation. Source open/yoloforever-loop retained; cleanup/runtime/restore outcomes UNVERIFIED and exact approval gates unchanged. Cody final5/5 SHIP IT for local repair; final DTD and cycle persistence pending. ProviderUSD0.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:33:28.416Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1928-ops MATERIAL documentation defect: existing TK-11821 reclaim memo still attributes historical recovery to on-its-own/APFS churn, while canonical source15:51:15Z records Steve dropdb stayclaim + ollama rm heretic15:41:19Z. Propose exact historical-attribution correction to existing memo only, pending root DTD; zero implementation/newmemos/slots. Fresh df WARN8percent 79.319GiB; prior repaired Source link resolves and original hash unchanged. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/ops.json and ops.md. Source owner/status retained; cleanup/restore/target safety gates HELD, runtime checks SKIP. GuardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent acceptance pending.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:36:05.723Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1928-increment-resume RESUME source for bounded local memo preparation. Canonical re-read open/yoloforever-loop, latest action our ops proposal; TK11821 is done and no ticket-named active process found, memo unchanged hashadd08e9a. Parent reproduced unsupported APFS attribution versus15:51:15.048Z canonical report. DTD majority A (panel Codex+Qwen and root+Ops; risk ballot pending). Execution waits final ballot; exact one-paragraph correction only with reported attribution, all remaining bytes/gates retained. No operational writes/closure. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN.",
+      "correlation_id": "action-mu4i3zze-73052-3pckew"
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:37:19.010Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1928-ops-repair COMPLETE local preparation only after root DTD A5/5 and resume. Replaced EXACTLY ONE State bullet in existing TK11821 memo: historical recovery now explicitly reported by canonical TK11784 event15:51:15.048Z, Steve cleanup15:41:19Z,66GiB/7.13%WARN; independent causality not established. Exact single replacement/all other bytes+gates/live backup equality PASS. Before SHA256add08e9a8cc39423a60a7027c5f6100f52cb2d27c603beb4072d2c2119679940 after SHA2567bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/repair.json before.md after.md ops.json ops.md.1localprep/1slot/0operationalimplementation/0closures; source open/yoloforever-loop retained. Runtime/restore/cleanup safety SKIP outside scope; no embedded command executed. GuardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent acceptance/retention pending.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:38:08.991Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1928-parent-accept Parent independently accepted repair: direct before/after splitlines shows exactly State line9 changed; all other bytes identical, live equals after SHA2567bbdb7ca4217f61796a0e7804dbe31098bac0dbac64dedf3dfaffd3df854e6c1; reported attribution and causal limitation explicit.1localprep/1of6 slots/0operational implementation. Source outcome UNVERIFIED/open, gates unchanged. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1928.eHGYeN/parent-repair-proof.json. Proceeding queue position2 assessment, Cody/finalDTD and retention pending.",
+      "correlation_id": "action-mu4i6n94-73052-v34bio"
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T19:57:49.691Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "correlation=yf1954-ops COMPLETE bounded read-only assessment: no-safe-increment. Canonical source open/yoloforever-loop; three existing memo hashes unchanged from accepted repairs, Source resolves, historical attribution/causal limitation retained. Fresh df WARN 8% 78.848GiB; scheduled12:51:41PDT WARN8percent78GiB. No further local defect reproduced; operational/restore/target safety UNVERIFIED. Evidence /private/tmp/yf1954.Dkx8oQ/ops.json and ops.md.0implementation/0slots/0newmemos/0closures; gates HELD, guardZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1/providerUSD0. Parent independent acceptance pending.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ],
+  "last_correlation_id": "action-mu4i6n94-73052-v34bio"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11848.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11848.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..342f53b5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11848.json
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
+{
+  "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+  "title": "yoloforever-watchtower watch.sh: pm2 God count greps ps argv text (PM2.*God) → false pm2-god:2 from peer tk-log text; anchor to '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon' on ps -axo command=",
+  "project": "yoloforever",
+  "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+  "assignee": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+  "status": "open",
+  "status_since": "2026-09-16T21:11:08.427Z",
+  "kind": "task",
+  "schedule": {},
+  "parent_id": "",
+  "created_at": "2026-09-16T21:11:08.427Z",
+  "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:11:55.101Z",
+  "comments": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:10.898Z",
+      "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+      "kind": "comment",
+      "text": "@vp-operations owner: reversible one-line skill-script fix, no launchd plist change needed. Watchtower left watch.sh untouched (READ-ONLY loop); needs a negative test proving it still goes red on a real 2nd God (spawn one under a scratch PM2_HOME) and stays green on a decoy argv.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ],
+  "actions": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:09.307Z",
+      "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+      "text": "Evidence 2026-09-16 21:07:47Z false pm2-god:2: live ps = 1 God (pid 3334); pm2-fracture-canary 21:05Z god_count=1; watch.sh L27 'ps aux | grep -E PM2.*God' matched peer claude-run-11715's tk-log argv text (TK-11715 events 21:07:31-33Z contain PM2+God). Fix is a one-liner: GOD=$(ps -axo command= | grep -cE '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon'). Also consider reading pm2-fracture-canary/data/latest.json god_count instead of re-measuring. TK-11431 class: measuring the wrong thing (argv text) and calling it a daemon count.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T21:11:55.101Z",
+      "agent": "yoloforever-watchtower",
+      "text": "Second-model check: codex 429 (project spend cap, TK-11571 class still open) → grok-4.5 fallback AGREES benign FP. Grok's caveat (a ^ anchor fails on 'ps aux' because the line starts with USER) is already covered: the proposed fix uses 'ps -axo command=' (COMMAND field only). Watchtower triage closed; no live action taken.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11852.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11852.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7194d050
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11852.json
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+{
+  "id": "TK-11852-model-arena-gemma3-12b-missing-from-mac2",
+  "title": "model-arena: gemma3:12b missing from Mac2 ollama — daily battles running short-handed",
+  "project": "model-arena",
+  "agent": "claude-run-11723",
+  "assignee": "claude-run-11723",
+  "status": "open",
+  "status_since": "2026-09-16T21:14:46.202Z",
+  "kind": "task",
+  "schedule": {},
+  "parent_id": "",
+  "created_at": "2026-09-16T21:14:46.202Z",
+  "updated_at": "2026-09-16T21:15:00.811Z",
+  "comments": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T21:15:00.811Z",
+      "agent": "claude-run-11723",
+      "kind": "comment",
+      "text": "Split out of TK-11723 (cron revival) as a genuinely separate degradation — surfaced by the NEW wrapper WARN line that TK-11723 added, which is exactly what that line exists for. model-arena battles the roster qwen3-14b + gemma3-12b + hermes3-8b (Mac2 ollama :11434) + qwen25-7b (Mac1 192.168.1.133). LIVE Mac2 tags: qwen2.5vl:7b, hermes3:8b, qwen3:14b — gemma3:12b is GONE. It was present as recently as 2026-09-13 (it was that day's aiPick), so it was removed/evicted in the same window the server died. /api/models reports available:false for gemma3-12b, hf-qwen-coder-32b, muse. Today's recovery battle logged done:2. IMPACT (why this is not cosmetic): the ELO/win-rate ledger is the entire product, and a contender silently absent from the field biases every subsequent rating — rows look clean (partial:false) while the contest was short. NOT auto-fixed: 'ollama pull gemma3:12b' is ~8GB and this box has a documented disk-CRITICAL history (memory mac2-disk-critical-root-cause-janitor), so a blind pull is not in the bounded/no-externality tier. NEXT: check free space, confirm gemma3:12b is still the intended contender (vs deliberately retired like muse was per TK-10980), then pull or drop it from the roster in server.js so the WARN stops firing on a model nobody wants.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ],
+  "actions": []
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11859-claim.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11859-claim.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..c8e70918
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/reread-11859-claim.json
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
+{
+  "id": "TK-11859-cost-backlog-join-repair-class-18-vendor",
+  "title": "Cost backlog / JOIN-REPAIR class: 18 vendors, 6,243 ACTIVE products hold a cost-ish column that joins to NOTHING live (0 reachable)",
+  "project": "dw",
+  "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+  "assignee": "claude-run-11427",
+  "status": "open",
+  "status_since": "2026-09-16T21:22:45.115Z",
+  "kind": "task",
+  "schedule": {},
+  "parent_id": "",
+  "created_at": "2026-09-16T21:22:45.115Z",
+  "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:05:10.352Z",
+  "comments": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T21:23:12.537Z",
+      "agent": "claude-run-11427",
+      "kind": "comment",
+      "text": "SPLIT OUT OF TK-11427 (session 5, 2026-09-16). Sizes refreshed TODAY by scripts/cost-source-triage.mjs (read-only): COLUMN_BUT_NO_JOIN = 18 vendors, 6,243 ACTIVE products, 0 reachable by any existing join. These vendors HAVE a cost-ish column with data; the join key to live products is broken, so nothing resolves.\n\nWORKED EXAMPLE, already verified end-to-end this session — Osborne & Little. The cost-map entry is TABLE_MODE, so coverage keys on osborne_catalog.dw_sku: populated on 787/14,107 rows, and its 214 live matches are ALL non-ACTIVE (a stale generation). It therefore resolves 0 of 602 ACTIVE. Repointing to a cost_sql joining on mfr_sku lifts it 0 -> 58, verified 55/58 exact against live Shopify with no fan-out. Memo: pending-approval/2026-09-16-TK-11427-osborne-join-repair.md.\n\nMETHOD THAT WORKS (from that example): (1) compare the catalog's join column against BOTH sp.sku and sp.mfr_sku, since live SKUs often carry a vendor suffix (-OSB) while mfr_sku is clean; (2) prove the alternate key is unique in the catalog among priced rows and produces no fan-out (join rows == distinct products); (3) check for CROSS-VENDOR collision on that key and vendor-scope the SQL (one 'Designer Wallcoverings' product shares an mfr_sku with osborne_catalog — an unscoped join would have leaked it); (4) verify the WHOLE resolved set against live Shopify, not a 3-row sample — widening from 3 to 58 is what exposed the EUR-71203 divergence.\n\nTRAPS: a join repair is a cost-authority change on a live vendor and is GATED. And per TK-11858, resolving MORE products through the map can put the map into conflict with an existing stamped cost_source — check for both authorities before assuming a lift is pure gain.\n@vp-dw-commerce",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ],
+  "actions": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:04:40.173Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "yf2139-i4-ops: Independent operations DTD VERDICT A. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-ops.txt. Fresh guard/env verified ZERO_COST_REQUIRED / DTD_ZERO_COST=1. Recommend isolated offline audit retaining original provenance and all18/6243/0 totals; three cross-name table candidates affecting4371 products explicitly UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY, no implication remaining15 are proven. Six attempts, silent SQL errors and unfiltered priced rows mean absence/broken-join claims remain unproven; fail malformed/mismatched inputs. Creator process alone is not child ownership proof; no source/DB/API/cost-authority writes or provider spend. Source remains unresolved; parent independent acceptance and isolated preparation are next.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:04:53.069Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "yf2139-i4-risk: Independent risk vote complete: VERDICT A, offline audit/artifact preparation only. Evidence /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/increment4-risk.txt. Fresh guards ZERO_COST_REQUIRED and DTD_ZERO_COST=1 verified; $0 provider spend; canonical source reread. Preserve source hash/generated_at and reported18/6243/0 totals without implying fresh findings. Three cross-name candidates affecting4371 products are UNPROVEN_TABLE_IDENTITY, not definitive mismatches; remaining15 also unverified. Silent SQL errors, six key attempts, and no priced-row filtering mean zero reported reachability proves neither absent costs nor broken joins. No DB/API queries, source edits, canonical/customer mutations, or closure. Next: parent independently review and prepare reusable offline audit with malformed/mismatched rejection tests.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:05:10.352Z",
+      "agent": "codex-cost-assessment",
+      "text": "yf2139-cost-assess-11859 READ-ONLY ASSESSMENT HANDOFF to root (no claim/status or implementation). Active collision NOT_ESTABLISHED: creator-assigned open ticket has no action claim; creator parent TK11427 done 2026-09-16T21:24:35Z; live PID2842 alone insufficient. Existing: Osborne repair memo has exact SQL, 58 matches, three divergences, approval choices; no additional join memo located. Missing: Bucket is not a verified repair worklist: three cross-name table associations account for 4371/6243; selection origin and query errors are discarded; no priced-row filter. Proposed bounded local increment, NOT executed: Offline 18-vendor review JSON preserving source hash/totals, flag Phillip Jeffries/phillipe_romano_catalog (3392), Designer Wallcoverings/designers_guild_catalog (978), Studio Ditte/studio_printworks_catalog (1) as table identity unproven; remaining 15/1872 stay unverified. Do not execute or propose a repaired SQL join from these aggregate data. ZERO_COST_REQUIRED + DTD_ZERO_COST=1 verified; no paid calls, DB, production, or cost-map writes. Evidence: /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/cost-assessment/assessment.json. Root must independently verify and decide before implementation.",
+      "correlation_id": "action-mu4nfoxz-86175-2orumc"
+    }
+  ],
+  "last_correlation_id": "action-mu4nfoxz-86175-2orumc"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/scheduler.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/scheduler.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..0c87b961
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/scheduler.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"label": "com.steve.codex-yoloforever", "interval": 600, "stopped": false}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/terminal-owner-final.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/terminal-owner-final.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..2d080fb3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/terminal-owner-final.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
+94755   4.5    45:29 S+   claude
+42322   1.1 01:25:11 S+   claude
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-durable.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-durable.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..7af2d19f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-durable.json
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+{
+  "archive": "/Users/macstudio3/Projects/ticket-system/data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower",
+  "versioned_commit": "dfa2963a10f92bd675c40d39ef5071898ece883e",
+  "memo": "/Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md",
+  "memo_sha256": "c2c1dbfdf5622443b356f499352950709f80676704b535e36b450fa78ebd3209"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-peer-final.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-peer-final.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9da431c1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-peer-final.json
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+{
+  "at": "2026-09-16T22:34:26.172Z",
+  "id": "TK-11848-yoloforever-watchtower-watch-sh-pm2-god",
+  "status": "done",
+  "assignee": "night-TK-11848",
+  "updated_at": "2026-09-16T22:32:19.820Z",
+  "actions": [
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:22:10.230Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "yf2139-i3-execute: Isolated preparation complete, source outcome UNVERIFIED/operational partial. Commit dfa2963 in /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/watchtower/review.uegK64/repo; handoff /private/tmp/yf2139.YF57g8/watchtower/review.uegK64/handoff.json; approval memo /Users/macstudio3/.claude/yolo-queue/pending-approval/TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md. Exact one-line anchored command detector; nine literal assignment/threshold checks pass including old decoy false-positive, new decoy rejection, zero/one/two replay and live count1. Zero grep exit1 continues under installed no-errexit. bash syntax, diff, JSON and isolated reverse-apply check PASS. Installed clean HEAD5659b95 and SHA unchanged; no full argv retained, only safe daemon title prefix/count. Real second-daemon and installed/full-watch proof SKIP/gated; never invoked watch.sh, Claude, daemon action, schedules, sends or state. Guards freshly verified ZERO_COST_REQUIRED/env1; provider spend $0. Parent acceptance pending; source must remain unresolved until scoped approval and independent operational proof.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:24:08.850Z",
+      "agent": "codex-yoloforever",
+      "text": "Parent accepted isolated commitdfa2963:9checks independently rerun, exactone-line diff, installedsource byte-identical, bashsyntaxPASS. Durableclone data/codex-yoloforever/verification/yf2139-watchtower/review.uegK64/repo. Activation and actual2daemon/fullwatchproof SKIP; sourceUNVERIFIED. Slot6/6. Evidence verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watch-parent-proof.json; memo TK-11848-daemon-detector-yf2139.md.",
+      "correlation_id": "yf2139-i3-accept"
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:32:17.158Z",
+      "agent": "night-TK-11848",
+      "text": "Applied one-line fix to installed watch.sh L27 under reversibility tier (reversible+local+bounded, no externality). Was 'ps aux|grep PM2.*God' (matched peer claude tk-log argv text -> false pm2-god:2); now 'ps -axo command= | grep -cE ^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon' (command field only, anchored to real daemon title). Pre-apply state matched memo exactly (HEAD 5659b95, sha 3d92f55). Committed a7e005c in ~/.claude/skills/yoloforever-watchtower.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    },
+    {
+      "ts": "2026-09-16T22:32:17.953Z",
+      "agent": "night-TK-11848",
+      "text": "VERIFY-BEFORE-ACT + real 2nd-daemon proof: live single daemon -> new detector=1 (matches real 'PM2 v6.0.14: God Daemon (/Users/macstudio3/.pm2)'). Fixture decoy claude argv -> OLD=2 (reproduces FP) / NEW=1. Started ISOLATED scratch God daemon (PM2_HOME=/tmp scratch, independent of ~/.pm2) -> new detector=2 and fracture alert (GOD>1) fired -> torn down -> back to 1, live ~/.pm2 untouched. Zero-daemon -> GOD=0, no errexit issue. bash -n PASS.",
+      "correlation_id": ""
+    }
+  ]
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watchtower-baseline.json b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watchtower-baseline.json
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..3870dfb6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/watchtower-baseline.json
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
+{
+  "source_line": "GOD=$(ps aux | grep -E 'PM2.*God' | grep -v grep | wc -l | tr -d ' ')",
+  "proposed_line": "GOD=$(ps -axo command= | grep -cE '^PM2 v[0-9.]+: God Daemon')",
+  "real_matched_commands": [
+    "PM2 v6.0.14: God Daemon (/Users/macstudio3/.pm2) "
+  ],
+  "source_head": "5659b951a5da820786da84bfd2079187e5f899a8"
+}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/zero-cost-preflight.log.txt b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/zero-cost-preflight.log.txt
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..8ca2b263
--- /dev/null
+++ b/verification/yoloforever-yf2139.YF57g8/zero-cost-preflight.log.txt
@@ -0,0 +1,12 @@
+EVIDENCE_DIR=/private/tmp/yoloforever-zero-cost-preflight.qQGVfV
+VERIFIED agents_panel 1c15b3a6164528c5baa1abbf799e599b002cfa7f1772c09125dd35bfcdaab004 /Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/dtd/scripts/panel.sh
+VERIFIED agents_post 877f177b8f3bfc9c17c44c4e20ea99df6d721b63c468aa5311e41223d71faeef /Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/dtd/scripts/post-decision-codex.sh
+VERIFIED claude_panel 1c15b3a6164528c5baa1abbf799e599b002cfa7f1772c09125dd35bfcdaab004 /Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/dtd/scripts/panel.sh
+STRUCTURAL_GUARD_AND_ISOLATION /Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/dtd/scripts/panel.sh
+STRUCTURAL_GUARD_AND_ISOLATION /Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/dtd/scripts/post-decision-codex.sh
+STRUCTURAL_GUARD_AND_ISOLATION /Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/dtd/scripts/panel.sh
+SKIP dynamic missing-environment case: inherited DTD_ZERO_COST remains intact
+ISOLATED /Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/dtd/scripts/panel.sh codex_exec=1
+ISOLATED /Users/macstudio3/.agents/skills/dtd/scripts/post-decision-codex.sh codex_exec=1
+ISOLATED /Users/macstudio3/.claude/skills/dtd/scripts/panel.sh codex_exec=1
+PASS zero-cost preflight scoped checks; dynamic missing-environment case SKIP; evidence retained /private/tmp/yoloforever-zero-cost-preflight.qQGVfV

← 89428d32 Stage anchored Watchtower daemon count with negative boundar  ·  back to Ticket System  ·  Persist cycle ledger and record host environment context ca66a4da →